Suncity Buildcon Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana And Others

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -1-



   
  








 

 


 

 



! 
 
"
#  


   

$
! %
&

 

 



! 
 
"
#  


'

 

 
&

 

 



! 
 
"
#  


  

()


 



! 
 
"
#  


 ! "#

 $
$%

&$$

  "#

$ $
$  
$



  *
(+"
" ,
 
(

-

*
!  "
.#,
*
"  
 ,

*
/0+,
(,

"
# 


1)
/
2

 '

*
 #
.,
(
 
*
(+,
(,

"
# 

1)
/
34,
23
 
324

 '

*
5 "
"6,
#
(
. ,
!  
  



5"

 
#

" %


##

-
"
# 

# %


"
#
7

- 
"
"


CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -2-  

"

 
 
&
-
! 8-
"
# 

1







 

 



9:
11
3  



 
 

"
#  
"

 
"
"

+
#
-
"
# 
 

-
"

&%  
7



"
,
",
6
6

-

"


#

1)
/ 2

 '

'

 
 
 
## %

"
# 

1)
/ 2

 '
"


6
-  
5"
# 
 # 
;

 


 
 
"
# 

 %%

"
- 

# %
 
 



#&
 
%
 
"
! 

(
5<
(,


'
9" 

-


="
(


'>:


 #


5"
! 

(
5<
,


'
9
",
?"
(5
8:
"
-
 
 
"
(
-
"

.  
 

 #

" 
 



"
(5

"
-
 
6""


 
6"
"
 #

#



"
(



'

( %,

#



"
(5
,

 
 
%
 
"

,

-

#
<
@
A

"


 


-

<

"
  ( ,
"
# 
"
-
%
 



"
(5

 
 %
"
-
# %
<
@
A





< %
"


"
 


 #

 5"
.  

! 
 
"
! 
( 
5<
1 # 
" 

1 ,
 2
9" 

-


="

" >:





2



<#
"
<,
 

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -3-  
# 

"

 
"
(



'


 
(
#

'

"
" ,
"
" 
6
-
##-


 
6""
"
"

"
"

%

 #

" 
 



"
(5

5"
" 
6
##-
#
'

'


7
6
-
##

B
1
'
9:
 
9:

"
" 
6""

 

"
# 
##
 


  ;
=$'()$'*)+)
  

               

    



   ! "##$%
"  

    

        

 

    &         

 

    &'

   

          

  &  



%( 1

9:
 
9:

"
" 

6
"
 #

-,
6""


  ;
!"
#
  $
%
   &  

  

        & ' '  

 

  

       

    &&

 

 ) 

 '     ' 

   &   

       *% +     &         

   '

 &   

   ' , -             & 



       '        

  

 

   '     

   

    &  

& 



CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -4-   '

 

   '         

    

%
" .     & '

 '     

%  ' 



 '

 

   ' '/

     %              

  ' & 

       

     

   '    '/  
   ' 



 '

0 ' 1 

%



    

0

      '

        '

0     ' 



%
5",

#
1
'
9:,
"
" 
6
##-
#

"

"
  

#  %

"
 
 

"
  

6
#  %
-
 
"
 
"
(

 
1

6
7
 
 
"

"
 
6"
"

#
"
  

 




"
(5

6
-
 

%
"
- 

"
" (
#
1


"
" ,

 
# %
 
"
" 
"
#

6,



<,
 

# 

"
- ,
-
6

 
 
  ,

 #

  
@
A

"
 
%%%
  ,


-

"
- 


 %
"
,
6"


 
+ 
 %
6"

"%
@
3A,
",
- % %
"

 

-
#



3A

"
  


-

"
- 


 %
"

(
#
1
9:

"
" ,
 
<
  


"
&  

"
<
-
"

-
 

6

-
&
% 
 
"
<
-

"
<#

"
"
5"
" 
6

<#
6"
 


"






2,

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -5- "6,
1

9:

"
" 




C
6
-,
6""


  ;
2
" .           &   '

 '      

%    '   

 '

 

   '  '

   %          

 ' & 

      

  

  '  '/

 
     '  



   '

0   

   '  



% 



       0

    '

        '

0      '  

%3

7
6
- 
-
 
 
 

"
# 
"

 & 
 %

1
'
 
1


"
" 
6

"

"
 
6
%-

##

"
" 
 
#

  
@
A

"
 
%%%
  ,


-
$

"
  

"
 
"
- 
 ,
"

+
- 

"
" 
 
"%
"
-





A
5",
"


! 
"%"
"
 #% 

"


"
  
-


"
 
#

 
 
 
## %

"
# 
"
- 
"
6"
"

"

"


A
6"

#
,

 

 
<
  

<
"
"
-
#
-
"
 

#
"


! 8-
"
# 
1


%

9#:

"
 

"
  
6




(

 
(
23

"
1 

7  

 
 # 
D
 


 
##
 
"
   
" 
 

 #% 




C,

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -66""
6
"




C

C,
"
#  
 
"
# 
 



3,'

,3,C4E;



 
 

"
# 
"
- 
"


& %
"

  
#-
 
"
" ,
"
<
  

-

-
 
 


