← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/50985/2023dismissed

Mukesh v. State Of Haryana

2023-10-09Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

  

 

    !" #$%&%&'!()'&*!*+,-.%/ 0123456378984:;!(<!<*!*+ %=>39? <<<<@328284:3A BCDEFE G212345H1AI1:1 <<<$39J4:63:2     K LM N      OOOOO @A393:2;  %A<P1=A1QRA4A1SR6Q4712354A2?3J328284:3A %A<T1U689?%1:7?1:61SR66V<RPH1AI1:1 OOOOO

    M M < @A1I3A 8: 2?3 9374:6 J328284: 58V36 =:63A G37284: "+) #A<@<#< 89 54A UA1:2 45 1:2878J124AI W18V 24 2?3 J328284:3A 8: XY$ Z4<("S 61236 *!<!*<*!**S A3U8923A36 =:63A G37284:9 * 1:6 *( 45 Z0@G R72S ()'S 12 @4V873 G21284: [1V1:1=AS0892A872$4?21>< *< \?3 5172=1V ]12A8^ 45 2?3 7193 19 J3A 2?3 JA393:2 XY$ 1A3 2?12 4: *!<!*<*!**S _?3: 8: 74::37284: _82? J12A4VV8:U 6=2I 2?3 8:Q3928U128:U 455873A 1V4:U&_82? 42?3A 4558781V9 _3A3 JA393:2 :31A T=A18] WIJ199S A3738Q36 937A32 8:54A]1284: 2?12 177=936 [4]1V 89 93VV8:U :1A74287 9=W921:73 8: 5A4:2 45 ?3A ?4=93S 2?3I A317?36 2?3 9J42 1:6 54=:6 ?3A JA393:2 2?

3A3< R523A U8Q8:U 1 :42873 =:63A G37284: '! Z0@GS 9?3 U1Q3 ?3A 74:93:2 24 W3 7?37>36 WI 1 U1`32236 455873A< aJ4: ?3A J3A94:1V 931A7?S +<') UA1]9 45 ?3A48: _3A3 A374Q3A36 5A4] ?3A 7412S _?87? _19 21>3: 8:24 J49939984: Q863 93J1A123 ]3]4< G?3 8: ?

  

  !" #$

" %



$"  &#''



'( 

    ) *) +

$" ,   #''



"   -

,  #''



" "$,  "

'"

"$ "-

,

.

$"/ -/ , - !

-  1

 

"  

) 2 '" 1/ '  '" # 

 3$1-

, 5   7$#- $ ' 

"

, 9:;<= >?=@A BCD >E<EF :; 9<G?H I<JKL &MN( O 788 N)  #''

 '" %  !''1 '  '"'1'



# !'  '"'1'1 1 %) $"/

 #%" ,  1 ,'

'# % ' '-) O) + 7

$"

## ""  #%

 1 $  '" '"   #''

,' %  #''

 "P'1 '

'# % '/

!/ !

 '  ,'"

/ '" $ !"

 '

' 1 ', ,  "- !" 1$ ,  - '- %  

$"/ " 

 ' 

  MQ)MR)M*/ ' !" '"# "

,

'"$ '

" , -  #''

/ !

!" % "$ ,   ' $)  '"

! 1 $ $1 '  #" #''

) 2"

, "  -'" 

/ 

  ' S$"'

!" 

 , - 

.

$" -/ !

!"   !' N*)TU 1-"

,

 ' %  '

 #%

"  ', -'

 '   !" "'1 

'

"$ "  ' , 

,



$") 

 "# ','

% -



$"  '))/  #''

/ " 

 !

 #$

" 

   "$##'  "-

) 

" '" "' '1 '"'1  ,'

$  $   '%

, 

 /

'"

$" ' ' 1'

'" ""')  '" % ## "'

,

'- #'1 

,, / ,'1 , - 3$"'

  -#'1

  

 !"  #$%  !$

& !# '%$(! )&%  !*!!$# &)  !$ '&

+ ,$%#$%  & !#& %!$ '% !)# - .  & !"  ! %#$  &

& $  ! /& % $! &  %0 &) !*!! 0  '& $)% $ 0 $%  $%0 * ! $%!! & 1$#) &)  '& % )&% !&* *" '$% #$%"  '%  )$  &) * $ 0 1

$* 1(

&  &% $ ! & )" !' ) $##( $ 0 !

