Gurmit Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!"!#$%!#&'$( ) * )+'&%,&-'&%./-'&%.0- '&%,'-'&%,#!"
)1#&'$ !"!#$%!#&'$( )+'&.22!2/!"
!#&'$ "
!,$''!#&''( !"!#$$!#&'$( !'&.00!"
!#&'$ !"!#2.!#&'$( )+'&22%!2,-'&0,#-'&/0'- '&/02-'&/0/-'&0&.-''&'&-''%,#- ''%2,-''.''-'#%0/-'#%00-'#/&2- ''./2-'#'2%-'##/%-'#.#%-'#&$#!
"
)1#&'$"
!,$''!#&''( !'&,2&!2'!"
!#&'$ !"!#2&!#&'$( !'&$$03'&$2&!"
!#&'$ !"!#2#!#&'$ "
!,,0'!#&'' "
!'0'&0!#&'$( !'&.&2-'&.&0-'&.'.-'&.%&- '&.&2-''%'0-'&/$&-'&/2&-'&0%#- '#2&'!"
!#&'$"
!',2/$!
'000 4)1 5 63+ 6
7+ 4)1 5 648+ 95 :
74 7+ 4)1 5 648+ 4)148);#&+'#+#&'$ <<<< ; =>?+ ?@ =>?+ ? >">
!"
#
$
!
!"
#
$
#
%
$
$& $
$"#
'
# (""
)*+"
$"# (,'%,- &!
#
$.
"
/ # @ - + )0* &." ""
+# ( 12 1201 .$( "
(#(#$ .($.3 "$"4 ( "$ 55( 0566 " ( # ( $ "078( &$ ##.$
( # ( ( $. 3 " )1* & ""
$ $ 9$. : #" (
( (($" ; ) * #25 0552
)
* <= " # $
# " "
(( ( &" !## $.
)
* . # 0552 $ "#
+ "# . " "
$ ) * ".&" $ ($ ""
(( ! # )* " " >$ $.
%$ #1202 05 2?
)7* #( $ !$ ; )* #(#$ $ 55(0566$ . 9#"
: 9" : 4 $ ( " " ).* #(#$ $ 55 (
((
. # $ !"; ( #. ( )* 0566#. (( "
) *
.
@ ( "# . $ # $ !"; ($ #" #" ;$ " )
* $" (
.
@"
(#" ($(&, $ "$.
. (#$ #$!";< )* # (#$ " 4 $ ( " ""# "(4#"$ " (
. $ # $!";
)* $ $ # $ 4""# ( $$ ($(&, &, (
""
( "# #" "# .
$" "$ % 02A( )A* B>$ (
%($.
%$ #1202 !$ " " ( #($$9#:($
%$" (#$ ( ( # 06 0562 "$" 4 ( "$ 86;!( 0575 (0566 # ( 20 2C 0565 0575 " ( $. (#$ # 25 0552 $ !
$ 6)
* " (
%$ " # &0552# # 10 055C ( D
%$E#D .(
.(. ! .( 407C # ". $E !
$C( # $. $ !
$C"
;%$ " )?* !
$ 6)
* ( # 25 0552 "
%$"(06 2C 05629#:
" 10 2?
0557./ %( !$ & '())#)) *+
, %,
" +
" -' ./0
)8* #
!
$;C(# #10 055C
%$B"(("# ( " $
$ #$ "
. $ .3:.
$"#!$
!" # $ $ % $
&& $ % "! & ' (
&,"$ $ (( $ >$ ( (# # )C* ( $. "" $.
%$ #122C . $ 17 122C &( #"$.
0A / %( !$ & ' (!1!122) *3 4 % ,
' . /0 08 2C 1225 .; #
"$ 022)A*(0566 "$.
#" ( %!
$)7*( " # "
!
$ (( D
5 6 7
,
E )6* < ( 1202 # (#$ "$.
05 2?
)5* & 1202 # . $ . !$ $ ((
; ) * # $ 55 ( 0566 . (#$ $ $$$#.
4 $ "
$".&, '( &, ($.
%$ " " $ )
* "" (#$ #. &, "
$ . # .( (#$ # &$ # (#$ $ ( # "$ #"
$ 55(0566 )
* $#.#" 1202 "# &,
#
&$
$. "$". "
%$" ) * "D
%$E $ #( 0566 (
( ("( )* # ( 9($$:
%$ " . &, . "
' # (9$ ($$" :.(#$ ) * .
>$ # . (#$ ( # .(
%$" "$" 4 $ (#"
#" $( ##($$($" " )
* #: "
%$ ! # ( #
@ (; ( # ! #
$#( #"$" )02* & !$ " 078)4 * $ (
>$ $.
%$ # 1202
%$ "# $
$
)00* $=(
3:.
$"#!$ $#( !$/#.121201 $ .
%$B" #. $
%$" &= # .$(="(.
%$" 3:.
$"#!$ "( # 21 1208 F ,8'*&0 (9:;
9#2 ,8'*&0 (9#2G (
# ) 4 * ; <= %
,
%
> &
%
/-
6 7
'
):2-
?
,
,
%
> &
%
-
> &
=
-
> &
"
% -
5
%-
@
)01* 3 ""
+( " .
