Ganga Bishan v. Ajit Singh & ORS




    
 













 


 



 

!"#


$$%% &'(")"

*!+
!

#

,
+#'("


$ 
- ./ %

01
&.
0.  $('"'

+
 (


!
 2
&'(2 3
,45 +'3

(
+#'
66'77

+
8
8
8 


#!"
(')7 (
"'5 7
!"
+
+#'
9'#'"+


9'!

(!'4',

+#'
5 5)(('

+
*),2'

,
,'5(''"
6 ""',
9:
+#'
7'

', 5)(+"
9'7;3
,!"2!""!


#!"
")!+ (
+#'
"

<'

5 4'

!'

5'3
+#'
6 (+!'"
('
9'!


('

'((',
+
6'(
+#'!(
(!!

7
6"!+!
!

+#'
5!4!7
")!+ #'
67

!7',

")!+
(
6'(2

+
!

*) 5+!
('"+(

+#'
,'

(2
!

+'( '((!


!

+'


,* 5'

+
+
#!"
#)"'3
,'+ !7',
!

+#'
#'

+'
 +3
)(+#'(
('"+( 
+#'
,'

+"

(2
6'

:
+'
(
;!

,;
!

( +

+#'
6(!4 +'


;

',
9:
+#'


#'

5+"3

(( +',
!

+3
('
+# +
+#'
67

('"!,'

+

4!77 '
 26)(
 7!:

7!3
'#"!7
;

!
=#'( 3
!"+(!5+ #!;

!

.'

;

"

;

'(

!

6""'""!
('"!,'

7
#)"'
2 (<',
;!+#

-- 7'++'("
 .
!

+#'
"!+'
67

++ 5#',
;!+#
+#'
")!+
+
;

4'((',
+# +
+#'

"
# 4!

+'


2 (<',
;!+#
7'++'("
 
!

+#'
"!+'
67

++ 5#',
+
+#'
67 +
!"
"

!,
+
9'
6 (+

+#'
#)"'


#'

5'
!"
+'



+#('

(2
+#'
,'

+"
+
!

+'( '('
!

+#'



+#'!(
6'


+#(''
+'"
!

+#'

3
+#'
67

!7',

")!+  +!5'3
,'

+

!7',
;(!++'

"+ +'2'

+
( !"!

6('7!2!

(:
9*'5+! "

2'(!+"3
!+
;

4'((',
+# +
+#'
"!+'
67

")92!++', 9:
+#'
67

!"
;( 
+
;

"
,'

!',
+# +
+#'


;

+'
6(6'(+: +
;

"
"+ +',
+# +
+#'
67

6)(5# "',
+#'
67+
(2
"#

# <)(

+# +
+!2'3
+#'


;

"
9'!


)"',
9:
+#'
,'

7"
+
!"
2 ,'
57'

+# +
+#'
67

6)(5# "',
+#'
67+
(2


 *6)+3
+#)#
#!"

2'

!"
2'

',
+
"2'
67 5'"
"
"#

# <)(

"


!

#
;#!7'

(!

"
$> 
+
;

77'',
9:
,'

+

+# +
+#'
67

# "+()5+',

9 +#(2
!

+#'



,
'

5( 5#',
)6
+#'
*!

+

 >#'

#'
;

"<',
+
('24'
+#'
'

5( 5#2'

+3
+#'
6('"'

+
")!+
;

!7', #'
7'

',
+(!

7
5)(+
2',
+#'
77;!


!"")'"
-  >#'+#'(
+#'
67

!"
'

+!+7',
(
('7!'

6'(2

*) 5+! "
6( :',
(
?
$$  >#'+#'(
+#'
67

# 
75)"
"+

,!@5 )"'
 5+!

+
!7'
+#'
6('"'

+
")!+
?
$ A >#'+#'(
+#'
")!+


!"
+
2

97'
!

6('"'

(2
?
$ B >#'+#'(
+#'
67

# +
52'
+
+#'
)(+
;!+#
57'

#

,"
?
$   >#'+#'(
+#'
67

!"
'"+66',
9:
#!"
;

5+

,)5+
(2
!7!

+
")!+
?
$   '7!'



-A- 
6(4'
#!"
5 "'3
+#'
67

#!2"'7 (',
!

+#'
;!+ '""

9C
"
$>

,
'C ',
%''7
 2D
2!(
#

3
(5#!+'5+D !"# 29'(D

,


!

