← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22316/2023dismissed

Harpreet Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2025-12-09Mr. Justice Namit Kumar25 pages



         

            



 !"





#$ %  "

 

 

     

&! %' ()   "*&

# "



  ('

+, *&&-*$ %     

  ."



 "

 /  "

0 $   # "

  %'  #  !  "

 

  

    & 

  12  #  "



#3 *

/ ! 0 #   #4

" ! "



   5   6& 7  8*     0" "  "



 

 #  "



 "

%



, 

  ."

% ##

*

"

%



  "



*

"

 "

$ %%    ,,

6"

 #

 #   

9,,

:8  

      

  #  "

 

 #  ;  <! 

  6  8    "

 =  ,   #     = ,    "

'

*$ %  ."





# %,

# 

 

0

 > ."



  %,

    

 # "

 %



 >  

*"

 %,

 "

 

  "

  ,    6& 7 8."

#

*

 "

 0



     

 

 ;   <! 

  6  8*   

  ,  



   6& 7 8 "

$   5  6& 7 >8

 "



?

("

 ."

#

*"



 )/( "

+ *=

  )  *0"

"

$     6& 7 8."

#

*  ##  # "



?

("

 

/  "



   %,   ##   % "





 "

 %,

 "



,   6& 7  8

  "



 ##  *"

 %,

 "

@3 A#    ! !



" ,  "

    "

   ,  0

## 

"

 

   %$    "

   # 

  #  "

 "

  





* "

=  ,  

  

  "

=

  ( !

#  # 

# "

"

  



# "



1  

 

  3  "

   # 

  

  

  2  *  "

 =

 

( !

*

"



 "

 @3 A

   

 *>*>5B># 3    *5 

 

+"

 -     ! !



 "



    #

"



  

*  

   A 

   "0 

   

  6& 7 8  "



 

 0"'"



 

%

 

, 



"

"

  

 %  "

 ,  

  !

!



" , "

  

#,."



  %,

 '

  6& 7  8  "

 "0

    

 5 6& 7 8* "



 

# "



 "

%



, 

 "

! "

 "



 "

  

%  "

 !

#@3  !



" ,

 "

 , ##  !"

 

 

 >  0"   %,

! "

  

#, 



"

=  ,  #  = ,    "

'

   ."



 "

%

 ,! %' "



   "

 





 

'%'0 '#  ##  #"+ 

 !"

"

"

*"

#<! 

* "

'



$*% / *=  ,  #

 = ,    "

'

*$ %*% "

##

 

A    *  "

 %

  #  *  0"

   "

 %

 

  "

 "

,,

"



 , 

#  ,    "



# ; <! 

6  8      , 

# "



#$ %& ,,, 

0

  %' "

,,

 =  ,  #

 



 6  =  ,  8  0

 , 

 

 A =  ,  #

 !."



 0

 

=  ,  #

   = ,      "

'

 6 =B  =  ,  8  

 !'*   ,  



   # "



#;  <! 

6  80



  "



  !0 " "

 

#  

 ,

  '* 

#   # 

#"

 





# "

  

  



; <!  6  80



    "

 =

   ( !

*  

*     

  

2  6& 7  8*  ,



  =  ,   "



  "

  #    

  #  *

* @3 A

      *>*>5B>#3

 

+"

 -  0

 !

 !



 "



   "

,    ."

#

* "



    ,   !"

  

#, "

=  ,  #C !

 C !

&## *$ %  "

    ,  *     

  

      6& 7  8*  "

$



 "



    ,   "

 # "



 "



"

# #  !@3 0"   ' !# "



#; <! 

6  8*"



 

 "%   

0 "  "

 !"

#  A5# "

   ,  

."

#

* "



  =  , 

 "0

 

     "



   ! " , 

"



  "



,  # "

,

#   !

 ! "

   #, "

=

  ( !

*

."



   %,

  "

  '  

    *  0"

%'  "

 "

 ,

 "



 "

 , # ' !# "



#; <! 

