High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6044/2014dismissed

Deep Chand & ANR v. Omi @ Om Parkash & ORS

2017-02-08Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages

! "# $ %&' (' %%)) (* + ** , ) *,- . *' (' * *%(*

- *( .*'', #/ (

(' %%)) (* 0 !+1#/ (

(' *%(* ( - ,0(2'#3#4 ! ***( ! '

,- )#56-) %%)) (*%) (

* ' / ) (' % *( 2) * %% ) 2 *(('02,( (

" % ** !) ( ) *( ( 72# 3 2 6' ! (' %% ) 2 *( (' 02,( ( % ** !) &/)727 /*#3 2 #6 **,** )!*( (#(' %%)) (*%) (

) *( %****

!6 ! ((6('*9( ) ) % , (0( *% ('%) (#('%) (

* (* )

(' * 5'! )2 )' &' 0 * 8'

5' (' %) (

* (* 6 *

6 %)( , * 2

*9 !

* ,% *2 ( 2) # :)) ;

*( ( 6(' (' / *( ( /)) 2 : ' #5'*) *( ( 3 2 / 2 ( 2 + *. $ ( $

<$< 5' %) (

* (* ' =%

<< ( '* ('# (' , *%( (6 6 ('%) (

2 2%**** ('*(% % (! 5' %%)) (*

( ()12 (' , =,, ( (' *'

# 6' * ('

*%(* (* ( !2( ) (('%)(9*( )* ( !2( **( (/ ('%)( 5' # (( ('%)(9*( !,(* **% (2*'

('% (*' *

% ! 5'2'(('*(6 ***((' (*# (('! ( %% ('( )& (#'6 % 2 *( > ( ) & (' *,**(' *(/02,( ( *(' %%)) (*%) (

)(% /(' (('! )26(' (* (')!)2 )' * 0> ) 5'%) (

(= , !6(**=%((',*)/*6')%*(' ((' %) (

* (* (')!)2 )' * 0> ) ?/(' 2 ( ($

<$<?= -*'626 *'% 0> )/ ('*() 6 *(% 2 ) 5'2 (' *( % /

22 ! )/ (6(** 22 / 2 *( (' 02,( ( % ** !('( )& (#(' %%)) (*%) (

) %% ) (' )6 %%)) ( & (# ( (' * , 6 * )* *,** ! ) ( ) *( ( 72# 3 2 / 02,( (

" ('

(*#6'' *

!"#!

$# %& $ ' (#!

"& ) % * # ) # + $,$## - .-.

$!$ %# $%#!

" $*&$

%$$&$ ) + $, / 0 % # % ' (#%$$!*&#) % # ## #1!

&$# "$ %$ - 2$#$3"#$%%$#%$-- 2$#$3"#$%% !& 1$ $$% % % 45

-6 - .-.

% #!

&! '&$ "$ % % % % # ) $% % ) $

$*&$) # !

'1 7$% + $, $ 8 &$# "$ % #& 7&$,!4

+11$/$# & $ % .

) *&# ! "# !

&% #%&1$ % % )&#!

'17$% $ "& + $,$# #' (# ) $ ) #)$ !

'1 7$% $ " $ 1!

#$ !& 1 $!$#$ !

%%#$

& $

!$#1#$ %&$ 8 %$#

& $

!$ #1#!

$# %& $

##$1 #

/ #%#+ $, ) %& # " # *& $ $ *&$

1$ ) # "#

# $

& % %

1$ & $ "# $#% $ *&$ #1$& " #$ '1 7$% 2 % %

1$$# $ % % ) $" " $ $ 11$$# $!

#$ / # '1 7$%

%& # &1 $ *&$ 2$ "$&

) $% $

",$# '17$% $% %$ & $ $# " $!$&1# %& # ! $# # 9$ %&$ &

!$#1# + 0 & & #" ! #1# $ &$# "$ %%# + $,/ )

# $*&$$# #$#$

## $# /)& #$ # $ $ % & $$ % $#%$$!

)# %&$ # )& # ! 1!

2$ % $ $# * # ) % $) 1:% 1$!$/ #%# $#%$

%$$!#"##$:%$#$$$ #%# & #"#!

1$/ #"$)& # # & $*&$$ $ & $ %##"##1$ / *&$ $1%!

!& 1$!

!%& !$ !$ $ "## $ 1

1$ $ % #& % 0 & %$$ 37

& $

"# $#% #$ / " !$!# 1

$ $*&$") $ 1 $ ; %$#$ "$ 1# $ %$$

!"$

% & !%& %#& $ ## )& # 1&$ " $ 1 $# %$#$

1$"$ '17$% &10 &$##1 &@ 5'*# (' 02,( % ** ! ) ( ) & ( 6 *

, !(')6 %%)) (& (

< ()) 22 /# (' %%)) (*%) (

* ' / ) (' % *(

2) * %% ) 5' %%)) (*%) (

* ' / ,) ( (' ))62 * *( ( )9*(* ) 6 *(6'(' *() *,**('2 0 ,*0 % (* /6 (' % /*,( A) &-&B *(6'(' ('> & (* )6)/ ( 2

!(' *%) !('%) (

* %%)) (*B * ( 6'(' ( %! 2 ( 6'' * )! 2*( # ) * ( ( % 2('% *(*(B / *(6'(' / * )' / ( . 2 *( (' (* *%(* ( ,2

((*(('*( % ,((',*)/*( % 2 *(=% (B / *(6'(' (',%202,(* * % / * ) )( *( *B / C'(' (' *,**2 (' %%) ( ( )/ *6)) ,%) 2('(' *'

