← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2907/2017dismissed

Gajraj And ANR v. Ravi Kumar And ORS

2017-05-26Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi17 pages

  

!"# $#%&'&()* +

!,-!,!($!(".#- //#00!("'

1' !2&345!-!($".#-'

#'/($#("'

) 67873   

    

  

   





 8739 7

 

!

"





"

  "   #

 %

#$   



 &

   ' 

(  )

 #

 %

*  



 



 % +

,  " '"





 



" 

 "

-.

/

)





 !)

 )+    0

 

 +12

 3



"

   4 )+ /

)!



 "

))+ /





 +556,5-   , 

 

 +1*2



 7

 "     

 

$ 

  7

 " 

  4

$ 



& 

8  

$ 

 #

/

"



 

" 

 #  





 "    3

/   

 

 

 9  &$   /

    ) "

#  8  +! .0 )00.

" $ 4  

 :

 "    4

$  8

     "  ;

   4  8 





  4

$  #    ) 



   

 

4





& 





:    ) 

 "

)+ /

)!



&    + 

 "

/

 <-)  . .< +..,

   )-5+

#& $ 

1#2 :    )  

 "

+.

/

)

   , 

 "

/

 )-)  )0 .- )00)

   <)0

#& $ 

12 :    ) 

 

 "

), /

))

   , 

 "

/

 )-  )0 .- )00)

   <+.

#& $

:  :

   /

    , 

&    





:    , 

 "

< /

   -=5 

 "

/

 ) )  )- ). )00!

1#2 :    ,  

 "

), /

   = 

 "

/

 ,!.0  )< ). )005

   )+-!



12 :    ,  

 "

+ /

-

   <

> / ((    ).

), 

 "

/

 )55.

 ), . )005

   )) 0

 12 :    ,

 

 "

/

)<

   )-=)5 

 "

/

 05.

 )- . )00-

   0)!

 12 :    , 4 " ).

/

)0



&

    <

> / ((    ).

),   ! ,  ), .< )00-

   0,<



:

 " 

#    





 #"



 :

 

&"

/

"

#       

/  

  





&

"      #      :  # 

  $"



  

   



; 6(  

&



$   +12

+1*2



   4

" 8     )



? 



 

&

$ 





" 8  +! 0 )00.

"





  

 

     

$  

 5 21#212

12



 



"





   



 



     



#   

&

   '  "

   

 "

& :

   $   "

$     

"

 /"

# $    

$



  

& 

   $    "

#     

 

   ) ,   '

  "

     $ #' 

$    - )5   '

  "



 9   " 

 

%   

"

 ( ) @

     $A 9 +

@ " 8  +! .0 )00.



"





  

    

    #  

"





  

+   

#  

A 9 ,

@

  

  



'

 $ A 9

-

@      # A 9

@

  

   A 9

@

 

    A 9

!

@

   

 

&

 

   "

 A 9

<

@   # 

 A 9

; 

@



   

 #"      $



 3     # 

   4 

$

 7 

        - )5

 

"

 4(     )- .5 +.)+ 

 

%   "

 

 

""

"  #"  

 

%    

  $   

"

"

"

 "

$ 





 

%   " '"

  + .! +.)+

    "



 

$ 



* 3  

 

% "   $   



  '

    

  



/"

 

   "  # 

  

 

%   







 

 



 %   " '"

  +) .+ +.)!

3  "





 #

 

!  "



"

  )

  



  + )- 3 

  





 7 

      

" 



$   







"

  #    3      $  "



$ 



$  $ 

#"  





    #





 

"

 4(  :

 

 

% " $  

  #   "

"

 7  

     

   $



  

#    

 

%

 

     - <

   3      

$ 

 

 

"

 



)5 '" 

 

%  

#     "





 

""

"



#  '"

 

%

$   

$ 





  #

$     

 

% " 

 

 

 : "

 

$



 #     "





 # 

 



 

% "

    %       

 %



  '  " '"



   7 

       

  /

 



   $    



"



 7 



      )  

 



  # 

#  "

 

$ : "

 

$ # 

 



 

%

   "

"

# 

"





 $   

" '"



 

%  "

 



7  /  

"

    "





 9





   #    

4    $

  #"        # $     # /  7 

 



#  B   

     $   

 %

  

 "

  " '"



      



< *

"

 '  

 



 % " $ 4  

   



#     :  

" " 

 



 % ))

)+  " '"

   

 ( 

  



   





 

 

   

   

   

     

  !

!

  

"#$%

     #!  "#$&

"#$    $  "#$ '

 

 #! (!

(   ) *$+%,

( )- . *$+&,  ( ( 

' *$+,



   

      /   !  -

- *"#$+%01  "#$+%0),

! !

*"#$+%0)  "#$+%0, ( (  #!    *"#$+&01,   /  *"#$+01, 1

  !  /





   



     

  



   /

 

   

  

/





  - ! 

  #

 

! / 2$1   %3 4 

!  /    ! 

   -



  

/

!5

 !    /  1  6 

.!  1

6     - 

 





!

  ! 

 /  -

7/ ! 

 

 

 (  

'



   1

6 )



 



 -

! 

 / 





 

 /

     ! 

   2 $- 



  

4 

     !   

(  3 

.!  1

- 

 

  ! 

/ 

  

    

!  - 

 !

  7-/ 

   





  

 

  ! 

  

/ !  



    





 

    -

  /

/  

  

 

   

 

-

/  5  





 



  



   !



     #

  / - 

  %3  





!

 

- 







  ! -

/ 

    





-  !

- 

       8 !