6  8*"

0

   "

/0 !

# "

 !

# "



@3

!



" ,."



 '0

#0    "

    

 

#  *

*  



 5  *#,, 

1  ."

      

   #    *  

*     

  

 2 6& 7  8* 

 "

 ! 

!

 @3

A  

    *   !

  !



 "

 

 *  "

3

!

!D##  

    

    *   *  > B >   "

"

# "





#/ ."

 > * "



  

% #

"

   0

 

 

 #

"

# "

 "

% %   ." *    

  "

 "

 

   0

   /0 !

 # !

#@3  !



" ,% "



,

# #, "

  =  ,  0"   ' !# "

- ,  $%3 "

# "

%



 "

 "



 #    

#,   >   "

#

* 

#

     

"

 , # 

! "

#

 *"

  

 "

#  !

 !

%

"

@3  !

 !



" ,."

# * "



 ,

 "

  =  ,   !

 - ,  $%%'0!   !

,

 >

 

# "



  %,

 "

 

# , 4  %

 "

 !"% *  '!  !

  @3 A

      *>*>5B>#3

  

+"

 -   0" " , # "



 0

 ,   

 %,

 "

 "

 

#   # "

   * "

0

 ,  !

# # "



  0"

# , '# "



 0

 "

  "

,  !

 0

 

%  '4  

 "

"

# "



 0

 

 "

* 0"

 "

 4    /      "

 

   0

     "

/0 !

# "

  !@3 0"

"

 %,

    

 > 

# "

 %,

 "

 "!"* "



     >  0



% %' "

  # " !% % %' "



 *"0 *  

 '*"

  

"

 # ,  #    !  @3  !



 " ,  0"

  "

 %,

  "

 

  "



  =  ,    

# "

%,

 "

 "



 "

 

'%

 4

  "





%'

"

   # 

  ;   ( !

 @ 

 

* 

$ *   

$!,  

  6& 7 8."

# * "

 #

"



 

 

, 

! "



 

# "



  

'

 !

  % '  "



   

 %  

 

  0 " 

4 

%  #

3  #"



  *

 

# "



 "

    "

$!, 

"

# "

 

 

   

 !



"#   *

 



"

 "

,  '

"

 ,# "



 %'

! "

@3 A   * >*>5B>#3

  

+"

 -  0

 !

!



 "

 

       *  0"

 "

 %,

  

 

#,# "



#; <! 

6  8 > 

  "

# *  "



 

 "

  !"

'  %

 

, 

  %'  "

  =  ,  

"

,,

# 

 "

 , ##  ! "

 

#, "

!  0! #,

 "

 ,  

  ! !



" ,3  #"



  *

 



"

    "

$!,  # :%  ,

  

     $   % & '( )*  

"+# 3"

"



 

# "



  

 "

 , 

2 &,

'*@3 A   *>*>5B >#3

  

+"

 -  0

 !

 !



 "



         D    *      

  0



%' "

,,

# "



#; <! 

6  8 



# %,

#  

0

 > ."





%,

"

    

# "





 >   

"



  

#,0 " !

  "

 

 "

 %,



  E&'()*)+,-./

0 & ' - ,     F AD

' %

 4  # %'% 1  %    F  #,  .

 AD

'%

 

%' ,   F .' #

=

# 

A

 #

AD

&)+1&*).2*,3,.)()/&4)/&5&**&6,/+&*&7 )6),./+2-89 .' #



 !  !

 =  '  

  4

 4  # 

 

  &

,  FG H< 26 8 ."

#

*  "

 

    

  "

 #

           %,

  "

  

  #,    "

 

   =  ,      

 "

  # ,  *"

 



 "

# ,# !

#@3  !



" ,."

     

   #    *  

*     "

 

  

   2  6& 7  8   

  "

  !  

!

  #  "



  @3

!

 !



 "



 *3

!

!D##  

   *  *  > B > *"0 * "

"

# "



 0

#/ ."

