← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3019/2017dismissed

Om Parkash v. Ajeet Singh

2018-07-11Mr. Justice Satpal7 pages



  

  !"# $#%&'&()

 

* +!,-!'. //#00!(" 1#,'2' 3##"&(4. #'/($#("  

 

,#'#(") ,!+#'.!0&-5$6%!"# ,".#!//#00!(" ,2$.7!,5$6%!"# ,".#,#'/($#("8%!6#!", 99999



  .#!//#00!("&'!44,&#6#$ $&'+&''!0 .&''2&"6&$#32$4+#(" !($ $#%,## $!"#$

 /!''#$ :; &6&0 2$4# 2(&, &6&'&( 5 (#/!" !' 7#00 !' 32$4+#(" !($ $#%,## $!"#$ *

 /!''#$ :; $$&"&(!0&'",&%"2$4#5(#/!"57.#,#:;!//#!0:;".#/,#'#("!//#00!(" 7!'$&'+&''#$ ,&# 0;'"!"#$".# !%"'7.&%.!,#(#%#''!,; ,".#$&'/'!0 ".&'!//#!0!,#".!"".#/0!&("&

</0!&("&

&0#$!'2&" ,$#%0!,!"&("".##

#%" ".!".#&'7(#,&(/''#''&( +!,0! ".#0!($'&"2!"#$&(".# ,#6#(2##'"!"# 1&00!4#!".$.!(!5#.'&0!($&'",&%"(#/!"!($".!"".# #($!("7!'&(/''#''&( !'.!,#&(#=%#'' ".!"7.&%..!$ !00#(" +#+:#,' 2($#, ".# !+&0; '#""0#+#(" !,,&6#$ !" &( ".# ;#!,

*

   ('#>2#("&!0 ,#0&#    /#,+!(#(" &(32(%"&( !4!&('" ".# ,#'/($#("8 #($!("7!'/,!;#$ ,!'7#00 "&'".#/0#!$#$%!'# ".#!//#00!("".!".&' !".#,!&&(4. 7!'".#7(#, !4,&%20"2,!00!($+#!'2,&(4

+!,0!''&"2!"#$ &(".,##$&

#,#("6&00!4#'!&&(4..!$+!,,&#$".,&%#.#!//#00!("7!' :,(2" ".# &,'"+!,,&!4#(#3&"&(4.!($!$!24."#,7#,#:,(2" ".#'#%($+!,,&!4#2" ".#".&,$+!,,&!4#7&".20%.!(!#6&5!,.0!$5 ?,&'.!(!($(#$!24."#, 7#,#:,( !&&(4./!''#$!7!;&(".# ;#!,

  !+&0; '#""0#+#(" 7!' !,,&6#$ !" &( ".# ;#!,

* !($ ".# #("&,# /,/#,"; 7!' $&6&$#$ &( &6# #>2!0 '.!,#'5 2, '.!,#' "7!,$' ".# 2, :,".#,'!($(#"".#".&,$7& #20%.!(!#6&2,'2!(""".#'!&$,!0 '#""0#+#(" :#"7##( ".# /!,"&#'5 ".# /,/#,"; %!+# &( /''#''&(   !00 ".# '!&$ &6# /#,'(' &(%02$&(4 ".# !//#00!(" .# !//#00!(" 7!' 4&6#( /''#''&( -!(!0'

+!,0!' 0!($57.#,#!'&"&'%0!&+#$".!".#&' #("&"0#$"@ -!(!0' +!,0!' ".#0!($&(>2#'"&( ".!' 2,".#,:##(!6#,,#$".!"!'/#,".#3!+!:!($&5".#!,#! ,# 0#%"#$ &' 

 +!,0!'5 :2"5 !%"2!00;5 &" &' 

 +!,0!' ?.#7!"  @5 ?.!"!  @*5 +#!'2,&(4  +!,0!' #00 " ".# '.!,# !,.0!$ ?,&'.!(!($ 2,".#,?.#7!" A*5?.!"!'

5

5 +#!'2,&(4-!(!0'B+!,0!'!0' #00"".#'.!,# !,.0!$!($?,&'.!(5 ".#,#:;""!00!($ !,.0!$!($?,&'.!(:#&(4 -!(!0' @+!,0!'5'2:3#%" "&"'!$32'"+#("!%%,$&(4"".#'.!,#<!,#!?.#7!"

