High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5992/2014dismissed

Ravi Parkash v. Jawahar Gupta & ORS

2016-04-08Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh8 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*

! "#$!

% % &'

()*+,"-./&,+../$(

,#'#(") ,!-,!.&(/0!1$.%!"#1

,"2#!33#00!(" 41 ,!0 2&'!33#!02!'5##( &0#$56"2#30!&("&

5# ,#"2#0#!,(#$ &.&0 -$/# -(&, &.&'&(17-,-8'2#",!1&(!'-&" &0#$562&9'##8&(/ ,#%.#,6 ' 1:;<1 !0(/=&"2 &("#,#'" "2#,#-3(1 ,9 "2# "2,## ,#'3($#("'2#,#&(1!00 =29=#,#$# #($!("'5# ,#"2!"-,"!0' 2#'-&"=!'$#%,##$&( !.-, "2#3,#'#("!33#00!("<30!&("&

2#,#&(!

"#,"5#,# #,,#$""2#30!&("&

156"2#0#!,(#$&.&0 -$/#15-"

"2#'!&$>-$/9#("!($$#%,##=!'3!,"06,#.#,'#$56"2# &,'"33#00!"# -," #(%#1"2&'!33#!0

2# !%"'1!'"!8#( ,9"2#>-$/9#(" "2#0#!,(#$&.&0

-$/#1!,#"2!""2#30!&("&

2!$ &0#$"2#'-&"!'!(&($&/#("3#,'(!($2!$ '"!"#$ &(2&' 30!&(" "2!" 2#2!$$#3'&"#$ !'-9 ':1

;<!'!( &(.#'"9#("=&"2,#'3($#("' !($ 1"2,-/2,#'3($#(" 1=2=!'

"2#!/#(" ,"2#93!(61&#"2# &,'""=,#'3($#("' "=!'%0!&9#$"2!""2#$# #($!("'!$9&""#$"2#$#3'&"5-"

=#,#(",#3!6&(/"2#!9-("!($"2#&("#,#'"!%%,-#$"2#,#-3(10#!.&(/ 2&9=&"2(3"&(5-"" &0#"2#'-&" : (,#'3('#""2#("&%#&''-#$56"2#0#!,(#$&.&0 -$/#1"2#

&,'""=$# #($!("'2#,#&(!

"#,"5#,# #,,#$"!'"2#93!(61$&$("

!33#!,$#'3&"#'#,.&%#!($=#,#%('#?-#("063,%##$#$!/!&('" #'3($#(" 2#,#&( &0#$ 2&' =,&""#( '"!"#9#("

%(",.#,"&(/ "2# !00#/!"&(' 9!$# &( "2# 30!&("1 "2#, "2!( ,!&'&(/ 3,#0&9&(!,65>#%"&('=&"2,#/!,$""2#9!&("!&(!5&0&"6 "2#'-&"1&"5#&(/ "&9#5!,,#$1%(%#!09#(" !%"'!($"2#30!&("&

5#&(/#'"33#$562&'

=(!%"!($%($-%" ,9 &0&(/"2#'-&" "=!'!0'%("#($#$"2!""2#30!&("&

2!$'-

&%&#("9#!('!($ !''-%2=!'("!(&($&/#("3#,'( #'3($#(" !0''-59&""#$"2!"#.#(& !(6!9-("=!'

-($$-# ,9"2#93!(612#2&9'#0 %-0$("5#9!$#0&!50#"3!6"2# '!9# "=!' -,"2#,%("#($#$"2!""2#30!&("&

2!$!0,#!$6,#%#&.#$ "2#$#9!($#$!9-("56=!6 !%2#?-#&''-#$("2##(",!0 !(8

($&!14!$=!1&("2#9("2 %"5#, *!($"2!""2#30!&("&

2!$#!,0&#,

&0#$ ! %930!&(" &( "2# &'",&%" ('-9#, ,-91 =2&%2 2!$ 5##( $&'9&''#$ "&00 -,"2#,1&"=!'%("#($#$"2!""2#30!&("&

=!'2&9'#0 !0' !(!/#(" 93!(618(=&(/!00"2#,-0#'!($,#/-0!"&('"2#,# 3( "2# !5.# 30#!$&(/'1 =&"2 ( ,#30&%!"&( &0#$1 "2#

00=&(/&''-#'=#,# ,!9#$56"2#0#!,(#$&.&0 -$/#)< @ A2#"2#, !330&%!(";30!&("&

5#&(/ &($&/#(" 3#,'( &'

#("&"0#$",#%.#,'-&"!9-("!'3,!6#$ ,B

A2#"2#,"2#3,#'#("'-&"&'23#0#''06"&9#5!,,#$B

: A2#"2#,"2#30!&("&

2!'("%9#""2#%-,"=&"2 %0#!(2!($' !($ 2!' %(%#!0#$"2#",-#!($ 9!"#,&!0

!%"'B

A2#"2#,30!&("&

2!'(0%-''"!($&" &0#"2#3,#'#("

'-&"B

A2#"2#,"2#30!&("&

&'#'"33#$562&'=(!%"!($ %($-%" ,9 &0&(/"2#3,#'#("'-&"B

+ A2#"2#,,&/&(!030!&("&'0&!50#"5#,#>#%"#$-($#, ,$#,C-0#

C #0&# D + 2#30!&("&

"#($#,#$2&'!

