High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3527/2017dismissed

Phool Kumar v. Sandeep Sheokand & ANR

2018-08-20Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()*)*

+"",-./0 11!,,'

2!0&.& '3!!1+!"4'3'" +!0 !&1"'3!' &

0!&!' (

0) '45 !+ 637"$ !#"0 +!11!,,' ) !#!'3' 11!,,' %&%'&!$"'311!,9!#"0! +%&".0 )

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

.0 +!0/"0!6&1!0<0!!/!' "&!,,3 !3)) +! 0<! 3 !#"0 !@!$. %"'"# +!&,!3!!3;&& %1., !3&)))))9!%'< +",%3:6 +!1,%' %##0!&1"'3!' +33.,:11!0!3%' +!"##%$!"# +! $"'$!0'!3.9 !<%& 00"' +!#",,";%'<3 !%)!)))'3<" +%&

10!&!'$!/04!3'3;+%$+;".,39!0!#,!$ !3#0"/3"$./!' @) >)

!3%'!&&'3;%,,%'<'!&&"' +!10 "# +!1,%' %##0!&1"'3!' ;".,3 #.0 +!09!0!#,!$ !3.1"'%&&.'$!"#,!<,'" %$!@) " +!3!#!'3' 11!,,' 6$4'";,!3</!' @) C'3"#+7%'<%'& % . !3 +!&.% #"0 &1!$%#%$ 1!0#"0/'$! %//!3% !,: +!0!# !0 '3 ;% +". ': 3!,: "' =))*) +!#%'3%'<&0!$"03!39: +!$".0 &9!,";0!;!,,0!&"'!3 '3 .1"' 3.! 110!$% %"' "# "0, '3 3"$./!' 0: !7%3!'$!) " %' !0#!0!'$!%' +!&/!%&;00' !3)

0!&!' 11!,3"!&'" 0%&!':A.!& %"'"#,;) +!11!,6$$"03%'<,:6%&3%&/%&&!3)

,.$4:

B+! +!0&1!4%'<?0!&"'!3( !&?"

B+! +!0 !1"0 9,!( !&?"