5?.!"! 5 +#!'2,&(4 @  -!(!0' '&"2!"#$ &( 6&00!4# C&:!'/2,5 #00 " ".# '.!,#   +" 20%.!(! !($ ?.#7!"  A5 ?.!"!  5 +#!'2,&(4 * -!(!0' * +!,0!' 6&00!4#!".$.!(! #00"".#'.!,# 3&"&(4.6&$#$#%,##$!"#$ @

,+!&&(4.@-!(!0' A+!,0!'0!($,#+!&(#$&(".#(!+#

  3&" &(4.5 7.&%. 7!' /2,%.!'#$ &( ".# (!+#   3&" &(4. 2"   ".# 3&("

!+&0; 2($'3&"&(4.",!('

#,,#$A-!(!0' @+!,0!0!($"".#/0!&("&

6&$# $#%,## $!"#$ @

 !($ !+&0; 0!($ 0# " &( ".# (!+#   + !,-!'. /0!&("&

 7.&%. %!+# &( .&' '.!,# ?.#7!"  5 ?.!"! ' *A " * 5 +#!'2,&(4-!(!0'

+!,0!'!($%#,"!&(0!($7!'",!('

#,,#$:;3&"&(4. &( !62, !,.0!$!($?,&'.!( ,!$32'"+#(" ".#.2'#".!".#4"" .!' 2,".#,:##(!6#,,#$".!"/!,"&"&( ".#.2'#!0'"-/0!%#!($".# /0!&("&

4"".#.2'#!$3&(&(4"?.#+.!($5C#+:#,$!,.#:&4.2'#

#00&  #00"".#'.!,# 3&"&(4.5".#,# ,#5.#.!$"%+/#('!"#,!.0!$ !($ 3&" &(4. 2"   .&' '.!,# " &' '"!"#$ ".!" ".# 0!($ &( ".# (!+#  #($!(" &' @  +!,0! &# ?.#7!" 

@5 ?&00! B*<< @ *8 D

*<<  8

5 <<

8

5 @5 +#!'2,&(4 A -!(!0' * +!,0!'5 '&"2!"#$ &( 6&00!4#!".$.!(!!($?.#7!"

5?.!"! @@5+#!'2,&(4

+!,0!'5'&"2!"#$&(6&00!4#!&!($@-!(!0' A+!,0!'&(?.#7!" 5 ?.!"!

5 !($ 5!($(70!($+#!'2,&(4@-!(!0' B+!,0!'&' ,#+!&(&(4 7&". ".# $# #($!(" !

"#, ".# '!0#   0!($ %+/,&'#$ &( ?.#7!"   5?.!"!

5  !($0!($+#!'2,&(4@-!(!0' *+!,0!'5 '&"2!"#$&(6&00!4#!".$.!(!5#.'&0!($&'",&%"(&/!"".!' 2,".#,:##( !6#,,#$".!"".#$# #($!(".!$"",!('

#, +!,0!0!($&( !62, ".#/0!&("&

5:2"".#$# #($!(".!'("",!('

#,,#$".#'!&$0!($!($.!':##( !6&$&(4".#",!('

#,((#/,#"#=",".#".#,# 0!"0;,# 2'#$"!%%#$# "".#4#(2&(#,#>2#'"' ".#/0!&("&

( !($!0'".,#!"#(#$" !0&#(!"# ".# '!+# " '+# ".#, /#,'( .2' ".# '2&" 7!' &0#$ :; ".# !//#00!("</0!&("&

 #'/($#("8$# #($!(" %("#'"#$ ".# '2&" :; '/#%& &%!00; "!-&(4 ".# 4,2($   ((8+!&("!&(!:&0&";   ".# '2&" ( !%%2("   +&'83&($#, !($

@  ((83&($#,   (#%#''!,; /!,"&#' " 7!' ".# '/#%& &% %!'#   ".# $# #($!(" ".!".#7!'(".!6&(4#=%#''0!($+#!'2,&(4 +!,0!5!'!:6# #"!&0'   ".# ,#'&$#("&!0 .2'#' !00&(4 " ".# '.!,#   ".# /!,"&#' 7!' (!,,!"#$&(".#7,&""#('"!"#+#("!'+#("&(#$&(/!,! ".#32$4+#("!($ $#%,## $!"#$

