High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3919/2017allowed

State Of Haryana Through The Collector Bhiwani v. Maharana Pratap Charitable Trust, Bhiwani And Others

2024-02-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma15 pages

!!!"

# $

!%!!!"

&'((!%) *+

! &!("%!%) *+ !

* ,-* & &

&. /

,-* & & & & * # $%& '() !

)%*(+ ++) !)% $+#) !)% ,+

-( &'((!%+ ,

.-( &!("%!%+ (/0 %) 12

+() 12 ,+

-( &!("%!%3

++($$) 12*(+ 1 4 +) 12*(+ /+%(1(+) 12 ,

56-( &!("%!%3

&. /

(2$++

- 3)(112009(

! ,*)$( )*++4 #0 22+# ($++

(200)+)+%0$$ 2( +#+ 2001 (2 2(1(( :;,5<<=) (>,,(0(1 2* 0 $%+ (1(? #22 )5@ <A 5<8:)1(>>1( +(,2(0 (+( ()(02+),+ ((, 2 , 0 % 0 (42( 9 + ( ) *++ , 22(0* 2

+ ( ,,(0(1 2 $20 ( $% +

> +()$,+ (

22 + (

+#+1 (20 <8 <6 5<8.) +

(,(

)* +

( +4 #0 2 $%+*

(###(1 ,0+1 (2,+ (

? #)*+$%+( +4 #0 2 $%+ *)++!02+% +, %+1(( +(* $,+(

1$2 324$1 :

, 2 (# 0' 4 (2( + 0)((2%2+2%,2 =

+(, 0 +($(%(42($20 ,( $%+ ((,,>)#() , 8-!02+%3) ,+ 2$(# +( 2> ,

8>!0 2+%)B2 ##( #(, (,1,+

((,,>)# (#+ 2($ (+ (0(#5@.

' <5 0 ( 1(# *) +( ((2 +(*(

' .

1) 2%(,$20 (+ ( ( , 2(# 1( + (

8 <= <:

5<<=) $%+ , >!02+%)+# ++0(+2%+(( 8 <;

5<<8

;

(()(,$20 )+, (( , 2, 0(42(+$%((# , 8> !02+%)2 +( ( ,((#() 1 ( 0(

A@;. 5< 5<<8) (,1,+)$%+1,,(2()(0,+#(, ( <;

5<<8

+(+$1 + 8( % 2( 1( 8@ .

5<<< +!02+%

( <;

5<<8#(1+ ( ( $%*%,#(,)$42+

1,+ !10 + 200 ( , % 00(() +(*() + 9(( 2( * # $% + !10,%$2(2 (( 8<

+ $9%) + ( 56 <8 5<<5 * $%+!02+% (,+ $20 + 1 ((,,>)8A 5<<8 ($(#

A@;. 5< 5<<8$202( (,1,+ ((,,> )+$(,

1#(1$%+!10 (2+)

((,,>+$2((#( (,+( % +( 22( ((# 2( (((

((1("(((*,( (+($%0

" ( , + 1(#) *+$% + ( ( , + !0 2+%) )+

1+# $%+!10)+ $202+# *1)+( *( ((* (0( (,2$%+(1( 8: 5<<@)(1(*, 0 0 ( 2( : , 4$ (# 00 - #(3)%0 02 +1(#,(

#(+( 2((,+ (#2+, +()+*1)+0* (0( (,2$%+( 1( 85 <.

5<<=$*(+ ($%2+#+ 1(,+( 0 2(:,2- 3

+ , >!02+%2 )+(* (42(

(2(( ( +# )+ ( ( 0(($(+ ,0) ++2(1()(+1(# 4( (2(% 2( + ( *2 + !02+%(+*,+ ( ( + 1( (*1( % ) +2 + + ,!02+%*(#%#(, $%++ 2+ ) *+ * ,2(# #( , 0$CC0 ,

$(2, ((,,

6)*+(00$,+)$(# ((# (+(#!10)+ +(01+(0 ,0#292 +)(*2 ++(0 # (

8 <;

5<<8 * + 20 , 2( $*+ ((,, ++ 2+,+!02+% 8@

+0)(*2 ++!02+% * #% ( ( + (# #(, ( <;

5<<8 +22(0*,( (2(#+ ((,,

5 + 1+ ( ( 2+% ,(#( + 0( A@;. 5< 5<<8 * +(+ %#(, +$B2 $%!02+%(,1, >(0,,, %2%2+#(, + $ #( + #(( 2 2) +

($% ((,,D1+ ( ) )+0( 2( (,1,+(20 %(# 8:

+)(*$0( ++( ((+,0, #(2 2(,+20 +(%+$ $( ,+

,+( *0( + , + *#(122,2,( 0((# ,#(2 $%+!02+%

,+(#+(12(,$++ ()+ ( 2 +22(0,( $% ,

8> !02+% (2 + ((,,> (1+12

(,+( % ,

8)*+)+ (( + ((,,> 8.

