Chanderpal v. Supayar Bai & ORS.

   

      

"#$ %$&'(')*

 
+

,")%$-."/ ..$//")# 0$-(1( 2#1."3"-"'")%#,$-( $(.)%$)#(

 *  45    6 5  -$($)#*7 -"'0'-"%"89%8&"#$9 -#,$"..$//")#
 :,$#,$-#,$$.-#$-( /&"/)$;(.".$-2"3<$"//;$%#($$ #,$=1%>2$)#?

 <$-$ $--$%##,$$.-#$--)#  :,$#,$-#,$=1%>2$)#(,1/%<$-$.-#$%')#,$%'>$(#? 77 77 5 9

5!

2.1>)$%')#,$.-$($)#  -$>1/"-($&)%"..$"/'(#,$ =1%>2$)#  ")%  %$&-$$  %"#$%  
 
9  ."(($%  <3  #,$  /$"-)$% %%'#')"/'(#-'&#1%>$9$;"-'9"

'-2')>#,$=1%>2$)#")%%$&-$$ %"#$%  +
 
9  ."(($%  <3  #,$  /$"-)$% %%'#')"/  '8'/  1%>$

$)'-1%>$!9$;"-'98'%$;,'&,#,$(1'# #,$./"')#'

(9;"( %'(2'(($%;'#,&(#( $ -$  #,$  /;$-  1-#9  "-2"/  ')>,  ()    "-%"- ')>,"(;$//"(6");"-"/")% ,")%$-."/()( "##")')>, () "-%"-')>,,"% '/$%"(1'# -%$&/"-"#')&/"'2')>#,"##,$3 "/)>;'#,.- -2"%$ $)%")#("-$$)#'#/$%##,$.-.$-#3 "-%"- ')>,')$@1"/(,"-$,$21#"#')(")&#')$%') "81-

"-%"-')>,4(! 1-()(")%"%"1>,#$-9)"2$/39,$<"'')$@1"/ (,"-$  ;"(  "/( &,"//$)>$%  ,$ ./"')#'

(  &/"'2$%  #,"#  #,$ (1'# .-.$-#3;"(=')#&."-&$)"-3.-.$-#3 ,"8$,$"-%#,$/$"-)$%&1)($/ -#,$"..$//")#")% ,"8$"/(&"-$ 1//3>)$#,-1>,#,$ '/$ #&2$(1##,"#"-%"-')>,%'$%')#,$3$"-
A
 ,$21#"#')') "81- 1-()(")%"%"1>,#$-9)"2$/39

,"##"-')>,9"##")')>,9"-2"/')>,B"-."/')>,96"-#"- ')>,")%,$<"'-$(.$&#'8$/39;"((")&#')$%')#,$3$"-
A
'#($/ ,$<"'"/(%'$%) +C
A,$-$"

#$-9#,$.-$($)#(1'# ;"( '/$%<3"-2"/')>,9#,$)/3(1-8'8')>() "-%"-')>, ")%<36");"-"/")% ,")%$-."/()( "##")')>,()

"-%"-')>, ,$/;$- 1-#,$/%#,"##,$(1'#.-.$-#3'()# ")&$(#-"/'))"#1-$")%'#;"(,$/%#,"##,$./"')#'

(D$.#212 - (1&,"/)>.$-'%9#,$-$ -$9-$/'$ ;"(%$&/')$%>"')(##,$("'% -%$-9)/3 ,")%$-."/() "##")')>, '/$%#,$"..$"/9;,'&, ;"(%'(2'(($%<3#,$/$"-)$%%%'#')"/'(#-'&#1%>$9$;"-'  #$->')>#,-1>,#,$=1%>2$)#(")%%$&-$$( <#, #,$ 1-#( <$/;9  "2   #,$ 8'$; #,"# <$ -$ #,'( 1-# "/(9

,")%$-."/  ()    "##")  ')>,  ,"(  '/$%  #,$  .-$($)#  -$>1/"- ($&)%"..$"/ $'(&/"'2')>#,$-'>,##,-1>,,'( "#,$-"##") ')>,,$()( "-%"-')>,$E&$.#"-2"/')>,9%1-')>#,$'-

77 /'

$#'2$9%'%)#&,"//$)>$#,$'),$-'#")&$')$@1"/(,"-$9;,'&,;"( -%$-$%<3-$8$)1$"1#,-'#'$(;"3<"&D')
A
"-2"/')>,9#,$ )/3&/"((7,$'- "-%"-')>,,"% '/$%#,$(1'#<$ -$#,$/;$-

1-#9<1#"

#$-/(')>#,$("2$9,$)$8$-&,"//$)>$%#,$ ')%')>(

#,$  /;$-  1-#   ,$-$ -$9  ,$  "..$"-(  #  ,"8$  "&&$.#$%  #,$ =1%>2$)#")%%$&-$$ #,$/;$- 1-#,$#,$-&/"((7,$'-(

"-%"-')>,"/(%'%)#&,"//$)>$#,$'),$-'#")&$')$@1"/(,"-$9 (")&#')$%;"3<"&D')
A
 8$)"

#$-#,$%$"#, ,$<"'')
A9#,$'),$-'#")&$ ,$-
+ #,(,"-$<3,$-/$>"/,$'-(;"()$8$- &,"//$)>$%#<$')>(9;'#,#,$/".($ #'2$9'#'(".."-$)##,"##,$ &/"((7,$'-( "-%"-')>,,"%"&&$.#$%#,"#,$<"''($)#'#/$%# #,$/")%')$@1"/(,"-$9;,"#($8$-2"3<$#,$<"('(,$(1'#;"(

'/$%')#,$3$"- '$ A3$"-("

#$-#,$%$"#, ,$<"',$ .-$($)#"..$//")#($$D(,'(-'>,##,-1>,,'( "#,$-"##")')>,9 ;,)$8$-&,"//$)>$%#,$'),$-'#")&$ "#,$-"-%"-')>,")%  ,'(('(#$-,$<"' #<$')>(9)(1<(#")#'"/@1$(#') /";

"-'($(')#,$.-$($)#"..$"/,$-$ -$9#,'( 1-#%$()# ')%")3 -$"()#')#$- $-$')#,$&)&1--$)# ')%')>(-$&-%$%<3#; 1-#( <$/; ,$.-$($)#"..$"/'("&&-%')>/3%'(2'(($%

5 !

 


 
+ (=D(