← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3319/2018dismissed

Bed Ram v. Vijay Pal

2019-05-01Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal7 pages

 

              

       

 

         



                     !"#$%&'($$) (''#      !"# $#%%

# $) (''#*% &$ % #%%#  '" "$#

( #(#' )* (+ #  " #  , -

 %#  ./ $  ''#  0''" 1* ( 2#' #.# 3$./#%%# #(#')* (+#  " #  , 4

4 %#  ./ $  ''#  '!'

 1* ( ' 0'!'' 2#' #.#  $'#      # $ '#  * 3# #

3  )* (+ #  "%# ./$'# *3#+ '

' # $% 5%

3##

3 %'"'%#  ' %"'

'"% #(+

# 

67  &$ % 5%

  *'  %' ./ 3#/  %"'

'" % +#"   #(+ # 

  %#/+  .# #" #  "' #'  2*$ %#/ 3# +#   #''( $   #5#%%

+# '#'($*'%%/7"%$%

  % $ "#  *% ./ $ %  $ #%%

#   ' #(+3'$$%

#  # +#*'(8##  # "' #' 

59

&$#%%

#"'! #

*+   :4

59 # # +/ #  7"*  $ #(+ #  "'%'%" 3'&$ #   3#

'7 # 4

;3##   $#'

$#%%

($ %%/ %#''  $ #  ('#'   #    3*  . #*+#'"#

/ 7    ; ' *$ #!  $# $ %  3# # 3#/ # / #  3'

'(  % + $' %#   $ #(+   4

$+#' %'$

'" *.('# #

#.$(#$ # (3'$.# #""' #'# ($'# #"+#8  (# '"3#'*  -

#8'($#%%

#($#    7"* .*#!#'

 &$ #%%

#5   #   $ 3' #+ #''( % '+'#/ .)"' '# '#$# $ %

$# "#* #"' #  "*# ' $*'# $$##%%#"$ $* 3'$"

#$# <$# ' 7"*' #(+"'% # +/# $' '#.'

'/7"*$#   ;$#.*.+' $# $% $#  $*'' #(*3'$'+# =# #! + 3$+$   #$# #8 ' # -4

59' .#'# #$'+ #' ##"''+# =# #!($''(#*  + .

#8 %#% #  #+% %#% # "*'/  &$ #3'(   #$# # # / %#'  #*+   4

59  '+#  =# #! .* *% #*#"   '+#  =# #! $ '   +#  $ '(  . #8 %#% #  #+% %#% + '+#  =# #!  ; ' *$ #

(  $# %

.'( #'! '+# =# #!+'* $#' .

#8%#%#  $#  $%*'

$+#'# #!+ $% #'$#! . ' 3'$#%#/  '+'# $*'

 &$ '#  * #+  '* % *"  ' %## 4   $ )* (+<#!'($# "* $%#''$ '($ +#'#  " $'# *#""% "# $% $#$#%%

7"* #(+



# #*+ :4

593# %#' $'+./$%

5% <3!$'# *(#  % #   $ %  $# $ # 3#/ +#'  # / #  3'

'(  % + $' %#   $ #(+ #  # # ">*" $ % 5%

 3# $  '    *    :4

59 3'$ ' # $ #   :? % #*+ + $ #   %#'(  "' #''

# '@#' $#.'" $'. $#%%# %  ./$ % 5%

3##

3 ./$ '%%

#*#  ' '(  $ '#  *  $ >*'   # ' #  3'

'(   $ %

5% % +$'%# $#(+3#' #  $#' >*'3##3 ' #!* $% 5%

#  !*#

/ $ %

 3# #

3  %'"'%#   '    %"'

'" %  * $#%%

#3* #(*$##%$"# *% ./ $ % 5%

 #(+  

 3# 7"*  

# #   3#.7"*  4

;'#(*  $# #%'  +$# /#3  4

'

 -

 %3#8./$% 5%

8'(%"'

'"% +#"  $ #(+ # $ %*% / '*  '"  -

  ; '

*$#(* $#!# '*#" '" -

$'# *' 3#   + $#  +$ $#   4

 +#'( $./ $# *' %"'

'"% +#" 3#  3 /# #  +

- $# '! +$ + $ # '7   7"*'   #     ; ' !$+ /#(* $#$'# *$# '($ /#8'" " *" $% 5%

3$'

(#'($'% #3'$(# # ' #  3'

'(  % + $' %#   $ #(+ #  7"''( ' '"' ' )"'( "

#'+   $ % 5%

 %"'

'" % $#(+ .*$%%

#*( /  ./!'( ' '( $'# *$'!'# #%" $+# * 3* %'*$#'%## $)* (+ *'#%%# ''+' $#$% ($'%"+#8 ./67"*'! #('# 4

"#/$ #"" #$#

' #!' 3'$ (#   # #" ' #  ./ #/ #   # 67"*'! #('#;' *$#(* $#$%   # *""

# +*"$ "(# "!'"'(!' "3'$(# $'*"%#/ .# #" #  "' #' #  '"* 7%   ('#' "  $ '%* #  #' 4

&$ #*.+''+# ./"* ' $#'"%'" $ # '>*'$# '"# #$#.#!  ./$% 5%

'%##, $% #'$'#*'3#   )* 3+$. 7%'/ '+'#'"8 3  4

$ ##

( '7     ;$#!$# "* $#%%

#%* $%#%9.8 # "%'  "*++# #!#'

#.