#
,'6"',
"
$>
+
$>
('"6'5+!4'7:
!+'

"
6(,)5',
"
C$ 
(,'(
+
('9)+
+#'
57 !2


3
,'

+


(',
!

+#'
;!+ '""
9C3
9)+
9'

('
5(""-'C

5)7,
9'

,)5+',3
#'
,!',
#'('

+'(3
#!"
;!

'
#

+!
'4!
;

"
'C ',
"
> #'
7'

',
+(!

7
5)(+3

+'(
66('5!


+#'

5+"

"!,'(!


+#'
'4!,'

5'3
,'5!,',
!"")'


"+
+#'
67

,
!

4)(

+#'
,'

+"
"")'"

+

;'('
,'5!,',
!

4)(
 ,'

"+
+#'
67


#'
'+
('")7+
;

"
+# +
4!,'
*),2'

,
,'5(''
, +',
 B3
+#'
")!+
;

"
,!"2!""', '!

(!'4',3
!("+
7
;

!7',
9:
+#'
67


%'

', ,,!+!

7
!"+(!5+
0),'3
#!;

!3
4!,'
*),2'

+

,
,'5(''
, +', E  
,!"2!""',
+#'
7 #'
5('
!"")'
!

474',
!

+
7!+!

!"
"
+
;#'+#'( +#'


"#;

!

+#'
"!+'
67

;!+#
7'++'("
 
!"
+'
6(6'(+:


(
+

5 "'3
+#'
67

97'
+
6(4'
!+
+
9'
+'
;

',
3
 7:
+#'

+#'
")!+
5)7,
# 4'
9''

,'5('',
#'('
!"

,!"6)+'
;!+# ('

(,
+
+#'
6#:"!5 7

,
'C57)"!4'
6""'""!
+#'
('"!,'

7
#)"'"


+#'
67

,
+#'
,'

+"
+
!"
7"
+
,!"6)+',
+# +
+#'('
!"


 "#;

!

+#'
"!+'
67

2 (<',
9:
7'++'("
 3
;#!5#
7'

,"
(2
6)55

"+(''+
+;

(,"
+#'
#)"'



#'
"

!,


!"
,* 5'

+
+
+#'

#)"'

+#'
,'

+"

-B- #'
67

# ,
6)(5# "',

67+
(2


 *6)+

"+()5+',
#!"
('"!,'

7
#)"'

!+
+
;

"
57 !2',
+# +
+#'
,!"6)+',

 !"
'C57)"!4'7:
;

',
9:
#!2

,
!"
6 (+

#!"
('"!,'

7
#)"'

(,'(
+ 6(4'
+# +
+#'


!"
+'
6(6'(+:3
+#'
67

(',
"
$>

('!+'( +',
#!"
57 !2
"
2 ,'
!

+#'
")!+
)+
!

#!"
5(""-'C

3
#'
;

+
97'
+
,!"57"'
+#'
++ 7
('

+#'
67+

,
+#'
('

;#!5#
;

"
7'

+
)+ 9:
#!2
)+

+#'
"

!,
67+
+
9'
)"',
"


(2
6)55
"+(''+
+
;

+ "+ +',
9:
#!2
+# +
+#'
+!2'

6)(5# "'

+#'
67+3


 *6)+
# !4'

5+) 73
6#:"!5 7

,
'C57)"!4'
6""'""!
+#'
,!"6)+',


$> %''7
 23
$>A
2!(
#

3
$>B
!"# 29'(

,
$>


!

#
(',
"
;!+ '""'"
+
")66(+
+#'
57 !2



)+
!

5(""-'C

3
$>
%''7
 2
,2!++',
+# +
+#'
,!"6)+',


# 9''

2 ,'
6)55
9:
2
$

5# :

+
!

+#'
:'

(



$>A
2!(
#



3
+#'
,(

+"2

3
!

#!"
5(""-'C

2'

',
+# +
!

+#'
"!+'

3
#'
# "
;(!++'

"
F6(!4 +'


+
+#'
!

"+

5'

+#'
67

 !2!7 (7:3
$>B
!"# 29'(
!

#!"
5(""-'C

,2!++',
+# +
+#'

 ;

"
9'!


