Karmanya Gupta v. State Of Haryana


 



       











  



 


 
!"#

$

% "
&

' 

#   

 

 

 

 ! "# 

 &
 (
&
)%
* +


)"

,
) (
)% 
+
##- #



.-/ 
& ,+
0

1(
)!(
' 

+
#&



)  
&,+ (
)%   

 

$ 

%&'&'%
( 2+
- 
&
"-

+
+
+

3/ 


+
"##-
3 -
##-  

+
* +
+
# % "
3 - ##-   4
- ,+

+
(
+
# 
##-  

--*

%% %%-
-%
( 5
 ,"
3
+  2+
# "  
!"#
+
",+
+   #
3 -
"
& 
6


$  


3

,
74 8




"
& 

9 :9:(
 

+ 4 
$-

,  

$- 
& 
;(
&
 ( !"

", 2+
# 

*
,
,  
3

"

 - (
*+
+##

3

--,"

+
# (

+
 %
3- +(

!"

",

2+
--, 
 
+
+ #- 

* ,



"-

+

# 
+
#

"

,
+
"



+

/3(


 * +
+
+

%-#
- ,

+
+

<

6( +
#- 
 %

-#+ 
--
 
+
# (
-- , +

1
*
+
*--

2+
#- (

 - 
+
( *

+
*-- ,
" 

+
#
 "
 ,+
 

4
"

,
+
% (
+
"
 
+


*+ +
*
-
* +
  %

4

"3="(
+ (
+
"
1
"" %,

+
#+  -


+
#- 

 -
+

, 
+ +

+




*
#+, #+(
*+
+ #- 
+ 
+
# (
+
#-, >

+ 
1 
# 



+

7 ,
+
"
*

,,- ,
"

+  (

+

#- 







#- 


6

%&% --*
3


(



2+
#-  



  ="



+
*+ -(
+
74

=" (
*
,

,  



2+
- 

"-
+
 ,"
+
+ #- 


+
# (
 
, *
"#
"


#- 
 +

 

* 


"-
- + #

4

 ," +
 
="




+
#



%,
 %,(
+
# 

+
3
,
,  
3
+ #- 

+ 


 -
% 

"## 
+
 2+
- 
&
"-
 
3
- 
"-  (
+%
 ,-
##
+
3 -(


- (

+ , "
+
" -


, 

+
# 
 -(
 % *

+
+ "

+


- (

3-
+

%

+
% (

--,(

+%
3
# # 
3
+ # +



3-1 -
+
#- 

4

"3  +
+
"(

+
# ?



,(
+
?#- 

", "


,

-

#(
3 ,
+

# + 3-
(
+ # 

 -


-  )##   ,
+
"3  


+ 
3 
+ "

(


- -

-
- 




,"- - + #

2+ # (
3 ,


- + #
* +
+
#- (

 + 
,(

+*

+%
--"


+
# 
#- 

+ # ?





,



+





1
""
%,

3+

%% +
"


-

+
# ?



,

2+
 

+


*

"-
- + #
3
*
"-

,
3
+  -
 
, ,
#-

+
 

4


-
"
( *+ 
+
"
"
+
#- 


"-- 
+

-  
3
-, ,

#- (
+
",+

 -- --
+



+
# ?



,
+ (
"--
* 
+
+
"
%







+
*
- 


- + # * +
+
-
--,"

4


3
1#


+
#





(

, 

% "-(
3"
+
 

- ,(
*+ + +


"
# " 

+
#+  -

-
+-+

+ %  




-

 , 

 

2+ ,"

+
&
+
+
" -


, 

+ # 
%
"+
 -

3- ,
%

+
% ( 
# # 
3
+
#
  - (
,+ +
+
--,    -
+
#


- 

+"(
 ,



(
+ # 
# 

  .

 

/ 
 
( 

 ;++
#1 ,   @8
;++
# 3-  @8