Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax-1, Chd. v. Jangpal Singh Tanwar

 

 



 

 


   




 !"

#"$%&%'(
)
*
++%&&%'"*

'$+"
 ,-
. '#%/ *.
011"22 '!

3&  '/1 2
4%'/.
 '5 * "&1'#"'!&      

     *"&"'!(

&
*%#.%
 &5%'#"*
4 '#.6-
6'%*
4! '#%'/
6'&"2- *
!."
11"22 '!

%!6
 .*%-
  ."
%'&! '!
11" 2
6'#"*
4"$!%'
8

!."
'$+"
 ,
$!- 8-
. &
9""'
%2"#
/ %'&!
!."
*#"*
# !"#
8
''",6*"
:

1 &&"#
9;
!."
'$+"
 ,
11"22 !"
*%96' 2-
. '#%/ *.-
5."*"9;
11" 2 %2"#
9;
!."
*"&1'#"'! &&"&&""-
*
!."
&&"&&+"'!
;" *
8<-
/ %'&! !."
*#"*
# !"#

1 &&"#
9;
!."
*%'$%1 2
++%&&%'"*

'$+"

 ,-
. '#%/ *.-
. &
9""'
$$"1!"#  ."
1*"&"'!
11" 2
*"2 !"&
!
!."
&&"&&+"'!
;" *
8<- *
5.%$.-
!."
&&"&&""*"&1'#"'!
. #
%2"#
*"!6*'
'
=)8 #"$2 *%'/
'
%'$+"

&:-->

."
& %#
*"!6*'
5 &
$$"1!"#
9;
!." &&"&&%'/
%$"*
?%#"
*#"*
# !"#
<)
''",6*"

."
%'$+"

. #
9""'
#"$2 *"#
6'#"*
!."
." #&
@
A
'#
@

 


 A

."*" !"*-
#6*%'/
1*$""#%'/&
6'#"*
4"$!%'
8

!."
$!-
!." *%'$%1 2
++%&&%'"*

'$+"
 ,-
?%#"
*#"*
# !"#




''",6*"
-
&"!
&%#"
!."
*#"*

!."
&&"&&%'/
%$"*
'
!."
/*6'# !. !
."
&&"&&%'/
%$"*
. #
 %2"#
!
", +%'"
!."
&&"&&""B&
"2%/%9%2%!; 6'#"*
4"$!%'
=:

!."
'$+"
 ,
$!
."
&&"&&%'/
%$"*
5 & #%*"$!"#
!
1 &&

*"&.
*#"*

/ %'&!
!."
& %#
*#"*-
!."
&&"&&""
1*""**"# '
11" 2
9"*"
!."
'$+"
 ,
11"22 !"
*%96' 2-
. '#%/ *. 

'
11" 2-
!."
*%96' 2
9&"*?"#
!. !
!."
&&"&&""
%&

*"!%*"# 1"'&%'"*
'#
."
. #
&2#
*"&%#"'!% 2
12!
<-
'&
"?%
+12",

 
!
*9 '
&! !"-
 '$.C62 -
*

& 2"
$'&%#"* !%'


&-)-=->
'
:=

."
& %#
12!
. #
9""'
22!!"#
!
.%+
9;  
'

*

&6+

&-)-)=>

&
1"*
!."
$+16! !%'


%'$+"
12 $"#
'
*"$*#-
."
. #
" *'"#
$ 1%! 2
/ %'

&<-<)-<>
'

!.%&
12!

6*%'/
!."
&&"&&+"'!
1*$""#%'/&-
!."
&&"&&""
. #
16*$. &"# 6&"

8=-
4"$!*
-
. '#%/ *.
'
)=
D%'!2;
%'
.%&
' +"

'#
%'
!."
' +"

.%&
5%"
4+!
46+%!*

&'
4.
46C.9%*
4%'/.
*

& 2"

$'&%#"* !%'

&-)-->
: 6*%'/
*" &&"&&+"'!
1*$""#%'/&-
!."
"?%&%' 2
6!.*%!;

. #
."2#
!. !
!."
&&"&&""
. #
%'?"&!"#
&8-->
'2;
*
16*$. &%'/ !."
9?"
& %#
1*1"*!;
4%'$"-
."
5 &
5'"*

!."
.6&"
!
!."
",!"'!
 >*#
&. *"-
%!
5 &
."2#
!. !
."
$62#
$2 %+
","+1!%'

&:8-8-8<> 6'#"*
4"$!%'
=:

!."
'$+"
 ,
$!-
96!
!."
&&"&&""
. #
$2 %+"# ","+1!%'

&)-<)-<>


."
1%'%'

!."
"?%&%' 2
6!.*%!;
5 & !. !
!."
&&"&&""
. #
$2 %+"#
","+1!%'
%'
",$"&&
!
!."
!6'"


&=-8-=> = 5"?"*-
'
11" 2-
!."
*%96' 2
9&"*?"#
!. !
!."
&&"&&""
. # 1*#6$"#
!."
9 'C
&! !"+"'!&
9"*"
!."
&&"&&%'/
%$"*
&
5"22
!."

"?%&%' 2
6!.*%!;

4.
46C.9%*
4%'/.-
&'

!."
&&"&&""-
. #
! C"'

 .6&"
2 '
'#
!.%&
 $!
. &
9""'
%/'*"#
9;
!."
"?%&%' 2
6!.*%!;

."