)"',
9+#
9:
+#'
67

"
;'77
"
+#'
,'

(
+#'
7 "+

9)+
A
:'

("
$>


!

#

!7',
+
,'6"'
+# +
+#'
"

!,


;

!4'

+
#!2
!

2!7:
"'++7'2'

7 
;!+#
+#'
7

+#'
67+3
;#!5# ;

"
"7,
9:
#!2
+
+#'
67

 77
+#'
94'
"

!,
,!"5)""!
"#;"
+# +
+#'
67

!7',
+ 6(4'
+# +
+#'
,!"6)+',


;

"
6(!4 +'
6(6'(+: +
!"
;(+#
;#!7'
+
2'

+# +
+#'
67

,2!++',
+# +
+#'('

!"

('!"+'(',
"

7'

,'',

('

(,!



6)(5# "'



+#'

7

,

(2



- -  *6)+


;(!++'

,5)2'

+
;

"
6('6 (',
!

+#!"
('

(,
4'



!

#
!

#!"
5(""-'C

,'6"',
+# +
+#'
7

,
"7,
9:
#!2
;

;

',
9:
#!2
"
#'
55)6!',
!+
;#'

+#'
)"7!2"
7'

+
+#'
75 7!+:
.'

,2!++',
+# +
+#'('
!"

;(!++'

(''2'

+
6'(+ 
+
+#'
;

'("#!6


+#'
7

,

")5#
5!(5)2"+

5'"3
'4'

#

!7',
+
"#;
+# +
#'

7'

77:
;

',
+#'
('"!,'

7
67+3
;# +
+
"

:

+#'
,!"6)+',

 #'
+#'(
"6'5+
( !"',
!

+#'
")!+
;

"
+# +
+#'
,'

+"
#

';7:
5 "+()5+',
+#(''
+'"
!

+#'


#'
"

!,
77'

"
9'7!',
9:

$>A
2!(
#

3
(5#!+'5+3
;#
,'6"',
+# +
+#'
+'"
+;

(,"
+#'


;'('
+
';7:
5 "+()5+',
6 (+
(2
+#!"3
!+
;

+',
9:
+#'
7'

', 5)(+"
9'7;
+# +
+#'
2 (<',
,5)2'

+"
;'('
67 5',

('5(,
9:
+#'

3
(2
;#!5#
!+
;

"
'4!,'

+
+# +
+#'('
;

"
,!"6)+'
;!+#
('

(,
+ 6'

+#'"'
+#(''
+'"
'

(7!'(

,
+#'
2 ++'(
;

"
('6(+',
+
+#'

67!5'
#'('
;

526(2!"'
'

+'(',3
;#!5#
;

"
67 5',
"
2 (<', ,5)2'

+3
!

;#!5#
+#'
6 (+!'"
('',
+# +
+#(''
+'"
;)7,
('2
!

'C!"+'

5'
9)+

)(+#'(
+'
;)7,
9'
5 "+()5+',

,
+#'
6(+!

#'

,
 7('

,:
'C!"+!


+#(''
+'"

+#'
,'

+"
;)7, #'

5'

(+#
9'


7 '
#!"
7"
'"+ 97!"#'"
+# +
+#'
4'("!
6)+

(+#
9:
+#'
67

"
;(

,
+#'"'
+#(''
+'"
;'('
+
';7:

"+()5+',
9)+
;'('
!

'C!"+'

5'
'

(7!'(
7"
 73
+#)#
!4'
G)'"+! "

7 ;
# 4'
9''

2',3
9)+
+
+#'
+!2'
 ()2'

+"3
7'

',
5) "'73
!

"+'

,,('""!

()2'

"
6'(
+#'"'
G)'"+! "

7 ;3
# ()',
+# +
+#'

5+
+# +


!"

+'
6(6'(+:
5

9'
6(4',
9:
( 7
'4!,'

5'

.'

)(+#'(

")92!+"

+#

- - +#'
"!+'
67

6(,)5',

('5(,
6(4',
+# +
+#'


;

+'
6(6'(+: .'
('7!',
)6
+#'
526(2!"'
'

'5+',
!

+#'
67!5'
"+
+# +
6(+!

+#'


#'

7('

,:
'C!"+!


