Boriya & ANR v. Harjinder Kaur & ORS

 
  
!


 !"#$ %$&'(')*  +',"")%")#-$+  ..$//")#(  0$+(1( "+2')%$+3"1+")%#-$+(  
$(.)%$)#( 
* 45
 5


+$($)#* +"+'(-"')6%7&"#$6

+#-$"..$//")#(  5
6 +"/  -'("..$"/-"(8$$) '/$%"9"')(##-$21%9:$)#(")%%$&+$$(

#-$/$"+)$%'7'/ 1%9$ 1)'+!'7'(')6"+;")"6")%#-$/$"+)$%!'(#+'&#

1%9$6 ')%6%"#$% <  ")%< 6+$(.$&#'7$/,6%'(:'((')9#-$(1'#

+.$+:")$)#')21)&#') '/$%8,#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(6")%#-$"..$"/

'/$%"9"')(#(1&-%'(:'(("/ -$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

((19-#.$+:")$)#')21)&#')"9"')(# #-$+$(.)%$)#(=%$ $)%")#( +:')#$+ $+')9')#-$'+.$"&$ 1/.(($((')

#-$(1'#.+.$+#,6(#"#$%#-"7$8$$).1+&-"($%8,#-$: +:+$(.)%$)#  -$+$')6
":-")%$+67'%$("/$%$$%%"#$% 

> =8$ +$ #-$/$"+)$%'7'/ 1%9$)#-$8"('( #-$("/$%$$%6":1#"#')'("/( (#"#$%  #  -"7$  8$$)  $)#$+$%  ')  "71+    #-$  "..$//")#(=./"')#'

(  ) ?

> =  -$1+#(8$/; 1)%#-"##-$7$)%+ #-$(1'#/")%##-$ "..$//")#(=./"')#'

6'$#-$"

+$("'%
":-")%$+6%$ $)%")# 8$ +$ #-$#+'"/1+#6-"%.1+&-"($%#-$(1'#/")% +:)$3+'(-)"!$7')#

 ':./$"%$%')#-$(1'#67'%$"("/$%$$%%"#$%  <

<3+'(-)"!$7'6') #1+)-"%.1+&-"($%?@A?#- (-"+$')/")%:$"(1+')9<B")"/(?:"+/"(

+:  )$  -")%")  ')    ")%  @A#- (-"+$  ')  #-$  ("'%  /")%  ;"( .1+&-"($%8,)$-$-")%() "'-")%6 +:#-$("'%-")%") -$+$"

#$+6-$-")%(4()61/"8 ')9-67'%$("/$%$$% %"#$%  ? < >!6-"%(/%

/")%:$"(1+')9 (C,"+%(# "+2')%$+3"1+6'$#-$+$(.)%$)#=%$ $)%")# 3+'(-)"!$7'-"%(/%

-$+(-"+$')#-$.+.$+#,6"(.$+#-$

#-$/$"+)$%'7'/ 1%9$6#8-$,
":() -$-")% 8+#-$+ 1/"8')9-67'%$("/$%$$%%"#$% < ?

 ( .$+ #-$ 21%9:$)#  #-$ /$"+)$%  '+(# ..$//"#$ 1+#6 "..$//")# 6-$+')9-(#%')#-$;'#)$((8>"( D")%-"% #$(#'

'$%#-"#-$")%"..$//")#-"%#9$#-$+.1+&-"($%?:"+/"($C1"/ #(C,"+%(6'$ @ ?(-"+$6 +:
":-")%$+67'%$#-$("/$%$$%%"#$%

 (.$+3+'(-)"!$7'6;-(#%"(;'#)$(( +#-$%$ $)%")#( !D 6(-$-"%(/% :"+/"( -$+/")%67'%$("/$%$$%%"#$% < ?

 )-$+&+((=$>":')"#')6(-$(#"#$%#-"#(-$-"%.1+&-"($%

(C,"+%( ")%-"%)$7$+(/%"), '##"+2')%$+3"1+81#-"%(/%'##
":31:"+ )##
":-")%$+ ;$7$+6  #-$  /$"+)$%  1+#  8$/;6  " #$+  "..+"'(')9  #-$ $7'%$)&$6&":$##-$ ')%')9#-"#3+'(-)"!$7'-"% "&#1"//,"/'$)"#$%-$+ $)#'+$(-"+$')#-$(1'#/")%?@A?#-(-"+$#8-$,
":")%
":31:"+6 7'%$#-$("/$%$$%%"#$% < ?

