High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3201/2015allowed

Kawaljit Singh Walia v. State Of Punjab

2023-03-29Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill23 pages

2023:PHHC:046954

!" #$%$!&'())

' *+

)

, ++

# !"

$! % &

, ++-) ' '))*+)', - . / 0 1! " )2)*+)', 0

3 4')1 #! - 0""1 5

# ## 67 " + " "- " 89 : 89/; )'''+)'' " 8-

:49 / 0 1 " * ! < " " 6+) 62; 6;' 9< 0

3 4'1 " 5

0+1

## " # = - > ?" ! $#@ > @ < "!-9 !" " " ! ! A! ! " # !- " ( "#

0 1 " "#

! "

9?$( ": "

0 1 !# # ,5

" " 9?$( * 5

! ( "# . - +)'' # , 5

0 1

" "9?$( " - - : - 5. +)'' "# :

0 1 !- %# # # ! # 25 ! " ! "

"# 9?$( "" " - ! # 59 "

"# # 7 # ! "

" ! " # "" # " 7'7 <<

3 4+1 " 'B'++)'6 9 # " # " 7'7<< -

071

""# " # " 3

+' ! ! ! " " ." C" -#" 6 : - #! " +;);+)',

3 4*1 5

76 #- <!+;);+)',0

34B1 ##

# A! - "

" ##

: - " )2)*+)',

34')15

# ## # -67 # ! '))*+)',

- --

! , $ "

# #

" 9 # -" " # ! " "--3#

: 2 C

" # 67

3# - !

! " " ! #- - "

# - "

061

; < " !#

* A!

## -" ! " -"

## " " ! " ! "

# ( ! - "# 5

D"" #- - 00 1 $!&%$&23$ " $&%4 ##5% 678 $$!& 3 "# 5

": "

" " 9?$( " 5 # ,5 # 25 " 9?$( " " "" - B - " #-" # # " " 7'7<< 4 " &# 80 % %#500 6!5"3!9% 9 &!"8 $$!& 357% 3)) 01 ( "

# = - ><## <@

- #5

0,1

A! " "

"" E

# ! " # 4 9 - E # "5 # - 01 ( & <.

0 "#-1 -4"5 - +))64), # " # #"

& : - & #

# !! " " %

" ." &

3 # & " - ! # #

%" ') " < #

76 !+;;+)',0

34B1

! " :## " " 0

3 4')1 ## 67 " " ##

!- 4

021

' C"D # # "

A @ < %" = - ." . 4"#4?

C" 8

- "89 #-"# ?

:- " GA.9( 9/&A # "" "

"# F?&G$ %? ( ?/( $

- 3

! ?/HG9I & 9/ ( A /9$

A @ < "# @" & G (A? (A?/ <.0.%1 " " # ! 8 (?A % 9/<? #" ! " ?(9?%J -

4+6)*+)', #"- #

%& & " ! " - : !+ + " " # " 8 " : 8

" + " '74)64+)'6= '*4)64+)'6"

# F?&G$ %? ( ?/( $ ?/HG9I & 9/ ( A /9$ & G (A? (A?/ <. 0.%1 8 (?A % 9/<? ?(9?%J "

%% = !

:"-)74),4+)'6 D " -

D " = #- # #

0%& 1 ." & 0% A

<1 & ! /';+2DA<0;1 7'4 )74+)'6 # C % 0 "1 A- 0( A

< A- < 1 8C C9%9/& (A? ?<G9(I

! -

D A ,+7 " 724 <

## "

! -

""-C%? !

:- "

8 - <!

"- < D""

-E- -

- ! 6$%9$%% 0

" $%

" "- ! A @ A

< "# ! " 5 "

E ! "-

0;1

7 C"D<5 #

< 9<% "

" 726D76'D76+D7679< # "

% A

<$ B'*D+))2 :

# -." &

- +))*4)B

" ." & #

- " # # " # #! : " -

##5 ( # # #

- " " D"" - +))* 3 "! % & # !

J /% A

< # - % & "

! # ." & % A

< " #

%& A9&A <CG( C8 %?$A9

<# "

% </ <$?4B'*D+))2 #

7;D+)); 67D+)); !