,/ !(' %%)) (*0*( (' (* ,*( * ('% *( *B / C'(' (' * 2 /,* 2 ('/ %) 2* !(') & (*B > *) (' %%)) (*%) (

*' * 2(' ((' %%)) (*%) (

2 (' )2 ) ' * (' &' 0 > ) (() ( , ( (' *( *.2 % (( (' %)( 9*( 5' %%)) (* 2 % /

, ( .2 (' , =,, ( ('

*%(/*'

#6' *(' (*( !2( ) (('*(% % (! )* ( ( * *( ( (' *'

(' %%)) (* 6('( 2 ! 2'(#(() ( *( 5'!' /%((' )2, ( ) / ('%)(9*(6('(2((2('%)(% (( !,(*

**%((' ((' ((' %%)) (*%) (

*' / *'

('* *(% % (! 5'*(' * *,**, (' )(!*%(('

((' (('& (' * /*(6(' ,%)%6 (

(/)! )6(' *( ((' 2'(* ('% (*

(/)! ,%)()! )) 5' *( 6 * ( ) ) ( *,** ( ,* 0 0 (' ** ! % (* A * ( ** !% (*6 * 9 ( , #('& (*,%6 ( ('** ! % (* ( ! *( 2 ( 2/

(/ ,%)( 0 ( 5'& (* )66 (0*( *,**2('*( (' *(' ((' %%)) (%) (

' (% ('%! 2 ( ?= - 2+ *. $ ($

<$<('2' ( %! (' * ,(6 *% (' (' ' # ) *) (' *%(* (* ' * 2 (' ( (' %%)) (*%) (

*# ,)!# % &' 8', 2' *%(* # ,)!# &'

2' 7 ) *7 ! ! ' / ) ! / )(' ( ))(,(

*9 !

*%)( !('3 ,- ' ! ( ('*', ,) ( !(' ( (3/ ,( A(*)! *%( , ) *,- . *'6' 6 * ( ))(( *' %)( ! (' 3 , - ' ! ( (' ( ( %)! 5' #'*(()((6('('%**** ('%)(*%( ) ( / ! '* 4 ' *

2 (' ( (' *%( (, ) *,- . *'' / 0!(' ( ))(,(

*9 !

* %)( (' *',;%)!

, ! (' ( ( 3/ ,(#6''' * 0! !('(' ** 0> ) 4 ' *

((' (* 2(' ( ('% % (!6''*

- )!

*9 !

*%)(6''(' *%(/*'

'*'

') ,*( (*9 !

*#(*(% ( ))!%** )(% ((('%)( 9*( 46/ #(' *%( (, ) *,- . *' * !(% !('% % ( (% %)(6'',*(('*'

%%)) (*%) (

* A ' / ' ) *) (' % (* % * ('

5' **%((' ((' %%)) (*%) (

*' / )(' *( %**** !6 ! ((6('(,%) 2 ))(')2 )' 0> )

,6',('! ) ,2*'

('%)(*%( ('%) (

*' /*2'( ) ((# (' /(,%) ('(' *'

*#*'*(*(, ( ) ?/(' 6*#('%)( 9*(' * 2 ( !('3 ,- ' ! (((' 0 > ) $

<$<# ('2' *' 2 ( ' * %) 5' # ( %! 2 ( ( 9 (6('(' ( %! * ) ?/(' 6*#( 2 %)(

*9 !

*#('*(

(( *'*, ))% ) *(% ( ))!%** ) *('

) ) ,('*(6) ,%** ) 5'*1 ('%)(*

*9 !

*6' ),*("<) , (* ) ,2(' *'

2)2 )' 0> ) 5'**1 %)( ( /("<%* *('* /*6)*( !('/ !()(! ('%)(9*( > %%)) ( & ( ('2' ' * *22*( / ! / ) , (( (%(('%)(* )*(' (('* )% * / ,2 (' )2 ) ' * &' 0 > ) ( *(() (' 9*( (* % (( , )! 8( / (' ( * ) * ( %** ) * (' *

: *%

('* ) ( * (()(' ))(,()(( # *('* %)(* 6 ))(( ( (' ) )** % ** ! (' 3 , - ' ! ( '*2% %** 8 (' ( * ( , !# * (' %%)) (*%) (

* ' / ( ,%) (' ** ! % (* ' / ) (' *( %**** ! 6 ! ((6('(,%) 2('(' )2 )' * 0> )#('* & ( *(' ((' *))2 )(!('02,(* *% ** ! ('& (* )6 A( 2 *

( 2 (* ! ('& (* )6#(

( * *( ( )9*( ) 6*/)/('% *( 2) * %% ) 5' #(',%202,(* *% ** ! (' & (* )6 %') (' % *( 2) * %% ) * *,**

"# D 2(( C'(' *% .2;

* D* C'(' % ( )