#

* > * "



  

% #  "

   0

 

 

 #

"

# "

% % ." *  

 "

 "



 0

  "

/0 !

# !

#@3  !



" ,% "



 "



,

  #  #,  "

 

  =  ,   0"   %,

!  "

 

#,# "

- ,  $%3 "

   ,  



  5



  ,+ -  !!



!

 . ))  ./

  !

12  

 - 

)

1 !

 

!

 *

 

2



:

4

 )  +  /  !!



!

* !



 /  

/

2  !



/

. * 

 *

  ! 89!)

:

/  !!



 

.



/

.

.

7 )/

 .

;

26 8 ."



   #  "

 

   "

 %

 

, 

      0 " "

  # "

   ,  

 5 ."

 :%  ,   

     $   ! <)=*0"    ! "

 , 

"

  

   

  

  

 

 

 



  

      



          

!    

      

 

! " "

#$%& '

   

     

  

 



 

(

 

   



     

) *

    !        (





  

 "  +   ' 







 

  ,  #     



    - 

. /  

    

 

 )       0.  

      

  1

    

        

        - 

  .  2   

;



   

    

 

 (



  3    

      

        

 

    

 

    $ 33 33 33 33 33 4 5  



  









  



 

 

   

        

 1



'     

 

 

  '  '      ,     / '  " 

 

           

       

   

  

  



 

  )   

 



  

   

/ 



)   ) 

     

  )       

   /

 



 









 

 

 0.       6  7

  9 7

   

#*   

   

   *      





   "    (

 :    

  

 



    

      +

      

 



 

 

          

   

  

  +  

   



        

 

!# 

 

   

 /

 



      )    

     +  

     

1

  '   

         

 

 

  

 

'  '  *   

/  

    

       

 

 

*      

  

 ;

 ."

 :%  ,    >  *

 5?

0

  @*

2 1 % <= ?

&#&*0" 

  ! "



 $!, 

 ' 

2 

 % <+=  & (A 

(A/ /



2* *

  '

C 7 / % <=   "+"

"

 "

!  !  #   0!  #,

    

 "

   

 #

  ,  3 "



$!,  * "



  )"

, !"(



  



.  - 

.

"

6.-.8#(

"

,

 #

"

0



%' "

= " % 

  

 )  

#

  $  !*   

  #,  0

 !    #    # 

  #





"

#,0

#  %'" , 0" ""

"

  "

4

9"

' %





:  !



!

#   "

 

 #,*0"

 !

"

   "

"

0

  



  0 *   !    # 

*   0

 #  "

  )"

, !"(

 0

    

   >1*>2***>2B>#33 "



$!,  * "

:%  ,  "

"



  : <

          

!!

 6 *   "  

= 4>?

"": 

@'   - 9 A+ B

  "   !

 

                 



   

     !

      

  

  



 



 

/  

 



 

          !

        

 

      '   



 

 

*       /  "'    

 C( ,? D



  

  

3  

 





 

   

  

 

 E  

   ,?          

  



   

!  

 

  



   

   

         

            !  ;

? / 

         

*   "  

= > ""

,4 

@.

*

.

*

- 7

# < A'- 'F



B

  "  

 C   /  

&!

  

     

   

B  

/ !

  

 

         

!



  ! 

! / !

     &    

 

 

    

     

&



 &     

  &    

   &



  

   

 

 









  

 

 /  !

 /.9//  

 









     



 & 

   

&  

        

 

    



 

   

   

 

 

  

  / 

& 

  

    

           

  '                 

 

  



  

    &  

  

   ;

% 33 33 33 33

   

 

)       

     

  

  



 @

B'   =  >

      /  "

     (



   

!

  



 

  

  



    D )

         

  

G;

. "

 ,   ##   "

$!,  # :%  ,

  

   0  C* 

 !

 % "<&= ?

&4*0"

 "

%

"



    



   

 

 

   

  / !

