Harbhajan Dass v. Gurbaxi Ram & ORS
!
"#$$%&'&() $*+,"+-./ "+*1"2"("''
33$44"(# 5$+','
,+*"6& "7#1$+'
$'3(8$(#'
! "
#$%&' () *+!' +*,&
+$'$(#) + ,(&'1,3#"/89%"#$/ +#1$"33$44"(# ::::: +*,&-( 33$44"(#;34"&(#& 1"' (# *$$( ',%%$'',4 &( '$$&(< 8&'%+$#&("+-+$4&$,(8$+$%#&(#1$3$%&&% $4&$%# +'1+#/ #1$%#!"'#1$8$%+$$&(#1$',&#="'%(&($8#+$,(8$"+($'#7($- / ./>;"4(<=&(#$+$'#?0@3$+"((,7+7#1$8"#$3"-7$(# #1$"7,(##&44#1$8$%&'&(#1$',&#
4"&(#&',<1#'3$%&&%3$++7"(%$#1$"<+$$7$(##'$44 8"#$8 . 00"(8(#1$'"7$8"-/#1$8$$(8"(#'"44$<$84-$6$%,#$8" 3=$+"##+($-&(1&'"9,+"(83"&8/>;"'$"+($'#7($-1$ "<+$$7$(#%(#"&($8#1$'#&3,4"#&(#1"##1$'"4$8$$8=,48*$$6$%,#$8 (4-=1$(#1$7,#"#&(="'$$%#$8&("9,+8$$(8"(# #="'
"4''#&3,4"#$8#1"#($$+1$(+1&'"##+($-=,487"A$"(-'#"#$7$(# "89$+'$#$"%1#1$+=$9$+/8,+&(<#1&'3$+&8/$1'&48"+"'=$44"' 1&$"4$'77&''&($+#A#1$',;7#,%<(&B"(%$=+$<"+8##1$ 7,#"#&("(8&(#1'$3+%$$8&(<'/4"(87$"',+&(<CA"("4'$"%1%"7$#
#1$'1"+$*#1#1$8$$(8"(#'1$"+$7$(#&($8+8$+="'%1"44$(<$8 *-#1$9$(8+#1$34"&(#&&(+$9&'&(/=1&%1="'8&'7&''$8 4"&(#&&'
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
+#1$+$"'('7$(#&($8"*9$/8(#&(8"(-&44$<"4&#-+ 3$+9$+'&#-&(#1$%(%,++$(#&(8&(<'=1&%1"+$*"'$8("33+$%&"#&(+"4 "(88%,7$(#"+-$9&8$(%$<+,(8+&(#$+$+$(%$&'7"8$,#/7,%1 4$''&(949$7$(#"(-',*'#"(#&"4D,$'#&(4"= $',4#"(#4-/#1$"33$"4 &'8&'7&''$8 ./01-2 +*,&
345 ()67'
,58549:
;4
<4;
,585 8/"
<4;