Gurdial Singh (Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc v. Jagdish Mittar (Now Deceased) Through His Lr And ANR
!
"#$%%$&'(')*
!"# $%"!! +$($)#, +")%$$-"').%/&"#$ +#0$"--$11")# $%"!!& ''(
+"2$+ ') #0'( "--1'&"#') '( + '3-1$"%')4 1$4"1 +$-+$($)#"#'/$ "--1'&")#5+$(-)%$)# 6 "4%'(0 '##$+ (')&$ %$&$"($%! )/'$7"/$+3$)#(3"%$')#0$"--1'&"#')(8--+#$%92") "'%"/'#.#0$"--1'&"#')'("117$%")%-$+()3$)#')$%')-"+"#0$ "--1'&"#')'("117$%#9$9+840#)+$&+%"(1$4"1+$-+$($)#"#'/$ "--1'&")#5 +$(-)%$)# "4%'(0 '##$+ (')&$ %$&$"($%! + #0$ -8+-($-+$($)#1'(.(89:$&##:8(#$;&$-#')( "#
0$ -+$($)# "--$"1 %'+$&#( &0"11$)4$ "4"')(# &)&8++$)# ')%')4(+$&+%$%92#0$ 8+#(70$+$92(8'#+-$+3")$)#'):8)&#') +$(#+"')')4 #0$ +$(-)%$)#(5%$$)%")#( +3 ')#$+$+')4 ') -$"&$81 -(($((')")%%'(-(($((')4#0$-1"')#'5"--$11")# (')&$%$&$"($%!)7 +$-+$($)#$%920'(1$4"1+$-+$($)#"#'/$(+31")%3$"(8+')4*<")"1("(
-$+:"3"9")%'+#0$2$"+
*
('#8"#$%')='11"4$ 0"))'">"1").
%$#"'1$%')0$"%)#$#0$-1"')#7"(%'(3'(($%92#0$#+'"1 8+#/'%$ :8%43$)#")%%$&+$$%"#$% ? ")%#0$-1"')#'5"--$11")#+$3"')$% 8)(8&&$((819$+$#0$'+(#--$11"#$ 8+# 0$ -1"')#'5"--$11")# &1"'3$% 0'3($1 # 9$ 7)$+ ') -(($((')(8'#-+-$+#2")%0"((7)(84"+&")$")%70$"#&+-("#$+ (-$)%')4084$3)$2)1$/$11')4.&81#'/"#')")%(7')4&+-( #'( "/$++$%#0"##0$%$$)%")#(')&))'/")&$7'#0#0$+$/$)8$'&'"1(0"/$ 4#&0")4$%
')"/8+%$$)%")#70'&07"( $"+1'$+')#0$)"3$#0$"--$11")#5-1"')#'
$(-)%$)#5%$$)%")#&)#$(#$%#0$(8'#+"'(')4-1$" #0"##0$-1"')#'$;$&8#$%"4+$$3$)##($11')"/8+%$$)%")# ")%0$'1$%(8'#+(-$&''&-$++3")&$"4+$$3$)##($1170'&07"( %$&+$$%')0'("/8+")%38#"#')7"((")&#')$%"+#'#')7"($$&#$% ")%(8'#1")%0"("11$)#(0"+$%$$)%")#")%-(($((')#0$+$ 7"(%$1'/$+$%92#0$+$/$)8$ 8+#")%%$$)%")##+")($++$%#0$ (8'#1")%#%$$)%")#70'()77)$+')-(($((')(8'#1")% 0$-1"')#'+$1'$%8-)&-2<0"(+"4'+%"7"+';@ +%$+(%"#$% ? ;?@%"#$%
;A@%"#$% ?
;*")%&-2(#"#$3$)#%"#$% ? ; 0$%&83$)#( +$1'$%8-)92#0$-1"')#'5"--$11")#-$+#"')##0$-$+'%(89($B8$)## ')(#'#8#')(8'#)
C8+')4-$)%$)&2(8'#9$+$#0$ '/'1 8+#+"'(')4%'(-8#$7'#0+$4"+%#-(($((')(8'#1")%.#0$+$/$)8$ "8#0+'#'$( "+$ )# &3-$#$)# # 3"<$ &0")4$ ') <0"(+" 4'+%"7"+'. #0$+$+$. #0$"--$11")#&"))#%$+'/$")2"%/")#"4$#0'(&)#$)#')
+3&0")4$')<0"(+"4'+%7"+'++%$+-"(($%92#0$+$/$)8$"8#0+'#'$( ')#0'(+$4"+%)#0'(&)#$;#.+$$+$)&$&")9$3"%$#:8%43$)#(#0'( 8+#
")% ! "
#
$%# )#0'(/'$7#0$3"##$+.#0$"--$11")#&"))#%$+'/$")2 "%/")#"4$#0'(&)#$)#')+3#0$%&83$)#(+$1'$%8-)920'3.') +%$+#&)#$)%#0"#&)&8++$)#')%')4(+$&+%$%92#0$ 8+#((8$+ +3")$+++38&01$((-$+/$+('#2 #0$+-')#0"(9$$)+"'($%
+#0$+$4')4+$"()(.#0$"--$"1"'1(")%'("&&+%')412 %'(3'(($% +%$+"(#&(#(
$<0" '##"1!
8%4$ * 30")9'39+"