High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/864/2014disposed of

Rajwant Singh v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd Chd And ORS

2016-06-02Mr Justice Jaswant Singh14 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!)*!'"%'+, !)*!'"%'+, !)*!'"%'+, !)*!'"%'+, --#..!'"

--#..!'"

/#0&1& /#0&1& /#0&1& /#0&1& 1')!2"!"#%3%.1--.%#&0-0!"%'4%5%"#6 !'6 1')!2"!"#%3%.1--.%#&0-0!"%'4%5%"#6 !'6 1')!2"!"#%3%.1--.%#&0-0!"%'4%5%"#6 !'6 1')!2"!"#%3%.1--.%#&0-0!"%'4%5%"#6 !'6 ",#0& ",#0& ",#0& ",#0& #&-'6#'"& #&-'6#'"& #&-'6#'"& #&-'6#'"& ( ( ( ( 74 74 74 74 8,#",#0#-0"#0& ",#.$!.-!-#0&5!92# !..*#6"&##",#)16+5#'":

2#0# #00#6"",##-0"#0&0'":

; 8,#",#0",#)16+5#'"&,1.62#0#-0"#6%'",# %+#&":

0#&#'"( 00!9!<63$!"# 0",#!--#..!'" 0#,!)%0%'+,<63$!"# 0 &%9!6,%<63$!"#

00#&-'6#'"&!'6 0=!52)<63$!"#

00#&-'6#'" >>> !)!'",0%< 0!.

!)!'",0%< 0!.

--.%$!"%'%&!..*#6<!&-0!9#6 0 'B1%090#-0"6!"#6 ?

;%&"!C#''0#$06

!%'!&# !%'!&# !%'!&# !%'!&# '",#%'&"!'"0#+1.!0&#$'6!--#!.<",#!--#..!'" ,!& B1#&"%'#6 ",# 3!.%6%"9 )16+5#'" !'6 6#$0## 6!"#6

-!&&#629.#!0'#6%3%.16+# 0%3' <!D%.C!

!'6)16+5#'"!'66#$0##6!"#6?

-!&&#629.#!0'#6 66%"%'!.%&"0%$"16+#<!D%.C! 0%# !$"& ",# $!&# !0# ",!" 0#&-'6#'"A 0-0!"%' %'%"%!"#6 6%&$%-.%'!09 -0$##6%'+& !+!%'&" ",# !--#..!'"' ?

; 0",# ..*%'+$,!0+#&(A E,# ..*%'+ $,!0+#& *#0# .#3#..#6 !+!%'&" ",# $,!0+#A&,##"#6

%$%!.& ,!0+#&!+!%'&",!)*!'"%'+,<'&-#$"0 0!6#A< "!.&,0"!+# ?

A@ A;

F".& *,#!"

0-@@?A@*!& 1'6%'",#&"$C&*,%$, *#0#1'6#0",#$,!0+# ,!)*!'"%'+,< '&-#$"00!6#A #!.'+*%",$'$#0'#6 612.#.$C#0!'6,2,!9=15!0,!*.!< %#.6

%$#0!0#0#&-'&%2.#!&-#0%'&"01$"%'&

0",%&&,0"!+#<",#$&" *,%$,$5#&"

< @< ;HA!'60#$3#09 ",#&!5#!.'+ *%",%'"#0#&"%&"2#5!6# 05",#5

'"0!09"",#%'&"01$"%'& ",#0-0!"%'

,!)*!'"%'+,<'&-#$"00!6#A<+!3#.#&& #I$#&&%'*,#!"0-@@?A@"",#"1'#

@;A A

F".&<",#$&" *,%$,$5#&" G?<?J

,%&#5-.9##<$'$#0'#6612.# .$C#0!'62,!9=15!0,!*.!<%#.6

%$#0 !0#0#&-'&%2.# 0",%&.#&&#I$#&&!'6",%&

!51'"!.'+*%",%'"#0#&"%&0#$3#0!2.# 05 !..",#&#",0###5-.9##& ; 6#61$"#6 05",#2%.. G

HA ' !$$1'" B1!.%"9 $1"& !'6 G< HA '

!$$1'" 1'6#0*#%+,"6#.%3#09 05&"$C& *,#!"@@ "!.G ;< @ HA < 0*,%$,, !)*!'" %'+,< '&-#$"0 0!6#A '$,!0+# < 3"!0%'+,< 12.#4$C#0 !'62,!9 =15!0 ,!*.!< < !0# 0#&-'&%2.# !'6 0#$3#09 ",%&!51'"!.'+*%",%'"#0#&"%& "2#5!6# 05",#&#",0###5-.9##&

'",#/<6!"#6; ;

K 2!+&7 .!&&!06!'!7*,%$,*!&%'",#$,!0+# , !)*!'"%'+,*!& 1'6%'2!6$'6%"%' 0 *,%$, ",#&# #5-.9##& !0# 0#&-'&%2.# !'6 ",#$&" !06!'!G;< JHA%&0#$3#0!2.#

05,%5L %51."!'#1&.9< $%3%. &1%" 0 0#$3#09

< ;<;@JHA %#G?< <

HA '!$$1'" &,0"!+# *,#!"

&"$C& 0",#9#!0@@?A@!'6B1!.%"9$1"%5-&#6'*,#!" &"$C& 0",#$0-9#!0@@A@@ -.1& &,0"!+# 77 $.!&& +1''92!+&!.'+*%",%'"#0#&" G< <@@;HA'",#!

0#&!%6 !51'"*# J @

"%..",#6!"# %.%'+ &1%"!.'+*%", MN-#0!''15-#'6#'"#.%"#*!& %.#6 ",",#6%&$%-.%'!09-0$##6%'+&!&*#..!&&1%" 0 0#$3#09 -0$##6#6 ,# "0%!. 10" 6#$0##6 ",# &1%" '

292&#03%'+!&1'6#0( E'",%&$!&#%"%&,#0#2906#0#6",!"",#&1%" ",#-.!%'"%

%&6#$0##6 00#$3#09 G ;J

G < <?@HAOG; JHA !+!%'&"6# #'6!'" '.9!.'+*%",&%5-.#%'"#0#&"M@N-#0!''15

05",#6!"# 0#-0"6!"#6 J @

IJ"%..

",#6!"# 6#$0##!'6",#0#!

"#0M N-#0!''15

05 ",# 6!"# 6#$0## "%.. %"& 0#!.%D!"%' *%", -0-0"%'!"# $&"&< *,#0#!& ",# &1%" !+!%'&" 6# #'6!'"& !'6;%&6%&5%&&#6L ,# !--#!. *!& %.#6 !+!%'&" ",# )16+5#'" !'6 6#$0##6!"#6

29",#!--#..!'",#!--#..!"#$10"

%05#6 ",# )16+5#'" !'6 6#$0## ",# "0%!. 10" !'6 6%&5%&&#6 ",# !--#!. ",# !--#..!'" #'$#< ",# -0#&#'"

0#+1.!0&#$'6!--#!. 4#!0'#6 $1'&#. 0 ",# !--#..!'" &125%""#6 ",!"

-0#.%5%'!09%&&1#&*#0#0!%&#62# 0#",#"0%!.10"0#+!06%'+ 5!%'"!%'!2%.%"9< .$1&A&"!'6%< .%5%"!"%' #"$ '# ",# $'"#'"%'& 0!%&#6 %& 0#+!06%'+ 0#$3#09 !51'" %& '"

-#05%&&%2.# *%",1" ,.6%'+ 6#-!0"5#'"!. -0$##6%'+& ,# &!5#,!&'"2##'!--0#$%!"#6*%",0# #0#'$#"%&$%-.%'#

--#!.1.#& 8%",1"",#0#2#%'+6#"#05%'!"%' !'9.&& $!1&#6"",#0-0!"%'%'!6#-!0"5#'"!.#'B1%09<",#&!5# $!''"2#0#$3#0#6290#&0"%'+"&1%" 00#$3#09 ' ",# ",#0 ,!'6< .#!0'#6 $1'&#. 0 ",# 0#&-'6#'"A0-0!"%' &125%""#6 ",!" -0#.%5%'!09 %&&1#& 0!%&#629",#!--#..!'",!3#2##'"!C#'%'"$'&%6#0!"%'29 ",#"0%!.10"292&#03%'+!&1'6#0(A E '",#",#0,!'6<6# #'6!'" ,!&2##'

-0$##6#6!+!%'&"#IA-!0"#<*,#0#!&6# #'6!'" ,!& !%.#6".#!6!'9#3%6#'$#%'&1--0" ,%& $'"#'"%' *#3#0< 6# #'6!'" ; ,!& #I!5%'#6 !& 5!'9 !& ",0## *%"'#&&#& %# 5!'%'6#0 %'+,< 0 &&"" $$1'"& !& 8A< !&,-!. %'+,< 0 &&"" $$1'"& !& 8A < 6# #'6!'";,%5&#.

&"#--#6%'"",#*%"'#&& 2I!&8A; 4#!0'#6$1'&#. 06# #'6!'"&,!& !0+1#6",!"",#0#$3#09&1%"%'",#-0#&#'"&#"

$%0$15&"!'$#& %& '" 5!%'"!%'!2.# !& ",# -.!%'"%

$!' '.9 0#$3#0 ",# !51'" %' 6#-!0"5#'"!. -0$##6%'+&#,!&!.&0#.%#61-'",#!1",0%"9 $%"#6!&

-!+# ;

-!+# ; "%&-#0"%'#'"" 5#'"%' ,#0# ",!" !' !--.%$!"%' 1'6#0 06#0 ? 1.#& #!0.%#0 !" ",# "%5# 6# #'6!'"

#3%6#'$#*!& %.#6!'6",#&!%6!1",0%"9*!&!.& 0#.%#61-'29",#6# #'6!'"& *#3#0<",#&!%6 !--.%$!"%'*!&6%&5%&&#6'5#0%"&,#)16+5#'" *!&6%&"%'+1%&,#6 05",# !$"& ",#-0#&#'"$!&# !'6",%&$'"#'"%' ",#6# #'6!'"&*!&0#-#..#6 0#3%&%',!&2##' %.#629",#6# #'6!'"&"",!"

06#0!'6",#0# 0#<",#6# #'6!'"&!0##&"--#6

05 0!%&%'+ ",# -.#! !+!%' !" ",# "%5# %'!.

!0+15#'"& 3#' ",#0*%&#< ' 5#0%"&< ",# &!%6 !1",0%"9%&'"!--.%$!2.#"",# !$"& ",#-0#&#'"

$!&#!&%'",#&!%6$!&#<'# ",##5-.9##&,!6 6#-&%"#6 ",# !51'" .&& $!1&#6 " -.!%'"%

0-0!"%' 610%'+ $10&# 6#-!0"5#'"!.

-0$##6%'+&!'6%'!--#!.#3#'",#0$A#5-.9## !.&6#-&%"#6",#2!.!'$#!51'"!'6%"*!&61# " ''A0#%'&"!"#5#'" ",# #5-.9## 6#&-%"# 6#-&%" ",#!51'"'!$$1'" .&&",!"",#9

!--0!$,#6",#10"%'3C%'+",#*0%")10%&6%$"%' *,%.#'",#",#0,!'66#-!0"5#'"!.& %.#6$%3%.

&1%" 00#$3#09!+!%'&"",##5-.9##&$'$#0'#6 !'6%"*!&1'6#0",#&#$%0$15&"!'$#&",!"",#$%3%. &1%" 00#$3#09*!&,#.6"2#'"5!%'"!%'!2.#L '3%#* ",# %'6%'+&0#$06#629"0%!.10"<&1%"

00#$3#09%&5!%'"!%'!2.# ,#0#%&'#000%'0#&-#$"

6#$0##%'+",#&1%"!'6 10",#0!--#..!"#$10",!&!

%05#6",# &!%606#0 ,#!--#..!'"%&!'#5-.9## ",#0-0!"%'!'6

0",#-10-&# "!C%'+6%&$%-.%'!09!$"%'!'6!.&!'9.&& $!1&#6 " ",# 0-0!"%' 0 !..#+#6 " ,!3# $55%""#6 5%&$'61$"<,#%&21'6296%&$%-.%'!091.#&!'6#+1.!"%'& ",# 0-0!"%' 5-.9##&H

%$#0& !0# +3#0'#6 29 0#+1.!"%'$!..#6E,#1')!2"!"#%3%.1--.%#&0-0!"%' #3%&#6#03%$##+1.!"%'&<@JL#+1.!"%' 6#!.& *%",%&$%-.%'#<#'!."%#& --#!.&I"0!$" #+1.!"%' %&0#-061$#6,#0#1'6#0(A E %..&1$,"%5# 0!5#&%"&*'01.#&%'

5!""#0 0#.!"%'+ " 6%&$%-.%'#< -1'%&,5#'" &,!.. 2# +3#0'#6 29 ",# 01.#& !--.%$!2.# " 1')!2 3#0'5#'"#5-.9##& 05"%5#""%5#-03%6#6 ",!"",#'!"10# -#'!."%#&*,%$,5!92#%5-&#6 ",#!1",0%"9#5-*#0#6"%5-&#&1$,-#'!."%#& !'6",#!--#..!"#!1",0%"9<&,!..2#!&&-#$% %#6%'

--#'6%I"",#&#0#+1.!"%'&L 5# ",#-03%&%'& ,#1')!2%3%.#03%$#&

1'%&,5#'"!'6--#!. 1.#&<@?

!0#0#.#3!'"3%D ;

" # $

$ " " $

% &'''''''

('''''''

)'''''''

$ "

'''

$ "

" "

,- &

" "

' +

, $

" "

- #"

. "

' /

2,3(42,3$ /

- &5 "

" /

2,3

- %

$ "

2 - & "

" $

" /

" "

( "

" "

3 6 "

% 1

7 /

" "

- ) "

" "

" /

6 "

% 1

7 /

" "

8- &&" '

" $

" "

" $ $

" /

7 $ "

&("'

5 $

$ 8- &

, $ "

$ +

2 0 +

"- &)"*

)

$ " "

$ "

,% $ %

" %

" % " $

" " "

$ "

" $

" '

% "

$ %

$ "

% "$

$ "

- :'

;

$ %

;1 #

- (&" .$

" "

$ ' $ %

$ "

% $ $

&, $

$ $

6 /

" "

$ "

" "

" $

$ +

2 '

$ 7 $

-< %&$'61$" ,!& '" 2##' 6# %'#6 %' !23#

0#+1.!"%'&H01.# ,# *06 75%&$'61$"7 %& !'"%",#&%& ",# *067$'61$"706%'!0%.9",##I-0#&&%'75%&$'61$"75#!'& *0'+0%5-0-#0$'61$"<1'.!* 1.2#,!3%10<5%& #!&!'$#< *0'+ $'61$"< 5%&6#5#!'10 #"$ ' ",# -0#&#'" 5!""#0 !--#..!'" !'6 ",#0& ,!3# !..#+#6 " ,!3# $55%""#6 5%&$'61$"*,%.#6%&$,!0+%'+61"%#& ",#0#&-#$"%3#-&" ,# 0#&-'6#'"A0-0!"%' !--0-0%!"#.9 0#&0"#6

0%'%"%!"%' #'B1%0929 0!5%'+$,!0+#&' ?