!! 2
1*%$"

!."
1*1"*!;
5 &
&-)-=->-
5.%$.
%'$26#"#
!."
2 '

! C"'
9;
4.
46C.9%*
4%'/.-
&'

!."
&&"&&""*"&1'#"'!

."
E'/
"*+

1%! 2
%'

&<-<)-<>
5 &
2&
%'?"&!"#
9;
!."
&&"&&""
9; 16*$. &%'/

.6&"
%"
8=-
4"$!*
-
. '#%/*.

4%'$"
!."
"'!%*"

+6'!
. #
9""'
%'?"&!"#
%'
!."
1*1"*!;-
5.%$.
5 &
'!
#%&16!"#
9;
!."

"?"'6"-
!."
*%96' 2
."2#
!. !
!."*"
5 &
'
"?%#"'$"
!
&611*!
!." $'$26&%'
!. !
'2;
>*#
&. *"
5 &
9"2'/%'/
!
!."
&&"&&""
." &&"&&""*"&1'#"'!
. #
%'?"&!"#
!."
"'!%*"
+6'!
*
16*$. &%'/
!." 1*1"*!;
'#
.%&
&'
. #
2&
$'!*%96!"#
%'
!."
& +"
!"*
! C%'/
2 '
*+ !."
9 'C

'
!. !
&%!6 !%'-
+"*"2;
+"'!%'%'/
!."
' +"

.%&
5%"
'#
&' &
$5'"*&

!."
1*1"*!;-
562#
'!
#%&"'!%!2"
!."
&&"&&""
!
$2 %+ ","+1!%'

."
*%96' 2
. #
2&
$2 *%%"#
!. !
!."
D6#/+"'!
1 &&"#
%' 

<

:
 -
*""**"#
!
9;
!."

"?"'6"-
5%22
'!
9"
112%$ 92"
!
!."
 $!&

!."
1*"&"'!
$ &"-
&
%'
!. ! $ &"-
!."
&&"&&""
. #
%'?"&!"#
+'";
%'
!."
1*1"*!;
",$26&%?"2;
%'
!." ' +"

.%&
5%"
'#
%'
!.%&
9 $C/*6'#-
."
$62#
'!
$2 %+
","+1!%'
* 2'/
!"*+
$ 1%! 2
/ %'
6'#"*
4"$!%'
=:

!."
$!


5"?"*-
%'
!." 1*"&"'!
$ &"-
!."
*"&1'#"'! &&"&&""
. &
%'?"&!"#
!."
"'!%*"
+'";
%' 96;%'/

.6&"
'#
.%&
&'
. #
2&
9**5"#

2 '
*
16*$. &%'/
!."
& %# 1*1"*!;
"*"2;
+"'!%'%'/
!."
' +"&

.%&
5%"
'#
&'
&
$5'"*&
 !."
1*1"*!;-
562#
'!
#%&"'!%!2"
!."
&&"&&""
!
$2 %+
","+1!%'
6'#"* 4"$!%'
=:

!."
$!
8 ."
*/6+"'!
* %&"#
9;
2" *'"#
$6'&"2
*
!."
11"22 '!
!. ! !."
+ !!"*
&.62#
. ?"
9""'
*"+ '#"#
!
!."
&&"&&%'/
%$"*-
%&
2&
*"D"$!"#
'

!."
/*6'#
!. !
!."
&&"&&""
%&

*"!%*"#
1"'&%'"*
'#
!."
 $!
*"/ *#%'/
& 2"

: 
.%&
12!
%'
 '$.C62
'#
!."*" !"*-
16*$. &"


.6&"
%'
. '#%/ *.-
%& '!
9"%'/
#%&16!"#
9;
!."
11"22 '! 6!.*%!;

."
%&&6"
*"2 !"&
!
!."
 $! !. !
!."
&&"&&""
%&
5'"*

!."
.6&"
'2;
!
!."
",!"'!

>*#
&. *"
'# *"+ %'%'/
&. *"
%'
!."
.6&"
9"2'/&
!
.%&
5%"
'#
&'
*"&1"$!%?"2;
!"* &"22%'/
.%&
12!
%'
 '$.C62 -
!."
&&"&&""
. #
%'?"&!"#
.%&
"'!%*"
+'"; 5.%2"
16*$. &%'/

.6&"
%'
. '#%/ *.

."*"*"-
!."
*%96' 2
. &
*%/.!2; ."2#
.%+
"'!%!2"#
!
&""C
","+1!%'
6'#"*
4"$!%'
=:

!."
$!
< !"*
/%'/
!.*6/.
!."
%+16/'"#
D6#/+"'!-
'
/*6'#
%&
+ #" 6!
!
%'!"*"*"
!."*"%'-
&
!."
& +"
. &
9""'
1 &&"#
!"*
11*"$% !%'/
!."  $!&
%'
!."
*%/.!
1"*&1"$!%?"


&69&! '!% 2
F6"&!%'

2 5
*%&"&
* $'&%#"* !%'
)

"&62! '!2;-
%'#%'/
'
+"*%!&-
1*"&"'!
11" 2
%&
#%&+%&&"#

 








  

4
 








   ) D1     (
"&>    (
"&>