>!?6")%"((1&-(-$;"(6') "&#6 /$ #;'#-)/")%#($//#
":-")%$+)#-$%"#$#-"#(-$;"((#"#$%#



-"7$$>$&1#$%#-$("/$%$$%')-'( "71+6)  <

< 87'1(/,6)&$
":-")%$+&1/%)#-"7$8$$)(/%/")% #-"#;"()#"&#1"//,')#-$;)$+(-'. -'(7$)%+3+'(-)"!$7'6-$') #1+)6&1/%)#-"7$(/%"),(1&-/")%##-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(67'%$("/$ %$$%%"#$% 



5$"+)$%&1)($/ +#-$"..$//")#(-"()#8$$)"8/$#+$81# #-$($ "&#1"/ ')%')9( #-$/$"+)$%1+#8$/; $6-;$7$+6+'9-#/,(18:'#(#-"#'#8$')9"(1'# +.$+:")$)# ')21)&#')6'#;1/%)#8$)$&$(("+,#(-;#-$#'#/$##-$/")%681# .(($((')#-$+$ 6#8$#-"#

( .$+1("/ #-$ #-$1+#(8$/;6-;$7$+6"/( (-;(#-"##-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(&1/%)#.+7$$7$)#-$'+.(($((')) #-$(1'#/")%6')"),:"))$+) "&#6#-$C1$(#') #'#/$##-$/")%;"( 9)$')#8,#-($/$"+)$%1+#()/,8$&"1($.(($((')#-$+$ ;"( ')#+'&"#$/,/')B$%##-$#'#/$6"(#-$("/$%$$%%"#$% 

"/((#"#$% #-$+$')#-"#.(($((') #-$.+.$+#,-"%8$$)-")%$%7$+##-$7$)%$$(6 '$#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(  5$"+)$%&1)($/ 1+#-$+(18:'#(#-"# +$(.)%$)#(=%$ $)%")#( ")% +$(.)%$)# 8$')9#-$-1(8")% +$(.)%$)#6"&#1"//, +$('%$') ")&-B1/"")%-$)&$6&"))#8$').(($((') /")%('#1"#$%') "+;")"6!'(#+'&# ')% -$  ("'%  "+91:$)#  '(  ;-//,  "//"&'1(  8$&"1($  #  8$  ') "),.+.$+#,6.$+:")$)#.-,('&"/.+$($)&$ #-$.$+()) #-$("'%.+.$+#,'(687'1(/,6)#)$&$(("+,.$+()/'7')9$/($;-$+$&") 8$6)$7$+#-$/$((6')&:./$#$&)#+/ .+.$+#,('#1"#$$/($;-$+$6#-+19-

 ($+7")#(6"9$)#($#& +$7$)1$+$&+%6+"),;'#)$(($>":')$%6#.+7$#-"##-$ (1'#.+.$+#,$7$+&":$')##-$.(($((')

(6-"( 8$$)+$ $++$%#6#-$+#-")##-$#$(#':), "..$//")# -':($/ 6;-$) -$"..$"+$%"( D )/,#-$:1#"#')$)#$+$%') "71+ #-$"..$//")#(6"(##-$ #'#/$ #-$/")%6"

#$+#-$("/$%$$%$>$&1#$%')#-$'+ "71+8,3+'(-)"!$7'

) 

6-"(8$$)+$/'$%1.)8,/$"+)$%&1)($/ $7'%$)&$/$%8$ +$#-$1+#(8$/;-"(8$$)+$ $++$%#6 #%'(.+7$#-$+$"()$% #-$1+#(8$/;5$"+)$%&1)($/(4 &)#$)#')+$.$"#$%/,'(#-"#"("/$%$$%-"7')98$$)$>$&1#$%') "71+

#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(")%:1#"#')#-$+$"

#$+-"7')98$$)$)#$+$%')#-$'+

"71+6#-$'+.(($((')##-$/")%;1/%8$&:$")"#1+"/&)($C1$)&$6 (')&$"+$&'#"/')#-$("/$%$$%(#"#$%#-"#.(($((') #-$(1'#/")%-"% 8$$)"&#1"//,-")%$%7$+##-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

( ) "&#6)(.$&'

'&C1$+,6/$"+)$%&1)($/(18:'#(#-"##-$+ #-")"..$//")# 6-$+')9-6)#-$+;'#)$(((#$..$%')##-$;'#)$(( 8>#(#"#$#-"#"&#1"/.(($((') #-$(1'#/")%-"%$7$+8$$)-")%$% 7$+##-$"..$//")#( $ 1+#-$+(18:'#(6)C1$+,6#-"##-$+$7$)1$ +$&+%6'$2":"8")%'$(+$&+%( +'9-#6+$ /$&#$%3+'(-)"!$7'67$)%+

#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(6#8$').(($((') #-$/")%6"((-;)')#-$ &/1:) &1/#'7"#')61.##-$,$"+(

= > = (+$9"+%(#-$ ,$"+(8$#;$$)

= #

<=

6)$'#-$+#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(6)+#-$ +$(.)%$)#(=%$ $)%")#(6$>-'8'#$%"),42":"8")%'E#(-;"(#;-;"(') .(($((')6"(.$+#-$&/1:) &1/#'7"#')

? ? "7')9&)('%$+$%#-$"87$6'#'(87'1( +:".$+1("/

#-$ ')%')9) "&#(8,#-$1+#(8$/;6#-"#3+'(-)"!$7'-"%"/+$"%,(/% 

-$+$)#'+$/")%#8-$,
":")%
":31:"+) <?

6")%"( +$9"+%(+$(.)%$)#6"+2')%$+3"1+6(-$-"%.1+&-"($%-$-")%(4 (-"+$ +:-'(()1/"8')9-6)? < -$6#-1(6%'%)#.1+&-"($ "),/")% +:3+'(-)"!$7' -$C1$(#')6#-$+$ +$6'(#-"#;'#-3+'(-)"!$7'-"7')9(/% 

-$+(-"+$')#-$(1'#/")%#8-$,
":")%
":31:"+) <?

6 81#(#'//8$')9(-;)#8$').(($((')#-$+$" #$+6&1/%(-$-"7$.1#
":

-")%$++$(.)%$)#').(($((')6"

#$+;-'&-
":-")%$+.1##-$ "..$//")#(=./"')#'

(').(($((') #-$(1'#/")%F -"#C1$(#')-"("/(#8$")(;$+$%')#-$)$9"#'7$6"(
": -")%$+  -':($/  ;"(  )$7$+6  "%:'##$%/,6  $7$+  (-;)  #  8$  ')  "&#1"/ #-$(1'#/")%$)&$6"),+$&'#"/')#-$("/$%$$%$>$&1#$%8, -':6') "71+

(6(#"#')9#-"#-$-"%-")%$%7$+ .(($((')##-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(6&"))#8$8$/'$7$%)#-$ "&$ '#
":-")%$+"/()$7$+(#$..$%')##-$;'#)$((8>##$(#' ,##-"# $

$&# -$+$ +$6(':./,)#-$8"('( ":1#"#') #'#/$$)#$+$%')

"71+ #-$"..$//")#(6)#-$8"('( "("/$%$$%$>$&1#$%')#-$'+ "71+ 8,3+'(-)"!$7') 

6#-$'+.(($((')7$+#-$(1'#/")%%$()# (#")%.+7$%')"),:"))$+ 5$"+)$%&1)($/7$+, "'+/,6)C1$+,6(18:'#(#-"#3+'(-)"

!$7'-$+($/ -"%(#$..$%')##-$;'#)$((8>"(!D ")%(#"#$%#-"#(-$ )$7$+"&#1"//,(/%#-$(1'#/")%"#"//#
":-")%$+")%$7$)%$)'$%-$+

 .-#9+".-)#-$("/$%$$% D-$#-$+#-"#;"()/,#("7$-$+-$+($/

+:&+':')"/")%#-$+.+&$$%')9(6'(":"##$+ &)2$&#1+$E-;$7$+68$ #-"#  "(  '#  :",6  #-$  "&#  '(  #-"#  ;-$) 
":  -")%$+  )$7$+  &":$  ')# #-$(1'#/")%-':($/ 6#-$C1$(#') -'(-")%')97$+(1&- .(($((')##-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(%$()#"+'($ $)&$6;-$)#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

()$7$+&":$')#.-,('&"/ #-$(1'#/")%6"(1'#($$B')9.$+:")$)#')21)&#')"9"')(##-$ +$(.)%$)#(=%$ $)%")#(  +:  ')#$+ $+')9  ')  #-$'+  .$"&$ 1/  .(($((')6 87'1(/,;1/%)#/'$  )7'$; ;-"#-"(8$$)-$/%"87$6#-'("..$"/'(%'(:'(($%6 ;'#-)+%$+"(#&(#( #-')9  ("'%  -$+$')  "87$  (-"//  8$  &)(#+1$%  #  8$  "), &::$)#)#-$+'9-#(+#-$+;'($

(C1"+$&7$+,  "),&)('%$+"#'):)$,."'%+)#."'%8,#-$:6#
":-")%$+ ),(1&-.+&$$%')9(6'

8+19-#8,#-$"..$//")#(=./"')#'

(6;1/%8$ %$&'%$%;-//,)#-$:$+'#(#-$+$ 

 )7'$; #-$ "&##-"##-$"..$"/-"(8$$)%'(:'(($%):$+'#(6


 #-$C1$(#') &)%)')9#-$%$/", %",(') '/')9'#6'( +$)%$+$%"&"%$:'&    .B