#&! $ 

& %$1$  % &% )%&* % & $ 1 ' % $! 1( * $  $  &% & %" $! $#!& $ %

$* $

&* '  ! % )&%*$& " $ ! $! !## 0 

& %$1$  )%&  &) % & !" %$)% & %$ $ 0 1

& " ! $! $''%  $#& 0 

& %$1$ ,&%" & '%$(% *$" & !% & ! %  )%&*  '& % 1(  #$% 

& !#  $ 0 ! ## !! & ! %% %"  '& $! !'&! &) ! ! &  '& &%   % 0 

& %! &) $%0 * !"

% $ (

 0%&  $! 1 ! 1*

&%  %$!& )&%

& ! %% % 0 1)&%  %$# /& % $! '%& 3 &%!" 4!& 5

&) ! /& %  %0$% & %$ 0 ! &  &% ! 1!6   1$# '&

% 7 & 89 /%:/" )%! $ 0 1 %$ $ &1!% $  & #

& 1 *$ $ $1# *%#( &  0%&  $ !&*



& !6  $# $ 

&!*

$ 0

% *!$

! $

&* $1& " ) %% #&'* ! !

$! $%%! &)

&;$

! &% *$ $

! &% 1$# 0%$  &

&;$

!" ))% 

& !%$& !" !&* *&% $#!"

 & * ! &% ## !! &)  $

! 2 & # $#!&

& 1 *$ $ $1# & '#$ &% 0%&  $  /& % &  $%#% &

$!& )$# &

& !% $ ( '$% #$% $!'  &% *$%$# & % &% &% $ $ ( '&   $$#$1# &  $

! $!

& $< "



    ! "# $ % & !' !( )*&+ ( !

,-.

/#- ' 

',- #- 0,- 12 $3$"$ &#'  4--' -'5   !  

-' 4 ' -

-+ ,!- - ! ,

#- - , ,#4 -,   ! ,  # 

/#- +- - '&$6 70 89:;9<=> ?8@> ABC DE8E= FG @9:8HI "JKLKLMNOPLQMQQ , - 1M$MO$QMQ1R$ S$ %  

  4T 

  -,  !    *-U' V! 0#

4 "# - ! ,    >8HW@X8X ABC =9E>8X Y@>=8@ FG Z8>[FE;[B ( &! - ! 0\3 ]"

'$^ PSLQMQQ &  4

 +   O$OQ$QMQQ(   4- !     4

'   -,  5 ' 5 K!5  ! *! "# (5 +-!# _L )` !+ !  ' - ,#- ' !

  ` - -

 -  -

L

'  !

- 

5 $ V!0 ,'\+3- (,, -'5( 4

$ V! - 4

,- - 5   OO$OM$QMQQ

- +, - +&   !  4

'   !

,' '+

-$ *&+ (   !

-

-

- 

'5

#' '( !

4 45  ,-   5 ! V ' "#  a # '5 

'- &-4  -,, -,&!'&$6 2$ V! -4   !

- !

, - !  ,' 

4-   ! +4-- ,L,,# ( &! !

-   ! & $ *-U' V! 0#

4 "# - ! ,    DE8E= FG 8>b898 ABC D8c8>EW ?@c8> ( QMQQ ]1^ J$"$J$]"

4-'^NNO!!'!# _ )S$ V!    ! ,' "# --

#' '  !

--

!& ! !

  &



 -

#-,   ! -,  5 ' - 5 ! *! "# $ V!   ( !

4 ,--   #-  !' ! !

- 

'

!+,4- #,## $ 2$ %- ,   ! -# ( !

-- 45  '  T +-   ! , - - V - 0-! + 0   V4' d# ]

^(

!

 ! 4    #- !

#' '

     ! ! 

  " !  #$ !   % &% '     ( )   $ !  $

# $



( *

 +% '

! , *  !  -*    ."

/#  ! 

 "

  "  () $ + $% 01% -* !  )-,  $  *+% '

 #"

+ +  $3$+% 4$   $5# ,  4 67 $

+  8 $$,   +  * *%9 &%  $ 

 +,  #"

 

++

 !"#   :2;,

*- , $ #$ " !  +#" "  + #"  + $

+ # $+    ) +   *$

 ++ - )(

  

$ *! ! $ "  $   +

 ,

- " $!( !"# +   $   !  , *$ 

++   $  "*  "+   ) +, *

! , $ 

+$$# $  +$$+

$

   +  )- !$% '

$#) $$ !   !   ( ) +   

$ ( +$$# $  ! 3#$+ " $  

, *  $  + $$),

$

 ! ,  # (  -* !  # !$ !  $ $ $  +$ ! . <) '

7# /#    $$ ! =>?@AB>B  + C>D>=E@ FAD>= G$# H% '

#$+  

" !  