&$!.&"&('-33," "2#30!&("!($ #E!9&(#$2&9'#0 "2#,#!

"#, # #($!(":#'3($#("( 2#,#&(!0' "#($#,#$2&'!

&$!.&"&('-33," 2&'=,&""#('"!"#9#("!($"2#,#!

"#, #E!9&(#$2&9'#0 C 3(%('&$#,!"&( "2##.&$#(%#1"2#0#!,(#$-," -($ "2!""2#30!&("&

=!'!%"-!006!(&($&/#("3#,'(=&"2!,#3,"&("2!",#/!,$ 2!.&(/5##('#3!,!"#06,#%#&.#$!($ -,"2#,15#%!-'#2#2!$!0'5##( $#%0!,#$"5#'&(!("2#,'-&" &0#$562&9 ',#/!,$'"2#%0!&9&("2#'-&"1&"=!' -($"2!""2#30!&("&

2!$&($##$&(.#'"#$':1

;<1($&

#,#("$!"#'1=&"2"2#93!(61 "2,-/2 ,#'3($#(" 1=2&%2"2#93!(62!$",#3!61!0(/=&"2 &("#,#'""2#,#-3(1%93-($&(/!""2#,!"# *F" F2#93!(6 2!$"2#,#!

"#,3!&$!'-9 ' 1

;<""2#30!&("&

15-" "2#3,&(%&3!0 '-91' 1

;<,#9!&(#$-(3!&$"2&9!($!0(/=&"2&("#,#'"G *F3#,

!((-912#=!'#("&"0#$",#%.#,!'-9 ':1

;<2#'!&$,!"#

&("#,#'"=!'2#0$"5#3!6!50#!'"2#!9-("&(.#'"#$!($!/,##$"5#3!&$ 5!%856"2#93!(61""2#30!&("&

1=!'!%99#,%&!0",!('!%"&( 2#30!&("&

=!' -,"2#,2#0$#("&"0#$"&("#,#'"G F3#, !((-91

,9"2#$!"# &0&(/ "2#'-&"1"&00,#!0&H!"&(

"2#!9-(" 2# &($&(/"2!""2#!9-("2!$5##(!%"-!006$#3'&"#$56"2# 30!&("&

1=!'-3("2#!$9&''&( ,#'3($#(" &(%,''<#E!9&(!"&(1 "2!"2#1!'!(!/#(" ,"2#93!(612!$,#%#&.#$"2#!9-("($&

#,#("

$!"#'1=2&%22#$#3'&"#$=&"2"2#93!(6-($#,,#%#&3"&''-#$56"2# !(!/#, # !0' !$9&""#$ "2!" !

"#, 3!69#(" '9# !9-(" " "2# 30!&("&

1"2#,#9!&(&(/3,&(%&3!0!9-("=!''"&00$-#"2&9 * 2#'-&" "2#30!&("&

=!'1"2#,# ,#1$#%,##$56"2#0#!,(#$ &.&0 -$/#1&(2&' !.-,120$&(/"2!",#'3($#(" =!'0&!50#"/#""2# #("&,#!9-(",#0#!'#$ ,9,#'3($#("' !($ 1&#"2#93!(61!($ &(%!'#2# !&0#$"$'12#=-0$5#0&!50#!0(/=&"293!(61>&("06 !($'#.#,!0061"9!8#"2##("&,#3!69#("""2#30!&("&

#'3($#(" &0#$!(!33#!0!/!&('""2#!

