← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2535/2018dismissed

Municipal Corporation, Rohtak v. Vikas Jain And ORS.

2018-07-17Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma5 pages



     

 !"#!$%&%"'()*)*

"0 1 ,,!--'

2!.&+& 2%1&%'" 0!.&  !&,"'3!' &  

      

.!&!' (

.*'%-04-/35"$ !#". 0!,,-%$' 6,,!--' *        8 '& ' ,,-%$ %"'0&9!!'#%-!3+'3!. .3!.: +-!;.!3 4% 0!$ %"'  &!!1%'<.!& ". %"' "# 0!=%' ,,!-'3#". .!$--%'<"# 0!".3!.3 !38*)*,&&!39> 0%&"+. 40!.!9>=%' ,,!-039!!'3%&=%&&!3#".'"',."&!$+ %"'* '5%!4"# 0!5!.=!' &=3!%' 0!,,-%$ %"''33+-> &+,,". !39>'##%35% "# 0!$"+'&!-0%=&!-#/,.>!.%&--"4!3* .3!.3 !38*)*,&&!39> 0%&"+. /%&.!$--!3* 0! !<+-.!$"'3,,!-%&.!& ".!3 "% &".%<%'-'+=9!. '3 0!&=!%& 1!'+,"'".3 "3>% &!-#* ,,-%$ %"'%&3%&,"&!3"#*

%',,!-

"0 1#%-!3&+% #".3!$-. %"' "

0!  !##!$  0  0!  ?+3<!=!'  '3  3!$.!!  3 !3  **  #".  &,!$%#%$ ,!.#".='$!,!. %'%'< "&+% -'39!3!$-.!3'+--'35"%3*'?+'$ %"' 4&-&"&"+<0 <%'& 3!#!'3' '"*%*!*!0&%-3./ "0 1'"  "!@!$+ !

'>3"$+=!' "' 0!9&%&"# 0!%=,+<'!3?+3<!=!' '33!$.!!3 !3 ***

 +% "# "0 14&3%&=%&&!39> 0!

.%-"+. "')*;*)*%5%-,,!-,.!#!..!30&-&"=!  0!&=!# ! 5%3!?+3<!=!' 3 !3**,&&!39> 0!-!.'!333% %"'-%& .%$ +3<!/ "0 1*

!&+- ' ->/,-%' %##,,!--' %&%'&!$"'3,,!-9!#".! 0%& "+. * .%!##$ &"# 0!$&!.! 0  0!&+% 4&%'& % + !39> 0! ,,!--' "' 0!,-!3%'<& 0  0!".,". %"'%&"4'!.%',"&&!&&%"'"# 0! &+% -'3$"=,.%&!3%'A0&."*8):=!&+.%'<1'-=.-&% + !3 4% 0%' 0!.!5!'+!!&  !"# "0 1*+$0"4'!.&0%,4&9!%'<&&!. !3"'

0!& .!'< 0"#'" %#%$ %"'"#.>' +'%$%,- =!'3=!'

$ /;;;

'39>$-%=%'< 0  0!&+% -'39!%'<  -'3&% + !3%'

+'%$%,-"+'$%- '"4 +'%$%,-".,". %"'

/ "0 1'3&.!#-!$ !3 5%3!=9'3%#". 0!>!.*  4&#+. 0!.,-!3!3 0  0! ,,!--' $=!%'1'"4-!3<! 0 3!#!'3' &'"*'3%'$"--+&%"''3 $"''%5'$!4% 0!$0" 0!.05!"9 %'!3'!@,. !3!$.!!,!. %'%'< " 0!&+% -'3%'&,% !"#1'"4%'<#+-->4!-- 0 3!#!'3' '"*'=!-> <3%&0&"'"#&+03'".%<0 %'-4 " .'&#!. 0!&+% -'3&% + !3 4% 0%' 0!.!5!'+!!&  !"# "0 1%'#5"+."#.!&,"'3!' '"** +% 4&$"' !& !3%' !.=&"##%-%'<4.% !'&  !=!' "' 9!0-#"#3!#!'3' '"**& '34& 1!' 0  0!,-%' %##%&'!% 0!. "4'!.'".%',"&&!&&%"'"# 0!&+% -'3*0!=9'3%&.!-%!3+,"'9> 0! ,-%' %##3"!&'" .!#-!$ "4'!.&0%,6,"&&!&&%"'* !#!'3' '"*#+. 0!. ,-!3!3 0  0!3!$.!!#".&,!$%#%$,!.#".='$!3 !3**039!!' -4#+-->'35-%3->,&&!3* !#!'3' '"*4&.!#-!$ !3&"4'!.%' ,"&&!&&%"'"# 0!&+% -'3%' 0!.!-!5' =9'3%&#". 0!-& =".! 0'

