← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3082/2018dismissed

Gurdev Singh @ Mal Singh v. Jang Singh And ORS

2018-05-16Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma5 pages





     



 !""#$%$&' ()* +,-".$&/01 2$&/0 33"22 &!

4",%+%  &/$&/0 !0",%  "%3&-"&!%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

,"%"&!'

,&-",5$!0 ,6 *-.# !"* ,!0" 33"22 &! 77777 )(*$+&

33"22 &!832 $&!$$%$& "/+2 ,"#&-33" 2 / $&%!!0"

5+-/6"&! &--"#,""- !"-),"&-","-9(!0"--$!$& 2$%!,$#! +-/"* +:!% ,*;0","9(!0" 33" 23,"",,"-9(!0","%3&-"&!8-""&- &! / $&%!!0"5+-/6"&! &--"#,""!0"!,$ 2+,!0 %9""&3 ,!2( 22;"- 9(%"!!$&/ %$-"!0"-"#,""!!0""<!"&!-"#2 ,$&/!0"32 $&!$!9" ;&",$&5$&!3%%"%%$&: & 2%=6 ,2 %2 &- &-+302-!0" ,"6 $&$&/-"#,""

,&-",5$!0 ,6 *2" ,&"-#+&%"2,!0" 33"22 &!832 $&!$ %+96$!!"-!0 !!0"%+$! ,"6"&!$&"-; %$2"-&!0"3,"6$%"!0 !!0" 32 $&!$$%;&",$&3%%"%%$& %#8%0 ,",2 &-6" %+,$&/: & 2%= 6 ,2 %&!0"9 %$%$&0",$! &#",60$% !0", 29$,$&/0 &-6!0", +,5$!> +,*!0",","*%+/0!3%%"%%$&9(; (3 ,!$!$&!0"32!*/ $, 6+6:$&  0,  &-  ,"%$-"&!$ 2  0+%"  %$!+ !"-  $&  !0"  ,"    .$22 /" 0 2 $ & ;$!0#&%"?+"&!$ 2,"2$","&-$!$& ##+&!%@!0%0 ,"



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

@B%0 ,"+!@A%0 ," +! $& $&0",$! &#" 29$,$&/0 &-+,5$!> +,; %&!% &#!$&"- % 33" 2 / $&%!!0"5+-/6"&! &--"#,""!0"!,$ 2+,!; %3"&-$&/ !!0 !!$6" $&#"  !0"  33" 2  0 %  9""&  -"#$-"-*  $!  $%  $&  !0 !  9 #:/,+&-*  !0"  %+$!



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

,

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

E=8%"":$&/#&-& !$&-"2 (BE- (%$&,"8$2$&/ !0" 33" 2&!0"3,"6$%"!0 !!0" 33" 2; %$2"-;$!0$&2$6$! !$&*9+!!0"

"/$%!,(, $%"-#",! $&95"#!$&%!",,"6.$&/!0"95"#!$&%*!0" 33" 2 ; %,"8$2"-*9+!!0"% 6"; % / $&,"!+,&"-9(!0" "/$%!,(0"," !",* !0",$/$& 23 3",9:; %6$%32 #"-0" 33"22 &!"&/ /"-!0",#+&%"2 9+!!0",$/$& 2$2"; %&!,"!+,&"-9(!0"" ,2$",#+&%"2 &-*!0+%*-"2 ( ##+,,"-$&,"8$2$&/!0" 33" 2*;0$#0$%+&$&!"&!$& 2 &-9"(&-!0" #&!,2!0" 33"22 &! 0","$%&32 +%$92"*6+#02"%%* &(," %& 92""<32 & !$&, -"2 (BE- (%$&,"8$2$&/!0" 33" 2

-

"%+2! &!2(*!0" 33" 2$%-$%6$%%"-&6",$!% &- %;"22& -"2 ( ./+   )(*$

012 &'34% *252167 81

 918

*252 5: 918