$ $+  )

$$ (    

I#$ ! $  + # $ !

 ,  * 

$ "+(  +#" "  + $  $    --  !

 $ $% 01% . <) '

7# /#    CJKK@>=>D C>EBJLM>NN> @OE=O PQR CE>EO ST >@>=>Q@E=> , GU100H 0 7// V&W, *  I# + "  *   ( )

+     --+ )(  / $#  X  YA=?>ZQ@CJLM@CJ??J>PQRCE>EOSTAL[>? , G0&\1H U7//V + + #$] ^% '

#  + -( !  #$  +  I

 !  #$+ #$ )  (  

++ )! 

$ $ +_ % '

 + $ !     #+ "  ! $ 

  

   !"

#$

% &"% !'!

"%'% "%"% !!"%($)"

!% "*%$"&%!+(#"**%, !!!-."

!(!#!$"*#!%"*#*"'/

!, ! - .

!(!#!$ "*  



#!1#!""

" 

!'!# """**% - - 2  

!"%   (% '  "%#$ !  "(/ "*!%/ !%&" '!#!!%&#!%($ !%&!'"- !- 3' "* &% "* %!!"$ (!# ! ##$ !%   "* #&'&%!

**!%& $#&% '("*"#- 4444444445 66- 3% 7 89:;<=;>;< ?@7 A9>BCDE>;DB EF GHFE>CB<BHD I JKL6MN M O)) KPI Q"%R(# . O ' )"

  "(   I ST !%!#$I  !

  "* "

 "*  !%  !&!"% "

  %" "%#$   % "*  

 ( 

 # "

"

 - U"

%  O!"% PVW )U) !

% 4" !%$ " % 

'  " ( 4!



!%&#$- . ! !#& "*  X (!#

"

( &% "%#$ !% 4!"%#   - . /

!!#

!

!"% "%*

"%  "

  " ( "#$ 4!

 * #!!"% "* '!%  "  %  % & !$ "*  

!"%,

!(!#!$ "* #!% *#!%& /

! % " *" "

!

  ! !

 *!   *" &% "* %!!"$ (!#- Y% "* %!!"$ (!# "

"' 4% !%* !% 

 "* !%  !&!"% "* % "**% % %I  "

 '

( ! '

 !# 4!

!%&

 " *" &% "* %!!"$ (!#- Z%!!"$ (!# !

%" " ( &%   ' "* # % !  " ( &% "%#$ %  "

 !

"% !%  4!"%# ! '

% 4!

" ""4" !%$' $- 5 6K- 3 !

'%!* #$ #  %!!"$ (!# !

%"  !&  '$ ( &% !%  $ "  - . )"

  " 1 !%" "% !

!"% ##  * % ! '

% % * !

'"

!

*!"%I &% ! "%#$ !% 4!"%# ! '

% I  ##  *" % '  ' %  !

%"

!(!#!$ "* !' !%*!%& !%   "* /

!- .

!(!#!$ "*  





   !"### $ "$%& !"' (   )  '" #*$$ # ($"$ "#") #!'   "'#$%+ ,-+ . /0102 32432526027 89 0:2 ;<;=; >5; ?6@A /:13B1C ,DDEFG H+I+H+EI%$ G JKL MN )  O' P&% I" '$ )#( "'$"  $## !' ## $

$"# '$( ) $

 $ "' ""' # " )  " % "' $ # "' #$% $  Q )  "' ' "' #"$ " $" $# %&$"R#" $##& "

!'#$ $Q$" &$"Q)$ + ,F+ O'   $ "# $  %#"$ # ($ "'$" "' %"  %$ "Q $" )   "

$

$"  &" "( %)

 &S$#" )$ " "' &"" !

%& "' "' ' $  "( (#" $" $# " %$Q

$( %$Q

# # $

$&# $# $ # "' $&&'#  '% S + M# #"$ " $" #  ##$Q " # ( "' %# &$ $  " "' ""'

&  !"' "' $)( " $" $ # )   " "'$" "' &"" !

"    $ "'$" "' !"###  "$%& !"' "' (     % T#" + O'# "' &#" $# !' (!  "'

'"  "' $S T %"# "'# I" # " " ) %"

## $# #( " ) $ # #%##+ ,U+ O' )#($"# %$ '$)( $ %$"  Q  "' &&#    "' &#" &"" $   %$ $ " ) #" $# $ V&##&"'%"#"' $#+

??W?XY?Z [XY\]

^0_823C  `+a$%$ b'"'#&$* c$# d e#cf b'"'&"$)  d e#cf