High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/382/2017dismissed

Avtar Singh v. Som Nath & ORS

2018-10-12Mr. Justice Satpal10 pages

! "# $$%% &' (# # $ !" #$ $$$ )

*#)'

"# !

#$$%% +++ $$$ % "&' "" ,#$ $$% -'

/)#$0 ##! %% )0 #$$% $$ ( #

# " #$$% ( .

/#$$% 1$$0#

# %# # .

2 '

#$$% '

(###$#$0 # !% %3##(* #' $0## " #$$% $$ 4$ " !3 # !( # $$% "'( $$% %%3 5 " # $$% $$ ( .

/ 0 % )#$0 #

# 6'07 '

--'8$

$$%% 9 ""! ' " " #( 0 # % % 6!% :'" :'

! (%#!-'"( /

.3%% #% %:'" ;#"## !-'"(

=!3##' % 0#$ >$%

3 #$$% % 0#$$%% #

( ? 0 -' ### ' !0 %7# $ $% ('

% "3# =

@> # /A$

'(3 /

% "3# '' 3 % 0 # $%

9 $ * 3$% ##$%

3$$# 0# 9$$%% % )%

9$ " $'##("( %%

33 '$ #$'# 3$% (' ". 7 % (% '!%%"4% ,#%?%#' #?#" "# " '%%0% #$% 3##$ $$%% #3 $ #(' ".=7 %'

%% (' " < 7 %(%3### %( #!$'# (" #' #! " '%%$$0"# %%#% ,%% " $'#

(# $$%% 3

<7 % (%# .

@> $

%7#3$

#$$%% ( 0

#$ 3 #'( %7#3$

# $$%%

/ #$ 3 %7#3 #' $ ( 0

#$$%% ; % 8'

#%3"

/,#(3(''%%08

/*3%(

# #0'!%%" 3#'% '

(% # 3# ' #( $'# .= 7 % % 3#% $'$ "#!$'##% (" 3## $$%% # $'##% (" % 3 # "# "( %%#% #(%0 "( $'##%

(" ! #$$%% 3%%" #3#% 3##3

(# %,# % #3 # $%

3 ' # ( 3 "'%'% '%%0'%! %% 53! #( 8'

#"( # 3#(% "! ' '( $3##3#%%0 '%! %($%%0,# $%

$%07# #3#$$0"#

$% (' ".=7 %* B'03(

" "#3 #$ # ". 7 % (% #0(7 3##% 3' #%%0 3 '%! %3## ##3 #( $-#% #$$0 %,#$%

% "

##0# ' 0# 3# '#($0 %7# ( 0

# 3#%%" #!(#(7 "'

#$%

1( 03#

<>.( #% "3# 53! #$%

!%"%

/ 3# #0 3 7 0 # (

3 " " # % 8' # !' (#$ %7# ( 0$'' "(

< %%

#%"% $%0 /

/ 3

"##3 B' " "# %8'# ## '#( #"( %%3#"% (' ".=7 % 3### 3 #3 (' ". 7 % (% 3##3 >'%! % ' ##%%0,#$%

!$$ #'

" ?%#',#$%

# %#(# ;*3'% %"" #( # "#(,# #3! B' # ( "'

# ( 0 ' '

#( 5 ##'3 % $$%% #'&'$%( 0 - 37 #3 ( !( (3 !*3#3#$%

3##$$## $'##% ,# "%%% (' "

<7 % (%#$%

@>$ *(# ( 03!$$%% %(##30 3%% "$ (#$ # ' #$%

#(%! #!# '

!"#% 8' %% !( " " 0 7 ($ 3 *3#'$# '0(7 0 B' " " #3 #$ # $$!! 2"%

/3'#$%

" "8' #%

'#0%% ( 3(% #'3$0 $% 3 % ;%%3 "'3 ( 0#% %6' #

#$% "

> C## $%

% !0

@>D)) C##' ( % #$ (D) C##$%

#! %' '

%#$ 'D) !C##$%

#! (#'3#%

# D) ! % E! 3 % 0 # # $ '

# $!%( 2 %6' %'## $$%% 3 #3 $ .=7 % #(

8' #"( %% # ## "#

"( %%B'#$$03##$%

# #'

9$ 3,#$%

3#% %!0 %7#% "3# # =A$

'( (# % " #'%%% $$% % 0# $$%% 3%( 0#% :'" ;#"##

!-'"(

=""!# ( $ $$%#

% 2 '

% # $$%% 9 !#( %0 "'# ##% ' %3#! "#'

9$ !0 %7#% "3# =A*'

(#$"( %%

$ %%0( ##$ $$%% #3 .= 7 % % $$%% # ( # #3!