 "

 1 1



/

  2$1 #

 ! 

 /



!  

  )



2$1

   

  

  !

     $ 4*,

*, 

$ 46*,

*, 





/    2$1

   /

 





 

-  - 

   

7



 - 4 



 



-  

  



 



 

 -  

4  / - 



 

  /



   - 



 

  

 

 -

 !

7

    

- 

 !  ! ! 

  

  /



  

  



 (



  

/  !  

   -   - 

/

  -

-   



 







 !

  

  

 





    "

  

  !  / ! 7

   / /  



 

 





 /   

/



/

 -

 /





 !



  - 

 !

/     

- 

 /

    



! 1 



 

-   !





:  /

- 

   /

 

/



 -

!

  /

 

 

   

   

     

 / 

  

# 

        -   



    $ 4%*1,  %*), 



  

     

  - ! 

  #

 

2 - 

   %3

! / 2$1  

   / 

  

 

   

 !;



'"  

  





 !$.4=!-1&'.>!(!".1'!$.!!($".#-'9

;;*9(#.4/"!1#2&!-4/!($".#'9

*  ;  -#5 &(?. !($ ".#-' 1' &-@!0  !($ ".#-'9 

*  +   :+:      

# #  

   3   

 '"   # 

$ 



 #"

" #   7   

  

  

4  

   #

 $"

$   '" 

    



    /

 

 3C#  % !$5!4'4($-!!!($!(".#-1'"!"# !5&0!$4!($ ".#-'9

 : +::9(&( ($&!1'5-&"7!0!(%.!($!!($ ".#-'9

; :  +9"!"# -&''!1'$00&A!'9

*

 +

"!"# !,!'".!(1'!(#'.&7!09

<  +::

@



 

  / #$ #   3D#  %

))

)+ 



 '" !(#'.&7!0D 1 2  "

  

/ 5-&"7!0!(%.!($!D 1

.$00&A!'D 1 2

 "



$ 

 

(

 %<= 

 -

7/ 



 7/  

  

  !!   

  -   "

   - 







/  > / -  / / /!

 

  

/  > /?  / 





 - 

    

  

 ! 

     !



   1/

-@ 



  

   

  

 A *, /  !  



   1   /   

 - 

> / - !



    A *, ! 

  - 

/ ! 

 A  *, /!

 

! 



    



 -





  +

 

       

    

  -

/ - !

   ! 

/!    

    - 

   

     /   *(B (  C

(  

(7    C *1 = 6 ( 63,  D 

  C

-    C *6 *6, ( ,  

: 

 /  -



#    ! -

 > / 

 /! 

   

 -  1

 $!



.

!

*, 1  *'.,

"  '  .  

 /!

!

   

        !

  



/



# - 

  

 

 

 #  

-  -

/   

    

  - 

#        



 -





  !/

  



  /   









 /



 $!

.7 1

 

    

   





!



 /

! / -    !

 $!

.7 1

-

 !       -

  

     $!

.7 1

    -     -   - " ( (  C F 

 

*%6, ( %3

%%

 %

% <  

    -

 / 

-



 

   -





 

  - 

   C     



   "

?

!     





7



  #    !

  

 #

 - 

; 

  > /!   

    

 9  

-

    



! !   /

!7  /

 

   !

# 

 > /  





 

/!   

- 

A

 - 

    



. 2 / 7  .

 F '  * 1 3&3

36,

.  !

 B *1

"=   @ , G9 !

 

  

 

 !

 /

!

   +

> 

/

- 

  1

 $!

  /

      

   

 

!

/

-/

 / 

/ / 





!

 /   /G

6

'! C



H

 *3 *%, 1 "= %, . =  *

1 "= %3/@ ,

G. 7?  



    

-

 

- 8     -  ! G /

>  (   '! .

 F ( !

*4%, *3, +.= 6%  B *1

"=  %3@ , GC !

  

     /!

 =  .>   

-  1

 $! G 1

 '/ 

) 

=-  ) *3% *%, +.= &3, .  B *1

"=  36, G9   -   

 /

-  



+ /!



/

 -  /   !

 



 !!



 ! 



/ 

     G 3  !   #

    



! !7 -    -   

-      /    

  -/ -  . / 

!

   / 

!   B *1  I !

= 6% ( 6 G"

    -    !

 -    

 

 /

   / /

  !  

  

 /



  

! 

  *  :, ! /

     /

   

 9 



 - 

 

  

 !



  

  G

G$

  -     

!7



 

!

 - 

!



   

-   



7   

 

7



      - 

  ! 

" ( D 

 F 1!

.  

*%, & ( 3

 &@

 @G

* 7   

  &



 





 $

 

"

 4( 

 

%

   $  " 

  "   



#$ $

 

"

 4(   $

$     9



   /

$ 

 "

"

 $

 #

: 

#  #

 %

9   



      "





 : "

 

$  # 

  

 $"



 

$ 

 # 

 



 

% 7   

 "

# " 

 

% 

     "





 

$ 



B   

 %



' "

  " 

"

    "









  " '"

      

"

  "

  





  

$ 

"

$  $ "  #

 %

E  &



 # 

&

     %

   &

   "

"





 4"



 '   )..

% %

 7  "

 

 

  3C# 

% !-!A!(!(!,#($-!(!($!(".#-1' 7#='.5A!-,&(&!($ ".#-'9

+ *; 

"

 %"

 

  

# 

 

  %   

  "









$  # 



$ #    

"   #   ;  $



#  #     "





   

  

  B873C + .5 +.)!





@  /"6  F6 @  # F6