M/S A.K. Engineering Works v. M/S Saini Fabricators
!!"
#"$ %&" '&(&'
))** +!"
,
& &(" -&."
%&" '&(&'
) / 012*34+0305 )"!
. 3& $&3& %'6-&.!%
".7!&88!99& . :::
7!8"!
."! ,9&" !- '&88!&97& 9!'&..7!(!7!
.7! '!
. (!
& " !6!' (; .7! &88!&9 .7! 89&
(!
&99<!'(;.7!9!&"
!'&88!99&.!-,".& '.7! , .
(!
'!-"!!' ".7! &$! - 6!
-!%.7!8&". !
&"!(!
"!
!""!'.&
8!".7! ""
&98 .7!- 6 9 , . 7!89&
9!'& , . ""!-6!"; =% =>/& &
..7!
. 7! %& &6!""!' .%&"!.7&..7!89&
8"8" !."
7 8- -!"
'!&9 .7!?(<"$ (!
'<!9'
!.- 7!89&
' '?(<"$ .& &
.6&" , -7&99&
!"!
.'&.!
%& '!.& 9!' .7!@&.!" &9<& ' "!-.9; ,889 !'
. 3&;& .&.
', ." !
%)!79&'8,"%&" '&(&'7!"&.!
/ / 6!"
?(<"$<& >/8!"8 !-!+&" , ( 99 <".7 % % =>/ <!"!
,!'7!89&
"!-! 6!' %
%
/(;<&; -7!A,!7!"!
<& & (&9& -! % % =>/ 7! '!
.
,!' & -7!A,! '&.!'
>
"& ,@ %
/7! & '-7!A,!<& '
7 ,"!'% "! &"'
<7 -7 & -" @ &9 -& ! , '!" !-. B .7! ! . &(9!
.",@!
-. " 7".%C.7!-.1<& 8!
.!"'!',-.
-7!A,!&@, .%(&9& -!&@, =% =>/<& ,.
#7!
."!
, !'.@&$!.7! & '8&;@!
.% 9!'(;.7!89&
. -!%<" ..!
.&.!@!
. <& 9!'+&" , 8"!9 @ &";
(?!-.
<!"!"& !'7!'!
.'!
!'.7&.& ;&@, ',!
.<&"'
7 @%.7, 7 .<& &'@ ..!'.7&..7!89&
' '.7!?(<"$ "
.7!'!
..<& &99! !'.7&..7!89&
7&'' !'!
!-. 6!<"$ "
8 !-!
%',!.<7 -7&8!
&9.; %
/<& !'.<& &6!""!'
.7&..7!"!<& &-@8"@ .7!-" @ &98"-!!'
B .7!-.& '& &@, D%
/<& 8& '..7!89&
7!9!&"
!'." &9-,". "&@!' 6!
,!
7!8"8" !."
- -!"
% "'!". ,88".7
, .% 7 @ !9 &88!&"!' & )# & ' !E7 ( .!' -7&99&
( 99 E) . E) =%(!
&"$ 7!'!
.% "'!"."!(,..7!-9& @
% 7 @ !9 '!8 !'& # 7! 9!&"
!' ." &9 -,".% & .!"-
& ' .7!
!6 '!
-!8"',-!'%'
!' .7! , . 6 '!?,' @!
''!-"!!'&.!'
=
// " !6!' .7!'
&9 7 , .%.7!89&
9!'&
&88!&97!9!&"
!'&88!99&.!-,".%& .!""!/&88"!- &.
'"!/
.7!!6 '!
-!%&99<!'.7!&88!&9& ''!-"!!'.7! , .6 '!
?,' @!
''!-"!!'&.!'
D
0!
-!%.7!8"!
.! ,9&"!- '88!&9 *!&"
!' -,
!9 " .7! '!
. &" ,!' .7&. .7! 9!&"
!'
&88!99&.!-,".!""!' &99< .7!&88!&9& ''!-"!!
, .7!
.!
'!'.7&. &@, ',! "@.7!'!
.%& &8!
&9.;<&
@8 !'%&
7&' ,889 !'
