High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/50806/2023disposed of

Angrej Singh v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-10-09Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary4 pages

!" #$%&%&'()(*&!(!+,-.%/ 0123456378984:;(<=(=!(!+ >:?@3AB8:?C ====D328284:3@ EFGHIH B212345J1@K1:11:6>:42C3@ ===$39L4:63:29 M NO P QQQQQ D@393:2; %@=$1A8RBC1@S1T>6R4712354@2C3L328284:3@ QQQQQ

O O = UC3 L@393:2 L328284: C19 V33: 58W36 54@ XY19C8:? 45 Z[$ \4='< 61236 !=(+=!(!T @3?8923@36 Y:63@ B37284: ]"&> [D#T 12 D4W873 B21284: ^1@:1W #8R8W _8:39T 0892@872 ^1@:1W 19 `3WW 19 54@ 93228:? 19863 2C3 4@63@ 61236 !)=(!=!(!( 637W1@8:? 2C3 L328284:3@ 19 L@47W18S36 L3@94: 8: 74SLW18:2 \4=\>#U&!+<(&!(< 61236(*=(]=!(<58W36Y:63@B37284:+)\[>72= != _31@:36 74Y:93W 74:23:69 2C12 2C3 L328284:3@ `19 9YSS4:36 8: 1 74SLW18:2 Y:63@ B37284: +) \[ >72 4: 1774Y:2 45 1 7C3XY3 ?8R3: 54@ LY@7C193 45 4:3 S4V8W3 LC4:3 C1R8:? ?

4223: 689C4:4@36= >9 1 S1223@ 45 5172T C3 C16 21a3: 1 W41: 45 $9=* W179 5@4S C89 @3W128R39 24 921@2 L4YW2@K 51@S VY98:399T `C3@38: C3 9Y553@36 W49939 1:6 6Y3 24 `C87CT C3 74YW6 :42 3R3: L1K 2C3 L@873 45 2C3 S4V8W3 19 1W94 `19 Y:1VW3 24 S1a3 L1KS3:2 54@ 94S32C8:? 19 V1987 19 @3:2 19 `3WW= UC3 L328284:3@ C16 94W6 C89 C4Y93 1:6 W8R36 4: @3:2 8: :31@VK 1@319T 19 1 @39YW2 45 `C87CT C3 74YW6 :42 ?32 8:54@S1284: 54@ 2`4 K31@9 1V4Y2 2C3 L@393:2 7193 1:6 `19 :42 93@R36= J4`3R3@T YL4: 2C3 @3?892@1284: 45 2C3 8SLY?

!" #$ %&$' !($)# # *! # # !#

!+ (& + ,!-+ ! .-$ ,!/"+ .-0$& !&+ /""+/!#,1 #$$% 0#.0 #$ 0##, # +/0.)#2 -!*#- # $".,!/&!&# "!+ ! 0#!#"&# # !#

+$0 &$# '/0 #$ .)-0) # "!##- !&1"$- # $".,!/&# '!0 $-+-+ #$ ( '/# +-!'& (1 # #-/!,

$)-# 4/+ $-+- +!#+ 25256 &&7) 2 !(0& $* # .#/#/$&- /0 &/# - '/,*), &$- +,/(-!# $& ! $)&# $* # -!0$& !*$-0!/+ !&+ # !# !*#- # $".,!/&# /#0,* '!0 +/0"/00+ !0 '/# +-!'& # )0 # $&#/&)!#/$& $* # .-0&# .-$ +/&80 '$),+ !"$)&##$!()0$*.-$ 00$* $)-#2 62 9$#/ $*"$#/$&2 2 :-2 ;!8+/0 :!& !&+!

++/#/$&!, < =!-1!&!

!..!-0 $& - /.# $*!+4!& &$#/ !&+ !0&$$(> #/$&#$# .-!1-"!+/&# .-0&#.#/#/$&2 ?2 - /0 &$ & 00/#1 $* /00)/&8 &$#/ #$ !,, ).$& *$- !&1 -0.$&0 *-$"-0.$&+&#9$2 /&4/'$*# $-+-'/# +-!'/&8# $".,!/&#2 @2 =!-+2 2 # /0 !..$0/# #$ -*- #$ # $-+- +!#+ 25256 &&7)- .!00+ (1 # #-/!,

$)-# '

-(1 #

$".,!/&# /& A)0#/$& /#0,* '!0 $-+-+ #$ ('/# +-!'& '

/ -!+0# )0B CD/, #!%& ). $& # !..,/ !#/$& *$- '/# +-!'!, $* # .-0&# $".,!/&#

!0 (& "$4+2 E!-&+ $)&0, *$- # $".,!/&!&#

!0 "!+ ! 0#!#"&# # !# !0 .- # /&0#-) #/$&0 $* $".,!/&!&#

+$0 &$# '!&# #$ .)-0) *)-# -'/# # /0 $".,!/&#!&+'/# +-!'0# 0!"2=!-+2 & 4/' $* # 0#!#"&# - $-++ !($4 # $".,!/&# /&

!&+ /0 FGHIGHHJF KH LGMNFOKLP 2 Q!/, ($&+0 !&+ 0)-#1 ($&+0 *)-&/0 + $& ( !,* $* ! )0+ 0#!&+ +/0 !-8+ !&+ # -4&) !)# $-/#/0R-8/0#-/&8 !)# $-/#1 ST3U $& -&+ !- +/- #+ #$ -,!0 # .-$.-#1R-8/0#-!#/$& -#/*/ !# $* / , $* 0)-#1 !##!