+#(''
+'"

+#'
,'

+"
;)7,
9'

;

',
9:
+#'
67


% "+7:3
#'
5 +'

,"
+# +
+#'
7'

',
5)(+"
9'7;

# 4'
2!"-!

+'(6('+',

,
2!"-('

,
+#'
'4!,'

5' #'
5 +'

"
( !"',
94'
# 4'

2'(!+

('
7!

97'
+
9'

('*'5+',
#'('
5

9'

G) (('7

+#'
6(6"!+!
+# +
;#'+#'(
+#'


!"

6(!4 +'
6(6'(+:
(
+
5

9'
6(4',
9:
( 7
'4!,'

5'

,
+#'
"!+'
67


)+ +
5 "'3
 '

+#'
;!+ '""'"
6(,)5',
9:
+#'
67

;(+#
('7!

5'
 +#'(
!

+#'!(
5(""-'C

3
+#':
,'6"',

"+
+#'

!2


3
'!+#'(
9:
"+ 
+# +
+#'
,!"6)+',


;

"
9'!


)"', 522 7:
9:
+#'
67

,
+#'
,'

+"3
(
9:
"+ 
+# +
+#'
,!"6)+',

;

"
2 ,'
6)55
9:
+#'
2
$

5# :

+
#'
67

5)7,
# 4'

!267'

,',
+#'
2
$

5# :

6 (+:
!

(,'(
+
'"+ 97!"#
+# +
+#'

 ;

+
522


9)+
;

"
#!"
6(!4 +'
6(6'(+:
)+

")5#
'

(+
;

,'
9:
+#'
67


#'
"!+'
67

++ 5#',
;!+#
+#'
67 +
;!77
+
6(4'

+# +
+#'


!"
+'
6(6'(+:3
"
$>A
2!(
#

3
(5#!+'5+3
!

#!"
5(""-'C

,2!++',
+# +
#'
('

'((',
+#'


"
6(!4 +'
6(6'(+:

+
+#'
!

"+

5'

+#'
67


#'
67

5

+
('7:
)6
+#'

526(2!"'
((!4',
+
9'+;''

+#'
6 (+!'"
!

+#'
$7!5'
+
+
6(4'
+# +#'


!"
+'
6(6'(+:3
(
+#'
"!267'
('

"
+# +
+#'
"

!,
526(2!"'

;

2 (<',
,5)2'

+
6(,)5',
!

+#'
")!+

,
;

+
,)7:
6(4', #'
7 "+
5 +'

( !"',
9:
7'

',
5) "'7
(
+#'
67

+# +


+#'


7'

',


5)(+"


9'7;


# 4'

2!"-!

+'(6('+',

,

2!"-('

,

+#'

-- '4!,'

5'
# +
9''

")9"+

+',
+
# +
9''

"6'5!

!5 77:
6!

+',
)+ +# +
;#!5#
'4!,'

5'
# "
9''

2!"-!

+'(6('+',
(
2!"-('

, 
4!';

+#'
,!"5)""! 94'3

97'2!"#
5

9'
5 "+',
)6

+#'
*),2'

,
,'5(''"
6 ""',
9:
+#'
7'

',
5)(+"
9'7; )(!


+#'
5)("'

#'

(!

3
7'

',
5) "'7
(
+#'
66'77

5)7,
+
6!

+
)+

:
!77'

7!+:
(
6'(4'("!+:
!

+#'
!26) ',
*),2'

""',
9:
+#'
7'

',
!("+
66'77 +'
5)(+
.'
5)7,
+
('

'(
+

:

G)'"+!
7 ;
2)5#
7'""
")9"+

7
G)'"+!
7 ;
;#!5#
!"
"!

'
G) 

(
+#!"
5)(+
+
'C'(5!"'
!+"
66'77 +'
6;'(
) ,'(
'5+!


+#'
$ 
+#'(
()2'

+
;

"
( !"',  "!,'(!


+#'

5+"

,
5!(5)2"+

5'"

+#'
5 "'
+',

94'3
5)67',
;!+#
+#'
('

" "

('-2'

',3
+#!"
)(+
!"

+#'

"!,'(',
4!';
+# +
+#'
6('"'

7
!"
9'('

+

2'(!+

,
;!+#)+

:

")9"+

5'3
+#)"
!+
2)"+

!7 '")7+

+7:3
+#'
!

"+

+
"'5 7
!"
,!"2!""',3
#;'4'(3 ;!+#

(,'(
"
+
5"+"  ! "# $ 

%
&

,*