High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3290/2017dismissed

Sunder Singh & ORS v. Vinod Kumar & ORS

2019-05-22Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

!"##$%&%'(!)* +',#-%'./ "/#-& 00#11!'"& 2#-&+& 2%',3+4!- "/#-& #&0',#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

-#&#'"( & %"+ !"/!5*,6$!"#* -"/#!00#11!'"& 77777 *)+%,' 89

- "/# -#!&'& 4#'"%'#, %' "/# !001%$!"%'* :/%$/ %& &+00-"#, ;) !' !%,!6%"* ,#1!) <= ,!)& %' -#9%1%'. "/# !00#!1 %& $','#, &"!',&,%&0&#,

00#11!'"9,##',!'"&!-#%' #.+1!-#$',00#!1!.!%'&""/# $'$+--#'"%',%'.&!$"*:/#-#;)"/#&+%""/#-#&0',#'"901!%'"%&- ,#$1!-!"%'";#:'#-&%'0&&#&&%'1!',4#!&+-%'.<<&>)!-,&+" ""!11!',4#!&+-%'.&>)!-,&%'-#&0#$"01"& =*8* 89!', =:%"/-#&"-!%'"-4-$%;1#%'"#-#-#'$#%'"/#0#!$#+10&&#&&%'* -!%&%'.$'&"-+$"%'!',!1&-4!1%#'!"%'."/#&+%"1!','"/#;!&%& "/#.%",##,,!"#,8=*/!&;##',#$-##,;)"/#"-%!1+-"!', !%-4#,%'!00#!1

":!&!11#.#,"/!" "/# !-#4#'"%'#, 01"& :#-# !11""#, " "/#%-4"/#-!-!:!"%*/#-&%&"#-3!-%&/'!!',/#-4"/#-3/!?!'%%'! 0!-"%"%'&+%"8=8=/#01!%'"%&;#$!4#:'#-&"/#01"" "/##@"#'"/!1&/!-#'!$$+'""/#,#!"/!-!:!"%/#)!1'. :%"/ "/#%-;-"/#- 2%A!) %'/#-%"#, "/# &/!-# " "/##@"#'" B8"/ !', #@#$+"#, !&!1# ,##, ,!"#, =< !', &1, 1!', 4#!&+-%'. == &>)!-,&",##',!'"&!',!',$'"%'+#,"-#4!%':'#-<< &>)!-,&:#6#-*%'+.+&"*=*,##',!'" !"/#-,##',!'"

& !00-!$/#,01!%'"%-"/#-#4!%'%'.1!',!',/#!.-##, ""-!'&#-/%&:'&/!-#*;+"6#-)$1!',#&"%'#1);"!%'#,!.%",##,*:/%$/ :!&%11#.!1!',01!%'"%:!&'"$40#"#'"",'!"#"/#1!',*"/#-#-#*! -!+,!',4%&-#0-#&#'"!"%':!&;#%'.01!)#,+0'/%4 ##',!'"&-#&%&"#,"/#$1!%4;)"!5%'.6!-%+&0-#1%4%'!-) ;A#$"%'&!',&"!"#,"/!"%":!&!61+'"!-)!$"/#$'"#'"&"/#.%" ,##,:#-#-#!,6#-!',#@01!%'#,"01!%'"%!',!"#-!$$#0"%'."/# &!4#!&$--#$"*!00#',#,/%&&%.'!"+-#& ##',!'"/!,!1-#!,) 0+-$/!&#, "/# 1!', 4#!&+-%'. 8 &>)!-,& -4 01" = !', "/# -#4!%'%'.!-#!:!&.%6#'%'!4%1)&#""1#4#'"/#.%",##,:!&%'-#&0#$" "/#;!1!'$#0!-$#11!',

1!%'"%&* %' &+00-" "/# !-#4#'"%'#, 01#!,%'.&* #@!4%'#, '1) ": :%"'#&&#& !', "/# ,##',!'"& !1& #@!4%'#, ": :%"'#&&#& & %"+ !"/!5*1#!-'#,$+'&#1-#0-#&#'"%'."/#!00#11!'"9 ,##',!'"&&+;4%""#,"/!";"/"/#$+-"&;#1:/!6#%.'-#,"/#01#!"/!" "/#-#&0',#'"901!%'"%&,%,'"$4#""/#$+-":%"/$1#!'/!',&'!$"* %"%&"/#01!%'"%&://!,"!5#'"/#01#!"/!",##',!'"-!+,+1#'"1)

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

-"/#-#!&'&4#'"%'#,!;6#*,'"%',!')%11#.!1%")-

- 0#-6#-&%")%'"/#$'$+--#'"%',%'.&.-+',-%'"#-#-#'$#%&4!,# +"*4+$/1#&&%'616#4#'"!')&+;&"!'"%!1>+#&"%'1!: #&+1"!'"1)* "/#!00#!1%&,%&4%&&#,

., *)+%

/01 '(23& +141056 70

807

+141 49!

807