( F #

! < 9J ( : - <7' +*4)B4+)', ! " %&"

# # "

" - : !+ 6 " C" #

:- "

8 < D""

-E- -

# "

!- # A

4G " " # :-

" " &8 "9 "& " " B4% <

"# " "

# 95#4 " 3 0!61$&1 !" 4 83 % & <# +24)74+)'7 ),4)64+)'7 +B4)64+)'7 +*4)24 +)'7++4);4+)'70% = "

! " " #

1 )64''4+)'7 ! / +)'7'766B ',4)64+)'6 - : !+

0*1

, "%!

<9%

"4B <

" #

D $ /

DK,+788 "4724 < +*4),4+)'6 :- "# ',4)64+)'6 A

- 9 = - !

:- "

8 < D""

-E- -

# "

!- # A

4G " " # :-

" "

&8 "

# 95#4 " 3 0!61$&1 !" 4 83 % & # # :-"

= %

0%! 3 #!36 6 95#4

" 3

89 "

! " " # - : !+ 2 "

" 9 "4'B <

" #

D $ /

DK,+788 "4724

< :- "# ',4)64+)'6 A

- 9 - !

:- "

8 < D""

-E- -

# "

!- # A

4G "

# 95#4 " 3 0!61$&1 !" 4 83 % & # # :-"

= %

0%! 3 #!36 6 95#4

" 3

89 "

! " " # - : !+ ; " # %# <##

9## ?

"54999 $!4 "4' # / % 4''))22 8

"#"

4 ' / 7*,6,;6 ! ',4')4+)'' ''+6;B' !'*4)B4+)+'

- %C +)4 )'4'B*7 #< D C %" 5 A- !

# 77B 9<(C9 % (AC/ GI ?$ CG/? 9<(C(9 7);' 08

"# ! 3 !

9/ 9/%9 # - ! ""

! """#5 # - - # "" 5 # " - " " - - )( " " "# # , 5

" 9?$( " - # . -+)'' "# # " - -

- -

! " " # - " #

%& & <.

." &

0B1

# " "# #1 # D " - 9/%9 # - 5

! -

" "" -

9/%9 "" "# 5 9/%9 - " 3" ""# " " # D " %# 9/%9 !

" - - 3" -

E -- -- ! ! " " "" - " !

" "-

- : "" " - " " - < "

: #

" " G " - # " " - "- "4 3# " "43# # #- 5 " < # "- 3# "

" ! " "

+/&;,';6B6! +64)+4+)'* .;7+'B77! )74),4+)+'

% # %C '64 )74'B*' D # $ D

( 5 A- 08

"# ! 3 !

9/%9 # # " "# #1 +( ":%

" # #

" ! "- - : ! #

0')1

; (# A 9% ?" ! $ + 8 2' < # "466 & A- '++))7

" '?#"!#

5L #"# L"# = ! !#L"#

# 9?$( - " 3# +)''4)+4 '; "- - ),4)*4+)'+ /% # )*4)*4+)'+ /% # '74)*4+)'+ /% # '64)*4+)'+

# --" !#)*4)*4+)'+ ='64*4+)'+ " " " "# 54 %4'= 4,D+ "" ! "# "# "

" ""

"#5 #

"# 5

" " " D 3 3" " " "# - "## - " "#

5## ! 9 "

! - " "5

4 "# " " " "# - "" " " " ""

9?$( "" " "# !

" 9 " "" : !"# - : !+ +

"# "

" - !

< /9/*,, < 4 9% 7*,6,;6 /)+*'); ?3# +)''4)+4'; " 7 ## # 3

" "

M?3# 9?$( M " " 8-+)'' " " 5 # -

" 9?$( "" 9?$( "" 5## ! 9 "

! - " "5

4 "# " " " "# - "" " " " 9?$( "" ! - D"" 5 9?$( "" ""! ! *

# "9% ?" ! $ <C '6B4 ',) + 8 " B4< <

" # "! # 5L

#"# ( L "#=! !#L"#

# 9?$( - 3# +)''4)+4';"- - ,4)*4 +)'+ /% # )*4)*4 +)'+ /% # '74)*4+)'+ /% # '64)*4+)'+

# --" !# )*4)*4+)'+ = '64)*4+)'+

"# "

" " " "# 54 %4'= 4,D+ "" ! "# "# "

" ""

"#5 # "

"# " 5

" " " 3 3"" " "# - "## - "#

0''1

- !

< /9/*,, < 9%

7*,6,;6 /)+*'); ?3# +)''4)+4'; "

## # 3

" "

M?3# 9?$( M " " 8-+)'' "# !

