High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5620/2014dismissed

Raghbir Singh Sandhu v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-01-08Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !(*!+, -.

!(*!+, -.

!/01&+&(/0!($0* 22#33!("

4#+'*'

0#"!"# *(5!1!($"0#+'

#'2($#("'

) ) ) ) 6 7 6 7 6 7 6 7

+#'#(")

+#'#(") + ,!3.#(&+$8%!"#9&"0 +*(##3!(!.$8%!"#

+"0#!22#33!(" :::::

:::::

. 22#33!("0!$ &3#$'*&" +$#%3!+!"&(%3!&;&(/ &("#+#'"(!%%*(" $#3!,#$2!,;#(" '#+8&%#1#(# &"'.

&#!++#!+' 2!,.#(#+!3 +8&$#("*($ ./+!"*&",.

3#!8##(%!'0;#("!($2#('&(#"% 0#%!'# "0#!22#33!(".&(1+&# .9!'"0!"0# 0!$ +#"&+#$ !' *1<&8&'&(!3

&%#+ ( = >> ( !""!&(&(/"0#!/# '*2#+!((*!"&(22#33!("9!'/+!("#$ 2+8&'&(!32#('&(9# = >> "9!' *+"0#+"0# %!'# "0# !22#33!(" "0!" ( $&'%&23&(!+, &(?*&+, 9!' 2#($&(/!/!&('"0&;22#33!("0!$'*1;&""#$0&'2#('&( 2!2#+'9#331# +#0&'+#"&+#;#(" #'2&"#"0#'!&$ !%".

2#('&(!+, 1#(# &"' 9#+# (" +#3#!'#$ " "0# !22#33!(" &;;#$&!"#3,(0&'+#"&+#;#("22#33!("9!'2!&$ (

./+!"*&",(

.!++#!+' 2!, +"0#

2#+&$ +; = >- " = >> ( = -

!++#!+' 2!, +; > " >- (

.!++#!+' 2!, +;

>-@"=

>-- !($ + "0# 2#+&$ +; >> " = = >> (

=. 3#!8# #(%!'0;#(" (

!($ $&

#+#(%# !++#!+' 2#('&( + "0# 2#+&$ +;

>>"= @

(= @

#'2($#("' &( "0#&+ 9+&""#( '"!"#;#(" !8#++#$ "0!"2+8&'&(!3 2#('&(9!''!(%"&(#$" "0#!22#33!(" 9# = >>(!;*(" A>.>=>B<9!'$*#"9!+$'

"0#!22#33!("!($0#0!$ !&3#$" $#2'&""0#'!;#"&33

0#+#!

"#+. "0# 2#('&(!+, 1#(# &"' 9#+# +$#+#$""0#+#3#!'#$""0#!22#33!(" ("0#23#!$&(/' "0#2!+"&#'. 339&(/&''*#'

9#+# +!;#$1,"0#"+&!3*+")< D0#"0#+ "0# 23!&("&

&' #("&"3#$ " $#%3!+!"&(!'2+!,#$ +E

D0#"0#+"0#23!&("&

&'#("&"3#$";!($!"+, &(5*(%"&(!'2+!,#$ +E

= D0#"0#+"0#'*&"&'(";!&("!&(!13#E

#3&# F +&!3 *+" 8&$# 5*$/;#("B$#%+## $!"#$

=$#%+##$"0#'*&" "0#!22#33!("!($0#3$"0!"

0#9!'#("&"3#$"+#%#&8#&("#+#'"(!;*(" #!"0<%*;< #"&+#;#("+!"*&",!($3#!8##(%!'0;#("!""0#+!"#

G2#+!((*; +;"0#$!"# !223&%!"&(.&#

"&33"0#2!,;#(" A .

=.@ -B<9!';!$#(

!($

= 3#!8# #(%!'0;#(" !;*(" A .