 >!.&'3&&+$0/4&$"=,! !' %'-4 " .'&#!.'3&!--0%&.%<0 & ,!. %'%'< "&+$0,.$!-"#-'3* !#!'3' &'"*'3%'&,% !"#9!%'<&!.5!3/3%3'" ?"%' ,."$!!3%'<&9!#".! 0!.%-"+. '34!.!,."$!!3!3!@,. !5%3!".3!. 3 !3*** ' 0! ,-!3%'<& "# 0!,. %!&/  0!#"--"4%'< %&&+!&  4!.! #.=!39> 0!.%-"+. (       

                   

!

      

"

 

#  "   $%& '(!

(   )     

*  +     ,- .

.

, $ / +% "#,-%' %##,,!--' 0&9!!'3%&=%&&!39>9" 0 0!$"+. & 9!-"4* B!.'!3$"+'&!-.!,.!&!' %'< 0!,,!--' 0&.<+!3 0  0! $"+. &9!-"405!!..!3 %'&=+$0& '" #%'3%'< 0& 9!!'.! +.'!3 & .!<.3&"4'!.&0%,'3%'&+% 40!.!%'.!-%!#"#3!$-. %"'039!!' &"+<0 /% 4&%=,!. %5!#". 0!$"+.  "05!.!$".3!3#%'3%'<&4% 0.!<.3 ""4'!.&0%,"# 0!&+% -'3*' 0!&=!9.! 0/% %&+.<!3 0  0!.!4& '"#%'3%'<.!$".3!34% 0.!<.3 ""4'!.&0%,!5!'%' 0!,.!5%"+&&+% #". &,!$%#%$,!.#".='$!'340%$003-!3 " 0!,&&%'<"# 0!!@,. !

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

-!5' ,."5%&%"'+'3!. 0! .>' +'%$%,-$ /;)/-'33!&$.%9!3%' 0!=9'3%&&  ! $*4&=+  !3%'#5"+."# "0 1 &,!. +  %"'"*8;'33+->&'$ %"'!3"'*)**"4!5!./'" !5%3!'$!039!!'33+$!3"'.!$".3 ",."5! 0  0!&+% ,.",!. >& ""3 =+  !3%'#5"+."# 0!,-%' %##,,!--' ".,".

+. 0!.=".!/&,!.=9'3%#". 0!>!.@* / 0!&+% ,.",!. >$"=,.%&!3%'A0&."*8):%&.!#-!$ !3&C

0 +/'3%&%',"&&!&&%"'"#&+%*!*# 0!."# 3!#!'3' '"*/-9%.%'<0/0'9%.%'<0'3 <0+9%.%'<0%'!D+- &0.!&9!%'< 0!,.",.%! ".&* +.!"# 0!-'30&9!!'.!#-!$ !3&1 %*!*4& !-'3*"!5%3!'$!4&33+$!39> 0!,-%' %##,,!--'  ",."5! 0 &+% ,.",!. >4&9!%'<+&!3#".$"=="',+.,"&!".#". 0!9!'!#% "# 0!$"==+'% >*5!' 0! !& %="'>"# E''3 % -3%3'" 3%&$-"&!

 0 &+% ,.",!. >4& 9!%'< +&!3 #".'> ,. %$+-.$"=="' ,+.,"&!*

 0!. E3!,"&!3%'$."&&!@=%' %"' 0 0!%&'" !5!'4.!4% 0 .!<.3 ","&&!&&%"'"# 0!&+% ,.",!. >*0!$"+. &9!-"405!.%<0 #+--> 1!'5%!4 0  0!&+% ,.",!. >3"!&'" $"=!4% 0%' 0!3!#%'% %"'"#  &3!#%'!3+'3!.!$ %"'"# 0!.>' +'%$%,-$ / ;).!34% 0&!$ %"'8"# 0!$ * "+'&!-0&'" 9!!'9-! "3!="'& . !'>, !' %'#%.=% > ".,!.5!.&% >%' 0!?+3<!=!' &,&&!39> 0!$"+. &9!-"4* '& ' ,,!-3"!&'" .%&!'>D+!& %"'"#-4* "=!.% /,,!-%&3%&=%&&!3*        





-+$1> E0! 0!.&,!1%'<6.!&"'!3( !&6"

E0! 0!. !,". 9-!( !&6"