High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3302/2015dismissed

Chandigarh Industrial & Tourism Development Corporation Ltd v. Mahajan Tent House & ANR

2019-08-20Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!" #$"% & $"' (% )' *

))%% +"$ ,- . ./ & 0 $

) 1"

1"( 2$)3 ( " ))%%

" 3 ( " ")

!"#$%& '()!* 1"5" ))% " ')%! %!% ")"( " 6*7 ,- . .8")

# (9 ("' ' ))% $)) " :5 ( &"$ . % ,- . . "!$' (3 ))% %% 9 )" ' )" ;

))% %% 9 : :"

$! " " %!% ")"(

,- . .8")

3 $:. .$ <) 3 " )$") )" % %5

) "!%5

' ''

)" - " "

+, -. %%! )" ))% : " ! $"" ! " " :5 $" 9 ":5 $ " " ("5 % :5 ") =)% ") $))%5!

"" '"% : 9 " :%% ;3

3;=8 9" " 9 " :5 "%

$" " " ("5 3;

3;=8 ") =)% 9" %

% % " > ;? )" $'

3;=8 "

' %!

$ %% "%@ & .$!' " ) :5 "% $" :' $:. '"

%%! ))% )""" :5 ))%% :$ ' 9 ' 9 :5 % " ,$!3 !" ( .$!' " A

)" $) :5 ") =)%3 = . & 0 $ )"

)" " ) " ,- . . )%

& ))%%= ( " " "!

!3 "

-"53 $%"5 9" " " )%3 )" "' ) %"

1% " $))%5! "" '"% B%% " $))%5 9 " ) :5 #%%53 " 9 " )" "

"" 9 ' (% $)

;

"% 9 $))% ! )% )% ')5 1% " (" $ :%% $:' ' " )5'

& :%% 9" ) $'

3;=8 9 $

%- 9 ) ,$%53

%(! :%

3;=8 A

$" A

') )5 $'

;3 3 % ! 9 $"5 '

3=8 9 $ & )% % ')5 ) " 9!

$) "( :$ '- )5' )"< " " ( : @ :5 B# ( ''

;

C ;

1% % ) " 9! $) 0!

$" % 9" ' '! )5' %- ,$%53

3;=8 %5! " $ )5:% )% % ! 9 9" ' )"

$ %" C ;

9" :5 % $(93 " 3 !" 9 " ' )5' %- ,$%53

%(! :% 3

3;=8 & ')5 ) 9 ' :5 0!

$" ; "%!! )% - "'5 : " (% $" )" ) ')5 ) 9 $% : <%$3 "' A *' 3 ;

0 $

& % 9" ' '! "!"! (! " )':"3

A %% ' "

)% "

" "' # % ' ')% " "'3 )% 9 %% 9 "- $)

;

# ("" )" !"% :$ )"3 )% $% ( )")" $:' :%%

')% ("5 (=$ 1% )")" %% :%% !% 5 & - )% " " % :%% :$ ))"

" )$") # '9 %3

: ')%3 B# @ " " %$!

:%% $:' :5 )% C

; ;

B# $:' ") " A C

!( ! )% $:' : !$ :%% $ 3C 3;;=8 '

( ))% "

"! )% $:' :%% " " % : " %!

9" ' ')5 ) " " % 3 9 $ :%% '

$! 3;3C " !$ "'!

3A 3 " :

!$ $"5 '

3=8 %"5 : "$ )%

& "

("5 :9 )" % "'!

$ ")"

$ )" A .$!' "% $" & )" 9" )"' $ ( $)) " " ")(

0(! " $% " )" %! '"% " "3 "% $" "' $

( $"

)% 9 " $

9 9" ! ($%%5 $ 9 " "' ": " & ))% )""" :5 =))%% ( $" 9 " ))%% $" 9 " ! " " :5 "% $" 9" "' 9 $ ("

$% " ))%% 9 $% "!$ '' 9

$ :5 ))%% <' $ 5= "" :%% $:' :5 ") =)% & '' $:' ") " )"

( " " 9 " :%% '

$! 3;3C 9" $ : "" " 3A 3 :

!$ # "!$ 9 ( ' $" ( " $%5 "" :5 "$! "%5 $) ") " )")" :5 '' 9 % )! %'

") =)% " " ("5 $! '

3;=8 # $" " $:' ( B# $:' ") " 9 ":5 9 $ :%% (%$! '

" C %- 9" :

# $" " "!$ (9 $'"5 ( )"

$ :5 ))%% 3 .$!' ) :5 $" " %:% : '

$% ")"! ") 3 ""53 $)) " $"" ! " " :5 $" 9 $:' $"3 % " '"% " "3 ( "$ "%5 $) 5 $ ") " $:' :5 '' :-

") =)% # "!$ ( $' "% $) :5 ))%%= : : ") " '' %5 % :%% '' "'"- %$' ! )"$%" :%% : .$ " $.$ # $" " "!$ ")%5 ')5 ) $)% 9 %" )) "

'"- D< 183 " 9 %" ' :5 ))%%= 9 "!"

$! %:%5 3

3;=8 $ 3 !

$" : $% 9 5 "3 9 ("

# ( " $% " )"3 )"$ ))" :

- " "

& " )$ 9 "!" 9" ' % ") ')5 ) % :5 = . & 0 $ # % )$ !" $ ))%% 9"

%" C ;

% $(93 " 3 !" '"- D< 1 # % ") $:' :%% (%$! ;3

3;=8 '

%- 9 ) $"! 5"

8 ;

& " !

" " $!!( ") 9" 5 )"

! $ :5 '' $ " (" :%%3 " "3 $' D< $:' :5 '' : ") ") "'"- " " :5 '' %! " :%% : $.$ & " % '"%

" " $!! ))%% 5 )"

! ! %= " 9 "!" $ 9"

" $))%5 !3 "

-"5 $%"5

: 9 " ") =)% $:' :%% " )5' # (9 '"3 # '5% $:% : )"$ 9 $:' ' :5 $% " ))%% ! " " :5 $" $" "

' ""

" '$ % )"("5 9 $% %% " "(

# (9 9 : $ ": "3 !

'"3 ))% % "!%5 ' %(! )"

:" "

# E " ") ":%

F =