High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3250/2015dismissed

M/S Chatha Service Station v. Lalmati Devi And ORS

2019-02-07Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!"#! "$% &"'""('!%

'')) *"$ +)(# "

,' &"

- !

&$.!"

& !

&$.#" ''))

/0)/".#/

1 !" ".# " "'2

&"5 " +)(#5/.6'"&)% 7". "("% 87"5

(9$("% 8 7"$% ",('"&).$"$#(" ) )( ' $" ! 33 "

* ). 88 """"" %"' !% 5"#".

!"#!#))%+1 $".

" ) "$% &"'""('!% 5/"0 2/:$"('7+ . )$""1"2 &; 3< = """"" %1" . )(% (' $ , .. $

,('"&)

"% )(. >$ (

">$ $9)."'2 5 !% >7 " %)%"#% %1" ,('" &)./ /%" '>$ $9). "$))7 $"($)')?$"@ $% ,('"&)/ &-:. %" >$ $$(> ?$" @ :,2 3= $"!=..8.=.

:&/%"%">7, "!% / &)! ;& / "%" "% )(.

/ % >$ = 7". /"1% ( "% , . '" ( )( /" ' $' "%(1 "> (

0 )('/>7)) ""'

,'2 5 !% $7 >7" %)%"#% %1""$)%$% ,'2 5 $"('7/ ) "% )('")%)>? "' 2 / #%#)"#%) (. "".>)#7)>)7'7(' :1$'

#"$)%)'))

))7. )) "' ( $' / '"7" " () )('

')% '". ))/% $ /" "(

A ",('"&)-$"1&)# $)" ./ 1') $" %)% "#%"'2 1"2 &;3< =B&&

A " )(")('/ C "(/ (B&&

A " "'2 / #%#)# "#%)))%B&,

= ,)

; '")#$''" ""'# )(

:$''" . )(C( "(" A , "!% A 0 )()"# :,DC & .' '7'("("'"DC & '7 "DC &

" ."'2 !% ''" ,A

" "%"%$(. 0">$)$2

#$" )(.$2 %"'2 ,$))7. )( ' / ' >7 0">$) (' , 8.. / " / %" #$" )('7>)>7)) ""'?)7 #"))7 </#". :$"('7/$)"#" ($'>7 )(('$" /" "("'2

0 /") "'2 5

!"#

= ! "$% &"'""('!% %%"# ''" $">7)% '"'')

2 '')/%# "'./ '$ ''" "$% $)

: # ")"$)" '">%% "$% ""

'')>"%2

:: >) > ) ''))$"""= ,$)"/ ! &"'"$%"%" !% 5"#"(( "#"7 )#% 0">$) %#"% $"('7")E ($ (''>7 )("( /" "#"" " $% "#"/ )%"#%)>$/ #%"("%"F$"$"! =

"* )@ (" "#" $"% "%"(2)D%"%))%"(

/ /#)$'

. /#". "$)> '"$>" 0">$) $)" "#" "( ("%"% '"$ "$" " $" (" ("#" ) ")#(. 1"/""7% )@ $"%#% :, 2 3= $"! ..8.=:&.&) !;; "%"% "#". 1"/1 '(("#"7.'))7( 1"/('7@ ''))/'"#>7$((%

"'"@ $% '')) %%! * '".

#. >$ ''" " "#" )7 " '')) /"./ /'"%C'"@ '')) (1/"%"%'% /")7 )/1 G$"7. / &"!"#"(""#$(( C$@ "" $)(1/ ('$%/" >' =@ ""$ %)% $). ''))$)'"$ "% " (( "#"7 0 "". '') > '

0 '')>%"> ) $" ('7>7)%"')7 % "( ! = "* )."( "#%)"# "'"# )""7%%%"$ " E"$$""F$">(./ #))7" 7" "/"( "#%)."#"

!% /$ "E"# )1" / )%#)"#%) 0 "". $$) '$"' /$) > "# >7 (")7 ')% "" " #%>"% "F$"(>% "("( +%$ "7 >(')/ >7 ''))""#" !% $" "(")7>$ # )/('7 ())%>7 '')). )1"# ) ''))$># )(" ""7%%"$" E"$% 0 "".')%((

3 "#"7 /$) $" " '')) 0 %"$ ( '')"# >' '') $)>(

" "% "#).: " (" '') ""= ,$)&)/ '"$ ) # '')) $" " "7 "" '"#"'"$$"

$ ! %

# &

% #

# !

' ( !

) #

0 ''))))7 " #$)'"#$" ! : '')) 0">$) "$( #./ $% #> ( 0 )( ' > # ()7 >7

"' 2 . '')) " >" 0">$) 0 #$)7("$ ''))" (" :

'"'$(>"7'"$ ?$%( :"%)7. "#" # ) )7'')

0 "% #>$"%>7 "#" :/"

('"$ ))%"%"$"% # )')"" "#"7(( %1"/ "'E$" 1"$"%#% "%" % ( ;$ " %"" // 7 D# '"'')) :>( " / ''))% "#" $"% 7""%" "%">'))>$ >"% )7'$>7 $"('7"')7 "F$"(! = "* )"( "#% ) # ) # " 7". / ()7 " "#%) "#" % # ) 0 "". '')$""">%/ $(" (

$" "(". ''))1#% E$"((. 1"(>('7/ " # ""7 0 0">$)'"2 = /" / )"""%("#" !% ./ ''" ,A ( " (. /""7%) 1".$ /"#%"'" # )""7%%%"$ E"$$". )

8 1"/('7 ")#( 0 0">$) $" " "">) "#""# # ) / #"#%)./ #)7/>"'" 7"$>?$>F$"/) </#". "#% )DC , ') ) / /$"' 2 "'" "7"% $)"# "'" # )>$"'"# )""7%% E"$$". /7. / )%#)"#%) ( " " $ #) "( $"')7. $"('7/%# "% "#" ($ "( "#" /" % # ) 2$)>$/ $ #"%#>7 0">$)

0 $. ''))> )''))$> / $7("("%)7

;"?

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#