High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2474/2018dismissed

Om Parkash Kalia Thr Lrs v. Sushil Bansal

2018-05-21Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma7 pages

!"##$%&%'(!)*

+ !,-!&./!0%! &%'$#1#$#!&#1 ".,23.4 & 55#00!'"& 6#,&2& 2&.%0!'&!0 #&5'1#'"

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

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

#&"%520!"#11!"# ,,#3%&",!"%'!'1#@#$2"%'".#&!0#1##1:!&%@#1!&A>>& 5#,".#50#!1%'3&*".#50!%'"%,#+!%'#1,#!1)!'15,#&#'"%'".#%$# 2; #3%&",!,"5#,,+.%&5!,"".#$'",!$"*;2"".#1##'1!'"&!%0#1 ""2,'25!'1".#,#!"#,&#,7#1!0#3!0'"%$#1!"#1>$!

".#1##'1!'"&"#@#$2"#".#&!0#1##1'> 0!%'"%,#$#%7#1!

"#0#3,!+,+".#1##'1!'"&%',+%'3.%+"3#"".#&!0#1##1#@#$2"#1 !'1&#'1&2%$%#'"!+2'",52,$.!&#".#&"!+55!5#,&$$,1%'30)* **?9 , 52,$.!&# &"!+5 5!5#,& :!& 5!%1 7%1# !) ,1#, 1,!:' ' '12&'1 !'-* 0!"%'2+ 0!B!* AC* !00 !1* +,%"&!,%'!72,".#1##'1!'"&!'1!0'3:%".".#&!+#*'"%$#1!"#1 A>:!&!0&&#'".#50!%'"%,#+!%'#15,#&#'"%'".#%$#2;

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

% & '

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

#@50!'!"%'.!&$+#',#$,1';#.!0".# ,#&5'1#'"950!%'"%&#'1%'3".#5!),1#,'>:.#' ".#&"%520!"#11!"#:!&A>>E ;

0&%'3".#;!'-!$$2'"%'".#)#!,C%"&#0%&! $0%'$.#,".!"".#,#&5'1#'"950!%'"%:!&'",#!1)!'1:%00%'3 ".,23.2"*,*%"%&".##&&#'"%!0,#=2%,#+#'"0!:".!"".# ,#!1%'#&&!'1:%00%'3'#&&.!&";#".,23.2",+".#1!"# #@#$2"%'".#!3,##+#'""&#00*12,%'3%"&&2;&%&"#'$#*"%00

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

# !3,##+#'" , ".# 52,5&# #@#$2"%' !'1 ,#3%&",!"%'".#&!0#1##1E .# 2,"& ;#0: 23." " .!7# !55,#$%!"#1 ".# !,#+#'"%'#1!$"%'&"#!1#,,'#2&0)3,!'"#1".#,#0%#!& 5#,#$"%'".#5#$%%$ #0%#$",#!".!,1&.%5.!& ;##'$!2&#1!&%"%&".#'0).2&#".#!55#00!'"91##'1!'"& !'1*".2&*2,3#1".%&2,",&#""%'39!&%1#".#%'1%'3&2'1#, $.!00#'3# .!7#.#!,1".#0#!,'#1$2'&#0,".#!55#00!'"&*!55,!%&#1 ".#5!5#,;-!'1".#7%#:".!"".#,#%&',$#!'1+#,%"%'".# &2;+%&&%'&,.5,!,".#00:%'3,#!&'&(9 % ":201;#!5"",#5,12$#".#$'"#'"&".#"#0#3,!+* :.%$.,#!1!

. ( )

'+, - ' . )/

3. )

45 6 1

#3,

' 3. 8

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

/ ".#&"!+55!5#,&*5!,"%$20!,0):.#'".#).!1$,1%!0,#0!"%'& 00 ".#&# !$",& 0#!7# " !' %,,#&%&"%;0# $'$02&%' ".!" ,#!1%'#&&!'1:%00%'3'#&&'".#5!,"".#,#&5'1#'"950!%'"% :!&'":!'"%'3E %7 '12$"".#5!,"%#&:!&$2&&#1 '".##@#$2"%' !'1,#3%&",!"%'".#&!0#1##1"%&'"'#$#&&!,),".# 52,$.!&#,"5,7#".#0%=2%1$!&.%'.!'1,1#$0%'%'3".# 1%&$,#"%'!,) ,#0%# .# !,#+#'"%'#1 7%#: +%'# %& 1#,%7#1,+".#,!"%1#$%1#'1%$200#12";)".#'F;0# 25,#+#2,"%'01 2 344$56 74, 8 9 :

#@50!'!"%' .!& $+# ,". ' ;#.!0 ".# 1##'1!'"&'"!55,!$.%'3".# #3%&",!,'>!& ,#=2#&"#1%'".#0#3!0'"%$#:.%$.:!&&#'";),#3%&"#,#15&" ' ,#$#%5" ".# ,#3%&"#,#1 0#3!0 '"%$# $!''" ;# $'",7#,"#1*,*%"$!,,%#&!5,#&2+5"%'&#,7%$#!&5#,".# 5,7%&%'&#$"%'".##'#,!00!2&#&$"E 7% 0&%'3".#;!'-!$$2'"%'".#)#!,C:.#'".# &2%":!&%0#1'C>$!''";#&!%1";#!"!0".!& $+#',#$,1".!"".#&!%1!+2'":!&1#5&%"#1%'".# 5#,&' $!''" ;# 5,#7#'"#1 ,+ "!-%'3 ".# %'!'$%!0 1#$%&%'%'".#+!''#,!'1+1#!&5,G#$"#1E 7%%

#&5'1#'"950!%'"% .!& 5,7#1 .%& ,#!1%'#&& !'1 :%00%'3'#&& ;) +!,-%'3 .%& 5,#&#'$# ".,23. HA? !'1

HA?*%#*".#!550%$!"%'!'1".#!%1!7%"E 7%%% .#!,32+#'",.5,!%&'"!;0#";,%'3".#$!&#

:%".%'".#,#!0+5#,7#,&%"):!'"%'3%'"#,#,#'$#%'".#:#00 ,#!&'#1%'1%'3&!$"!'10!:

,".#,#!&'&&"!"#1!;7#*'3,2'1,%'"#,#,#'$#%& +!1#2"*+2$.0#&&!')&2;&"!'"%!0=2#&"%'0!: #&20"!'"0)*".#!55#!0 %&1%&+%&&#1

;, *)+%

641 '(<=& +1214>7 ?4

@4?

+121 2A!

@4?