High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/651/2014allowed

Shyam Sunder Singhal v. Haryana Urban Development Authority And ANR.

2019-07-30Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!"#$%&!'

(('' )%$ *!+%",%-.'(#$!%"/0!1$'!%

( %&$-"

+%.!/.% 0%#'2/.%!((''

% #2!/. %!%(

4%'"/!%!('!"# $%&!'!'$%'%5!6$' %'#%"7$&+%",%-.'(# $!%"/ 0!1$' !%% %%% +, 8 %/9$%$1!%

(% ! .% ! ('/ &%$'$%' '

$.''&%%9'/*!%/*!'*!%/% 9$%$1!%/5!!!5!%%/56$%-" ! %.'(#% /9$%$1!%:!% $%"/5%5$

5%&#(!'5%:! (' 5 5! ! 6$$# #( 5%/$!!!'%%$%;! <6$/!5.%/!#$5!:! !('((%!!+&!=$%-"5"'&&$'% >%(('/5!!5

#( #$5!:!(%!('"!?.%# !/!(%5!'56$%%' ''#('%%.(%$6$#$!! '6$%%%#%/!!'5%' & (' #$%& 6$% "% '(' 6$% -"5. %/!-#'% ''#('!.&% 6$%"%%%.(%: !(.%$%6$#-"!('/! '%!'#/&.&%$!# -%&!$6$/1&'%!!'% %' (' #$%& ' 1' ,%- 8/ 9$%$1!% %%. (% (% '% ('" ! ?.%#: ! %.& % &% #%"

7$%&!''$!('!('

&&/!((%' 75%#%&.%$(%'#%"-7/5/ !!('5!.&"'$'!$:! !$5#-':!!=.'=$%!." 7$% % %" ! $: ! ! (' 5 ((-"!5$%#'&!$ #%/ $! # ! ! ' (' 5 6$%-"!#-$%&!#/5%($-'$ .'(#!'%-'#(!-( !(':!!#(5'%!/5!! !'-(!#/$!5!('!%&! '# " (' $% $ 6$/ $%!%#% !% 5 &%#-52 $%''#(' '$6$%&!'$:!!%$!(%. <6$/;

5''$%+%",%- .'(#$!%"/ :!% !'%"- .'(9$%$1!% $&!%#&''&! ('/!(%"%#'!$

@$#%5%%# *!(%5%% 6$((%$'.

%!%&!'%$'%!(%/!%' =$%.7$&#% /%!$

!('

*!5%&&%.-"!7$&# %!"!'(('-%!=$%% A$&/9$%$1!%/5!!5&'%A$&/ 9$%$1!%/ 5! . 7$&# %

(!(('/!7$&#%(-"! %'=$%#!$!('5!

255$%!(''! !'!(%%&$'%(('-%!=$%/ 5!! 5 $ ! %(B/ 5! !. ((%!%$&!$'

@!.!%'%$'%!(%-&& !%$&!!%%@!!#($&7$&#% ( -" ! ' % A$&/ 9$%$1!% % $-'%'-'- *! %' =$% -" (%(% ((%' . %%'"!$''&'(!'$! !('$'''!%"%6$%#/!%. - &% 6 "% (' ,%- 8/ 9$%$1!% ("#%%.(%$%$6$!'#5 5%&'"%7-"!5!$%&(%(%!%& !(' *!%'=$%!%%%('"8C ! *!!('"%$%

D*!C&('"'"5!'"!' 5%/ 5! ' 5 6$% % %

%'&-'6$%%'('

''5$(!+E-' 0$7-+%"+&! =$%&.=F0 2 ; 'E$#7)%$ +%"E/!#%5('-%! $!%"! #&!' @ !%&'"-!.5! 7$&#!0$7-+%"+&!=$%/ 5!%!'56$%(%%

; ('%''.'-'/5!''&!(' $!'/!$'#!''-. !"5''!.!(%%%&!%!''# ('

@ (% 2 7$&# ! %' =$% ! (''"-%.!!#'.!.#(' 5!!%#!%5&$'B('"8C

8C 0 . 5!! !" $%&!'" %7 ! '# ! (':!!%"5&.!('%" ((%$"%!%&5%:!(1&%%5 (%7&'#!(' @5$%!%-%.! FG!0'//5C#-"!

!%C#!#!$!('"5!%&% ''#('$6$ *!%'=$%!%%% 7$&#-"=.'=$%5!!('5''#'%'" ('(%$%$6$/5!!7$&#5%#-" '%A$&/9$%$1!%(('

+5.%/'%'%A$&/9$%$1!% -" #((%' ./ 5%& %(% ! '&' ( ((' # %7 ! '# ! ('/!(%$(&!'&'.'7$&#( -" ! %' =$% *!7$&# % ( -" '% ' % A$&/ 9$%$1!% % $-' *! ('%'"'% 6 "%(',%-8/ 9$%$1!%("#%%.(%$%$6$! -%&!'"-%.-"!%'=$%

*!$&!'%$'%!%(H+,! %%%>$''4!7$&#(-"!=$%'

#$ %

& ! ! %(('%6$%$-#((''&5!! %6$5!.%#%-"!+, 5!%&%''#('$%!$&%"! -!'-'''#('$!#%

+5.%/@''%! *!%'

=$% % %& ! .% ! ! ('+,/9$%$1!%'&!!$''&' (!%%.!'$!'#('!#% !'''#%'(' 6 "% $%$6$ *!&#('"--%$! !('1$-#(('&5! .%#%-"+, *!7$&#-''"

' 5! .%$ $ .$' 5! %&% ''#(' $%$6$!'$&(%/ !-'%!!%'!%(%# !%-'&#('"5!%%7$&#!=$%/ "/.$'$'-5!!$6$

*!%%/!7$&##%$!%( "#%

*!7$&#%(-"!%'=$%5'' %/-$((%(%((%'((%. %%%(%'555%&'"$(-"'% '%A$&/9$%$1!% *!5%&-&$ -"(!(%(('

$''" ! 7$&# % ( -" '%A$&/9$%$1!%%!7$&# %(-"!%'=$%%&!$('% %%

; *!(('''5%&'"5!

! # ((' ''5/ ! .' #''$ (('/ "/ !'' ( %&'"

4%7

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#