"( $'##.=7 % (#"

= ,# % # "( #

# # $$%% 9 3'% '

#!#%8' (#" % 3 !' #$ 9$%

* #' 7 0 # $ 9 $%

# # # ($ #$ #$$%%

%! #$ 9$%

#!#(%! 7 ##.=7 % 3'

B' %0% 0# $$%% %%0#3##$$%% 3 #3 #'$$0C#% "#8(

)C 4# 2% )C ?%- "# )C(# '

(# %% #(#!(##0(7 3##$ $$%% 9 #3 $ .=7 % #8'

#"( %%

,# # 8$%

3#0#0 !7 0 ((%0# * %0 #$ $$%% '%"%

/#$%0 /

/3'

( 0#$ 9$%

7 "'$# !'$%( #$% ! '

(## ' !0 ($% 3 ( % # $ 9 $%

#'%#!'"##(0'

#$ %

/= #91#1 ( # $ %%0 * #' $0 # # $$% %%3 ($'"

-'"( /

.$ 0#% % 6!%:'" ! (%#3%%-'"(

=$ 0#% :'" ;#"## ' %

9$ ( *#!#% '

% #$$%% #!"

#'"# # $#$0 # 3## 3 '

# 0 % '

% 6'0 *#!$'"( %%

,# $'#"(

E8) 3 3

#$ $3$% (' ". 7 %

(% # .=7 %# .

@>$ '(

%7#3! 0#$$%% ( 0

#'( %7#

/$'%

8' #%3

/* #.= 7 % 3$'#'

B' %0 0#$$%% ;'%#! $% E8 $ 7 % (% !%%"4%' 7#</@.

,#%

E8% = =

$ . 7 % (% 3### %(#!" %#$%

,#$%

#!$%#(#% %'

#(3#3 #(% /

/ $< 7 % (% 8# E8<' 7# @<E8.

% =

/ $

7 %(%' 7#=@ !%%"4%?#(0 #.= 7 % ( "(

7# @/

7# !%%"4%3$'# 0#$$%% ! "# (" ('#'

B' "(

)'% #"(

E8) !%# #% $.=7 % 3# % 1.=7 %4# @/ ' %% (' " <

7 % (% # $'# 0 # $0 $$%% ! "# (" 1 ,# %#

# %0 "( %%3### 0# 9! "# $ .=7 % 3#" ## % #"( !' #$%

,# #"'( ## 3 #$ $'# "#% B' ##"#8'#% !' 0#$ !%#$$%% ,# % ( E8) (%0 #% # $'# 0#$$%% '

B' %0,#$$%% 3%%0 #3 #$$0

2 '

% #$$%% !#( %0"'## $%

#(%! $% # % (' " .= 7 % 3 '

B' %0 % % (' /

#8$0 %( #0 8

8' " #%,# # '" ##$%

%7#$% # "

#3 #% B' *%! #"##$%7 0# $%

3##$$%% 3 #3 #%

B' #( 8' "( %%

E8 ) 3##$-#(% #3 # #",# $% '%0 '

0 # ! % # "( %%

## $%

3(3 0"( %%3##(0#!

/ 0#$$%% 3##" (' ".=7 % ##%3'% 8' 0# " #$%

1 !',#$%%%0$$

#'"# '

0#! *'

/E8= 0#$$%% %% "'$

#$%

8'#% # '( # %%0%! ,0# 0 "# 3# # $$%% %%0# %# '%

$'#6' %'## ( 0(%0!

0#$$%% #"'

##$%

3 ( " 3 8' "#% B' ,# # $!0

(0 # "'

0#% %6'3%%% ;$$%%';'#( # ( #"'( 0% '

% #$$%% ## $ ' !0($%3 ( % #$%

9$ #'%#!'"#(0!% %'

#,#

# ## 7 0#$$%% % " #"'( * %3##$$%% %(# ' %"%

/#$%

(

3 8' # % # # 3%% "

$!E! # ' #%"%

#$$%% ( 3 #3 #$$0 (' ".=7 % 7# @/ !%%"4%,#$%

#! #' $! ##$$%% !'(

%7# ( 0 # "( %%

E8) ,# #!%%#%

#%! (2"%

= E8=3'%0 $%

% 0 "## #!% %!#$$0(%%0 # ## 9$$%% # '

B' %0%#% B' #! "$'##%

0% #$%

9$ ?# # % ' %3 #! '

" " # $$%% 3#%( $$ $$ ! 3##3 * (0 $ B' %3('#%'

%B'

%3 !%! #$$% #"'( 3 2 '

% #$$%% '

%$ ' %%"%0

(0 ($'"

-'"( /

$ 0#% %6!%:'" ! (%# 3%%-'"(

=$ 0#% :'" ;#"## 3##%% 0 0#6' "%0 #$$%(3# $()*(++

,-./ C##$7 "@

F@ C##$ %