Super Multi Colour Printers (P) Ltd v. Haryana Prathmik Shiksha Pariyojna Parishad

   
   
  


 !"#

$%& '&()*)+,  
 

               
          
", - ."
 
   .

/&*&+%, "/$/*011$/2$34'5($%& /%0&$66&33$+% 
$7&*0 )+'$3  0&'& &+'$+%)*8& /&%0)*(9/%$1$)+*%(+(9//&+% )+')+1*  $(%/&(/'&'8:8%0%0&(9/%*8&32420&/&8:%0&*9)% //&(5&/:

)3&'8:%0&/&*6+'&+%;63$)+%)

/ 
 4 4 <=;42$*6$/%3:'&(/&&' / /&(5&/: 
4 4 >=;$3+12)%0)+%&/&*% .&$/+&'(9+*&3 /%0&$66&33$+%*98?)%%&'%0$%)%)*$($*&)+ 20)(0%0&/&*6+'&+%)+5)%&'

&/* /6983)($%)+ 8@%)%3&'$*A"&/) 9*%$@;B0&

&/*2&/&%8&/&(&)5&'96% 6?+ > >420)(0 2&/&%8&6&+&'+%0&*$?&'$:$%>6?0&

&/*98?)%%&'8:%0& $66&33$+%2$*5$3)' /$6&/)' '$:*0&/$%&C9%&'2$*


D 6&/ 8@&1%)$%)+*2&/&0&3'+ > >$+'%0&

&/ %0&$66&33$+% / 6983)($%)+ %0&8@2$*$((&6%&'$%


6&/(6:+  >4%0& /'&/2$*63$(&'420)(02$*/&(&)5&'8:%0&$66&33$+%+ >0& '&%$)3* %0&63$(&*4%20)(0%0&*9663)&*2&/&%8&*&+%42&/& 9/+)*0&'

/? >%D >0&$66&33$+%0$5)+1 $)3&'%'&3)5&/%0&*9663:4 %0&/&*6+'&+%?$'&/)*@69/(0$*& /?$+%0&/ )/?E
 =;6&/8@
&(5&/: %0&3***9

&/&'4+$?&3:4%0&')

&/&+(&)+%0&6/)(&C9%&'8:

%0&$66&33$+%$+'%0&6/)(&6$)'8:%0&/&*6+'&+%%%0&/*9663)&/2$*

  *910%%8&?$'&8: )3)+1%0&*9)%420)(02$*'&(/&&'8:8%0%0&(9/%* 8&32 F0)3&)?691+)+1%0&79'1?&+%*$+''&(/&&*43&$/+&'(9+*&3

/%0&$66&33$+%*98?)%%&'%0$%%0&

&/*98?)%%&'8:%0&$66&33$+%2$* 5$3)'+3: /$6&/)' '$:*%2$**98?)%%&'+ > >0&/'&/ 2$*63$(&'8:%0&/&*6+'&+%$ %&/&G6)/: %0&6&/)' '$:*+

 >420)(02$*/&(&)5&'8:%0&$66&33$+%+ >40&+(&4%0& $66&33$+%2$*+%89+'8:%0&/$%&C9%&'C9&*%)+ 3**$/)*&*$*%0& $66&33$+%2$*+%89+'%*9663:%0&8@*& 9/%0&/*98?)%%&'%0$% %0910%0&8@*2&/&%8&*9663)&'8:%0&$66&33$+%%%0&/&*6+'&+%E


6&/(6:402&5&/4%0&/$%&%8&6/)+%&'%0&/&+2$*
 > 4$* %0&*$?&2$*%8&*9663)&'%%0&*%9'&+%*$%%0$%/$%&F0&+%0&8@* 2&/&1%6983)*0&' /?$+%0&/*9663)&/4%0&6/)(&6$)'8:%0&/&*6+'&+% 2$*
 =;6&/(6:$+'%0&/$%&1%6983)*0&'+%0&8@2$*
 * %0&(*% %0&8@2$*/&(5&/&' /?%0&*%9'&+%*4)+ $(%4+3**2$* *9

&/&'8:%0&/&*6+'&+%40&+(&4+/&(5&/:(93'8&*910% /?%0& $66&33$+%  %&/0&$/)+13&$/+&'(9+*&3 /%0&$66&33$+%4'+% )+'

$+:/&$*+%)+%&/ &/&)+%0&(+(9//&+% )+')+1* $(%/&(/'&'8:8%0 %0&(9/%*8&32* $/$*5$3)')%: %0&

&/ /$6&/)' '$:* /?

%0&'$%& *98?)**)+%0&/& )*(+(&/+&'4%0&

&/2$**98?)%%&'8:%0& $66&33$+%+ > >0&/&2&/&+&1%)$%)+*+ > >$+'%0&

&/  %0&6&%)%)+&/2$*$((&6%&' /*9663: %0&8@*E

6&/(6:4 0&+(&4%0&

&/ %0&$66&33$+%0$'8&&+$((&6%&'2)%0)+$6&/)'  '$:*3$()+1 /'&/ /*9663: %0&8@*$%')

&/&+%*%$%)+*)*+% /&3&5$+% $*  %0&  $66&33$+%  0$'  +% C9%&' $+: (3$9*&  %  *02  %0$%  %0& (+')%)+2$* /*9663: %0&?$%&/)$32)%0)+$6&/)' '$:* /?%0& '$%& *98?)**)+

&/40&+(&4%0&(+%&+%)+)*?)*(+(&)5&' +%0&/(+%&+%)+/$)*&'8:3&$/+&'(9+*&3 /%0&$66&33$+% /&1$/')+1%0&3***9

&/&'8:%0&/&*6+'&+%)*(+(&/+&'4&5&+%0$%$3* '&*&/5&*%8&/&7&(%&''?)%%&'3:4%0&$66&33$+%0$'$1/&&'%*9663:%0& 8@*E

6&/(6:+ $)39/& %0&$66&33$+%%*9663:%0&(6)&*4 /)*@69/(0$*&2$*?$'& /?$+%0&/*9663)&/E 
 =;6&/(6:0&

> ')

&/&+(&2$*%0&3***9

&/&'8:%0&/&*6+'&+%4 /20)(0%0&$66&33$+% 2$*3)$83&98*&C9&+%/&(5&/: %0&$?9+% /?$+:%0&/*9/(&)*+% /&3&5$+% /%0&69/6*& /%0&/&$*+*?&+%)+&'$85&4'+% )+'$+:/&$*+% )+%&/ &/&2)%0(+(9//&+% )+')+1* $(%/&(/'&'8:8%0%0&(9/%*8&32 C9&*%)+ 3$24?9(03&**$*98*%$+%)$3C9&*%)+ 3$24$/)*&*)+%0& 6/&*&+%$66&$30&*$?&)*4$((/')+13:4')*?)**&'
$7&*0 )+'$3#  9'1&

  ?@