High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3240/2018dismissed

Sant Ram v. Dolly Vijay And ORS

2019-03-15Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal8 pages

!"# $%&'( )*+),-.( (/0! -,,!'

!"!#$%

!()"$%

!"!& *% !

(/0! -,,!'1* +"'' , " &! &&' " - ! , .!! , ! ! -/ " + .! 0"!-/ . !

'! " " &'

"! ! 1 0 !

&! &!/#.! #!' #&! 2"! .#-!3 * *

3 . ) ". ! 4 ( .!$ 5"' ! 4' "!$ .''/!- " "&' " 0 ! &' " ! # !/ ! , * " %! % & " &! &!/

&. "!& !# '" , !# % , '','

." !!..!! "&' &.0!-/" !' + .! % 1.,# ! 3 &&'

&! !!-/.

. .' *&&'' # -#-/" '!4.,$4' "!

5" !&

2 "! '# " . &! &!/ "&!#"6!# ,"71/$ '&! &! ! * 8'! . #"- ,-. $ $4' "! 9&.!"&' #.! 2 ' . !2"! .#-!% ' :3

. ' &.!"-/6!# ,"71/$"' & ! ' #.! #!'$".$' 0"

#!' ' ! ' "!% .! ! " # !#* 8'! . # !" 6!# ,"71/. ! $ " &! &!/ ;. "! -/ " - ,'("! "< *" "!" 5" &&! ""!% .." ! ! !& ! "!

# "!% .! ! "/# 2 0"".&! &!/ .

!'',' ." !& &&'' * 0" "

!,"$' ! !

0""# 5"&&'' * '"0! # ! &!'# !/ -1 $ !'

".$ &&'$ &&! &!%'. $.- ,0" .. $ '#

#!' $.- ,-!!.

! " "& '

$'# $

1 ! #1 ! &!(%!!"1 #$,! "! "&&'' " "&! &!/ &. /! 3 "#$0 '! =-" > ##.

/ -'" "! ' '/ " &! &!/ &. 1 # ! !. .& "&! &!/ &.0"""!!

# / !!, "! "&&'' #'/?11#0 '# &! &!/ &.0''#!!, "&&'' "-' ,0

!# "! ! '!/ -'' " &! &!/ ! '# - % .! "&&'' "&&'' '

, 0"" #'/.'$& .'$.

!!.& 0" . / !

! ! # /'' "!#!'%!# "&' "% - 0"&!/! #' ". 5"!'+ .! !#.$!&! . &! 1.,# 5"&!0!&!# .% .&& !

"!!&% 9% ,"! .

!"&! '," #!' ! !$ " !' + .! '! "

- 0 ! ".&! &!/ "- "! $"/0!"' ' # !/ &!/ !@,'

-1 !-/"&&'' !&

.$.- ,-!!.

! " "& ' $ 0" . /. "!& "% &&! "" + .! 0" ' " 0! 0! , " &&'' ;. '/$".0! "&&'' 0! " %! % & " . &! &!/$ "! - ! ( &.-'/$"&&'&! !!-/"&&'' % .!0"

" !&&''+ .! + .

* 0 .'!,." ,

"+ .!'! ,"!& - 0 ! ".&! &!/ ' !

" !. < ,"& !"!.' #! ,

% (!,."&!&' "!& $6!# ,"

71/0"&! &! ! *8'! . # ' #.!

2 '0&.!" " # !

(!,." '!

#."' , % "- &! . &! %"6!# ,"

71/0"&! &! ! *8'! . #( .!"!!,." &/ #<!.!

*8'! . # "!" !, '

!&! % ! 0"'0(!,.0"%"# "" ' -'""6!# ,"71/0"&! &! !

*8'! . #$"/

!% /! ," "!

! #'3

( $!,." "!% . ! ! &! . - ! " + .! &/ 1#- 8< $ * 8'! . #A !2! ! - 0 ! "<

* ""!0""' ' -'&' "!& " ' -'

, 6!# ,"71/ "!.-# #-/ .

