Abhishek Kumar v. Central Board Of Secondary Education Delhi And Another
!"#$# %&'((
))* +,,-- ./$0$
1
+($, %2%
3&
%45-*/(0$ #"((6 -# /$% & */(7# #%89:2. "
! /*/(/0%9 /3 :2. "
! /
( */() %% %* -#;:2. "
! //$, %2% (( <<< ((6 -# :(=/ ->
--%8 #% 9 #%$
/80- / $" %2 - #$ 70283% %2 2"/ 2
2 (?( , $$2 5@ /%2 #$ 028:) -#% ( !/./$#%8 970283% %22"/
2 A(( , $$2 5@ #.#- 028 =/( #.(>: ) B9/0, % 9"#.#-$0# !#-25@ #!!B $2"/2
#!! 2"- /2 5 A(?(??A B9#- 2#/"
#%8 9 /$, %2% $C2!%2 /"
#!@
#!! #% 23#" /" /2 ! A(?(??A#% "" /2 %"B# 99#$5#/
( % 9 5 $#$ ! 9 ,- 2#%8$ ! 9 , #$: 9 ! -- B#%8 #$$0$B/!/ 32&
!
"
#
"
$
$
%
& "
'
(
) *
9/ !
/: % 95 $#$ !.#2%"-25@ 9, #$ $B--
$$053#$$# %$3 2: 9- /# 2"#22#$$0 (#%!
. 0/ ! #%$ 9 /$, %2% $C2!%2 $: B9#- #$$0 $( B/232 58#.%0, %2#%" %$D0%" 9/ !:
9$0# !#-25@ #!!B $2"/2( A % -: /%2 #$ 028: ) - /./$2 !#%2#%8 %#$$0 ( % 98/ 0%2
9/#89 $;" //"
# % !
99 5E/"#$2B# 9#% 9/@ /$ !
#%#%83 7 /# % 95 $#$ ! 95#/
#$$025@ 98#$ / !#/ 9$
9$: B9/ $ #% 9 #%$
"
$:
#!!#% 9*#22-
%2 /2 3#%
# %
= E( > %2 " %2 /@ "9 - 3#%
# %
= E( > #$$02 5@ /$, %2% $ B $ /!-"
$ ('(??A B9/ $"- #3#%8
9#$
9#% /3$ !9#$5#/
= E(> #$$025@ 9 22# # % - #$ 8#$ /=#/ 9$C
9$> ,0
#.#- 0/8 %: ) A(?(??A
#!!9 ,,/ "92 #.#- %(?(F:B9%9 $3 / %@ /$ ! 8( F - /803% !- /%2" 0%$-! / #!!#$
9 ! $,/5#/
= E(> #$$025@ 9 22# # % - #$ 8#$ /=#/ 9$C
9$> ,0 #.#-0/8 %:) -#$A(?(??A: 9/! /:#! 9$ 3B " //"
2 #% 9 /" /2: # B 0-2 /$0- #% 8/
,/702#"
#!!( / " % : - /%2 " 0%$- ! / /$, %2% (C2!%2 /-#$0, % 92"#$# % ! #.#$# %%"9 ! #%
!"# $% & '!()&#!*#! $(+ ,"
-)$(+ "."
#(-.
E 9$ 3#$/,/ 20"2
$0%2/& +!
,- ( & "
. "
/ (
&
"
-&
"
"(
(
0 1
2 %3 45%
"
&
& & 6 "
A
"
& "
"
/%2 " 0%$- -$ /-#$ 0, % 9 2"#$# % ! 9/ #.#$# %%"9 ! #%$(+ -'
#%B9#"95@/-@#%8 % 92"#$# %#%35#;
) 0-4$"
$ =0,/ >: 9"- #3 ! 9/#%! /" //"
# % !2
9 $/7"
2 % "" 0% 9/#%9 .#%8 ,,/ "92
5@ %2 9 ,/# 2 ! 9/ @ /$ !
/
#%#%8 8 ! 7 /# @( 92"#$# %#%35#;
) 0-4$"
$=0,/ >B -$ ! -- B2 5@ #% 6 (? # -2 $#3/ %.$(8# % -!!#"/:
- /2 !"9 - 20"
# %= >:"
/F: %"9;0- 2"#22 % (?(?( ' 9 ." %$#2/2 9$053#$$# %$ !- /%2" 0%$-( ? 23#
2-@: 92
9 ! $,/ 5#/ 9 "/
= E(C> #$$02 5@ 9 22# # % - #$ 8#$ / =#/ 9$C
9$> %2 ,0 #.#- 0/8 %: ) - #$ A(?(??A(
B./: *#22-
%2 /2 3#%
# %
= E(> " %2 /@ "9 -
3#%
# %
= E( > #$$02 5@ /$, %2% $ 2,#"
('(??A( #.#-0# B $!#-25@ #!! %(?(F B9/ $ % 95 $#$ !9#$
= E(C>:
$ %2
!!#-#%8 ! 9"#.#-$0# B $@ /$ %2A @$ -2 9/! / 9"#.#-$0# B $!#-25@ %2 9,/# 2 ! 9/@ /$
F $ #,0-
2#%/ #"-F' ! 91#3#
# %"
:? B9#"9$ #,0-
,/# 2 ! #3B# 9#%B9#"92"-
# %"
%5 5
#%2(/ #"-F' !
91#3#
# %"
:? #$/,/ 20"2 $0%2/& #) -"
$- $
&
$0-
-@:#% 9-#89 9, $# # %% 5 .:2 % !#%2 %@#%!#/3# @B# 9 970283% %22"/2
2(?(, $$2 5@ 9- /%2#$ 028:) -/./$#%8 970283% %22"/
2 A(( , $$2 5@ #.#- 028 =/( #.(>: ) -( $05$
# - D0$ # % ! - B 30"9 -$$ D0$ # % ! - B /#$$ ! / " %$#2/
# %5@ ( "" /2#%8-@:!#%2#%8/80- /$" %2 -5/!
!3/# :
9$ 3#$2#$3#$$2(
'(( 74 8
&9 : ;9< : ;9<