" 9 " "" : !"# - : !+ B

< <$ "

## < < # #"

" !<! ## -"

3# - -

- ! " " # " - : !+ ') # A N - # 5

# "" < <

" "-

## < < - " # "" "

## < " "4'<

# "

D< # D < $ -

L < - - " -

! 3# #

# 6) ! - 5 #

"" "# 5 "# "5 " - "# "

# "

"# A! "

! " : "

" - : !+ < ( (

"# " " M !D A#

L< - = 89 /', +)') D 7+,7+76+;6,*6''7*),)2 9< M

4'*4)*4+)', '' # A N "

3 "# - # # " 4"

! "

"# "! "5 # ! < -

" "

" ! " !" "#

! ! " - : !+ < ( (

"# " "M

= M <# < # "

4+;4)*4+)',

0'+1

'+ # A N < -

. 9< < 0G(1

"#" " M !D

L < - 89 / ''B+)'6D+,4,64,B # " "472< M

4);4)B4+)', -

L "

- - " -

! 3# #

# 6) ! - 5 #

"" "# 5 "# "5 " - "# "

# "

"# A!

3# (

! ": " #

" - : !+ '7 C" # %# < %"

< "4'; <

"%% %- " = %"

""#+)4')4+)'' +4''4+)'' #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ '6 C" # " C

8 4' 4*

/ "5 8C? ( <C $?O

G9$%9/& "42*

" ' %% %- " = %"

" " # +)4')4 +)''+4''4+)'' +

"" 0A1 4* 8 '

8# +)4')4+)'' +4''4 +)''

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5"

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

0'71

', C" # C" 8 4+

" %% %- " = %"

" " # +)4')4+)''',4''4+)'' #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ '2 <5D"# " /

89 /';, +'4')4 +)'' 4'

(

++4')4+)'' =+24')4+)''

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5"

" " (

- (

" "!-

(

" "" " (

- A

4G "" " " " -89 - " (

3# - "

3# - 89 (

! " "

!+ #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ '; <5D"# " /

"# +64)'4+))B #-&#

9 " # 0B*',,;;',;1 / %- /'26D,D D / D+;4)'4 )B <

+24),4+))B <# "

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5"

0'61

'* <5D"# " /

"# ')4''4+))B #-

/ ! %- /7);D,D D / D')4''4 )B / = ++BD,<D D<- ')4''4+))B<

';4)+4 +)') <# "

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ 'B <5D"# " /

"# ''4''4+))B # -

= <- / / %- /+76+D D / D''4''4 +))B <

''4);4+)'' <# "

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ +) <5D"# " /

(9" '+4''4 +))B #! -

"# %- /''6;D(9D)B = # %- /')+);D<D(9 +64''4 +))B

! # "" # " A N< 4

5 " #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ +' <5D"# "% <-4' /

%% %- " = %"

" " - +))B +)') = +)''

"# "!= # = C" = "

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

! # "" # " A N< 4

5 "

0',1

++ <5D"# "

%% %- " = %"

" " - +))B +)') = +)''

"# "!= #= C" = % <-4'

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ +7 9

A H < "4'; <

! # "" # " A N< 4

5 " #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ +6 9 A#

48 4+ # /!# +)''

C" 9& A H ""4B4 <

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" " "

- #"

! !- !"- "

!) #"

" # -"

" "! " :!"- "" ! " "

! " 2,4 ?! " %4 00 0= <%2 !8 &!3$ 0 !53!%5!9!!# 00"!3 &< >$6 &# -$"6 9 6& # %% 3<

# " "" - #" " " "

" #! "" # " "- - - ! ! "" #

0'21

+, 9&#

/;D22 8 4' " 2*

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ +2 A<

/*)D')6, 48 4 +

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! -

!+ +; A<A#

48 4' "2*

# " "" - #" " " " <<( !" #

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5"

" "

- #" "

" <<( !"

! ## !- !"- "

! " # <<( " # -"

" "! " :!"- "" ! " "

! 2,4 ?! " "

0';1

+* A< 5

# " "" - #" " " " <<( !" #

" " " <9 #

- #" "

" <<( !"

! ## !- !"- "

!) " # <<( " # -"

" "! " :!"- "" ! " "

! " 2,4 ?! " +B A<

# " "" 5 "# 5 " " "5 "" #

6 )) )'4''4+)'' " " <<( !" #

" " " # 5 - " " #

'''+)''6 " " <<( !"