" "!& '. !# !/ 2 ,! %!/

& &' . , . !& &/#

!;.+ .! & -1 0!-/"&&'' "" . "&! !# # -' "!'+ .! !#. B "!,!-.0!

,'/ 0!". % .!

(!,."" &' "!& ""&&'' ' .' $"! !$. !# !/ # -' ."1.,# !& -/"+ .!!'-' - " !'

+ .

'!&! ,!&

".&& !" ,! !-/"+ .!0"".-# "" + .! &&'

!&&!"% ! !

! .!! ,#!'/-.

! %0& -' (

.!"!!,."' .# ' "##!2 8< 5"' !& ' #.! 2 '$0 <. % .! *8'! . # "#' ! ! "! 6!# ," 71/ 5"&&'' " '# !"&!," ".' 9" !&' "% ,- # ! . ' -/ 0/ %! & ( !,. 0"

%"# " &! .

." ! &

& ! '' # # !. 0 ! ' ! %!

& ! # .

." ! .& -/2 ,! .! !#/

'0 A"!,! "". # -' &! !#$ !,. " . B 0 0! , " -/"!'+ .!-.- !" !&&''+ .!$"!

"'' , , "!'+ .! .B ."$ ,

"!'+ .! .B "% '/ ("%"! .

!"&!$&!."&&!- 2 ! ! &

"%'#"! 0 !"& ' #.! #!' "- ' !& 2 '' <. % .! *8'! . #$ -&! &! !"&

6!# ,"71/ !.' '8< #2% " #2 ! ! * 8'! . # &/# ' ! -/&.!"!6!# ,"71/0" ", "' &.!"!0"!''!!% ! ,"5"' ;.

" - "'' ,-/<. C"! !$"!& 0!

!;.! &! %"'-/<# , "!0 . ! &' "&!$- # .

&.&

"""! "'' ,;. / .&! &!/ !" #- ,&! 2"! .#-!3 * * ( "1#- $8< $

# 0 !! !8'! . #A !2 &' * 8'! . #8% "!% .." !"% ## !! !

! ! ," !! # " !

0" "!01#-

.# '-. % '$ ! 1#-

-,% &!#/%D%'8< $ .# '(

"%0 "#!$( #/'

-' & ""!& "% ' &! %"&!% .'/6!# ,"71/0 0 ! ".' ""$"/"%- # 0 !- ,. ! ! 6!# ,"71/ 5"-! ,"+ .! ;. # .

"&! !#B .-$"!& '#"&&'' -

'',' ." !& ".' $"! !$&&! &! !#/ ! %!& .' 0 .. !&

0"' 2 , '! ;. "! 0 !"& 9 0%!$ " &'

.,"# !/ !. ! " " %!% & "&.&! &!/5"&&'' ! & -1 0"!,!

. "&!

!# "!'+ .! !#.B "& "#!5" !' + .! 0! . B , " *&&'' 0"' ' ,0".B 1 '/(0"'""&'

"% 2 ! "+ .! !!/''E "!!,"B %

"- ' " 0. "&'

# -' "/ "% . '". + .

$ !& & ;.!/$"

!'/ " ",! .

&&'!- !" !&&'' + .!$"! "'' , , "!'+ .! .B !, ,"! .,""1.,# &-/"+ .! &&'$""

.!"! "% .! , .! "! ,$ "'' ,"-

', , "!'+ .! .B ( &' "!,.# 0!% - !" !&&''+ .!

";.

" . -. " # 0! %! -/"&&''+ .!( ",% ! $ '/- "'" , "!'+ .! .B "% '/ -0 "&!5"!

-&."% !!

. , -/+ .!"''" '" '.

'"'' , &&! &! &! ,5"- , $ & "'' ," ;. # ". "&! !#$- !"+ .! B "!& "- ! ( %0 0""- ."! - !$

#!$"&&' ' ! ,'/#

(/0! -,,!'

+23(

" )#-! A""!&2 ,*!

F*B A""!!& !-'

F*B