← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2356/2024dismissed

State Of Haryana And Others v. Sher Singh

2024-09-26Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda11 pages

    





  

 



!"# $% &#'()($*+ , -, 

."!"# $% !/0!*!

!*& $"1#/)

2,33#44!*") 5#/)6) .1#/ .(*71

,,,#)3$*&#*"

 +  8 , .

9 .  8 , .

9   

    



 



9 . 

:

,



 

            





  

!  "



         

 

           !  



 

   

 $" %





  & '(( )



 * + + ,  

- 

.

)   

 "

& ((' " 

/ /  0     



  "  '

1 0  

 

  

    

"



 "

2  

/"    

 % 

 "

   "  

      "  0   

     

!" # $ %& '(  ) 3 "



 

 





4

   "  0 





 

% " %



" 

 "  0  " 

   $ 

) # 

 

       

          

  /



    )



  %



+   1

'  % 

  /

   

 

   

   6

7   

&

')   



"   

        

 

        ,  



 

  )   

%%

8

   

"   "  

   

* "  

%  

#  

 

   

$  # 9  :" 



 

 

  "

:         

 

      5 " " /

 "



"  

<

:    

 

 "    

    



 

       

     "  

  

:

6

7  

   "   8 

 



    

  7 "  

 

 

8  = $  # 9  : %

   " 

      

!=

     %   )% 

   "  

)                #  

  



  

 

         "

  

   +

  

  =  

% 

 

!   

   



  

2 $

)    

    

 

   $  # 9  :" "



 1 0 

  

    4 0  



 

"

 

:

"



         5       

  %  +



<

:



 

 



   

    "  8 

 !



"  



: 

      #  

    



   "   8 





    

   " 

    ' =  

 



- 

.

)   '((  "

< (('

" 

"    0  <

 "  '

1) 0  



 <

8

)  0 

  

 

"



  2

 

/"      



<

  "  0   

 

   

37+

+

4<" # 

  



  

    

    /"   0  <

 

)  

"      0    " 

   <   

)  # 

 

  

   /

 

 <    )

 

     %             "   %  

(   

2'  =          %      

)    



   %  * + +,  )  " 

)    2 "   % " 

 "

2' 

    

 %

    2     





"   %"   

   "  8     

  "

"      

>



+=?  " "/ "     2 "  > 



  "     =  + 

,, -#  

: 

 

 

 

    %  .   /) - 9  @ A  :  ' 4

" ) "

 

  





A     



"  " 

" 

$ 

!     

" 0# 



 "

 

 

 

 

     

     

  



         



  

 

  

 





  

 



 

 

 

 

 !

  

 

     "



    





  

  #

   

 

$  

 

!"     

 

-   

 .   /) - , -# " "

.

%

,    

4 

%

 

    ;+ 0"



 



 

 

 



  

%            

  

  

    



  !







      



  



       

   

%    

 #     

&      

 

  !

 



  

 

   "

    





   



      "

          

       '( 





  



  



 

$  A    

.

%

, 

  0#     9  :              - /1 2  

 .   /) - ,, -# )" "  



' 

 )

  

"   " 3 

4 -#

 .   /) -  

!

 

 

   

   

 

 

"

   +% 





$ 

) 



 

      % "   %  "   

% 

  "

)





 



  



 

      



      

  

  #   

   

    

 

   )*  +,+-  +.//   0

 1   

 2 "



3    

0     +..4+./4 





 

          

  



  

 

 "

    

 

    )   

 2 3  7

 

    

0  

  +./, 9,: 1; -// <   

= 





> = 6        

    

       

 

 

  

 



 

/+      

   







 )   

 

 ?    

 

  3786 

   

    





#   !

   



   

   



  

     

 $ "

 

   

   

  

  



   < 





 "



 

 "

   <     @$

 

 

 

 

       

 )*  +,-(+  +./4 01& 8  2 3  2

*  1

0    /=./+./B 



    

 

    

  ; 1  6

   

    "







  

 

C  

 2 7 8    

 +..- 9(:  /   

 

  

5         +/  



   

   

< 

 



 

 



  

 

 





 

 /.     /..(+..-  







 7   9 : ;

  

  

 10  9 :  )*  //+.=  +./4

  0   * 2 3  2

*  1

   

0   /=.4+./'   1*6  4'.  +./'



   +4.B+./'

   0C     

 2 

3 0 +./4 / " -.( !

       #     !

 



 





 

 



       

  +.// 





    

   "

 



 



   

 

   



  6  /( 

  

   

   6  /( 



% 

  

 



 

 

     

     #  "

  

  6  /( 

    



 

 &

 



     #    

 D5          

    4#* 56 & 6        

     

    



   96

& *%/: 

 .4.,+./4  

  !

 

 

   

 



    



  

    "



%  

  #

   

 

 

   <



        

  



  

     "

#   



 

 +=.'+.//$   * 0# " / 

 

-  +   

 .   /) - 4 -# " "

.

%

, 

 4



 "

 % 6   

 

   

 





6 &    

#   

E

!

 



  

6 &   7 8 0      

///++..- "

  





"

       %



   







"

  

   #   3 

"

  



 

 "







 



 !

 





 

    



 

    



  6  

  

 

       

  % 

  

 

 ,..-+./( "

  

 

   

 //.=+./( 



  

   



  

 /.        /..(+..-



  7 8 0   ;



    



 

 

     

 

        

 "

    

  

3   

&     

        

    

   #   ;





     

 



   

    

 +.     %

   



    E %8    ./.(+./4   

 +.       

   

 !

    



     

 

<

        %   





!  9 :  

 !

 

  / /)   8  *

9'

 

   





6 &  

# 





3  6  

E



 

    

    /==, "

6 & 



     

 

+(        



   

%

    



 # 





 "

  7 8  9 : 



 

     



   

  

 



 



&  

 !





   

  





      







 

  

 

  

 /.     

 

 



 ;





 

 

    



 

  

8

6  3  



     #   "

 

   <  

     

 

  !

      

   



 





     

 

  6  /( 

  

 !

 

     

 -   

   

 7  





# 

     



 

  "



 &    (4    

  

  1   /./  

  

 1& 8  6  

   





   

 



 



   

      



  



  

 



  "



     +4       

     

  

  



  5D  

   

  

 



 

 

 

 

  % 

 

   !

 

     &   

 6  ++- 

  

 !

    

  



   

<      

  

 

 

    

  



 





 %!2 

   

 

  

 

   

 

  

5D



    

 

 "





   

 

 

 



  

     $ 2 !

 0# 9  : * 0#  :"  "

 

  

 8

 



- +3 

8

:;#  /) - :,# !" = , .%

A"

A  "     

  

  

  

  "



 +



3  

A  

 "

;+ 94: !





  



/  



  

   ,/   



 





   

 

 

 









 



  #

    

/  



   

  

/    

 

        

   

/          

       <  

      "  

  

 

 

&  %!2 

    

      

     



&

   

  





$

 ' 1 =   %) 



/    





  )   4    

     

   

   

       



 

%

 % 



    

7 



%    7    ) 



 

 $  



" 

 "

  

:B  )



* + +,   '((  "

<

" 

 (('"     0  <  "  '

1 0  

         

)        

 "



 "

2  

/"    "

  %

 "

        

    <    "



     "  0       "

 

 

 



" 

 

  "   ) "  0   

   

       

 

 "      

8

)   

  

"



 





 ' =    

)

" 

      )



 

 

 

 6

7  

  %  



  

      6

7  

 

 ( =   % 

)"

  

 

.



A



$  

 

    

:      



9 .   

9 

  , -, 

  6  )

  

D  G D )

   D