! ## !- !"- "

!) " # <<( " # -"

" "! " :!"- "" ! " "

! " 2,4 ?! "

0'*1

# " "" 5 "# 5 " " "5 "" #

6 )) )'4''4+)'' " " <<( !" #

" " " # 5 - " " #

'''+)''6 " " <<( !"

! ## !- !"- "

!) " # <<( " # -"

" "! " :!"- "" ! " "

! 2,4 ?! " " 7'

DC A /*6' 47 4'

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! - ##

! + 7+

& DC A/+'+B 4; " # " "" #" " A N < 4 5 "

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! - ##

! +

0'B1

D $ C#5

D C '7*D', % #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! - ##

! + 76 D"5 # " % 5

5 ''D'+ %5 " +,4% <

<# / A9/%9 )+4''4 +)'' 0

# M<## < 5 &5-M1 " # " "" #" " A N < 4 5 " 5## # "# " % 5

5! " )+''+)'' "

# "- - # "

!+ 7, D"5 # " A (# / '264< = '2, 4*4

<# / ?/&$9 A )+4''4+)'' 0

# M<## <N M1 " " ""

"" 5 #

" " 5## # "# " A (#! " )+''+)'' " 5

# "- - # "

!+ 72

$5 # 0< 1 DK+' "4;' " D9(

"" "# - # " " " ""

"" 5 #

" " "# 5 # " " 9?$( 3# "

! " # #

!" : < ! "

0+)1

7; "5D"# " %- %" C "#(309 !1499< -5

"4+ "

"# "# " 8/ %%9(D9 !499D< DO4'*D+)',4 '2D,+6 "

# ## D " '7'9 "#(3 "'B2'1 " "# " "# ?3 A N < # . +)', "- # " #

-# <# "" # -

" "# 4 ## -"

" " -#"# "" "# (3 %# ( ! " "

!+ 7* % ! %D # 5 ! D K '+ . # $

A <! % - "( =%& #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! - ##

! + 7B <5D"#

"46B <

<# /#D

/B6';+2)2)6= %"#+))*

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" 5 ! " - " "

/B6';+2)2)6

# - " : !

- 5 ! " " - ##

! +

"# 3 - ""

! " ! " " #

0+'1

6) <5D"#

"476 <

<# /#D $ /)';++;)6''2 )';++,6**** " %"# +))* 5 ! " - " " $ /)';++;)6''2 )';++,6**** "

# #

< %" " A!

# - " : !

- 5 ! " " - ##

! + 6' <5D"#

" 9( 5 <

<# /#D

/B*',*))),B = B*;*'7B+6' = " %"# +))*

"# 3 - ""

! " ! " " #

" " < %" " 5 ! " - " "

/B*',*))),B = B*;*'7B+6' # ! # A!

# - " : !

- 5 ! " " - ##

! + 6+ <5D"# 9%? " <4'), 9 4;

<# /#D

/ B*'67)))*7 = B*'62***7B %"# +))*

"# 3 - ""

! " ! " " #

!# 5 ! " - " "

/B*'67)))*7 = B*'62***7B # !# #

# - " : !

- 5 ! " " - ##

! +

"# 3 - ""

! " ! " " #

! # = #

0++1

67 <5D"# / <4'7' ?$(C 4 999

'2));'

<# /#D

)B***,6)B)B = %"#+))* #

! " # # " "" " ! - " " #!" " " " "

! - ##

! + '' 9 ! ! "!:"

! # " "" # " A N < 4 " 5" < - ## "!:

3 #

3$ 0 592 3 $&+$%!":%) 0

" )2)*+)',

34')1 9 &6 3$#50 3%!":$& %% 0 # " 2*+)',

34')1 + ""# " "8 ; " # " <##

9## +6 9A#

P8 4+ +; A<A#

P8 4' "4 2* +* A<5

<9 +B A<

< 7)

< 72

$5 # < '+ ""

- #

" )2)*+)',0

34')1- 3 ##

! # * " ""D ( -: #

0+71

'7 (

" 3 #

01 ( 3# 3 #

"! ! # "Q 01 - " " ! "

: ! "- "" " ! " "

! " 2,4 ?! " "Q 01 9 - < 4# " - ! "# "-Q 0!1

- "# " ! " D"" #- !

# < :

"" " " " ( < #- 5 # < ! : 0!1 ( <5 "-"

" " 3 < : # 0!1 9 "

-" " # " #

< " -"

! "--!" "

'6 ( -"" 3 "! ())

, ++ #

D %7!

%7!