← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6287/2014allowed

Devender & ORS v. Parkash Devi & ORS

2017-08-01Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal13 pages

 

      

 

 

  ! "!

##$$

%!

'!( "  "!

 # 

    

 '! ! 

)"*  !"##$$ !+,-#&*  !"! #  ....



  

 !"

# /"

   ##$  !  0!

)

)    !!  "  $)$ !#!    #!1



$##$ ##$ 

$$2* &0--& $$3#

 

 !$ # 4!"!

1 

"##$  *"$5 6 5

$

)"#! ##$

   ##$   $$2 %&'%() /"  !##$$ 0 !"

,&!

"#! )&$! ##$

  /"  #$

$      !  $!     #!1

-&  $

)""#$

!2 !

#

""$

"! "$  !

0

"#$

72 &!"!

!"" !  & !

2!

)

" 1 8&(1,"  9&) :$ 

 "  $&1    &$   2"      ;

  /"! !* 0 & $5" !

#

"!  &!!!!! & 7 2 &!"!#$""  *2"!$)$" 8&(1 ," *2 ( ! 0$#

 /"  ##! (  "" 

!

#

"#!#!5 !"" " ! "! 1$5 8&(1," /"  &

$   !!" !

*"2 !* "#

"#$

2 ! )$5

 /"$!

!

$,&! !##! 

)"    $0$ "

$!!

) "#$

"  0 0$ #! " !#

/"!$   "2

31



 ! !5

&!/"

)!!05"$!

/!

$,&!

3! & !    

           

    

         

 

  

    

 



  

    

"

 !#$                

  %

&   '           

  "

 '#$            

   

 !  



(

     

   

 !))*          &

 

<  &       + !  +

        

"

+ !#$                      

 

   

  

 &  

 

    

 ,  

 

     &

&   

   

  

  

 &    -       

 

    

     

    

 "

!    "

*               

 

     

   

  &   

   

                    

       

            

      

      

      

   

           

         .    



"

+!    !)/(0   (      

&

2 3     

 

 &4   

   "

+'  & !))(!)56    (     

  



 &

 &



2 $ 



  & !)5/(!)50"

+*

!)5)(!))6"

+/  !))/()0"

+0 !)))('666"

+7 '66/( '660"

+ 3 8   & '66'('660 "

+5 3 8   & '660('6!6"

+)

   (         

  

 &

 &

 2 $  

%  //  9 :   $!55 

 

  

    



 

         &

   &     

      

  

        &  

  

    

 2 

         

    

 $    & &     

  

 

 &  &   





 &

    

 

    

 

 

   &  

              & 

 4   



&    

   "

+!"

+)  

 (   

   

        

       

  

  

     &         

    

 

    

&   

     

 &$   

%  !!6,

"   $

           

  

     & 



   

    

    

  

  

    ;

 

 

                

     

   3 8 

     

 ))9 :  <

 &         

         

           

          

         

   ,

 

     

 

  



    &

    

 

= /"#$

$ ##$0 !"4 ##$$,&! /"$!

4 ##$$,&!" ! !

"-&)1 #

05" $!

!

$,&!/"4 ##$$,&!

#! < !!

& !

6 !*    

      

 

&

    >   ?*@



 



.  &  

 : (!

+

   >    ?/@        



  

      



 

        

  

 &,

(

             

      !    ' 

 A    '       

  

&                       



  

 

 

         

   

   &  

           



           &       $               & 

 + !+

    

         

  

                       

( (

   &   



    &         

 



     

( (  

&1

2   1     



             

    &    

  

 & 

         &    

  

               

  

  

 &           

         

    

&     !/ $        BA

 "

+!

 "

+          1

2

#A 9  #    #% :

   

    

   8

  <

   3 

"

+5 "

+) 1

2

   



"

! "

' +            !/60!)6 1

2   6/!!!)5/= !  !!

)  #!   <     *  "  ,&!  

&

#! ! !!05"&

$ !"#!

#! 6* "-&)1  "! !

#! *",&!"  $&

! !5 %      

   

    &      

   &        

   

    &     

        & 

     

       

                

,

  &  &    ?*

     '      

       

      

   

   &             &          &

 &

    

    

 



  

  

     



 

        

    

     &      & 

              &     

 

   =  !

) " !  $&

!2 05",&!

#!<*  * 

$!""4 ##$$,&!"   "

##$

! 2 ""#!

!!&$

< ", ,

$'!&!8 =0$&#!1,&!

"-&)1 !#!   '6!>!@  2   2   2

 70  >%2@ "  "$  "  4 ##$$,&!0

)$ ,&! 1& &$$&"#

 !

!1

  (

"! 05)

)"!

!" 

 "!$ 2"

""#! ! $'! 6 " ! -&)1 !  & ! !! $  . C9,:

 *!22         

 &       

        

      . C9,:

 *!22  D    

 

          E    $   2       E

    

F   

  F     

F         

           

   F

  

   

   & A  & A      = ,

           

     

  

      

1   

 G

&      



 #   

 

                     

        & 

 !'  $        

                            

          H     

         

 &       

      

  &   



   2

       &     



  >'6!0@!%22*)!

  

 D(  ,%  1 



 >'66!@ *%22!)