 

 

   

   /   

     

&

        

        



/

            

         

  

  



 

 !     

        

      

 



      

 

 

  



  

! &

                

   



 

  

 





       

  



0    *  

 



      ;  =- C  7 "



# =1

> <.

    =1

>  <.

A+ %%=>...$,C'.%%

"?$,<  H < 6

%$4'H. ,% "    ! 

  *  "  8

 

 



     

 ;

!$  '  7

 0 "   8& 5'..

(.8 A'%%=>...,?C'.

%% "$I  8

 A +  7  =%%>""?  "

     "      ! 

*   



   

    

 "         * 

 

  H!   ) 

 

 

   

  



;

,   1

 8& 

6 %%=> .".=.

>C'.%% "$$$



 

 CJ 0     

     

    

* 





     ;

 9   

" < .

* 

  A  +   

=>  .".  =" >  ?,  C  '.  

 "4$  "  0   * 

 

  

   ;  =   *  !

  >     3

   



'   



    "878   2

A+ '.%? "??? $   .

  "

         1   A  +  

$=>.".=" >4%4C'.

 " %4   "   

      ;     

 

 

  

   

 

)

  



            

        )



  )

   *

!%

              



  







 ;/

  *  

 

            "-

("

 F 

-

 

' 5  K =

>4"",$ 4 /       " 

 

   

 

          

       

   

     

 

"                     

9 +  8

) %%4=>"/4%C'.%%4 " 4?4  "  

 

    

 *  1   "

A"

  -E  D  .

      8/  1 =%% >,""4$$ 

 CJ        

    



"<

 

          

;

: 1  '     "  

+   F =%%4>""4 $  "

      

    

   7

"   "  

 C 

  







        





         /  



 

      

      

 

   



  



!"

            

      



"   

 

/  

) 

    

)

  

      

    /

/   

 *    



  

/ 

 

    

!       

  

          

!

D   

  

    

      

 



 

 



      

 

 )

 !

/  



   

  

   '         

    

 

 

    

; =H

 > ?   F 

 -

       .

  .

K 

,=,>"/:4C'.

, ":

%I

  '7  7    

 "

    F  - )



4=>"/::C'.

$

"%  "   





  

   

  

     / " *

 

)  

 0

 H

 )         

 

 /  "  

   

 

  0  !   

  

         

     /   !     

!0

#  , '

0;

      

    

  



  

  

'

0

     )     

  

    

 

 

  

   

%       2

 A  +     1

 F  

?=>  .".  =" >  :$  C  

?=>  .

  '   =.'>,$C'.

? " ?,   "  

      

  







      

 



 

      

    

1  2 '7A+  6 "  # =

$>"":4  " 

  

  



         



   !    

  

 

        " /



                   

   



   

   / !





  !  

     ..

)  1

5 7

  +   

?=>  "/    C  

:=4>  .

  '   =.'> C'.

? "$:?   "     

 

)   )

   

       &  

!:



  



 



             

    2  " 

 



 5 +  '?%$?   



 5       

     !       

 



    



                    



      *

 



 

     

     

  /  

)         

  



 

      

*

 

  *

)        

D 

    )  

                    

          

 

, 8   

 

 

  !     





 0 

 ;(            '    

 )        

  

  

 

 "

  3# ""

7

1 *  7 

/     

   

 

 *

!   

 =- C9  8 *5 8 < K %%4=>"/,:C%%4=>.".=" > ,

!;

C'.%%4", I < / 

 9 A + 

=,>.".=" >$C'.

 " 4$ ;  . "



,  ##   "

$!,  # :%  ,

  

(A 

  

D

% <= ?

+&*  0"

   "

 %

  "

  "

 0"

 "

 ,'

  #

 "

,'

0"

 



!



