High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/839/2019dismissed

Manoj Batra v. Simran Batra And Another

2019-10-23Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma6 pages

! "#!

$$$% &'(' )*!#!

!!!

+ $$$',

----- %' )('+./! 01 !

2+ , +('

! +!' . ,' *!. 1' *,(33 + "(3* !

,!'' 4 .! 0 !. '

!)'' '/(3 %,!./(3 !*.4 ) ,!

5+

!, . '() 6 % +!*.4 5+. '3 +'!.!4 !''

6 7 ,* + +!'!5!*! !!..

5!8'

9 7 ,*

!+

', ' +!

.3 #.4'

'+!.!, () 6 % (3+ +!

(!.3(!!7*

+)*

!+(#!

! 5+ ' .3!..455 ( +'5.

: ',

!5

9 ! ', 1.4 )

'5!' 3*!.

, ;

+ '++!.!!,,.!

!3!'

()

+ %

< * * *'

& . 0 6 2+ +!,+4'!..4!''!(.

+'5! +'!'

'++!!.'

. ! *,.! !3!'

+* ( ) ! 69 =% 2+ +! . + *,!4 + ', ' ! + *

+ ' ( ('.4!+5!'3. 3 +* '' 3 +*

. ,' , () 6 % <+!'

5!''

(43 +.!''> .4 +.) ) !4)+

. ) ,!

',

5!''

(439 .!''/!:!''?!,(%( .)+

. ) ,!

2+', '+!1 ( *! 3 +* '

!@(

*! ! 4+*!' +4+!1 * 1!

.!** 1!

., 4 + !*'

2+, '!*,.

45 5=!0''(! *,!4 A* 5.+ '3 + , ' '

(' + ,!

' ! !'

!

@(* '!'5..!' *!, +,!

'

1!..!!., ' !+'.!

4 .!!*.4 +!'3! ! '!*!

''!

' 5 + ! '! *! ! !5! !*.4 !1 ( ' +!'. +,' *!.1' !3!'

+*,(3"(3* !

,!''

+!*.4

A! ('. +!'!3(

'+!. 55 + 3 !4'( !(' !'

A!!*.4 +!'!5!'

7

,* +!'*!

' 5+!' +'!, (3+

+!1 '*''!'

', '+!. !. * !

+ 5 ! '+ ' !!..4 5.. '

. )+ ' 5 :3 !' 1* !+!'!53'!.!4 '

97 ,* + 5+!'

' !53 '!.!4 !

'

6 7 , * = +' *!

''!53*(++3+'!.!4 +! 2+, '.13! ! ** !

!'++!'

5

'!

'!'3 +'!+ ('!.

35

+ = +' *! '@(

,!4 +! ** !

5++ +''3 5+!' '!'

!43 5 ,!43!4 7.!'* 4 >+!'( +!3( ! +,' , +!' .!

+'

', ' '

!'

+!!'' 2+ ', ' !

.

!4 *! ! <+. *3 + !* ( *! ! + +!'

!:

'!

+ !!. ! '

(' + ,!

' !'

!

5! +.!*! *!, +.!*! ! ++('

! !'5..!' +(* ,'

'5+ ++('

!'

+5'@(

*! ! '(+53+ !3+!' 31

+' '!

'

2+ ' @(

!: ! +' . ,! ' ! + '

;, '( ! !.!* ( +*!. *

=+!1+!.! ('. +,!

'

2+' ',( + ', '! * '

(+'

''+!' 31

!'

!435

+ 5+ '!!..45..,.!!'5 :3!' ! !+!53+3+'!.!4 +! ! +!'

('

', 2+' ' 3 .

3!.'

!

*! *.4 !(' *

''*,.

4 ) ''+!' 31 +

'

,* +*

,!4*!

'!'

' @(

*! ! +' . ,! ' 5++ '( !* ( '@( +*!. *

2+!*

, ' 5++*3'' '! * '

!,('(3 +(!

! +4!!

14 (!. '

!3 (!

2+4 ! '

(43 5.. ,.!'+

.'

! + *

', ' ' !3 * +! + '!.!4 !

!

.1 +'', '

*! !+' * '

'

2+ , ' *,.

4 5 =! 0''(! *,!4 A* 5.+ 2+(' +'

!,!

!,! *!3 2+, 3!

''.3!..4 '

!..4 !* !..4.!

*! !+'+.* ',!..45+ +4! ,('(3 +'

('

B1 ' (

', '' !3! '!'

!435

+'

!'( !'

!1 +'', ' 4!(

*! !+' * '

'

0+. +'7+(, 33 '

@(* 4 .4 ! .

*!

3 '(, 33 !+. = 5 (.

.

+,! '!@(!..4', ' . ;,'' ++. = ! ! *

+ 5+ +!' ('

4 ! +.

.4 ',' * 4

(, 33 + +. !

+ '!* * '+ ' @(

', '( ! !. *!

33(, ++. >*

4' *,. .4 '

!

,( 1!.(

*!

,(

+ (, 33 ++.

+ '+'!3 '+ (.!.'

5!' +;,'' !+. +;,''!

1 @(!..4 5

> C . )(,* !! "#$%&'()&)+!'+.!'(

! !

" "

"

# $ !

% !"

"

#

"

# $

!

" "

" ! # & ! "

% " ! "

#' "

!

" "

" " #( "

! % # & ! "# &

!! "

)

!

" " " # $ !

"

! " #D 2+('

3 +! '! .'

.

3!. '

! +4 ! !

(!. '

!3 + (!

+' ' +!5!*! !' !.4

+3+',!

(.!.45+ + .13'!'3!4 4!4 2+ !*.4 +!'3+ .4+. '.!

,!4*!

'3!.'' +!

+'!.'

!*,.

4 2+ ' 5!! 5 + *,(3 "(3* !

,!'' +!*.4

0 3.4 !*3 +*,(3"(3* !

,!'' + !*.4 ,' *!.1' 31 !4 * ''*''

!"#$ E!3(

<+ +',!:37!'

E' <+ +,

.