,#'!&$>-$/9#("

" #$%

& '(#

)

+ "

#%%, ("-.(

)

,#%%12

3 '4

5 #$

)

,,(

$ %- #%%(

%-('#0 ,"2#!33#00!(".#,6 !&,06'-59&"'"2!"2#2!'("5##(!50#"

&($!(60!='2=&(/"2#0&!5&0&"6 !(!/#(""5#3#,'(!0"2&9,!"2#, "2!("2&'3,&(%&3!01&("2#!5'#(%# !(6'3#%& &%%(",!%"&("2!",#/!,$ &00-'",!"#1 #%"&( :

"2#(",!%" %" (##$' " 5# ,# #,,#$"2#'!&$3,.&'&(,#!$'!'-($#,)< @ :

("2#!5'#(%# !(6%(",!%"""2!"#

#%"1!(!/#("

%!(("3#,'(!006#( ,%#%(",!%"'#("#,#$&("562&9( 5#2!0 2&'3,&(%&3!01(,&'2#3#,'(!0065-($56"2#9 -%2!%(",!%"'2!005#3,#'-9#$"#E&'"&("2#

00=&(/%!'#')< A2#,#"2#%(",!%"&'9!$#56!(!/#(" ,'!0#, 3-,%2!'# /$' ,!9#,%2!(",#'&$#("!5,!$I =2#,#"2#!/#("$#'("$&'%0'#"2#(!9# 2&' 3,&(%&3!0I :=2#,#"2#3,&(%&3!01"2-/2$&'%0'#$1%!(("5# '-#$D 2-'1 ,9!5!,#,#!$&(/ "2#3,.&'&(&"'#0 1&"&'!9306 %0#!,"2!"!(!/#("!%"&(/(5#2!0 2&'3,&(%&3!01&("2&'%!'#1,#'3($#("

(5#2!0 "2#93!(62#=!',#3,#'#("&(/1&#,#'3($#("'

!($:2#,#&(1%!(("5#2#0$0&!50#"$&'%2!,/#"2#93!(6'J0&!5&0&"61=&"2 (#&"2#, "2#:%($&"&('/&.#(&(#%"&( :

1"20$2&90&!50#1#E&'"&(/ &("2#3,#'#("%!'# "2!'!0'("5##('2=(&(!(69!((#,1"2!""2# &($&(/

"2#0#!,(#$&.&0 -$/#1"2!""2#30!&("&

=!'!=!,#"2!",#'3($#("

C =!'!%"&(/!'!(!/#(" ,,#'3($#("' !($:1&'!3#,.#,'# &($&(/( !(6%!'#1"2!"%-0$("2!.#5##('2=("5#'1=2#("2#!33#00!("< 30!&("&

&00#$&(!3,&("#$ ,9&''-#$56"2#93!(61!' -($56"2# -,"'5#0=1#(!50&(/2&9"9!8#!$#3'&"=&"2&"1!'!(&(.#'"9#(" #(%#1=&"2,#'3($#(" 2#,#&(2!.&(/!%"#$(5#2!0

2&'3,&(%&3!01&#"2#93!(61,#'3($#("' !($:1"2##E%#3"&('

%!,.#$-"&(#%"&( :

1""2#5!'&%3,&(%&30#"2!"!%(",!%"!/!&('"2&' 3,&(%&3!0%!(("5##( ,%#!/!&('"!(!/#("1%!(("5#&(.8#$56"2# !33#00!("<30!&("&

1"2'#:%($&"&('5#&(/((<#E&'"#("1!'!0,#!$6'!&$

"!0'(##$'"5#'"!"#$2#,#"2!""2#&''-# 0&9&"!"&(,!&'#$ 56"2&'-,"1.&$#&"',$#,$!"#$ :

+1=!'5.&-'069&'<30!%#$1

&,'"061"2&'("5#&(/!(!33#!056"2#93!(6"2!"2!'5##(2#0$0&!50#!' "2# >-$/9#("<$#5",1 56 "2# >-$/9#(" !($ $#%,## "2# 0#!,(#$ &,'"

33#00!"#-," #%($061&(!(6%!'#1!(&''-#=!' ,!9#$(0&9&"!"&(15# ,# "2#0#!,(#$&.&0 -$/#1=2&%2"2#$# #($!("'<,#'3($#("'2#,#&(%-0$("

3,.#!/!&('""2#30!&("&

<!33#00!("I2#(%#1("2&(/ -,"2#,(##$'"5#'!&$ &("2!",#/!,$56"2&'-,"

: 2#,# ,#1&(.&#= =2!"2!'5##(2#0$1"2#3,#'#("!33#!0&'

$&'9&''#$

1-320$&(/"2#>-$/9#("!($$#%,##$!"#$

"2#0#!,(#$33#00!"#-,"1&#"2#$$&"&(!0 &'",&%" -$/#17-,-8'2#",! ,$#,!'"%'"' ' : <!($ <

(.&#= "2# !%""2!""2#!33#!02!'5##($&'9&''#$

1 "2#?-#'"&( %($(!"&( "2#$#0!6

$!6'!($ :

$!6'1&(

* ,# &0&(/!($ &0&(/"2#!33#!0,#'3#%"&.#061&',#($#,#$!%!$#9&%!($&'(" /(#&(" *

+ +../$( "-0$,