← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2801/2017dismissed

Vikram @ Pardeep @ Guddu And ORS. v. Mukesh Kumar And ORS.

2018-12-13Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages





     



 !""#$%$&'"#"()"*+, -$.* ( /$ % *0""1 /$ %2002 !3"*% 11"// &!% -"*%2%

2."%342( *  &!3"*  "%1&0"&!%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

*"%"&!'

* ( &43 *( ,05# !", *!3" 11"// &!% 66666 )(*$+&

 7

* 8"*  $&  !3"  11/$# !$&  $%  *  *"%!* !$&    !3" *"("&!$&"0 "92/ *"#&0 11" /,:3$#3 : %0$%($%%"0*&&7 1*%"#2!$&&+

*  !3"  *" %&%  ("&!$&"0  $&  !3"  11/$# !$&,  :3$#3  $% %211*!"0)8 & $0 5$!,*0"*0 !"0+$%*"# //"0 &0!3" 11" / $%*"%!*"0!$!%*$9$& /&2()"* 11/$# !$&%! &0% //:"0

 11"// &!70""&0 &!%3 5"&!)""&%2##"%%2/$&0""&0$&9!3" %2$!*$&;2&#!$&,:3"*")8!3"83 5")""&*"%!* $&"0*()%!*2#!$&9$& * $%$&9#&%!*2#!$&21&!3"1*1"*!8$&0$%12!"%3:&$&)/2" &0*"0 #/2*$&!3"%$!"1/ & &0$&!3" /!"*& !$5",( &0 !*8$&;2&#!$&$&# %"



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

3"  0""&0 &!%  $% )2!!$&9!!3" %!%$0"!3"1*1"*!8!3"1/ $&!$ &0$&# %"!3"8 %2##""0"0$&1"&$&90* $&,:$&0:%,5"&!$/ !*% &0 1"*!2*"!: *0%!3" : //( *.<!<=&!3":"%!"*&%$0"&!3"1*1"*!8)"/&9$&9!!3" 1/ $&!$,!3"1/ $&!$:2/0%2"*0$$#2/!8$&* $%$&93$%211"*/* &0 !3"1*$5 #8:2/0)"3$&0"*"0 ""&0 &!%11%"0!3"%2$! &00"&$"0!3":&"*%3$1!3" 1/ $&!$,(2#3/"%%%211*"%%$&:*$!$&90 !"0B@=)"!:""&!3" 1*"0"#"%%*7$&7$&!"*"%!!3" 11"// &!70""&0 &!% &0!3"1/ $&!$& !!"(1!: %( 0"!9$5"1"0$9*""! )/")80"&8$&9!3":&"*%3$1!3" 1/ $&!

/ $&!$,$&%211*!!3" 5"*("&!%,"> ($&"0:$!&"%%"% &0)*293!&*"#*0!3"//:$&90#2("&!%'7

,

> ?C $0 5$!  "5"&0"* 42( *   0 5!"&0"*"0  $& 3$% "> ($& !$&$&#3$" > 7 $!"1/ & > ?C $0 5$!3$542( *!"&0"*"0$&3$%"> ($& !$&$& #3$" > 7!>

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

"1*!/# /#(($%%$& > ?CD

293%$!"1/ & > ?C !$#"

> ?C 1!("( > ?C@

"#"$1!

> ?C 18 11/$# !$&0 !"0@@@ > ?C 18 11/$# !$&0 !"0= > ?C $0 5$!3$542( *!"&0"*"0$&3$%"> ($& !$&$& #3$" > ?C  ! > ?CB

3!9* 13% > <7 " !3#"*!$$# !"3 &$&93

-

&!3"!3"*3 &0,!3"0""&0 &!%"> ($&"0%$>:$!&"%%"% &0 )*293!&*"#*0!3"//:$&90#2("&!%'7 >?C $0 5$! *$%3&"; !"&0"*"0$&3$%"> ($& !$& $&#3$" >?C

>?C

3!9* 13% >?C+  >?C=

"#"$1!&";  3!!20$ >?C $0 5$!     *"&0"*  42( *  !"&0"*"0  $&  3$% "> ($& !$&$&#3$" >?C $!"1/ & >?+C $0 5$! &!%342( *!"&0"*"0$&3$%"> ($& !$& $&#3$" >?+C 18*"9$%!"* >?+C #2("&!$&2*02 >?+C+ !%$&0$!* &%/ !$& >?=C $0 5$! ( *. %3!"&0"*"0$&3$%"> ($& !$&$& #3$" >?=C! >?=C@

3!9* 13% >?=C >?=C  >?=C

"#"$1! 39 / 3!!20$ >?BC $!"1/ & >?BC >$%!$&91/ &

*.7<  !

*.7<C+

3!9* 13%

*  ( &  4  3 *( ,  /" *&"0  #2&%"/  *"1*"%"&!$&9  !3" 11"// &!70""&0 &!%  %2)($!!"0  !3 !  !3" %2$! 1*1"*!8 : %  ##*0"0  !3"

2&$#$1 /2%" >++,:3"*" %!3"$&;2&#!$&9* &!"0$%)"8&0 %2$!1*1"*!8 &0,!3"*"*",!3"*"$%9*%%$//"9 /$!8 &01"*5"*%$!82*!% )"/:3 5"9* 5"/8"**"0$&&!$&9!3 !( *.7$&> : %  $!3 .& 5 # &!1/!:&"0 &01%%"%%"0)8!3"0""&0 &!%3"1/ $&!$($%"* )/8  $/"0!1*5"!3"13!9* 13%!3"1*1"*!8:$!3!3"%$!"1/ & &0$&%2#3 #$*#2(%! &#"%,  !3"  $&;2&#!$&  293!  &!  !  3 5"  )""&  9* &!"0  3" 0""&0 &!%"> ($&"0?7+ &!%342( *21! ,*" /%&/ !"3 &0 E /  ""0  ?*$!"*  :$!3  *"9 *0  !  !3"  #(1*($%",  )2!  !3"  % ("  3 %

.

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

*!3"*" %&%("&!$&"0 )5",0&!$&0 &8$//"9 /$!8* 1"*5"*%$!8$&!3"#&#2**"&!$&0$&9% #! &0/ :,:3$#3 *") %"0& 11*"#$ !$&* / &00#2("&! *8"5$0"&#"9*2&0*$&!"*"*"&#" $%( 0"2!,(2#3/"%%$&5/5"("&! &8%2)%! &!$ /A2"%!$&/ :

"%2/! &!/8,!3" 11" /$%0$%($%%"0 / 01,+   )(*$

023 &'/4% *353267 82

 928

*353 51 928