← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6481/2014dismissed

Hargopal Singh v. Punjab State Tubewell Corporation & ORS

2017-07-11Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi8 pages

      

!"# #$%&%'(

) ) 

       

  ( * + ,+-  

 

!" # $$$$ ,+- + % ""#

## 

"  

 " #

##""& " &

 #' &

  '

&   "

#  '

& #  " ( ##"# " "&  "

)#   

## 



# '

*+,-.' 

"

 "' # /  001 / 

21-"&#' # & )++)3)++0 

!





##'"

  "

'

  "    &# !

4#  5 *'

& & 

&  &  #/ ))#"

5.  6  #  "' #" 5. / 

))708-,31 9 4#  5 * 

"

! "

#  -0  #:; " " """ "

/ ))70#" 5.

!

'

)) )++2  &  #"

&         &     &  

  -*7-<    " 

0</'

  #)7)3-7) ,'

   6  #/ ))70 =  

##  

!

   '



##  ' >&   & #'

&'' #  !" """ "# &#'#

#

!

 "  "

#' #'

&'' !

 #   &

' "

#" = "'

 " " # "& # 

  

##   

  #  !" ""

&

"/  # 

##"

#  * &/

' #' !

  ; #' '   & ! &" " " %  # !  "  " "&             (

   #  

## "

#  -0

## "  ; #' '  & & " " " ";



    "' 

   #   &     '     '

'' &  #   

 & " #  5 * &





&

 

"#'

 " '#

##

!

  " #  " #    " 

     '   

  '        '

& " 

## #  & "

= "' #

 #     "#' #

  -       

##         ' &

   "

     #     '

" & & #

 #& 

 #

  &#?= ) 6    '



?=4 6   # 3

# "&  ?=4 6  

## #    &

 " " "?=4 *  # !

  " ! /



     ""' & !

" # 

 " #   



  !

"       "           "  "'     " 

## # !

" &

" 

  !

"  ""

& 

     #  ' & 



"

# ' " / ))70  '

&  "!

  " )+ -) )+-0 @

 ! 

### 

#  

"' '

& # " !

 

 "-* )+-5  "

"  #

##  " #

  &'  & " #   "

;  "

  8A> 09 -*)# ""   ! /

"      ""  #     #  

"

  ##   # 3  " "

"   # #/ ))70 !  " # /# & ' !  " 

"

 &      "  

/ ))70

# '   # &"

'   &  

'#"     "

!

"!  "#& " #   

'

    "     ! # "''

 &#"   

 

"

;

!

  

#     "  "

    " !  " '!   : &

 



##  

'    ! 

    "  &  

  "      "

!

"  !  #  #  /  

'

:

 # 

  ##  "    / & #  



!&

! !

" 

"" " 

' " 

#!#

##3

 "#! !

" %  #" "

"' "# "  " #&" "  ""''



  #     

  

     " !    '    " '!  (#

 " "    " &>'

 "  "

#"# " !

"!  " 

""" !  #

"& # "

-<-1 #   

! "     

          

        

             

  

       

  



   

 

   

         

    

     

   

      !

"  



 

         

               

              #         

  

              

         

                 !

$  %   &    

              

            &      

 

           

     

     #    

     



    

   





  

'

 "

  ( )*+,  )*-, 

       !              

     

    .     

     (

         

          

  /

   

  

   ( ) *0,*0,

/ 1 -   #   

&   

   !

                                                             

  

    

         1 

          



   "  2 2 !

"   3   -      $        4))4* , %  -   %   5       

  6 !4))*4,%- %            



                          

    +!$   " 

!

789%%%:; -   <  

 7)8 

 7:      "    3 "  -    .

  =   "  

"  -    .

      7:4 

$ =

5:  &    "    +    "     778*,  $=  ;;7              

    #   

 

       

     

  

   - > 



              

 

  

      !          

%   



       



$   

          

   

 

     

   ?             

   

    

        

      

  

              ?                          

  1

4 5     

    

 

 @ :  "  ## 

##3   !#  !

 & 

 "#  

 6"

;

"!&     

"" " !

#" 



    4

" -1.0  B  " # " 

 

  '

 &! !

#!

&     %      "

"' "    #  "    #         '  '!  #

  4

"# 

  " # #     

     &      &    ! & 

    #  

& " " # &; #'"

 ; # 

; # 

"  #

 

>"

     " -++# # " :

  "" "    &  C '

!./!'!'!0#'1.!'!'1 !'"2#.3&+#4&25/!.0%'%!'1"2#.&6 7 $%8%9  !'"&2!:!.%3& ;.&2""!5%<!.%6  = )7

 '    

" #" "

"' "# "

! "  #'  

 # !

    '

" " ! ##'   & "    '#  "#

# " 

'  &       !   !   '  

 "   '

  !  " -- .

)+-.

,+-

" 

 < ( A(/

<  B A(/