← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2368/2018dismissed

Neta v. Kamal Singh Deceased Through Lrs And ORS

2018-07-11Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages



    

   

      

 

    

    

    !"#$%&'($$) (''#     !"#$ %%&& ***** $) (''#+%  % %%& "($ $ &&) )( $$*

("() $"" + ,* -  + *(

(&" + %%&&.%&((

/()"$&("%(0*&""(&"(

" %&(-"((" + (&,*#(" "$ ""   1 %" +   ""((& ,(#(& 2*") ( 3(#((! &-&   $   

(" ( %%& +   ""((& 3(($2*")!&-&'

$&# "(%& %%%& %%&&"&4!"%"  (# &!-( %( ( 0*&     )($*&*& &" *() 55 /&  &(*"-( #* #(&&)2("%*!' (&" "(($&-&6(#" &"*() 7 () 1 (-!"(&" (% %&(--""%" +( &() "4 (0*& ( &" (# & 8#("'

+  "("  #+ (# &"%"4"( &() "%"

('

*(%%+- $&%%+&((

"4

 () "%" )"9   8#("  )#" + $*+ &- %#(&() ( 3(($ &-&   % $*!   $ &(  $& %%+ -( * &)& $(+ " &- *& $("( '

*(&"-$&("" +8#' &""(&"(%  %&(-)(#(&(* &""$( "(% %&( 3*() $&("(! 4 (&&)&&+ " *&- *&&+! ( $&&*( -( $&("(* (+!)$""&+::/& &&"(    %&((

 -   - (&"  &    *( %%+

" *() 

 /& - $"" (      4  ;* #"   ( "  "  ()    %&((

! 4 (&&)&&+ " *&- *&&+&("*(%%+#("*( 7 ""  17:5   ( "$%" +* 2*")6,&!&-&($(#(&*( :1.7:5 ""  7:5 6 ( $&("  *") " "$  (" ("()()  %&((

4 "()  &( *(&" ()$&(*4 "(*&((

( (&+&)& (3 "  #() !(&( *(%%+'

7:5(&&)&! *&&"#(""&( & (" 3 ".%"  (&" (-( "$#" (&&&)(("( %&(-( )" (&   %%&&  / + "$&( " %(   $0*(& &(   6 ( #"   %%&& $ $ &&) $&("( %$"() + #(*   $( 55   '

 < *   =&"(),&("("#( ;)($!75 (   >  $>  6- "("   ( & "  (# &$(*" ( =("* (&+  4 # ("" -(  %&((

 6  (&+

)! 4 &(0*( " ( ()  " ( (   *( &" (

#* " " $#+ - %(&" () (* %"*$"(% ": *") (&,* =#() "$*& %(  ( (& $"! (&,* $"%& %%&& +$ &&) &&"*()$&("(( & ("   $(#(&,*(#(-  $"*"$(55 $'

,* &  $" $&(   %%&& $ &&)()  *") " "$ ""  7:5 %" ( ,(#(& *( :1.7:5 "" 7:5 ,*&    %%&& -*&" )*     *") ""$""  7:5( "*% *"%$("*%4!*$ "$( () **&&(+"$ $ &&)"+%( ( -( * %#(( ((($!7  ()$"*( () " +-+ &(((6()*" ( %&( ,(#(&*( :1.7:5%"." " #("$"($+%&-( )"   ( () ( "# %(   *( &" " & 

(&+& #() (#" - " "%&((

 ("4($"$"" "( ("*(6( * )*" *(-((*"  7:5! -(- & (&" "+" %$"()$*&("( "$ #"(  7:5!*

($(%# *") ""$""  7:5( *& *"6""((!(()*" 7:5$ &" (&" -  )((" $*&" + (&+& -4

" " "  " " -  &"  4   (  ( ()

 (&+ *& (   (&+ "%(#%6 *%%  ( $(!  &(" *% *")   => &  *% ,*          ! "#$# %"&  %'(')&"#* 6 # "$*& %%&&!%*" %%9 / %($*&&+ *")%" + ,* *&   # %"*$" %$(&+ +   (& ,*( *")-*&"/(#(" %%&&((*" *("?%" ()(#$-)*"'

(%&(" + %%&&( -(&"&" &"*():: /& &&&"( ( #*"*()$&("(   () &+ &" +   ,* + $ &&)  " %" +  ,&("(* ((((( &   ,(#(&,*( )(# $"$($*$! $*  $"*"$(55 $'

 ()!$((" + %%&&-( )"   && "*() $&("( (   & "  () &+   $" + ,* ( () ,*$ &&))( "$""  7:56"(%* &+!4("&(#(&&7 1 *

 # (" + )(#$ )( *") " "$ "" 7:5*( 7 ""  17:5$("  (  7:5,*& %%&&-*&"

(&+$$" %%&&$*&"""*$+#("$ -(  (&" ( ,(#(& *( :1.7:5 "   "   4  =  & (&"  %( * + (& 

$"  * ( ( $(    *") ""$ "" 7:5 (   *&  *" %$(" *% 4    ,*!  ! $( (" + $*&    %%&&     (  &(((  $ &&) *$ *") " "$ + &+() *%

*") => & *%,*(+,*%( ((* " &( &    $"  '

  $  *") " "$  %" "+- ($ *(-((*" (& $$(*)*" &" *")""$ *& *" 6+,*% *")""$- &"   *& *"   -(*&-("- "   - "$(#" +   " % -   & * " -   ("$"$-( )"&"( (" + 

(&" *($ &&) *")""$"* (" %& ( *& *" $+!( $ "! 4 (" &(#   %("    *  +   *") " "$""  7:5-%" *#$ &&)" '

%%&&  (&"  ""*$ + #("$     -(  %*%"&+ (&" +4"  ( * (%(@" $($*$! %%&&$"(#+"#) ($(

    " * (+  '

( %! (  4 "   $+ /-&") *")""$" %%&&($&(()()  *) 4!&(((-*&"  " /-&") 4 "  %%&&&+" +)&!$ &&)

7:5($&&+ " +&((( *$ ! %%&&$"(#+"#) ($( 

$* 9)(( *")""$ #" %&( ,(#(&*(:1.7:5  %(  (" ; )()! %%& (&"($$"()&+ "(("(&(("$ -$$!"#$.   % /0-& A38*&(B    %/()."  +.  % &  +.