;%$". !$ )07* =$ (" . & ."$ )0A* & (# . ( (
%$ B" ($$" A7;( 0575 .($..($.' 7A(05C6 27 05C6 & " (
; < ) "
,
3%
5
,
" +
" +
-
" +
%
%;
*0-
%
-
A; * 0
B *0
%
,
&
,
B * 0
%
%
;
%
A; *0 7
& B *0
*
%0B *05;%
B *%0
B
*0
-
-
A '%
%
5
;
*0 " +
%
,
" +
"
%
"
%
%
!9-#2 #9
;
*0
1:;$ *+ & $ C <7
& @
,
3%
<
@
,
3%
D
%
,
3%
% E
*0 ;
*0
@ )#" ""
* )0?* <$ "$"4 ("$ A7;)0* # ( $. 06 0562 )1* F (D#EG9 :D
" +
'
5
,
!!;+
6 +
- ))-
% 67A; + %
%
?
- % * 0 "
5
% *0 (
(
,
>
- * 0 /
% F5
C67
-
5 1
%
E )#" .$* )08* & ;""
+
%$"$ "# $ A7; 06 0562$#(#$ 4 (" $ 86;! ( 0575 " " 55(0566 &$ !$: 12 1201 $(("# $ "$$$9 :(. &($$ # ( ($. A7; # ( 05C6 06 0562 $
)0C* <$ 06 0562#
0575" 0566 # ( 20 2C &(($. (( ##25 0552$ 55(0566 !
$;6)
* 4" D
6 7 %
,
% 3% ' - $
" - (
(,/ 9&+ !),- !;+:2-
:
G- ):2E & $ # # ( "
%$ " < $
%$ " ($# ."
($
$ . !$3:.
$"#!$ . ( !$ "# "$#
$
)06* & ""
"# $
%$ # 1202 $ ( !$4 # (( # .$
%$ "# $ "
$
"$ # &# %( A7;(0575 06 0562 $$$
)05* 3 $ $($ $.# ( # ""
" (. ( ( )12* & ""
" #
"
$" A7; ( 0575 . ( $. 05C6 &
" # "(!";< " ( D! ( &" E " (
#D $ &"$ E )10* B
# !"<; D" &&", E 0575 .( )##*05?8)' 022(05?8* 85;% ( !" )" 56 ( 0566 * $((" (!" <; $ # $
(( D
&
=0 ))+
%
%
)11* B A7; . = $ $4" 86;%(!
@ $.; )A* ( A7;
"$ ;
86;%(0575 30575. " $ $ $ $.; )A* ( A7; .($. . . 1?0 1?A(! $ &" ( #
$(" $ $ (# " $.
$ A7; $ . (" !" <; 06 0562 $ H$ $ ( " ( ' 0562 . $ $
$ $
)17* $# 06 0562#$(
$(" $ .
0575" 20 2C &# ((#$ $!" <;(0575
%$"# &( #
($.(#$ 25 0552$ 55 (' &4 #$(" "# (# 20 2C 0565
( # 25 & "#
%$ " $ 0562 "$.
.# ;4 2C 0565 $"# $ "$ )1A* ($.#"
"# (
%$"$!
$6)
*(#25 0552 D
67%
,
% 3% ' - $
" - (
(,/ 9&+ !),- !;+:2-
:
G-):2E )1?* < # ( !
$ 6)
* ( # 0552 $ . !$ & ' ())# )) *+
, % ,
" +
" - ' . /0 10 2?
& $# (
)18* & ( $. # #" $ # # 10 055C $. $!
$C( #.(!
$C;" D
- %
%
6
-
% - %
?
- %
-
-
67
,
" &
-' E )1C* & .;"$ # !
$ C; 055C $ #.3:.
$"#!$
(
!" )$"* )16* &( # ( $.
%$ # 122C (
"$.
0A & # " "$.
# #;
" ( F"
& '!1!122)*3 4 %,
' ./0 08 2C 1225G )15* &$.
(.
# # (20 2C 0565$ "# $ . ($(
%$" )72* & ((#.($. ($(
%$"$.
%$ #1202 . $ . !$ $ ( "010017( )70* . " . 4" $ "078)4 *($ 12 1201 1202# >$ .
.$"((#.($.
%$ "# .
# .
$
)71* I # ( " ( $ "00?017 . !$ ( >$ 1202
%$ # .
"$. ""
)77* <
( $ ( ""
$" 10C;(0566$"# $ $0575 "# .$ $ "
$ # ( ( A7;)A*(0575
$". ""
( $ $
"# $ .$" ( " ( ((#$ ($"# #".$ & #(#$ $!"<;
0575 ( >$ ( "# $ H$ ( $.
. #( "# $!";(0566
(#$ #$!";<25 0552# (# # # # .# " (( !"; H$ $ # . " 4 $ ( &, "# ( .+$ $# "
%$" # # ( $ $ )7A* #
("
. ""
"# #$ .
$ 68( 0566 # " (
! $ !$ .
$ $ $# )7?* H(;( # ""
# )78* " ( . "
( )* A:
@ B
4 #&+'#+#&'$ %
A C * B
4