#
1

9:

"
" ,

  


C,
 
-
 

"
 ,
",
- %
%%
-
"
 #% 
1

9:

"
" 

% 

6

-,
"
# 
"
#
"
6
# 
 %
"



-



(
23

"
1 
 
",

 '

5"
 #% 





C
6"-
"
 

 
7

-
# 

"
"

  %
 

 


"
,
"6,
"
  

  

 
 

"

"

"
"
 

B

-
#
 

&  

"
<
-

"
   %
 3 )
"
"
 
 

"
# 2 )
 
"
"
" 
"
-

##-


 
6""
"
"
#


#

"
 #

" 

 



"
(5

5",
"
6"
"

#

 #

" 
 



"
(5

 
6
# %
@
A

"
%%%
  ,
6
-
#


 %
#
;F;
"
6"



#
"
  

 
"

#
 



"
(5

7



"
"

"

"


 #
@
A
6"
#




CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -7- C 7


?

9#:
! 8-
"
# 
1
"
"
 ,/ 4%    '  &%5 '



' 

        

'



 %.

        

   &  

 % 6  7      8$     

    

  ,/ 3!

,/
9    &   

     

     

     

      

  

%
"9   & 

   

      

*     ' 

 

  %
$ . & &     '/


 
"  &     

0

 '

   '/


  '/


"     

   

    0

  

%
5

   '/


'/


"  0

   '/


$  

        

  



'

    

    

       

    & 

      

   '

                

   

                     

 0

%3

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -8-  %   "8:   ;  5

      '

   

'  % 5         &   &         '



    

 

'

  



 % "#% 5   '                 ' '  &            '  *  '

   % 5      '

   

     

   



 &    <0  

=

 

> '

  %    ' 

 ' &   1       ; 5 %( 4 5",

"
 %

"

&%  ,


-
 
"
"
  

6
 
1
9:

"
 2
" 

+


 &
 "

 



"
 
 
 &-

" %

<
7
+



 
 

- 
"
 
6"
"

-
" 
# %
"
<
6""

 %

"
 
6"
"
-
%
# %
@
A
<

 




"
(5


7
1)
/
34

 ',

"
-

"
"
# 
"
##
 
"
" 
6"
%

  

"
G  
H


';



 '; 


G

51;
5"

##

6

#

 


"
#  

 

"


"
# 

"


#


<

  





3,23,C ,2 E;
-
-
"
 #% 


C

C,
#  
 
"
 
"
 

"
<
  
 

#
1

9:

"
 2
"

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -9-

7


"
"
# 

1)
/
2

 '
"

"
"
"
##
 
"
" 
6"
%

  

"
G  
H



C;

4

 '; 

G
51;
5"
##
6
#
 
"
#  
 
"
"
# 
"
#
<
  



3,'

,3,C4E;
-
-
"
 #% 


C

C,
#  
 
"
 
"
 

"
<
  
 

#
1

9:

"
 2
"  7
1)
/
23

 ',

"
-

"
"
# 
"
##
 
"
" 
6"
%

  

"
G  
H


';



 '; 

G
51;
5"
##
6
#
 
"
#  
 
"
"
# 
"
#
<
  



2,4',4 ,CCE;
-
-
"
 #% 


C

C,
#  
 
"
 
"
 

"
<
  
 

#
1

9:

"
 2
"  7
1)
/
24

 ',

"
-

-
"
# 
"
"
# 
 # 
"
##
 
"
" 
6"
%

  

"
G  
H


2;

C

 '; 

G
51;
5"
##
6
#
 
"
#  
 
"
"
# 
"
#
<
  



4,3,'3,C43E;
-
-
"
 #% 


C

C,
#  
 
"
 
"
 

"
<
  
 

#
1

9:

"
 2
" '

7
6

"

6


?

9#:
-
! 8-
"
# 
1,
6
 
"
1
9:

"
 2
" ,




(
23

"
1 

7 ,





 -
"
#  ;



  
6""
 
"
-
#


CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -10- <

"

<
#-

 

"
 2
" 
6""
"
-

##-
#
5"
  
#


"

-

 
6"
6
 
-
"

6
(
23

"
1 

7 


  ;
,-.)

C

-


 %
"
6 %
#

"
1

  ;
=



       0

   '

    '

0 

   '  

>
2 "
#

"
 

1

9:

"
" 

"


-
  

(
23

5"
1 

7 
 
 

"
6

<#
-
! 8-
"
# 
1


%

9#: ( %,
"

& %
"


 



C
 
##  


C

C
 #% 


"

6
# 

CWP No. 22260 of 2023 2024:PHHC:052658-DB -11-   %
"
 

"
<
<
  
#

-
"

B"
 


 


"
"
"
# 

 

"
 

"

 
5"
6

-
 


 

#


"

 
5"
<

#  

 
"
-
 
6"

#


6+
" ",
 %
6""
"
 
@
A
"
-
#-

"
 
  



"
 
B

-
#

"

C 5"
6
# 

6
 % 4 (
#  %
## 
"
 
#


/
 $%

&$$

  ;<==  $  
$

%$   )""
#+ %E 
HE/
)""
#-
HE/