'!
!-. 6!8 !-!
7! ,".7!"
.!
'!'.7&.!6!
.(!'!-"!!'%.7!&@, D%
/ 8& '(;.7!'!
-@8"@ !&@, . 7,9'7&6!(!!
&'?, .!' .7!"- .!
!' .7!&88!&9%.7"!!A,!
9&<7&6!(!!
"&@!'%(,..7!
9!&"
!'-,
!9%
.!&' &''"!
&" ,@!
.7 !A,!
%7&
9;"& !'.7!& "!
& '- .!
7!- .!
!'(;9!&"
!'-,
!9 7&6! -! .7& .(!!
'
8,.!'.7&..7!89&
' .7!?( <"$ .7!( 99 8"',-!'7&6!&9 .(!!
'
8,.!' "@.7!-7&99&
'.7!( 99 8"',-!'% .7& -@! "!-"'.7&.&
&@, % % =>/<& ',!.(!8& '(;.7!'!
...7!89&
% ,. <7 -7&-7!A,! "%
/<&
,!'%"! &"'
<7 -7-" @ &9 8"-!!'
B .7!-.<!"!8!
7! , .<& 9!'
/ / & .!"'!',-.
& '&@, .7!@& 89!&.&$!
(;.7!'!
..7&.
.7!"!<& ,889;
'!
!-. 6!8 !-!
.8"6!'.<& &'@ ..!'
.7&. . -!"! &"'
.7!'!
!-. 6!8 !-!
,!'..7!89&
0!
-!%.7! & ' '-&
.(!&--!8.!' 7! !- ' - .!
"& !' (; 9!&"
!' -,
!9 " .7!
. .7&. .7! &@, . D%
/ 8& ' (; .7! '!
.
-@8"@ .7!8"-!!'
B .7!-. 7,9'7&6!
(!!
&'?, .!'-&
.(!&--!8.!' .&.!'!&"9 !"%.7! 9!'& .!"
'!',-.
.7!&@, .% "<7 -7.7!-7!A,!<&
,!'7!-@8"@
.7!-" @ &98"-!!'
9;A,&%
/% !.7!-7!A,!&@, . .7 7& 89&-!' "!-"'. 7<.7&..7! & '-@8"@ !<&
".7!!
. "!(&9& -!&@, . ,-7- "-,@ -!
%.7!"! (9!@ 7
.7!
"!-"'!'(;.7!&88!99&.!-,".& ' &,9.-& (! , '
, .(!
'!-"!!'(;.7!9!&"
!'&88!99&.!-,". 6 !< .7!&(6!% &,9.-& (! , '< .7.7!- !
"!-"'!'(;.7!9!&"
!' "
.&88!99&.!-,".& '.7! @8, !'
?,' @!
''!-"!!'!
!"6!.(!,87!9' ,"
.7!-,"
! 7!&"
%9!&"
!'-,
!9
& 9!'.8 .,.& ;8&.!
. 99! &9 .;"8!"6!"
.; .7!&(6!
& '- !
& '- -
"!-"'!'(;.7!9!&"
!' "
.&88!99&.!-,".0!&9 -,9' ."!
!".& ;A,!
9&<@,-79!
. &9A,!
9&<% <7 -7
!A,& "!
.!".&
&"! ,9&" !- '&88!&9&..7!7&
.7 ,".%<7 9!!E!"-
.
&88!99&.!?,"
' -.
/D/ .7!'! 6 9)"-!',"! .7!"&" ,@!
!'
.7!8!-,9 &" '- "-,@ -!
.7!-&
.!'&(6!%-,89!'< .7.7!"!&
"!@!
!'%.7 ,".
'!"!'6 !<.7&..7!8"!
.&88!&9 @ -! 6!'%(!"!
@!" .& < .7,.& ; -!7, % .@, . & 9-& " .!"
!"!
-!7&
@&'!,. !
,9.& .9;%< .7.7!&(6!
& '( !"6&.
%.7 &88!&9
!'%7<!6!"%< .7 "'!"& .- !" #
$%
'?