High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/645/2023disposed of

Rachna Rathee v. Mandeep Kumar

2023-12-07Mrs. Justice Archana Puri7 pages

!"#

#%&'& (

#"&"&

) * +*

#', * ./ *

#'#(" *

!(%0&"

1(&!2 -3 %!"#2

(4&"

0!0!5 *

!015 &(602 -3 %!"#'2

4#- &'-&%"&

"0&'

1(-#

"&%5#

('"&"1"&

(-&!2

'#""&(6 !'&-#

-!"#- 9 :((#;1 < ,!''#- &(%&,!5 1-6#2 !?&5> @0# #=> !( !,,5&%!"& $&5#-

'##4&(6 &?

?&(

-#(&#-

3&'&"!"&

&60"'

0!"2 &(&"&!55>2 !%0(!

!"0## 0!- $&5#- 1(-#

#%"&

-&!('

%"2

'##4&(6

?&(

-!160"#

#&(2 !( !,,5&%!"&

-&', '#-

3&-#

@0# #&(2 0#5- !?&5> #'"

&$ '0# ("&(1#'

5&3#

3&'&"!"&

&60"'

@# !("#-

## '2

-!"#2 "&?# ,5!%# (3#(&#("

"&#'2 4##,&(6 3&#@

@0&%02 @&55

#B1&

#!"?#("

##5&(6 !66 &#3#-

,!''#- / @#

0!(-&(6

?&(

!("&(6

3&'&"!"&

&60"'2 !%0(!

!"0##2 $&5#- #'#("

#3&'&

,1 '1!(%#

"&%# &''1#-2

?!-# !,,#!

!(%#

/#!

1('#5

0#!

$!%"'2 %155#-

,!,#

@' 0!"2 ?!

&!6# =#"@##(

5#?(&C#-

'!&- @#-5 %42

?!"

(&!5 -&',1"#

'# =#"@##( "&#'2

#'15"

@0# $2

"#- @!>'

5#$"

?!"

(&!5

#?!&(#-

@2 !?&-'"

?!"

(&!5 -&'%

1($

"1(!"# -&',1"# =#"@##(

:$!"0# <2

#6!

0!(-&(6D"!4&(6

?&(

"1''5#2 ?!""#

-#%&-#-2

5#6!5

&60"'

"&#'2

5# ?&(!("

&"#

@0!"

=#'"

'# #'"

@#5$!

3&'&

-&!('

%"2 ?!4#'

?!(&$#'"5> %5#!

1("

@#5$!

?&(

'"!"1"

&60"'

#("'

?!""#

53&(6 B1#'"&

?&(- B1#'"& E@0!"

@&'0D-#'&

%0&5-F -&$$# #("

-&'"&(%"

B1#'"& E@0!"

=#'"

#'"

%0&5-F

# "!&(5>2 @&'0D-#'&

%!( !'%# "!&(#-

!%"& "0#(2 B1#'"&

E@0!"

=#'"

#'"

%0&5-F2 ?!""#

-#%&-#- @0&5# "!4&(6 &("

!%% 1("2 !55

#5#3!("

%& %1?'"!(%#'

-&',1"# 53#'

01?!( &''1#'2 !5@!>'

?,5#;

?,5&%!"#-

%!( (#3#

!&60" 8!%4#"

?15!2 #3#(

!-81-&%!"# B1#'"&

$!%" -#,#(-#("

#;# %&'#

(-1%"#- "'2 =!%4-

@#5$!

@0&5#

3&(6 %0&5-F'

#'"

%!(

"#%"#- @0&5#

#&"0#

#("

"&(#("

"# @0#( 1,5#'

66# 0#!-'

@!("

@!>'2 "0#> ?!> 5#3#5 #;"

#?# !55#6!"& !6!&('"

#!%0

-#,&%"

1(@

"0>2

%& %1?'"!(%#'2 1(5#''

1("&52

3#( =!- (-1%"

#("2 ?!4#'

0&?D0#

1(@

"0>

%5!&?

(%# (#-2 B1#'"& %!( -#%&-#-2 5#5>

4&(6 &("

B1#'"& E@0!"

=#'"

#'"

(%# (#-F

#3# "&(6 =!%4

%!'# 0!(-2 '0 "#- ,5#!-&(6'2

5&'

!&'#- !55#6!"& 1("#

!55#6!"&

#6!

-&(6 =!- =#0!3&

(-1%"

#!%0

"0&'

'"!6#2

(##-

-&5!"# 1,

"&?#2 '0 4#,"

?&(- B1#'"&

>#!

"&?#2 @0#( $&5#- >#!

2 '#3#( >#!

!6# @2 != (&(# "#( >#!

A#5$!

1"?

&?,

"!(%#

1, @#55 =#&(6

!',#%"

!6#

@#&60'

?&(-

"0&'2

?#-&%!5 !&5?#("

',#5"

,5#!-&(6'

$&(-'

?#("&

=##( ?#("& "0!"2

?#-&%!5

=##( -&!6( '#-

=##( '1$$#

&'4 /!(6# 0!('

#55 &'"& %>"

'&'

: '&( ,0&5&% !(15 ?!< : $"

"&''1# 53#?#("< '0# 1(-# #!"?#("

#3&-#("

#!"?#("2 !-?&(&'"#

) / =!'#- %0#?

