High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/593/2014dismissed

Jasdeep Singh @ Bobi v. Inderjit Singh

2018-02-21Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

"#$$%&'&() $*+,"+- . / "'0$$1&(234*& 11$55"(# 6$+','

(0$+7&# $'1(0$(# ! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

+$'$(#) + 8 359".0:%"#$.

+#3$"11$55"(# +8"+,($'38",'3"5.0:%"#$.

+#3$+$'1(0$(# ;;;;; +*,&-(

11$55"(#<0$$(0"(#&'&( $2,5"+$%(011$"5"2"&('##3$ %(%,++$(#&(0&(2'#3$,+#'*$5=.=3$+$*-+$%:$+-.>.?< "5(2=&#3&(#$+$'#4/@(#3$1+&(%&1"5"A,(#=&#3,#,+$&(#$+$'#4B@ +A#3$0"#$0$%+$$#&55+$"5&'"#&(.3"'*$$(+0$+$0

$'1(0$(#<15"&(#& &('#&#,#$0 #3$ ',&# + +$%:$+- #3$ "+$A$(#&($0"A,(#.>.?<(#3$*"'&'"1+(#$"(0+$%$&1# 0"#$0 /B(#3$1+$A&'$#3"##3$0$$(0"(#3"0"2+$$0#+$1"-#3$ "A,(#"5(2=&#3&(#$+$'#4 @1$+A(#3(0$A"(03$1+(#$"(0 +$%$&1#=$+$$C$%,#$0&(#3$1+$'$(%$#3$A"+2&("5=&#($''$'"(0#3$ 0$$(0"(#. "#$+ ,(0$+'#"(0&(2 "(0 "0A&##&(2 #3$ '"A$. "11$(0$0 3&' '&2("#,+$'D3$(#3$0$$(0"(#"&5$0#1"-#3$,#'#"(0&(2"A,(#.#3$ ',&#="'&5$01+$%$0$0*-5$2"5(#&%$0"#$0 B 3$"11$55"(#<0$$(0"(#%(#$'#$0#3$',&#*-+"&'&(2*7$%#&('

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

D3$#3$+( /B.0$$(0"(#*++=$0"',A

'5"%'+A#3$15"&(#&"(0&(5&$,#3"#$C$%,#$01+(#$ "(0+$%$&1#&(":,+#3$15"&(#&F

&'',$( &'1+:$0.=3$#3$+15"&(#&&'$(#&#5$0# &(#$+$'#"#=3"#+"#$(#3$1+&(%&1"5"A,(#"(015"&(#&&' $(#&#5$0#+$%:$+1+&(%&1"5"A,(#+A#3$0$$(0"(#F

D3$#3$+1+(#$"(0+$%$&1#&(E,$'#&(0(#*$"+#3$ '&2("#,+$'0$$(0"(#"(0'"A$="'+2$0"(0"*+&%"#$0 0%,A$(#'F

D3$#3$+ #3$ 0$$(0"(# ,'$0 # '$55 3&' %+1 "# #3$ %AA&''&("2$(%-15"&(#&"(0"5','$0#1,+%3"'$#3$

&('$%#&%&0$"(01$'#&%&0$+A#3$'3115"&(#&F B!

$5&$ #3#3$,+#'*$5=.(#3$*"'&'#3$$:&0$(%$.0$%+$$0 #3$',&##&'&(#3&'*"%90+1#3$A"##$+.#3$1+$'$(#"11$"53"'*$$( &5$0 + 8 359".5$"+($0%,('$5"11$"+&(2(*$3"5#3$ "11$55"(#<0$$(0"(#',*A&#'#3"##3$"11$55"(#<0$$(0"(#3"00,5-$C"A&($0 D< +"&(23"(0D<"5=&(0$+&(23#1+:$#3"#(1+(#$"(0 +$%$&1#0"#$0 /B C

C !=$+$$C$%,#$0.*,##3$,+#'

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

/#3$$2#&"*5$ ('#+,A$(#' %# 3$+$ ="' ( ($$0 1+:&(2 #3$ 5&%$(%$ "' #3$ +$'1(0$(#<15"&(#&="'(##3$+$2,5"+A($-5$(0$+"(0.#3,'.,+2$'#3&' ,+#+0&'A&''"5#3$"11$"5

3":$3$"+0#3$5$"+($0%,('$5+#3$1"+#&$'."11+"&'$0#3$ 1"1$+ *9 "(0 #3$ :&$= #3"# #3$+$ &' ( +%$ "(0 A$+&# &( #3$ ',*A&''&('#3$5$"+($0%,('$5+#3$"11$55"(#<0$$(0"(#.+. D<

"+'$A 8,A"+ "(0 D< 6&7"- 8,A"+ 3":$ 1+:$0 #3$ $C$%,#&( 1+(#$"(0+$%$&1# C

C !"A$=$+$+$"0:$+"(0$C15"&($0# #3$0$$(0"(#.=3'&2($0#3$'"A$&(#3$&+1+$'$(%$(A-:&$=.#3$ +$'1(0$(#<15"&(#&0&'%3"+2$0#3$(,'*-1+:&(2#3$'"A$3$+$="' (($$0+$C"A&("#&(#3$$C1$+# (%$#3$1+(#$"(0+$%$&1#3":$ *$$( 1+:$0. #3$+$ 3"' # *$ %A15&"(%$ ,(0$+ $%#&(

/ #3$ $2#&"*5$('#+,A$(#'%#.=3&%33"'(#*$$(+$*,##$0 3$=&#($''$'#3$0$$(0"(##$##3$5&($#3$0$$(0"(#. *,##3$"%##3$A"##$+&'#3"#&"#"55#3$0$$(0"(#3"0(#"11$(0$03&' '&2("#,+$.3$%,503":$#"9$(#3$"''&'#"(%$ #3$$C1$+#&(+0$+# ',+"%$#3$#+,#355#3$'$"%#'3":$*$$(59$0&(#*-*#3#3$,+#' *$5=

+#3$+$"'(''#"#$0"*:$.(2+,(0+&(#$+$+$(%$&(#3$ %(%,++$(# &(0&(2' #3$ ,+#' *$5= &' A"0$ ,# ',*'#"(#&"5 E,$'#&( 5"= "+&'$' + 0$#$+A&("#&( $',5#"(#5-. #3$ "11$"5 &'

0&'A&''$0 ./0-1 +*,&

234 ()56'

,474389 :3

;3:

,474 7/"

;3: