Noman Khan v. State Of Haryana

0 ;<;5







  
   

 
   

 
   

 
   

  
  

  
  

  
  

  
   ;



  B: -- "

" % "$($ #

 ! "# B: $'*   !  !  !  !" $ "% " $ "% " $ "% " $ "%  !  !  !  !'"( '"( '"( '"( (*+ '" (*+ '" (*+ '" (*+ '"  !',*  !',*  !',*  !',*
&
&
&
& " $  " $  " $  " $ & & & & &  ) 3 "</;<;5  ) 3 "</;<;5  ) 3 "</;<;5  ) 3 "</;<;5 ()   ()   ()   ()  &&&&  ) 3 "  ) 3 "  ) 3 "  ) 3 "<1/;<;5 /;<;5 /;<;5 /;<;5 () *& () *& () *& () *& (,, (,, (,, (,, *-+& *-+& *-+& *-+&   ) 3 "  ) 3 "  ) 3 "  ) 3 "<1/;<;5

 8.

:



 8.

:



 8.

:



 8.

:



 .

 .

 .

 . ": (-,="/ -"*%) ": -/*%) / ": "(% -+ /*%) * $: >$=--/*%) !" '

 =-  ' -- ": $:"-#? *"

?("/ - " "#: @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@  .

 .

 .

 ./:6.9 /:6.9 /:6.9 /:6.9















 " $ ' -- $3 !-, *( (* " )-5;4! 
* !

!
"--,") ) *(" /0126!"$ "7
"::
:8 9/$ ?-+C($ -+!-'(+ * * "* " * * 0;:<1:;<; 6 A("  9 '

'$$ * 3#  , " * (*-)-, , +-$"  $ $
,$$/"-*3*/= " 3#/

' -- " $3 * )," *$ $ '"),- * '

' "$/ - )$    :5;*  * ;:<0:;<;;/ " +-$ " * !"

" )-$$- !!! ) '(-$ 3, (* " ) )-$;;
D;1! ")-) ) "(+$*$ $#) "'-) (3$) $)/0145 6!"$ "7  )89/,-)

-3( /"-*3*:

; ;: . " *)($ ,!" ' -- " $- " * -'(+ * "* "/= " 3# ' -- " $3 * )," *'"),- *' "$/-$= ,,# -,, +,/ "3-""# * ($($-3,  -  # $ ! ,=:   -$ "+( * ' -- " $ 3  !,$ ,# -',-) * -  '" $    * '"),- '") *-+$ %  3  )*() * - )',   %-,- ! $("#* :. " *)($ ,$(3-$ ' -- ")(,* %  3 * )," *'"),- *' "$%-* "* "* *0;:<1:;<;6 A(" 9 =  '"),--$ ,! *3 -$$( *!"'' ") 0:0<:;<;/-  "$! "* "* *<5:<:;<;'$$ *3# 
("3 ,=: -$!("

" "+( *  -$$()  ! =""$ ! '' ")  *  $(3$ C(  '"),-= " 3- * 3$-$!!,$ *3$ , $$" '"$/,, +-+

 * $'-  $ % ",  '$   ' -- "8$ **" $$/  )(,*  3  "" $ *:. " *)($ ,$(3-$ / )""#/ ' -- "=$ % " )) */ %  (+ $3 )-(($,#" $-*-+=- -$!-,# -$ ' " **" $$* $ % " ' * %*  '") $$!,=: -$ !("

"$(3- * ' -- " $3 !,$ ,#-',-) *-  

 3$-$ !  !("

 $('',  "# *-$),$("  $   !  )))($ *: . " *)($ ,'-$( "') ! ") #/="/ $= ,,$$ % ",) # 3 "$* .3"*"/ % ) +"-),,# $ * - -" !!-*%-$E'' * * =-  ' --E   $($ " '"),--) =$ % "-$$( *"'$ *- %-,,+ <2:<2:;<;/*

# % ,$ $ * +*)*()*) ") "! ' -- ": -$ "+( *  -" '") $$!-$$(-+ '"),--$-,, +,/)""#

 *"# $("# '"%-$-$/ * $ )($ * $ "-($ '" >(*-)   ' -- ":. " *)($ ,$(3-$ -'(+ *"* "-$ A!)- -,, +,/

 "3-""#*($($-3, / %-+3 '$$ *=- ('"' ",#$)"(--F-+ " % "-!#-+  ( -)-# !  ,, + * $ "%-)  " '"$:
$ C( ,#/ , " * )($ , $$ "$  "* " * ),"-+  ' -- "  '"),- * ' "$-$($($-3, -,=** $ "% $3 $ $-* *C($ *: :  ! ""-+ " ',#G$($" '"3#=#!!!-*%-* * <:<4:;<;5! H-* ("/ $$-$
-$$- " ! ,-) / *? ,/ "-*3*/, " *  )($ ,''$ * '" $ ' --:I -, " !(-+

)$ $ ('3# ' -- "/* -, *"+( $= " *%) * "-$/ ) *-+ ' -- " $3 "-+ ,#* )," *$'"),- *' "$/ %-*  -'(+ * "* ": . " *   )($ , $ $(3- *  , " *
(" 3 ,= $ $)"('(,($,# * " *   '") *("  '" $)"-3 * (* "

)- 4; ! 
*  !
"--, ") *(" / 012/ *  -!-"-# " -"" +(,"-#-$*-$) "-3, !" " )"*:. " *  )($ , $/ " !" / ) * * )*()! ' -- "), ",# $3,-$ $ -$* ,-3 "  * !-)  !  >(*-)-, '") $$ * -$($  !  )) $$- ! 3-,: ))"*-+,#/*-$-$$,! -$' -- $3 '"# *!": : %  "* , " *)($ ,!" "-%,'"- $*)" !(,,# ' "($ * " )"*! )$ : 5:

 ,= -$ = ,, $ , *   ' "$ ) 3  * )," *  '"),- *!! * "G' "$(, $$ '") *(" '" $)"-3 *(* " )-4; ! 
* !
"--,") *(" /012/-$ -)(,($,#)',- *=- : -$ "-  '"%-$-$! )-4;" *"#-(" *#* %-- ")',-) %-- $  -" '"),-'") *-+$:  '" $  )$ / '"),- +-$  ' -- " =$ "* " *  3  -$$( *  <5:<:;<; !" -$ '' ")   0:0<:;<;: = % "/ %-*   -'(+ *

 "* " * * 0;:<1:;<;/  ' -- " =$ * )," *  '"),- * ' "$E ()  '"-"   % "# *  !-A * !" -$ '' ") / -: :/ 0:0<:;<;:

' -- " $ $' )-!-),,# ', * *   ' =$ % " *   ))

- !" -% $-+- " !" +-%-+ --- " +"*-+ -$ ,, + * -%,%  /* $'-  -$)-(($,#" $-*-+=- -$!-,# -$' "  **" $$:("

"/ "') / 3 ") #/* .3"*"! )) " * %-,,+  % / 3# =# ! !!-*%-$ 6 A(" $ 5  49/ ) +"-),,#$ * $($"'"),--) =$ % "-$$( *" '$ *+-$ ' -- "- %-,,+ : $'-  -$/ "-,
("/%-*  -'(+ *"* "* *0;:<1:;<;/* )," * ' -- "'"),- *' "$/ * " )"** $* $"  $() '"),- *3  A )( * - )!"-# =-  *"# " C(-"  $ ! )- 4;
"::
:

-+-!-),#/ '") *(",$! +("*$ 3 ** *- )-4;"  "  !",-- $3($(3$-% '" )-$- * * $("  ' "$-$ 3"* *$'"),- *!! * "G' "$- ) -),""3-""# ":

'" (" * ),"-!'"),-/)(', *=- 3$ ) !# '"!!*( $ "%-) "'(3,-)-) /$"-? $ % "#"!(",>($-)  *" * "$ -'(+ *"* ", +,,#($($-3, : :

-$
(" !-*$  )("$  *' * 3# 
(" 3 ,= -$ - $-$ '"%-$-$! )-4;! 
* !
"--,") *(" / 012:


(" 3 ,= $ )- * -,, +,-# 3# -$$(-+  $-* '"),-(* " )-4;! 
"--,") *(" 
* /012=- ( )',-) !*"#" C(-"  $!,=:

, " *
("3 ,=/= -,  * ),"-+ ' -- "$'"),- *' "$/!-, *$-$!#-$ ,!" +"*-+ *(  A )(-!'"),-*'") * *- ) -), ": () 

5 "* " 3 -+ %-,-%  ! *"# '"%-$-$ ! ,=/ ) 3  $($- *:

)-4;! 
"--,") *(" 
* /012" *$$(* "& J4;:"),-!"' "$3$)*-+:

4;:"),-!"' "$3$)*-+:

4;:"),-!"' "$3$)*-+:

4;:"),-!"' "$3$)*-+:609 !#
(" $" $ 3 ,- %  6=

" ! " ?-+ %-* )  " 9  # ' "$ +-$ =   ="" $ 3  -$$( * 3# - $ 3$)* * " -$ )) ,-+

-$ ,!$ $() ="")3  A )( */$() 
("#'(3,-$  ="- '"),-" C(-"-+ -'' "$' )-!- *',) * $' )-!- *- , $$  -"#*#$!" * !'(3,-$ -+$() '"),-: 6;9

'"),-$ ,,3 '(3,-$ *$!,,=$& 6-969-$ ,,3 '(3,-),#" *-$ )$'-)(($',) ! =" %-,,+ -= -) $() ' "$"*-"-,#" $-* $K 639-$ ,,3 !!-A *$ )$'-)(($'"! ($ "  $ * -= -) $() ' "$"*-"-,#" $-* $"$ )$'-)(($',) ! $() ="%-,,+ K 6)9)'# " !$ ,,3 !!-A *$ )$'-)(($'"! )("

($ K 6--9 
("#,$/-!- -?$!-/*-" ))'#! '"),- 3 '(3,-$ *-*-,# =$'' ")-")(,-+- ',) -= -) $() ' "$"*-"-,#" $-* $: 69 $   - ="--+ 3# 
(" -$$(-+  '"),-  !! ) '"),-=$*(,#'(3,-$ *$' )-!- **#/-  " $' )-!- * - ),($  6-9 ! $(3$ )- 6;9/ $ ,, 3  )),($-%  %-* )  " C(-"  $! -$ )- % 3 )',- *=- / * '"),-=$'(3,-$ *$() *#: L69I " '"),-'(3,-$ *(* "$(3$ )-609-$-" $' )! ' "$))($ *!!! ) '(-$ 3, (* " )-$<;/<// 2/4;/1;/1/1/15/1/12/14/11/<</<;//1/51/ "<!  *- ,
* 65!04<9/ *$() ' "$ !-,$ '' " $' )-!- *',) *- " C(-" *3# '"),-/
(" #/ ! " ?-+ $()  -C(-"# $ - -?$ !-/ '"()  -  '"),- *!! * "*? * ),"-  !! ): 659

'"%-$-$!$(3$ )-$6;9*69$ ,,'',#* ),"- * 3# 
("(* "$(3$ )-69$ #'',# '"),- '(3,-$ *(* "$(3$ )-609:MN 2: 
"*-  ) ! -$
("= -, * ,-+=- -%)- ! '"%-$-! )-4;! 
* !
"--,") *(" /+-$ ))($ * -  )$  ! 7 ( %:   ! "#/ ;<;0609 
 6
"--,9

( %:   ! "#/ ;<;0609 
 6
"--,9

( %:   ! "#/ ;<;0609 
 6
"--,9

( %:   ! "#/ ;<;0609 
 6
"--,9 018 018 018 018/ ,*$(* "& J1:

 $$ -, " C(-"  $ ! $ )- 4; ! 
"::
:/ 012 !" -$$()  * '(3,-)- ! '"),- +-$  3$)* " * * ),"-+ - $ '"),- * ' "$G!! * " # 3  $("-F * $ (* "& 6-9 "-" -$$()  ! ="" ! "" $ 3# 
(" -$ $-  C(  !" -$$()  * '(3,-)- !  '"),- * 
(" $  !-"$ -$$( =""!"" $+-$ ' "$)) " *:6  - ("%:

 ! , -&;<<4
",::;509:

 6--9

" ($3 " '"3 !"  
(" ' "$+-$=  =""=$-$$( * *3$)* *" *3 )) ,-+ -$ ,!$

 ="" ! "" $ )(,*  3  A )( * +-$ -: = % "/
(" -$  3(*  ?  %-* )  - -$ " +"* 3 !"  -$$(-+  "),-(* "$ )-4;609! 
"::
:/012:6  - (" %:  ! , -&;<<4
",::;509: 6---9


(")-$$(  "),-$ "!)("$ 3 )($ 

,-) -$$?-+!"-:


("($3 '"-!)- $-$!- * ' "$ $3$)* *"-$)) ,-+ -$ ,!$ =""!"" $/ '" %-($,#-$$( */)3  A )( */* $'- " $3, *-,-+ ) :6 -$ (*#,  *  "$ %: ' "" &   01   *  % * " -+ +-%:  !::&011
",.6,, 3*
90249: 6-%9

" C(-$- * *',) !"'' ") ($3 $' )-!- *- '"),-" C(-"-+$() ' "$'' "$() *  $' )-!- * ',) : ()  *  ($  3  , $$  < ), " *#$ !"  *  ! -$$()  * '(3,-)- !  '"),-: 6  ("'' (+, *  "$ %:   ! #$"  & 011
"-. 4; *

?,- %:   !

"#&;<;<6;9
6
  .919: 6%9 I "   ' "-* 3 =  -$$()  * '(3,-)- ! '"),-* $' )-!- ** ! "-+-$, $$  -"#*#$/ ))($ * ) 3  * )," *  '"),- * ' "$G!! * " * '"),- $3 -$$( **'(3,-$ *+-:6 -,3+ -+ %:

  ! (>3 6D 9 & ;<05 649 
 6
  .9 0 * $ ?

("%:  ! "#* "&;<069
6
  .955<9 6%-9

 "),- $  3  '(3,-$ * -   " ,-* *= - $ )-4;6;9! 
"::
:/012:"'(3,-)- '"),- $ 3 !-"$'(3,-),#" *-$ )$'-)(($',) ! ="%-,,+ - = -) ))($ *"*-"-,#" $-* $K  $  $3 !!-A * $ )$'-)(($'" ! ($ "  $ *-= -) ))($ * "*-"-,# " $-* $" $ )$'-)(($',) !$() ="%-,,+  * " ! "  )'# !  '"),- $  3  !!-A *  $  )$'-)(($ '" ! 
(" ($ :

"  $(3),($ $ 69 6)9 - $ )-4;6;96-9! 
"::
:/012" )>()-% **-$>()-% / = -)  $ " =(,*3 %,-*'(3,-)-! '"),- (, $$,, " * $!'(3,-)-" '"% *:6 = (" ('%:

 !I::&012
"-.049:I "  
("$"* "$  )'# !  '"),- $  3  **--,,# '(3,-$ * -  *-,#  =$'' ")-")(,-+- ',) -= -) ))($ *"*-"-,#" $-* $: *%-$3,#/'"),- $3 -$$( *=- !(")'- $$   ) ! "  )'- $ !  '"),- # 3  !!-A *  $  )$'-)(($ '" ! ($  "  $ * - = -)  ))($ * "*-"-,#" $-* $/$ )$'-)(($',) !$() ="%-,,+ *  $  )$'-)(($ '" ! 
("

($  * " '" " +"*-+ '(3,-)- # 3  *    !("

 )'# !  '"),-: **--,)'#=-,,3 " C(-" *= "  '"),--$,$" C(-" * 3 '(3,-$ *-  =$'' ": 6%--9   ! $ "%-+!!-) " $3 " )"* *3# 
("$

* ** !'(3,-)-! '"),-:6 -"*%:

 &0154
"-.159: 6%---9


(" -$$(-+  '"),- $  ?   $   - ="--+--$"* " '"),-=$*(,#'(3,-$ *$' )-!- * *#- "$' )-!- *-$ )-4;6;96-9! 
"::
:/012: () $  -="--+3# 
("-$* )," *3 )),($-%  %-* ) 

 " C(-"  $ ! )- 4; %  3  )',- * =-  * '"),-=$'(3,-$ *$() *#:6 -"*%:  &0154
"-.159:

2 6A-9

)*--$$' )-!- *-$ )-4;6;9! 
"::
:/012!" '(3,-)- !  "),- +-$  3$)* " "  *"#:# )',-)  " =- )3 )(" *$O-"" +(,"-#O*" * "$

 "),- * '") *-+$ $(3$ C(  "   (,,-#: 6  % *" -+ +-,-$ 3(%:  !::* "&011
"-. 024*, -+ %:

 &0155
"-.049:N 4: -$' "-  - --$3#=$ , *'"-)-', ! ,= 3 !" -$$(-+'"),-(* " )-4;
"::
:/ 
("($ " )"* -$ $-$!)-  ))($ */ +-$ =   '"),- -$ $(+ 3 -$$( */-$3$)*-+")) ,-+ -$ ,!=- -  %*  "" $:

-$ !(*-, " C(-"   -$ )$'-)(($,# 3$  -  '" $  )$ :' "($,! -'(+ *"* "* *0;:<1:;<;" % ,$ $() $-$!)- =$" )"* * 3# 
(" 3 ,=/ "=$ "  #  "-,  >($-!#  -! " )   ' -- " * 3$)* * " =$ * ,-3 " ,# %-*-+"" $: 1:

'"%-$-$! )-4;! 
* !
"--,") *(" 

%-+ $ "-($ "-!-)-$ C(  "-+  !  ))($ * )) "-+ -$ '" $ ) - )"--,"-,'") *-+$(+ 3 *)3 -%? * -)$(,*)%,- " ":

" C(-"  !" )"*-+!$-$!)-/

))($ * $3$)* *"-$)) ,-+ -$ ,!$ =""! -$ "" $)3  A )( */$ 3*- *- )-4;! 
* !
"--, ") *(" / -$  3  $)"('(,($,# )',- * =-  3$ *  " , %  "-, %-,3,   " )"* !  )$  -  " +"*: * " )   $-* " C(-"   = -,  * ),"-+  ))($ * $ '"),- * ' "$ %-- $ '"),-'") *-+$--- *+-$ ))($ *: 0<:

) /($ !(,'("'$ =(,*3 $ "% *3#? '-+ )"--, '") *-+$' *-++-$ ' -- ": -$/ " !" /''"'"- )$  !"  A ")-$ !'= "$(* " )-5;4!

)-4;!
"::
:

4 *3"-+ * )"--,'") *-+$--- *- ,-+ !   -3-*+-$ ' -- ": 00:  %- = !  3%  !-*-+$/ -  -" # ! !)$ * )-")($) $ !  '" $  )$ /  '" $  ' -- -$ ,,= * * -'(+ * "* " * * 0;:<1:;<; 6 A("  9 '$$ * 3#  , " * (*-)-, +-$"  $
,$$/ "-*3*/ = " 3#/  ' -- " $ 3  * )," *$'"),- *' "$/-)$   :5;* *;:<0:;<;;/" +-$ " * !")-$$-!!! ) '(-$ 3, (* " )-$;;
D;1! ")-) "(+$*$#) "'-) (3$) $)/01456!"$ "7  )89/,-) 

-3(/"-*3*$= ,,$  ")$ C( -,'") *-+$"-$-+

" !"/" C($ *C( ' -- ": 0;:  *-+ '',-)-6$9/ -! #/ $ ,, ,$ $* *-$'$ * ! ))"*-+,#:  

 .



 .



 .



 .9      ) 3 "  ) 3 "  ) 3 "  ) 3 "<1/;<;5  %-" I

"$' ?-+G" $ *&   $G  I

"" '"3, &   $G