 /!''#$ :; ".# ",&!0 2," 7.&%. !,# (" :#&(4 ,#/,$2%#$ ,".#'!-# :,#6&";"7!' 2,".#,'"!"#$".!"+"20%.!(! $&'",&:2"#$.#,#("&,##'"!"#"!00".# 2,'('7!($!.!0 !%,#' 0!($ !".!"4!(!($'B5 <8 +!,-#",!"# E!%,# 7!'4&6#("".#/0!&("&

7.&0# 4&6&(4 ".,## !%,#' :; +" 20%.!(! " ".# $# #($!(" " 7!' ".2' /,!;#$".!"".#'2&":#$&'+&''#$ #/0&%!"&( 7!' &0#$ :; ".# !//#00!(" !($ ( ".# :!'&'  /0#!$&(4'5".# 007&(4&''2#'7#,# ,!+#$:;".#0#!,(#$",&!02,")8

 F.#".#,".#/0!&("&

&'7(#,&(/''#''&( ".#'2&"0!($G

 F.#".#,".#/0!&("&

&'#("&"0#$"!$#%,## ,/#,+!(#("&(32(%"&( ",#'",!&(".#$# #($!(" ,+!0&#(!"&(4".#'2&"0!($G   F.#".#, '2&"   ".# /0!&("&

 &' (" +!&("!&(!:0# &( ".# /,#'#("

,+G @  F.#".#,".#/0!&("&

.!'(%!2'# !%"&(!($(0%2'8'"!($&"

&0#".#/,#'#("'2&"G B  F.#".#, '2&"   ".# /0!&("&

 &' :!$ , ((83&($#,   (#%#''!,; /!,"&#'G A  F.#".#, ".# /0!&("&

 .!' (" !

&=#$ ".# /,/#, %2," ## ( ".# /0!&("G   #0&# H C#!,(#$",&!02,"(%('&$#,&(4".# !%"'!($%&,%2+'"!(%#'  ".#%!'#$&'+&''#$".#'2&" &0#$:;".#!//#00!("8/0!&("&

(

"

B  &'5 &("#,8!0&!5 :'#,6#$ ".!" ".# /#,'(' 7. 7#,# ! /!,"  !+&0; '#""0#+#(" 7#,# (" &+/0#!$#$ !' ! /!,"; C#4!0 .#&,'   !& &(4. 7#,# (#%#''!,;/!,"&#'"".#'2&":2"7#,#("&+/0#!$#$"7!' 2,".#,:'#,6#$ ".!"".#!//#00!(" !&0#$"/,6#".!"".#$# #($!("8,#'/($#("7!'.!6&(4 0!($ +#!'2,&(4  +!,0! &( #=%#''   .&' '.!,# !' /#, !+&0; '#""0#+#(" //#!0 /,# #,,#$ :; ".# !//#00!(" &+/24(&(4 32$4+#(" !($ $#%,##$!"#$

7!'$&'+&''#$:;".#$$&"&(!0&'",&%"2$4#6&$# &+/24(#$ 32$4+#(" !($ $#%,## $!"#$ *

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

'.20$.!6# :##($#%,##$!($$# #($!("8,#'/($#("$&,#%"#$"",!('

#,".##=%#''0!($   +!,0! &( .&' /''#''&( " ".# /0!&("&

8!//#00!(" " &' ".2' /,!;#$".!"".#!//#!0:#!007#$5&+/24(#$32$4+#("'!($$#%,##':#'#" !'&$#!($%('#>2#("0;".#'2&" &0#$:;".#!//#00!(":#$#%,##$".,24.2"  .!6# .#!,$ 0#!,(#$ %2('#0

, ".# !//#00!(" !($ ,#'/($#("<%!6#!",&0#.!':##(/#,2'#$

A  #0!"&('.&/:#"7##(".#/!,"&#'&'("&($&'/2"#C#!,(#$",&!0 2,":'#,6#$".!"".#/0!&("&

57.&0#!//#!,&(4!'F 5!$+&""#$".!"!/!,"