!,>

0&'

?#-&%!5 !&5?#("

'1%02 -&',1"#-2 #3#(

B1# =##( -&'%5 '#-

#615!

#!"?#("2

'1%02

!( #(-2 '"&55

?#-&%!"& #'

',&"!5

@ 1, %0#%41,'

,!,#

#3&-#("

#!"?#("

#;"#(-#-

:$!"0#

+!,1

*#?

&!5 ',&"!52 1'!

!-2 #@ #50&2

#?&#

?#-&%!5 &('"&"1"&

1"?

&?,

"!(%#

?!4# !(> '1%0 -&',5!%#?#("2 %!1'#'

,0>'&%!5 #?

"& (!5 '"

#''

1="2 &("#-

1"2

@&(6 !6#

%!(

&#(-2 61&-# ?#("

@&(6 "&?#2 ?#-&%!5 !&5?#("

'1%02 %!((

4#-

#'&-#'

#'!&-2 #3#( !55#6!"& 1("# !55#6!"& ('2

#6!

=!- (-1%"

#("'2 '!?#2 '1%02 %!(

3#-

#3&-#(%# !?&5> !,,

&!"# '"!6#

01'2 "!4&(6 !$

#'!&- !55#6!"& 1("# !55#6!"& &("

"0&'

'"!6#2 %!(( '!&-

#("

=#""#

'&"&

!$"#

1="2 &("#-

1"2

*# %0!("

!3> @&(62 '1%0 !3 %!"& ?!>

#?!&(&(6 !@!>

1'#

(6 -'2 0&'

!='#(%#2

4#- !$"#

( B1# '"!"#- 1('#5

'"!>&(6 0&'

5!'"

>#!

3#( &$2 !@!>2

4#- !$"#

@#55

(-#("2 @0

4#- * (?#("

',&"!5 '"!"#-

#"&

!''&'"!(%# !3!&5#-

1'&(

'!?#2 '0

4#- #'&-&(6 $$&%#

!?&5> 0!- (!5 !%"& -#"!&5

(3# '!"& =##(

-1%#- !6 !,0

#3#!5'

"!=5# 1'#

?#("& ?!-# !=

@&55&(6

5&3#

-1#

!66 #''&3# =#0!3& '1%0 !(

3!"& #3#( ?!-#2 ?!>

!%% 1("

'!>&(6 "0&'

&,'

$!%"

"0&'

'"!6#2 #'

?!4#

=!-

(%51'&3#

,&(& '1%02 %!(

"#- ?!(

?!( ?!> =!-

("#;"1!5

#5!"& ('0&,2 #'

(#%#''!

&5> ?#!( =!-

0&'D0#

5&60"

#'!&-

3!"& ('2

"&%15!

5>2 @0#( 0!3&(6 ?#-&%!5 !&5?#("2 @0# #&(2

#B1& #("& #!"?#("

"!4#(2 1(-#

'1,# 3&'&

(-#("2 !,,

&!"#

-&',5!%#

'01$$5#

=#(#$&%&!5

@#55 =#&(6

0!3&(6 ?#-&%!5 !&5?#("

#'!&- %& %1?'"!(%#'2 !,,

&!"#5>2 0#5- / @#

'0 ("&(1#

#?!&(

(-#("2 @0

"&?#2 '0 -#, &3#-

!$$#%"&

5&60"

'!?#2 3&'&"!"&

&60"'

160"

3&'&"!"&

&60"'

=##(

-1

-!"#2 "&?# ,5!%#2 (3#(&#("

"&#'2 4##,&(6 3&#@ -1 @&55

#B1&

"!4#

#!"?#("2 #B1#(%>

'!?#2 '1%02 =##( ?#("&

'!?#2 =#'&-#'

-1

3&'&"!"&

&60"'

'"!"&(6 !=

!(6#?#("

?!-#2 @0&5# "!4&(6 &("

(3#(&#(%#

#("2 @#55 #("'

$!%&5&"!"# !3!&5&(6

3&'&"!"&

&60"'

"@&%# ("02 @0&5# 4##,&(6 3&#@ #!"?#("

-1 '#

'1%0 ?##"&(6'2 #;,#%"#-

-#'&

#;"#(-

#!%0

#!"# (6#(&!5 !"?

',0#

$!%&5&"!"#

0!3&(6 0#!5"0> !%"&

#3&'& "5> !55 @#-

'"!(-'

-&$&#-

#;"#("2

3#- !$

#'!&-

3!"& %& %1?'% &=#-

,1 '#'

?!4&(6 ,1 #5> "#?,

!(6#?#("2 @#5$!

#2 --&"& (!5 &(%&,!5 1-6#2 !?&5>

%##- $1

-#%&-# ?!&( #;,#-&"& 1'5>2 !$"#

!--1%# #3&-#(%#2 &($51#(%#- !(>

3!"& ?!-# #&(!=

: Himanshu A0#"0#

',#!4&(6D #!'

A0#"0#

"!=5# #'D