- B< (

22#33!(" 2+# #++#$ !( !22#!3 !/!&('" "0# '!&$ 5*$/;#("B$#%+##!($"0#'!;#9!'$&';&''#$1,"0#&+'" 22#33!"# *+" 8&$# 5*$/;#("B$#%+## $!"#$

#(%#."0#2+#'#("!22#!31,"0#!22#33!("<23!&("&

7#!+(#$ #(&+ %*('#3 + "0# !22#33!(" 0!'

'*1;&""#$"0!"!""0#"&;# +#"&+#;#(" "0#!22#33!(".( &(?*&+, 2+%##$&(/' 9#+# 2#($&(/ !/!&('" 0&;. 90#+#!'. "0#, 9#+# &(&"&!"#$ !/!&('" 0&; &( "0# ,#!+ >>@ !($ %;23#"#$&("0#,#!+ >>- 7#!+(#$#(&+%*('#30!'

*+"0#+'*1;&""#$"0!"!22#33!("9!'(#8#+%(8#,#$!1*" "0#+#?*&+#;#(" 2!,;#(" "0#!;*("$*#!/!&('"0&;

1,"0#+#'2($#("'"9!'"0#$*", "0##2!+";#("" 0!8#%;23#"#$"0#'#+8&%#1H "0#!22#33!("!($"0# '!;#0!$1##(%;23#"#$1,"0#+#'2($#("'1*"0!$1##( ;&'<23!%#$ *#""0&'+#!'(.!22#33!("0!$'*1;&""#$ !("0#+!223&%!"&(I0&1&"(

( "0# 2+#'#(" %!'#. !$;&""#$3,. !22#33!(" 0!$ +#"&+#$ ( = >> ( !""!&(&(/ "0# !/#

'*2#+!((*!"&( 3"0*/0."0#%!'# "0#!22#33!("9!'

"0!"($#2!+";#("!3&(?*&+,9!'2#($&(/!/!&('"0&;1*" 90&3#!22#!+&(/&("0#9&"(#''<1I.!22#33!("!$;&""#$"0!" &(?*&+, 9!' 2#($&(/ !/!&('" 0&; !($ "0# '!;# 9!' %;23#"#$(

>>- "0!' *+"0#+1##(("&%#$1, "0#*+"'1#39"0!""0#!22#33!("0!$$#2'&"#$A>.>=>B<

( -

22!+#("3,. "0# '!&$ !;*(" 9!' $*# !/!&('""0#!22#33!(""!22#!+'"0!"$*#""0# !%""0!"

!;*(" 9!' 3&!13# " 1# 2!&$ 1, "0# !22#33!(" " "0# #2!+";#(". 2+8&'&(!3 2#('&( 9!' /+!("#$ " 0&; 0#+#!

"#+. $*# +#"&+!3 1#(# &"' 9#+# +#3#!'#$ " "0# !22#33!(""0!' *+"0#+1##(("&%#$1,"0#*+"'1#39 "0!""0#!22#33!("0!$'*1;&""#$!223&%!"&(I0&1&"(

!($ 0!$ %;23#"#$ "0# (#%#''!+, +;!3&"&#'

9&"0 +#/!+$ " '*1;&''&( 2#('&( 2!2#+' 0# !+/*;#("' +!&'#$ 1, "0# 3#!+(#$ #(&+ %*('#3 !+# (" '*1'"!("&!"#$ +;+#%+$!8!&3!13#("0# &3##(%#."0# '!;#!+#9&"0*"!(, +%#!($!+#3&!13#"1#+#5#%"#$ 0#*+"'1#39+&/0"3,0#3$"0!""0#!22#33!("9!'#("&"3#$ "%3!&;&("#+#'"9#

'*1'"!("&!3?*#'"&( 3!9!+&'#'&("0&'%!'# 9!++!("&(/&("#+ #+#(%#1,"0&'*+" &';&''#$

!(*!+, -.

;!0!8&+