High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2529/2017dismissed

Kuldeep Singh v. Balbir Kaur & ORS

2019-02-11Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

!"##$%&%'( #)*+!*,- .+/0##1%'23 11#//!'"

4#*&+& !/)%*.!+* !'"3#* #&1'0#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

*#&#'"( *!*&3+'2#*-05$!"#- *"3#!11#//!'" *+*'!-05$!"#- *"3#$!5#!"*6*#&1'0#'" 77777 *)+%,'

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

!5+*"3#1/!%'"%-:3%$3:!&:%"'#&&#0),%/)!23%'23-D!8)!*0!*- 3!*!'1!/!*1!'$3!'0&$*%)#0),&3B.+8!*

##'0!'" 11&#0 "3# &+%" !'0 $/!%8#0 " )# "3# $//!"#*!/":!&!&&#*"#0"3!"5"!*%'23<.!*"!*%'23'#%"3#*#9#$+"#0 "3#=%//0!"#0> ?*1*1+'0#0"3#=%//0!"#0?), 0##'0!'"-:3%$3:!&&"!"#0")#!/&#-%$"%"%+&!'0!)*%$!"#0 ##'0!'"1*1+'0#0"3#=%//0!"#0?-:3#*#),5"!* %'23<.!*"!*%'233!0)#@+#!"3#03!/&3!*##!$3%'*#&1#$"3%&&3!*# %'!5+*"3#1/!%'"%!'00##'0!'" %'$#"3#1!*"%#&:#*#!"5!*%!'$#-"3#"*%!/+*"*!8#0"3# //:%'2%&&+#&(6 E

# $

! % &

% ' #

( # % ) * +

/!%'"%-%'*0#*"1*5#3%&$!&#-#9!8%'#0 =6%/)!23 %'23 !""#&"%'2 :%"'#&&- =6 &3B .+8!* ##0 =*%"#* !'0 "3#* :%"'#&&#&- :3#*#!& 0##'0!'" #9!8%'#0 3#* 2#'#*!/ !""*'#, +*)!$3!' %'23 !& =6- :3#*#!& 0##'0!'" 0%0 '" /#!0 !', #5%0#'$# *!*&3+'2#*-/#!*'#0$+'&#/!11#!*%'2')#3!/"3# !11#//!'"61/!%'"%&+)8%""#0"3!""3#%'0%'2&)"3"3#$+*"&)#/:!*# ""!//,#**'#+&!&"3#"#&"%8', =6%/)!23%'23!'0 =6&3B .+8!*3!0 2'#+'*#)+""#0 #@+%*#8#'" #$"%' ?> "3#'0%!'

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

% (

-.#

0 1 % 2 (!#!

# 3,

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

*%'23*#9#$+"%' "3#=%//":!&#813!"%$!//,0#'%#0-)+"&%'$#3#:!&!*#&%0#'"*#%2' $+'"*,-0%0'")*%'2"3#1!&&1*",0*!:%'2!05#*&#%'#*#'$#-#/#8#'" !$"%5#1!*"%$%1!"%'$!''")#*+/#0+"!/)%*.!+*0##'0!'"-!& 1#*"3#$3#0+/#0!""$3#0"#$"%'>"3#%'0++$$#&&%'$"-:!&! /!&&63#%*5%&6!65%&"3#1/!

&*#2!*0&"3#1&&#&&%'-'1&%"%5#!'00%*#$"#5%0#'$#3!& )##'/#0"#&"!)/%&3"3##9$/+&%5#1&&#&&%''&+$3$%*$+8&"!'$#&-"3# &"!"+&"3#1/!%'"%:%"3"3!"0##'0!'":+/0)#!$6&3!*#* //"3#&#!$"*&3!5#)##'#9!8%'#0!'0:#%23#0%'"3#8%'0 "3#$+*"&)#/:3#!*2+8#'""3#/#!*'#0$+'&#/*"3#!11#//!'"- "3+&-%&'"!)/#")*%'2"3#A+028#'"&!'00#$*##&"3#$+*"&)#/: :%"3%'"3#*#!/81#*5#*&%","*8!0%#*#'"1%'%'2*+'0* %'"#*#*#'$#%&8!0#+"+"-8+$3/#&&%'5/5#8#'"!',&+)&"!'"%!/ @+#&"%'/!: #&+/"!'"/,-"3#!11#!/%&0%&8%&&#0 /01, *)+%

234 '(56& +474389 :3

;3:

+474 70!

;3: