← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3348/2018dismissed

Dhbvnl & Others v. Pawan Goyal

2018-06-01Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill7 pages



       

  

  !"#$%&!'(%)* *! +,,%% &!- !

./0"%

,*     

  .! !

./1-2!)(3*4!,,%%

55555 

   

!% 



6!*%"*"%(,,% 74/!2*,,%2 %%/* 6*%"*"%(,,%** 6,,%**,*

!!"



 6,,%%8**  !"#$%&!'(% )*  #&')  %(  /  !  4  %*    ,,%  %%(( $-*(2  ** 

  ,*  9"  %!* **%  !  :-*(3 /!  -,%*(  $-*(2    %!*  %/!  ;-!  /!9"    -  !



*%!%*9"!,*,%*2*-*!"!( - 3<3 8%%(%3-%%*4*3*9*!*

6-,9",%!4*9%% 2-(-

!2- 3 =3<8%-*(-*!"!( -   3<3 8 >,?-!2*!2'(23/ !2**2-   3<3 8/-2 ,!4-9%!"!

@ 6**!!,%"  *,%**4"!"- 2,!-*-*!"!(*92,*,! !-%  6** -!!!*    ,%* ,!4-%" ,,!*    !  ;-2!  ,-  *!%  A!-23 /!3/!2,%/*2*

6%!* %/!;-!-,,,!%4*%*9",!*!*- *%**2*-*!"!(-   3<3 8 %%(%3-%%*4* >,,,%4(9%*9"**3 2/*2*9"%!*%/!,,%%;-!/%%3/ 9%%(*9"/"%(,!,,% 6  %!*  -%  !    ,,%%3  /%  %(   2,-(*$-*(23-92*%!*%/!;-!%%!!! %*(2--(9!4!*9"/"-*!"!(/ 9(!4!*9"*,!!9*,!*%2/"! ,!!9*-*!!-% 7-!!9-92*-/ 9!!*9"%2*2/429% 2,%%*9!!;-!**2*



74!*%!*-%!,,%%*4% ,!-*2-(*$-*(2 6-(37***!/!24 2,*B,%!!(!-*!(!4!" -*!"!(9-!2!(-2,-!9!%/!;-!3 !,!3/,-!-4!-%(- ,%,!(,!*

@ !4!"/-(9 2* 74/,!4--2,,!3:-!C(!* !,!*      2!  /  !-(        B    ==D  * ?-%"*$-2 3 3 8/2*- ,%  /4!3*-*4!2 ,!- '(23*9*$-2/((4,% 2,29!

!2,!*  !,!*:-%"

@ 29!

@*2-   3<3 8/(*$-* - -9?-%"3/-*,!"3/,*- <

< ,%%**2-!*2 7/ !!2-   3<3 8/-(9!4!* -*!"!(9%%** 

6-(37*E'(2F-%*4!4!*B 2-*$-*--2!39-2-%*49 *%"!,,!,!*9-*-2!* /,!!9*,!*2 7!(!*3!,!4 */%%!%4*99!2*3 /!*%%/



G #$%&'( ")*+,')+-*-.$+-)/0$+'0    "1#'.+2-.-+3 %44#3)0'54'2+$-/-/6+) '6%#$+-)/) 7  "

( "7%9%*-!(!4/!!/! !-%-*9!4-2!9-*! !(*3   =  *"    %%  9  !4* -,   -2!9%2*2  /4!3 **%*2*9(2*-9"!%H-*  !, "-2!  ! !*%% "2%2!9!(4( -2!

!!,!,%"!2-2!3 %%%!4/2-!(*! ( -      -92*  9"    -2!  A!   2-/!(9%3!*!(!,%" -2!3%%%!4!2-/- %4"-!!(!2-2!9"-(,! 9%%*-% *"%%9(4 -2!,"9%% 7-2!%,"

9%%9"*-*3%%9%9%,"3**3 -!!(!,!**%"

I 6%!-%!9!(' @8< /-%*%9!%4 .! ' *2!*%%/ G7!(-%!-!C%!"#!*-* .!-*-2!F-*,%" 2,*/4!"*!,",*-9" -*.!"

 7-*!*/4!"

*!,",*-9"-*.!"3 !!?-!* !,!9-,! ,%"2,*/-"! (9"

 !*  #!2,(,%" !?-!*9(4-2!B,% , I

=

=

C%!"3

*%(/!4!" !!!!*%%/ G'/*("(*"!%/ !29(!3-2*-!2" -2!3-*!-%%9!4!9%! ,!*/"!!2*/--2 92!*--%--29/ --%"!4!9%!!!!(! %!"-,,%**%%%- -,,%"%!"

I '-(9!(!4!"-9% 2-     3<3 8  ,%%" 4  /  !-%!  ' @8< -,! ,!4*!-2-4%,!,%-!% $- 4!"2*4%!9-,%* 6-(3%!*-%!,,%%-92*     /     "! 

<    -*  ,!"*  ,*  -   *!,"**!4!"--*!"!(/-( 92*-(-

3!!34%*%2! !4!"/"!%%2//,!!9*,!* %239-72-9%(!/!*2- 2-?-*!**--2! 2,29!

*9%%?- (!4!"/ -* 

3/9"*,!*/"! 7%9-92*,%-%*49 B**9!2 )23 ;-2!A!-2/2,B*%2 ,!-% !*!** @

,*9";-2!A!-2!*%%/



G74/94*-*!!((!3 A!-2      $-!*    !"    2,%  !  /   $-!**-2!9"*2* '*% "2,9!A!-29*%"%%9B%-** !,-!,%2,!4**-*!     )2 3  < 3      2,%  ,,!   ,,!,!-!%/3*4*3/,!!9*,!*

A%9(*!!*!2!*-2,% I 7;-!/!4%-%*/B2 /!9B%-2,,!-(!4% ,!*(9B**!2 )23 < 3 /!!"9!4!(!*(B%-492*9" ;-!  /!  ,%  /  ,!-(  !%!   -2!  A!-2    -!"-!"-*-*!;-2!.!3 << * ,!*(9!A!-2%!(B4!,,(;4%;-!

;?-%"2,*9",!,!-((*9!- A!-2/A!-2**4$-!*!%"9 B%-**/%2,-(%2 ,!-%94!,!*-*!*!;-2!A!-2 /2!*9*2*%%"-$-!* !-2*,%%"9!!**,%9( B**!*9

C43,-/!2*!(!*9"!% ;-!3%%*2!9*-*9";-!9%/* 9-*,%*,,!*/!(!-2-*! 

9%*/-%*B%2 !2 )23 < 

@

'!!(-249!*!-!(*9!;-! 7 **"!2"2,-(*$-*(2*2-,%*

6!2!,,%*2!9"*2*

  (

1%29-/0'2-/6,-##5 , $   %06'

J!, (8!* K8' J!,!9% K8'