+ /& $&& #/$& '/# # /0 $".,!/&# /""+/!#,1 $& *)-&/0 /&8 -#/*/+ $.1 $* # /0 $-+-2 VGWJ XJ YZPHG[PJF MZ MNJ OJYZOF OZZI K\MJO F]JYZI^WGKPYJ_ `

" #$$ %& '( %$ ' ) *+,-,-./-01/) 2345232 6 071/01/7) 895: *6;<8 =;>:932 893 ?+ <3@5:83<32 ;23< A34856 /B.-C D* 5 E;<:;>43 6F 893 :388G3H38 ><<5I32 >8 J38K33893E><853:)>293G289;:L MD<>N3< 5 895: E385856 5: F6< =;>:95@ 6F ?+ O6P. 2>832 /Q1001/B F5G32 ;23< A34856 /B.-C 6F 893 25> D3>G *623 <3@5:83<32 >8 D6G543 A8>856 A3486<-Q) D>49R;G> >2 >GG 6893< :;J:3=;38 E<643325@: ><5:5@ 893<36F >: K3GG >: 6<23< 2>832 0./101/P E>::32 JN 893 8<5>G *6;<8 I523 K9549 > 25<34856 K>:5::;3286<3@5:83<893>F6<3:>52?

+ SSSSSSSSS T3><32 46;:3G F6< 893 E3858563< 9>: <3G532 ;E6 893 2345:56: <323<32 JN 895: *6;<8 5 U V5R>: A9><H> I: W;<E<338 A5@9 X69G5 >2 >6893< Y:;E<>Z) 01/B) YZ TC+Q.) ,54<6=;>G [3496 T5H5832 >2 6893<: V: A8>83 6F \><N>> >2 >6893<) 01/Q Y0Z +*+ Y*<GZ B71 >2 U+>]33:9 X9>> V: A8>83 6F \><N>> >2 >6893<U 01/BYZ TC+ QQQ K93<35 5 > 523854>G 45<4;H:8>43) 895: *6;<8 9>: 93G2 89>8 :543 893 H>5 E385856 F5G32 ;23< A34856 / 6F 893 C48 :8>2: K5892<>K 5 I53K 6F > >H54>JG3 :388G3H38 J38K33 893 E><853:) 893<3F6<3) 4685;>856 6F E<643325@: ;23< A34856 /B.

C 6F D* :9>GG J36895@J;8>>J;:36F893E<643::6FG>K SSSSSSSSS I53K 6F 893 :>H3) F52 H3<58 5 893 E<3:38 E385856 >2 >446<25@GN) E<3:38 E385856 5: >GG6K32 >2 893 5HE;@32 6<23< 2>832 0./101/P E>::32 JN ^;2545>G ,>@5:8<>83) /:8 *G>::) D>49R;G> >: K3GG >: ?+ O6P. 2>832 /Q1001/B <3@5:83<32 ;23< A34856 /B.

!" #$$ %& '( f 01/Q Y0Z +*+ Y*<5H5>GZ B71g h

! i

!" #$$ %& '( %$ 'f 01/B YZ TC+ QQQ) *+,-,0P/0 6F 0101) #c'

' #` j

!" #$$ %& '( %$ ' 2345232 6 /01/010/) 893 E<643325@: 5585>832 ;23< A34856 /B.-C

! "# $ % & $ %' $ ( &) *+,- ./0 123 45056 78 0+90:0 ;<;=>?@ ABBAB>%C%'

D@ EF? "# &"G%'H $ %' $ $ I

G (&'%!! $ %G D

"C%%&' &) $ J $%B K LA %

' & $(&C &) $ &! !(D %'H $ J$%$%&'

J&(D %C! J&' %' J&(!%'H %'%$% $!

'! ($%&' =?M &) N O($ %( $ '! $$D! $ (&CJD %'$

"' %$ ! '

'! $ J&(!%'H

%'$ $

(( ! J$%$%&' !&JJ!B '

( (%( C$ '( $ (&'$%'

$%&' &) J&( $%&'

'! P($%&' =QRO %' J

'( $& &! J !"#$ $% D& $( ''&$"JC%$$!$&(&'$%'

BS =<B ' $ J'$ ( $ J$%$%&' !(D !

J&(D %C! J&' J

'$ $& %( $ %CJ H'! LA H%$!

)$ C& $ '

'! $ %' (&CJD %'$ %$D) $&&! %$ ! ' '( $ % & $ )%'! '& T $%)% "D &' $& (&'$%'

%$ $ J&(!%'H %' $ LA %'

$%&' %(

D% "D $& "

! %' U(% &) J&

'! P($%&' M;

D! %' .*V62/ 46/V0, 123 4/0W2/6+ 4-:V/ X7V- >;<<Y@ = P FM? "%'H

&) $ J&( &) $ (& $B ==B O((&!%'HD# $ J'$ J$%$%&' %

DD&!B K %CJ H'! &! !

$! ;MB<;B;<;< J ! "# $ Z !%(% D [ H%$ $ L%$ D \ '

D % $

'! $ D$ '$ LA N&B=EY !

$! ;=B<?B;<;= H%$!

'! P($%&' =QRO $&D%(P$ $%&'\ '

D%G%D]%'^%$%($\ '

D% "#

__`_ab_c .abXd

e57f6+gh [B\ C i $ J j%'Hk &'! l mkN& i $ J&$ "D l mkN&