 *'($"* $#'(

 # !'($*.+''+# ./"* $ #%%

#''%'+'#$*$#$#%%

#'$

 ##%%# "$#

($)* (+#  "%# ./$'# *    " .)"'  ##'

' '(   $ '#  * ' %"  # 

# %#/+ ##+*

:4

59./% $#%%

#3# #+/*  #  "' #'   

59 #  # *"$ ' '(   $ '# *$# #' #%"##'  '# '/.3$%#' &$  / '* $# *!'!   "' #' .  $ %%

#*#3

#'" #%%# '3'$(# % A # '# 3'

'(% +$'%# $#(+'%#/+  .# #" #  "' #' #  +'( 7%   ('#' " '"$#%%

#$#  ' 7"*' $%'.

"* #'#% #$#$3## /# 3'

'(($#    7"*   $ '%* #  # .* #*   97"*' ' 3'$ $ % 5%

 *#    $ )* (+ %#  ./ $ * #!  +#  *.$#*.>*$'%* #  #   ' 4

 $ ' % #8 ./ $ % 5%

 3# '*#"   '" #  -

 #  $#  $ *' 3#    4

  &$ % 5%

 #%%#  ' $ 3' .7 #    '!' "$' * /3#

' #!'67B 5#  "*+ 67   :   % #' .* "# *  # '(   " 7#+'#'   $ % 5%

3* +#8'!' $#$'"$#

($' '+/3'$(# $'%"'$

'" (''(*$'/  4

 # ( 3'$  -4

59 ' "#$  &$ '  ! # *(('  $ % 5%

 $# '$ $ 3#  # /  3'

'(% +$'%# $#(+ ;'#  %%''' #3$#'

'+/ #3' '"$#

( #+#'# #%"'#+*# +''$%#  "'( %#/  &$' #%# ' #*+ (# '(' '"#" 3$

:

!'3 '$ '($ " *" $#%%

#3$ ' 7"*' #(+ $*($ # +'  $' '(#* ./ #''( # % #   .

#8 '(#*3$'"$$  *.#'# *"$  $# . #'  ./ $ #%%

# >*#  #/ ' '*#" '" -

#  '( *''0"+.

#  $'%* #  #   7%'  4

&$ "# . '#  $#  '#'

/ ' "#"  #    '++!#.

%%/'+'" "#"* '  ./$%#' ;$"##$#  ' '( $'# *3'$%"#(+ # $#!##'  '# '/;"

#* $#(+'3#+'  $# # ('#'   ' 4

.*'"#$ #  #( . 3#%#'' *%$'%* #  #$%'  #(+3* . + .7  '+'

#"'# 3#+# ' "

#*4 # '(3'$' + %*"$#  '#+/' "#$!   ($#   7"* *%$'%* #  # .**.)"$" ''$#' $.#' %#''("

#  &$'$'(" *(('! $ #"$#$#%%

#($

# %#'' '$*%$'%* #  #' 4

!'

'( $*''0"+.

"$%#'$# #( $#$ '%* #  #   3* (7  #*+#'"#

' "# $ #  3#  ( %#''  $ #%%

# "# '$ . #

3   #8 # !##(   $' 3 3(   "  $# $ % 5%

3## /# 3'

'(% +$'%# $ #(+#$''* $*'3/## #.* '!+$#  7%'/ '%* #  #' 4

&$'# *  #8' "' #'$'!'# #%" $+#$*+' '" ' "' '(

, $>*' # '# 3'

'(#(#'$% 5%

 &$#.'( '"'7"' ./$'# *' #!* #%%

3# %# / * #  $# '($ / .  #'  ./ $ %%

# *./(#'(%"'

'"% &$+

#" $# $ %%

# * $# +'  $# $ %  ( $' %" +#8  ./ 67"*'! #('# ' % #"   #/ '  # "'"*+#"*%$ % # $#%%

#$#$)* (+%# ./ $%%

#**

 +%!'/#'#>*' #3$#   +'#'# '"$"'(%#/ ;!'3 3$#$#. '"* $'#.! ' '( +'$#%%# # '#"" '( / '+' ' '+' # "         C0 * #'A        B$$%#8'(5#   /5 B$$%#.

 /5