← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/686/2014allowed

Laxmi Devi And ORS. v. Haryana Urban Development Authority And ANR.

2019-07-30Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

  

     

  

 !"#$%%& '()&&(

**++ ,(- .&/(01(2$+*#-&(03'&)-+&(

*       (4-20  /($&3$(  '(#+53$(&**++

( #5&3$ (&(*

 7(+0 3   & ( & *+  '()&&+-(+(%&8-+(+ #(0  9-  4  /(0  1(2  $+*# -&(03  '&)-+  &((  (((      /1     : (3;-(-)&(

  *(  &  $(    &  *+3  4(-+-(+  +

 -$++4((;+3.&(3.&+.&(3( ;-(-)&(3    %&&  & %   &((  %  8-(  20 & ($+*#( 3;-(-)&(<&( -(03%(%- 

=%(4#*&+%(3%&+ %8-(<&*+%%&&8--# #*  %(3    -&  &  &  +    ((  -(  &!8-3&%$(3&#-% &<&&*+**(&&/4&>-(20%0 +44-+(?(**+3%&&%

 #*#-%&<&*(&*+0& @$(#    &  3  &  *(  %&  +  % 8-(  %( +    ++#   *+   (($  *(  -8-#-&&+8-(%((#(3 &&+%(%+4*+#-(4=8-( 0(+*+8-(20%#( &$(3&2#+(++#*+&$4( =8-(0((($*(<&*$(-(8- #20&*+3&+(&+#3 4$4(-&#2(4&-8- )4+(&&+((+*+#-(4 + )+1(2:3;-(-)&((($*(*( +(*+0&@$(#<&($4(

  4(#(09-(4&++-& *+&*+

443&**(+ 9%(#(4$(-*(+#(0293%3 &&*+%&$40+-+&-<& &-%#2+<&&>$+>-(&$0 9-(    (    (0  &  -<  &  &  *+  % **20&%-(#+4&-  #(3  -&    #  &  &  +    *+  % 8-(20&#2-(4&#3%(*-2+- $+*#&+(2+#*&2* &*+<&&#*%+(&3%&& &+2*&#3-&%&*+&(4& +#  0  *+  -(  -  8-3  -(&(#(  &(  %   4(#2%5 -(++#*+ +-8-(4&+-<&&(-&*($ !

A-#(%((# .&*(%(( 8-**(-+$

A#02#&(&*+'()&

  &"*(-(4&*0&-&+4+(*($ +-4&%%# !"#$%(2(-4&(( -&

(&(4&+(-+(&*(3&(+ >-($9-4#(    (&- &*+

.&%(44($20&9-4# (&0&+**+2(&>-(( B-43;-(-)&(3%&&%4+(B-43 ;-(-)&(3  %&  $  9-4#    (    



*&**+3&9-4#(*20& (+>-(#&-&*+%&

5%    %  -(    &  +4+  (*($    & *++&0&$+&*((4-+( **+2(&>-(3%&&%-& (*C3%&&$**(&(-4&-+

A&$&(+(-+(&*(244 &(-4&&((A&&#*-49-4#( *  20  &   +  (  B-43  ;-(-)&(  (   -2+(+2+2 .&  (+  >-(  20  *(*(  **(+    $   (((*(&+4+*&+-& &*+-+++&(0(8-(#3&($2

= 4(=8 0(*+1(2:3;-(-)&(*0# (($*(-(-8-&+#%%(4+0 (920&%&-(4*(*(&(4& *+  .&  (+  >-(  &  (((    *+0  :" '=    &  .&&*+0(-(

D.&"4*+0+0%&+0&+ %(3  %&  +  %  8-(    (  ( 

(+42+8-((+*+

++%-*&/E2+ '-92/(0/4& >-(4$>F'

5

 +E-#9,(- /(0E3&#(%*+2(& -&(0& #4&+   A &(4+02&$%& 9-4#&'-92/(0/4&>-(3 %&(&+%8-(*(( 

 *+(++$+2+3%&++4&*+ -&+3&-+#&++2$ &0%++&$&*(((4&(&++# *+

A*(5 9-4#3&(+>-(&*++0 2($&&#+$&$#*+%&&(#     &(  %  4-+C*+0 :" '=  .&0 &$

 -(4&+0(9&+#&*+3%&-4$40     &#  (  (4  0  **(-0    &(4     *)4(((94+#&*+%* A% -(&(2($&F G&*+33%"# 20&&("#&#&-& *+0%&(4(++#*+-8- .&(+ >-(&(((9-4#20>$+>-(%&&*+% ++    #+(+0  *+  *(  -(  -  8-3  %&& 9-4#%(#20+(B-43;-(-)&( **+

/%$(3+(+(B-43;-(-)&( 20  #**(+    $3  %(4  (*(    &  +4+ *    **+    #  (9  &  +#    & *+3&*(-*4&+4+$+9-4#* 20 & (+  >-(  .&9-4#   ( * 20 +( +  (  B-43  ;-(-)&(  (    -2+  .& *+(+0+(=8 0(*+1(2:3 ;-(-)&(*0#(($*(-(-8-& 2(4&+02($20&(+>-(

.&-4&+(-+(&(*H/1& (((?-++7&9-4#*20&>-(+    

      

 



 !

"

#$ %

 4  &  &

 (**+(8-(-2#**++4%&& (8-%&$(#(20&/1 %&(4(++#*+-(&-4(0& 2&+2+++#*+-&#(

/%$(3A++(& .&>-( 2+%  (  (4  &  $(    &       & *+/13;-(-)&(+4&&-++4+ *&(($&+-&+#*+&#(   &  +4+  &(    &  *+  (  +    ++#   (+*+=8 0(-(-8- .&4 #*+022(-&&*+)-2# **+  4      %&    $(#    (  20 /1 .&9-4#2++0+%&$(-- $-+%&(4(++#*+ -(- 8-&+-4*(3&2+(&& (+&(*(#&(2+4#*+0%& ((9-4#&>-(303$-+ -+2%&&-8- .&((3&9-4# #(-&(*0#(

.&9-4#*20&(+>-(%++(3 2-**(*(**(+**($(( (*(+%%%(4+0-*20+(+ (  B-43  ;-(-)&(  .&  %(4    24  -  20

 *&*(**+

-++0  &  9-4#    (  *  20 +(B-43;-(-)&((&9-4# (*20&(+>-((4&-*+( ((

.&**+++%(4+0%&

  &  #  **+    ++%3  &  $+ #++-  **+3    03  &++    *   (4+0



   7(9  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

 '# !+,

 "&#