← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6284/2014dismissed

Shakuntla Devi v. Satyabir And ORS

2019-02-20Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill10 pages



           







  !"

#$%

%&'('

) *    +  

  

    

  !* ,- !

   

 --  

 

 

  !



     !

 

  !

#

     !

#$   

   !

   



%

!

&'&(   ) *

+ 

, -.  %

!

/&(/  

! *

-.



 "!

!

   

 ""

" !

((0&((&



+234,

 

 

!



  . 6 4    .

  +7,   4  8 6  4 #&

1' (((64 .! !

7 

  8

!  

 

 "" 9



4  & .

 

&



 " 

4 "" : "

!

 %!

  . 



 .

3   : " 

($&00;

+23 4/,

4 #& "  



6 4 #$  

 "

 ""





($&00;





 "" 9

4  

 !  4 #&  8 +7,  ! 

!



34

&'(&(  4 

 

.  



   4 #&

7  " 

%



   



4 #& +7, "  



4 #$ 

 4 #

 4     

. !

 

($&00;







  

  

. 

 < <

(1(100&  4 #$ 

! 

 

.  

6   

 

# $$;/ ($&00;



"

 "

$   

 !!

 .

  "   

!  

 " .  .

"

4  =

#&  8 

 ) 7     !

>? & =



 7

.

!

" 

 "">? $ =



($&00;

#&  8 "  #$ "

!

1100& 

  



 ""

 



!!

>? / =

 ""



!

" !

1100&>? ' =

 ""



 %!  ">? 5 =

 ""

! 

>?

; =

 ""

  . ! !! "

" 

>?

1 =

 ""

!

!

>?

0 =

 ""



/ >?

(=

 ""



 >?

=

 ""

!

! !

   

  "! "

! "

 

""

!>?

&=

 ""

 . !

>?

$ "

"  

 !

!

 ) *

+ 

, -.



%

!

&'&(   !

!  4  &



"  1' (((64 .! 

 

    @ 5A 

"

 

  B  

" ! 

   

%

!

&'&(   ) *

+ 

, -.  

      4 #4     

%

  ) * + 

, -. 

! *

-. .

  

  

+23 4, "

!

 " "

!  !

 4 #4  74 4 #&4 8  !!  



'

 

"    9

!  4 #4     .

3



" 1' (((64

!

 



(1(100& 

%



! .



  !  

:





 !



 !

 4 4

:



 !

 4   B 4 #&4  8  7 &&00 +234;,

  7

+234,

" 

4 "" 9

 1' (((64 !

 

 

4 "" : " 

($&00;

+23 4/, 

""

!



 : 

($&00;

$' (((64   .

!

  1' (((64



 '

 



 



!

$' (((64 !

  !  

!

)

 

%



    &(('+$, ) +)  , :

 !

 !"!  

"!

 

 C



 

  



9

 C



!

 "

! 

=

!

4 #&

7 

" 

4 #$ !



!

 !  .

(1(100& 9



  "



 %

 ?

 

 !

4 4  .

! 7 (&&00 +23 4;, 

4 #&4 8

   



 9



($&00;





 " 

 !

  

!

 ! 

%

 

! .

4  7 4 #&   23 4 ;

 7 (;&00 .

4 #& B

.!

"  



4 4 #$ 9

4  " 

!

 !

1' (((64 "

      !



 !

 "

4  "" 9

.



! 

  . !! 

+234, "

!

 " "

!  !



 

;



.

" !

!   ! &( &   ! 05$ 

!

 4

 !!"!#!"#$! %  

       

    

    

          

             

  

       

 





    

  

            

 

              !

             

       

               "

 "     

 ""    

     

"" 

    

         #     "" 

   



      

      

      "

  $   %          &  !'   % 

 

             

      

     "

           

        

 "        

       & 

!%         ""

   

      

 

         %      

 

   

   

(   



   

        

      

 %       

)                              

   

& '((!$"!! % *

                  

                 

  *  

  

         

      $               

           

    



( *  

  

                       

 

  

                              

       



) *                 

  

   

   

        +(      *

 , -.+ /.+

0 1          

   

   

           

   

   "

                      

             

              



     &  !

   

                            

    

  



 

 6 ""



" !

((0&((& .

"  6 #$

C

($&00;

6 ""

" .

 .  



!

6 ""



 D<



) :

!

 )*   '

   &(1+, )+)  ,/



 "

! .  !

 . 



  

   !

!   .    ""

.!

!

!  " !

  

.

 D<



) : !

 + )*    +,+ "    &((5+$, ) +)  ,;/(

"

!! "

!!  

! ! "

" !

"

 C ! "

 "

!

 

. !

9

C 

(

((0&((& "

  (   .!   !  

  !

"

!



" !

 .

!

  !

! !

!!  !

%

 !

 $ -  

 .$'- 

! 

4 "" : . 

  C 

"  



"! !! !

 

!  "

!

!

.

 %

 

! *

-. /&(/ #  C  .



  9



     

 --"

   +  %  3 $ 4   6 41 3  5 6 41