;%# 2# 0# %.%'+ &1%" 0 0#$3#09 ' ?

; '$# ",# 6%&$%-.%'!09-0$##6%'+&,!3#2##'%'%"%!"#6 0",#-10-&#

0#$3#09 *%", 0# #0#'$# " ",# !..#+#6 .&& $!1&#6 29 ",# #5-.9##& 0-0!"%'<&1%" 00#$3#09%&'"5!%'"!%'!2.# ,##5-.9##& 0-0!"%'!0#21'629#+1.!"%'!'6 %&$%-.%'# --#!. 1.#& %' & !0 !& !'9 5%&$'61$"

$55%""#629!'#5-.9##0

%$#0# 0#0-0!"%' %.#6 &1%" 0 0#$3#09< %'%"%!"%' #'B1%09 *!& !.0#!69 06#0#6< ",#0# 0#<%'",#!2&#'$# *%",60!*!. %'%"%!"%' #'B1%09 !'6 %.%'+ &1%" 0 0#$3#09 !'6 6#$0## -!&&#6 %' &1%" !0# *%",1")10%&6%$"%''&#B1#'".9<",#!--#..!"#10"6#$%&%' %& !.& *%",1" )10%&6%$"%' 3#' " ",%& 6!9< 6%&$%-.%'!09 -0$##6%'+&,!3#'"2##'*%",60!*'0 %'!.%D#6%&$%-.%'!09 -0$##6%'+& 0#!$,#6 ",# &"!+# &125%&&%' 'B1%09

%$#07&0#-0""6%&$%-.%'!09!1",0%"9,#0#! "#0'!$"%'

,!&2##'"!C#'!--!0#'".9 0",#0#!&'",!" !310!2.#06#0

,!&2##'-!&&#6%'",#&1%"<",#0# 0#<0#&-'6#'"A0-0!"%'

6%6'"-0$##6%'",#6%&$%-.%'!09-0$##6%'+&,#!--#..!'" %&!'#5-.9## ",#0-0!"%'<% !'95%&A$'61$",!&2##'

$55%""#629,%5<*,%.#%'&#03%$#<",#0#&-'6#'"A0-0!"%' ,!3#"%'3C##+1.!"%' ,#1')!2 "!"#%3%.

1--.%#& 0-0!"%' #3%&#6 #03%$# #+1.!"%'< @J 0#!6 *%",",#1')!2%3%.#03%$#& 1'%&,5#'"!'6--#!. 1.#&< @?

'.9'",#!2&#'$# !'9-03%&%' 0 %.%'+&1%" 0 0#$3#09 29 ",# 0-0!"%' !'6 $'&#B1#'".9 "0%!. 10" 6#$0##!'6)16+5#'"6!"#6

!'6!--#..!"#10"

)16+5#'" 6!"#6 ?

!0# &#"A!&%6# 0 *!'"

)10%&6%$"%' #&#03%'+.%2#0"9"",#0#&-'6#'""-0$##6*%", ",#6#-!0"5#'"!. #'B1%09 *%", 0# #0#'$# " 'B1%09

%$#07& 0#-0"6!"#6 ?

;!'6$5-.#"#6%&$%-.%'!09-0$##6%'+& %'!$$06!'$#*%",.!**%",%'!-#0%6 ",0##5'",& 05 "6!9 ",#6%&$%-.%'!09-0$##6%'+&!0#'"$5-.#"#6!&'

<",#0#&-'6#'"&!0#6%0#$"#6"0#.#!&#!..0#"%0!. 2#'# %"& !.'+ *%", %'"#0#&" M @N -#0 !''15 2# 0# ;

,!3%'+ 0#+!06 " ",# !$" ",!" !--#..!'" ,!& !""!%'#6!+# &1-#0!''1!"%'!'60#"%0#6 05&#03%$# --#!.&"!'6&6%&-&#6 %'",#!23#"#05& 1'#

1'#

C!'$,!'