,+ 2,'('!($(#7&$75!&&(4..!$"7$!24."#,':2"".#;.!6# (" :##( &+/0#!$#$ ,#6#,5 ".# %&,%2+'"!(%#' !($ +!((#,  $&'",&:2"&(   ".# ".,## ,#'&$#("&!0 /,/#,"&#' &' (" ,#6#!0#$ !+(4'" ".#

!+&0;+#+:#,'&'"#,' ".#!//#00!("7#,#("#6#(/,#'#("!"".#"&+#

!+&0;'#""0#+#("F I&0#&(4.#=/,#''#$.&'&4(,!(%#!:2"".#"#,+' !($%($&"&('#"% ".# !+&0;'#""0#+#("!00#4#$".!6#:##(!,,&6#$!" C#!,(#$ $$&"&(!0 &'",&%" 2$4#5 (#/!" !

&,+#$ ".# ",&!0 2," 6#,$&%" 7.&0#.0$&(4".!"".#!//#00!("%20$("/,6#".#"#,+'!($%($&"&(' ".# !+&0;'#""0#+#(""%20$(":#/,6#$".!"".#$# #($!("7!'.!6&(4 #=%#'' 0!($   +!,0! &( .&' /''#''&(  C#!,(#$ $$&"&(!0 &'",&%"2$4#5(#/!".!''/#%& &%!00;:'#,6#$!'2($#,)8 J"&'!//!,#(" ,+/!,!!($@ /0!&("".!"".#,#&' %(",!$&%"&(' !:2" ""!0 0!($ &( ".# (!+#   /0!&("&

 !($ #($!(" 2,".#, !' /#, 7( %!'#   /0!&("&

 !' /0#!$#$ &( /!,!  ".!" !

"#, /!,"&"&(   0!($ &( !+&0; '#""0#+#(" ""!0 0!($   ,!.0!$ !($ ?,&'.!( %+#' "  -!(!0 !($ @ +!,0! 7#6#,5""!0'.!,# ,!.0!$!($?,&'.!(&'* -!(!0F.; ".#; 4"  -!(!0 @ +!,0! 0!($ +,# ".!( ".#&, '.!,#G 7 +2%. 0!($ 7!' ",!('

#,,#$ :; $# #($!(" 3##" &( ".# (!+#  ,!.0!$ !($ ?,&'.!( &( 0&#2   .!6#0&G .#,# &' ( #=/0!(!"&( /2" ,7!,$:;/0!&("&

 " &' !0' (" %0#!, ,+ /!,!  !($ /!,! @  /0!&("!'".7+2%.0!($%!+#&(".#'.!,# $# #($!(""&' !0'("%0#!,!'"7.;$# #($!("",!('

#,,#$0!($+#!'2,&(4A -!(!0 @ +!,0! &( ".# (!+#   /0!&("&

 6&$# $#%,## $!"#$ @

H

  $(" &($!(;+#,&"&(".#!,42+#(",!&'#$:;0#!,(#$%2('#0

, ".# !//#00!(" ".!" (%# ".# !+&0; '#""0#+#(" 7!' !$+&""#$ :; ".# #($!("5 ".# '!+# '.20$ .!6# :##( .(2,#$ !($ ".# $# #($!("8 ,#'/($#("'.20$",!('

#,".##=%#''0!($ +!,0!&( !62, ".#/0!&("&

8!//#00!("(#=",#+#0;'&+/0&'"&%!,42+#(".!':##(,!&'#$".!" ".# 0!($ .0$&(4 '.20$ :# $&6&$#$ &( #>2!0 '.!,#' !' /#, ".# '!&$ !+&0; '#""0#+#(" .24. !"",!%"&6# !" &,'" 02'.5 ".# !,42+#(" &' $#6&$   !(; +#,&""7!' ,".#!//#00!("8/0!&("&

".!6#0#$'/#%& &%#6&$#(%#(,#%,$ "/,6#".!"".#$# #($!("8,#'/($#(".!$4"0!($&(#=%#''"".!" .&' '.!,#"&'("&($&'/2"#".!"%#,"!&(",!(' #,'.!6#:##(#

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

,#+#("&(#$5".&'!//#!0:#&(4$#6&$ +#,&"5 &'$&'+&''#$7&".(,$#,!'"%'"'   

   



'.7!, !"#!"$%&"'()*+,$"'%-*"./0"%, - !"#!"$$"&-$#'1"/0"%, -