#, #



,   1



  ,

  #

 1  

  ,

  #

  

   

     #  

 "

       %'  "

 

      ! <)=

  *    "

 "

#

# "



0 

' ##    "



$!,       %

 "



 



  "





* "

 "

 



   #

"



, )  

*

0" "



 "

   "



# "

 ,'



 0"

"

    %   



*0"

"

 !  '## " !#

   #,

* 

 0"

"

 "  

"

 %

 

 # # 

,'

"

 !!  #

   #,

%' 0 !" ,

   

  ."

   #, "



$!,   

  '

 !

  

 (6     "     

  . , 6.



% 

 

 



     

      

  









    

#

   

        

    





     



      

  

   

    



        

  







      

 

 



  

    

    

  /  

  

  

     

!     



     0                  

 

      

   



 

*     * 

   *





,$7"

  (

/





    

 



    



 9     



 

,,7"

   



,$7"      /  " 

  

 

    

   

 

       !  )  

      

  

 

 





      

   !  )    

    * ' 

2 <)=









        

          

!

  '     (

    

)  

 

 ) 



      





                           (



 

  

  





  

      

3 

 *    

    

        

       

     

        

       6        !  )     & 

 

 

        !   

  

 

" '  



 

            

   

 

   

  

 

     

)         (



 

 0   

. ,6.



%



.  

    



  

      

          

.  

  





  

    

  (          

        '

   

   

   

        

    



        5   8   2  ' 

 

    

  

 

 





  "'70   0  #($  &4&

(7       



  



        

  

 

  

    "

=> =>/    

 



  /

    3

      C(  '

   



    8      "'70  





 



LLL LLL LLL =>   

  

   

   &    & 

  

= >

 

= >

 

  7"  '

 "

   5   

 



 

    

 &7H/

& 



& 

        

      

         >  /

         

 C

> 

  &

& 

    

   ' 3 ('

>  

&   

   '

   

                

 

 

   

 

> /





   #  

 '

&" "

 '

&     

  

   >     &



  

    

    

> &



    

  

       7   



    

 0.



  &

  

  





   0.  

"<

7         



    

      &

 

   

! &

  "

 

   

!  7         



    

   

  



"

 & 5   7         



    

      &

 

    &   &

   

 ' 3 ( 6             "

   -  A  L   " 7

 %:,;

   

         

  



!     

       "     

  

  

! / 

   

  

! &

 

3  

     

           

   

E

  



$       

   

! &  

     





  

 

     

= 

> 

  

   

   

  

 

      

 

 



    

 

 

 

 

  

   )  



 

9         

   )  

     



 

  

   2B  "   ' 

2 <)= 

  

* (

 C* 

   

<&= B7 F <= "+ 

   

   , =' 3  7($>  

    1   

  5 =7  >

 

6     

     3  '



!

 

 



 (      

*

             

  



  

 

       

 ( ' 

/  

   

       (*

 

     !    



 

 

 

3 

    

 

     

     

 

 % 



 

)"+-1(%   



  *

 3  2

 



%

*

 

      

 

  !       

 ;

 3 "



 

* "

   

,   "

 # "



 

0"  #  !    

#,# "



# ; <! 

6  8 > * "



 "



 "

,

# # !

#@3 A

    !



" ,

 0"  !  ! "



  

  "



  =  , 

  *"

    

 "



# ."



 

# "



 "

%



, 

%' "



  =  ,  

  ' 

,  #  

 5  #  "

   ,   

 ."



      #, '0 " "

 0 0%' :%  ,  

     $   ! <)=

 5?

0

  @*

2 1   ! <)=."

# * "

   !

'  # , '  "

 

/ %' "



  =  ,  # 

 "

$!

,  

%' "



 

# "



    * "



,      %   "

#

  ,



# "



 

> (  * "

 4

# "



 *  $!,  

 

%'

 ;  ( !

@ 



*

$ * 0" " ," #

 "



, 

# "



 * #

4   3 0# "

 % *#  !,   "

 

 

*

"



,  "

%' ,

0 " 

 

 #;!#%   

) 

   "

"

 

/ !1

 

1A "

"





%

1A