High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2528/2017dismissed

Krishan v. Azad Singh & ORS

2018-10-25Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

!"#$%&'

##('&&" ! "!##$$! #('&&")$*+ %" # & '(& &$ & " # !##!$ & )""*&"! %$&+("& !&-!$&&$

./" "! & (& $! 0")! )"& " & "$ 1 ! !$ #! !2##2&""! "!&-!$&"#&($&&,!& &&&! 12 !&-!$ "!$$,"!$ !

34/

34 ! 3 / 5 ( 12 " !& -!$ "! ($6&! & 7( ,6 ! ! 3 4 )"12 !$ !

34! 3 / 5 ( 12!&-!$)!& %" ( &!##!$"!#!$2 $!&6 "#$!&&

.!##$$!126 & 2&, "7( ,6! #! 12"&!$ ( &6&&,"(&12 &0&, &/ "8& 3 /9#!! 3 " 7( ,6 " ("!"$

"(: ;

3 !!"'(&&

&"& !&& &#( ! "!"(&##2&"! !$##2 # ! !& -!$ & )"& " "2 ) &5 #! %$&+("&)!" !&-!$!

! "&6 # & / " 8& ( ( & 3 /& ! #! 5#&$!&,1"& !

6!$"&1 !6 6 8&

" " "! "! #! )&$$ $ & "& $,!$ "& ! # & 8& ( ( & 3 / #(!$ #2 6(!&< =5"&1& !$"! !

" !" !&-!$ 6 "&!&*")! )!6(! & !( (1&,"

!6 "!& >!

&,"

?!$)!&,"! !" &,""5 ./"! )"!*&"!"!&"& ./"!!&,"12 " !2 !" !&-!$ ")!(& 12 &! ,! #:

! !(," &!$ #!&&!&-!$)($ "!, ./""!&"(&##2 "& ./""!"!1&"& 12"&$,!$"&!# & 8& ( ( & 3 / & " !##$$!:#$!&&

&" #:

! !& -!$ ! "( & " $!:9 "& !& -!$ ! & &$ &"& ./""! #! !2& !&-!$ )"& "& 1 6& "1!& &!$#!&&#" &!$ #!&& !& -!$ )($ , ./" "! & " (& ##2! "& ./""!)($ $&"&$,!$"& '(!$$29" "!##$$!:#$!&&

"! .4/"!& "(&##2!

" !" !&-!$8) "& ! "! 1 !## &! 12 $!

&&!$ &&$ ( , @& "!6 & &," ## & " '(& # 1 "& (! !) ! &,$2A

%"$(16&&6!

12 ($&"!& "#$!&&

1&, #:

! !&-!$"!&"& ./""!& $! 6#&&, 0")!

" & !$ &$ ./" "! & 0")! " 7( ,6 ! #! 12 " ( & !##!$!$&!1$16 & & ! &,$2

($ " !##$$! & # ! '(2 "!

&#( "!&"#&($&&,!&"! ($6&! &"7( ,6!

! 3 4 )"12 ) !$ ! 34 !

3 / ) !& 12 "$ &, "! $! (17 6! !$ & ! !$ #! !2##2&""! !&-!$ "!&-!$)!! #!2&"!& (&"#$!&&

.!##$$!& $!&6&,"&&,"&" (&##2"(,""!&-!$ " ! !# 6 & &, & 7( ,6 ! 3 4 %"! 1&, " ( & !##!$ "! &,"$2!##$& &/ "8& 3 / !$ ($! "! !&-!$!"&6 "& !"&! !$ #! !2##2 &$6 "& $!9"&!& ./""!"5 ./" "!! "!!&-!$"!

! !#:

! !(," # && "#$!&&

9"&&) "6! 9 & ! 6( "$#&2& & &, 12" (&!##!$"$ &, "!##$$!&$ .4/""!&(&##2 "&"&, (,,& " ! "!$! 6#&&,0")! )!!$! !$ #! !2##2&" "! "!&-!$ &"&! "5 ./""!& !( " !##$$! )($ ( "& 1 & $!&6 " !6 "! '(! 0")! (17 6! #(&

< B" ,&,! & &,6& "!##!$ !&$ &! &,$2 &6& &$&6&

C@D($!&E F""#!0&,.! 2. F""#!1$ 2.