2    D>%22!55(5)  !0@ !0I       

   

       

   4  

   



   &

    

                

           

      

 

  

 &

 

      

& 

 

      I     

        

  G

    

 & 

   

       

 

&              

     &    =        &  (A     



2  <  % 

>'66!@/ %2207         

   

  & 1 2      

           &    

       ,13?%

, 

>'660@!6%22'/*



2     D>%22'//  *@ *           

; ,   

       G

    

    

 G

  

 

     &  J  &  1  2        & 

   %       

   & 1 2     

      & 

          =

"

$

 A   $  >'660@!'%22*6*

  

     %  )7 2       !)65  

 2         >%22*6*  '@

#

$

    K  ?

     1K  % 

 < & >'6!6@!*%220*6

2           

 2                    D>%220*6(*!

 *(0@ *1     

 

 &

    #1 2   

  &

2     

  

  .   /!  22     

      $  



:

 *!

        

  D> @    

F >@  

  F >@    

F >@        

   

        

    /       

   

    

    



  



   &  

     G



                     

         

    

 

    

  & 

    

      

&  

 

      %        & 1 2     

      & 

         



   

      

        

 



  

  

    &  

   >K  %  1 



 >'66!@*%22 !) %22!55  !0 <  % 

>'66!@ /%2207%2205  0@= 7" "!$!

&

$ !"#! $ )" 2 "

" !0$

 ) "!&)""!! "  !

) "-&)1 #

05"4 ##$$,&! 2&$#! "   ! 

)""2

"##$$ " (  ! !5  2 "!)!"#

"#$

##$$ *"

) #

" 0 ! !

 ")!& " "! #  "  #!& 5

  #! " #

"  !&1   * $$2

) &0  $>&

$2 !



"#!    ?""!"#$

"    " !2 $)  #! "  @ ?""!" !5

"!  &!!

)

" 1

 2""  2&$$"#! &1# """

" ! 

#

"$ @

 /"  #$

 2!  !>& !    #!   " !       

#!

)

&2 "#$

/"

) !&!

05"4 ##$$,&!

 !5 ("5/"$!

4 ##$$,&!"  "  !"

) "$!

!

$,&! !!

  $&

""

) !!05"!

$,&!2 !! & /" $!

4 ##$$,&!2 "!

)"

##$ /"  $!

  4   ##$$  ,&! 

 #!  <    " -&)1 !

A0""2

31

 0"$ "#$

 $&"!$   "#$

 ! !582 !* "! !  "  $!

  4   ##$$  ,&!  2  

  $$5 

! ! /"! !*"$!

4 ##$$,&!2"

$!!

)

)

#!  !!

)"  $ 0"$ " #$

"

" #! "#

"   "&

#"##$/" !##!" "$!

4 ##$$ ,&!2 $!$5!! & /"4 ##$$,&!  "!" #!

!!&$<,', 2 "

&

10 *">& 

2!)

"#$

! #   "#$

$#!  " !#

"$ 05$

))    /"4 ##$$,&!11 !!!

"

)"

#! "#

"  0!$("

& !1 05"!

$,&!2&$ "2"" #! ""#$

! $#!1 

-&  2 "#$

/"

&  &$$ &05"!

$,&!! & !

  !@       

 

        

 

   & L.

!>$@    

      

      

 

            L  .

>$ 



606)'6!'@ '@    

 





   L.+ *@    

 

    

L.+ /@    

        M



 

 

  2 L.+ 0@    

  &

L.+ 7@     

  &    ( L.+ @ :  = $("

& 2&$$  &!"!#! " 

&2 "

!)!2 !

"

# "#$

2 !1/"  "  $ 1"2 !

"

# !"#!#!5/"  " $5$ 1 ""5!

#

" #!#!5 !" 8&(1," * " !#!

!

! /"#$

"1 $  "#$" !$ !"$ 2

#

8&(1," 82 !* !"

8&(1," *!  & !

!

)

" 1 8&(1,"  /"!

    $0$ "

$#! "8&(1," !"

$)$" 2! !

#

"!*"   

&

05" ,&! 0$2$!$5 "2 " 

"  2"

&0

#

/"$!

!

$,&!" 

&

"&1 !5   #$ "

$

" !1 -10 !"5!

;

 6B3<* -10 !"5!

;

;;

B3*-10 !"5!

;;;6

< B36*-10 !"5!

;;;

B3*-10 !"5!

 6B3  (" !) !2!

!"5!

6 B3 +" ! !2!

!"5!

6  B3;#! ""#!#!5

&0

#

#!

!

!  "  /" #!#!5 2 "2 0 2     :    $ 105"#$

 #!

  "'& -0:   &*

*" !

"!  & !!" #! &1# !&" 2 "

&

10 *>&  



2! )

"! #    

"$"1!$50&  "   !5

&

" 1  2""  *",&! 

!2

! "" " 2""  ! 

)

#

 *"!

$,&!   !1 5

&2 "!)! "2 !

"

#    " #$

  * "! !* 7  "     !    " !   /"-&)1  "$!

4 ##$$,&!



 " "!

$,&!

! ! 82 !  0 !   $&

)    2!    & *  "  #$

2&$0$ 0!5(##!#!

#!

) 0 !"1# ,&!

!#

"$  !#!

)" !2 !

"

#  $1  !

)$5*"#! )&$! ##$

$$2

 *# $ 



  +,)-,).(/)%0&'12.)%(3')4 )(23 +,)-,)..)/3.-%56)

)(23