+( ,+ (*2+# $% + ((,,>$,+ (

)+ (

+#+1 (2 *<8 <6 5<8.) ,*(#+ ((,,>

+) 2 + ((,,D () )+ (0( + , >!02+%D 2 2(0 &#6788

32491 $ # 93 241::991 2)+ 8;

+ + ((,, 2 + ( <;

5<<8(2(*(+++ 2+,(#)$2

((,,

6>+ ++( 40* )(+(#

!10) )+ ++ 2+1+(0,0+ 0$CC02+##(+(0 +++ 2+) + (0 # ( <;

5<<8$( +2( 5<<8$++1$ ((2 )$2

((,, 6>+ ++( 40)* (+(#

% 8A

++( 2 (#(#+#(,,+(

%*2 2 (+%0 (1((,+

1((,+4$(#00 - #(32) 8A=8-

(2$%3-+(,,+2 +D2 ,8A=8D3 ++ ,D$(#+ 8: 5<<@ 85 <.

5<<=+1,,2+0(,+ 2) $2+* 0( 5<

+ + 1 ,,(2( (2 + (0 # 0(

A@;. 5<855<<8-B>A3($1((,+

1((,2(85@,,, %2)8;;5 ,+ 4$ 128;;.)(02+) (+(0 (1 20 (%#($ ,#(,)+(+$(#B2 $20(# , #(( $20(# 22 , #(()%+ ,0($20(# (,1, + ((,,>)+$%)+( 0((2 %)+ $(#$2' $%+#( ,#(, ++2$

#(* + * ) 0(0 #(*(,2$+ (2( ,

+ , $ $% + 2( , 0(%

(%0)$2<;

5<<8+* 1(((+D2,8A=8D$%1(,*+(2+!02+%

% 2 #(, 2(2+($((( +

((,,(*9( $ (0( % +)+( 1(((+ 2(,(2 (,2 8A=@) + $(# + ((,, ' 0 % (42( (2(#+*B2 #(#(, (+( ,1

++ ((,,+1+*(,( +*% + % 1(( 2 * *+ + 2(0 , 0 %(42((#%($ +,( ,2 ,,(2(+ ++ ((#%0(($ +(+$2,#( #(, )+ ((,, 22(0%(#+)()((+( % 5:

+(0 # ( <;

5<<8 2( 85 5<<8+(#$ (, ,

8) #(,+( % ((,,

8 +9(*+++( (*

($ 5=

+ + 1 ,,(2( 2( + (0 # 0()(+$2,#( #(, )+$%+ 0'(#+0((,1,+ ((,,( 1( &#621 2819;#28

3-1< 5.

, (#+4 #0 2$20 $%+ (1(? #22 5@ <A 5<8:) 2(1((

:;,5<<=) ) +22(0)0 $% ,

8> !02+%)*+$%+ ((,,(* (0( + , D22(0* 2 )$( , (# +4 #0 2 $%+ (

) 2(1(

5@8,5<8:)*+$%),9+(#+4 #0

= 2 $%+ (1(? #)+ (

2 + ((,,( (0( + , 2 2(0)+(,0++(,$(9(,*

"++ + 2+% (

8 <;

5<<8)*+(2+

1$20# $%+0 +(%*+$%+( *#(, +((,,> * 1( (+,2,) 2(%*+++ #, (#, 2+%( E+(0,

1+$20(#22 $%+20 +(%) +*% 1(((+D2,8A=8D)9+ 0'(#,%#(,(,1,+ ((,,>F "+++(,0(2 $%+ 1,,(2(5< 5<<8)*+$%)(*$20 2, + ((,,>+*1( )+*(+ +20 (%#($(0,#(,)+0((# (+ B2 $20(# 22 , #(($%+$ #(22 )$( *++( + *' , + $1) ( * $ , + (

22 )% (2+ , >2+% B2#( ,21%2(,1,+

((,,>) 2(% *+ +#+ ( <= <:

5<<=)0 (0,+1% 1(() ++(( <;

5<<8$20 F @3 "+++(

2 * + ((,,>%#((0B 2( E*++( *$,+ (

)+$( , ,2(12+%(

8 <;

5<<8

( ,2(1

1+$20(## )+2

0(%

#(+ , 2+%F 241

2 618> 48 1321992416 #621 ?#28

11 <1>18 224:918 2833#21 8 31 # 24 1::991 20 246@ 6 24 24 1::19 1 199 < 1 24 :918 2833,#2#8288781 243 1 2$ # 2$9187 8$ 5;

+,0'(#+$122((,0 +',20)+1( %+(0, (#, 2+% ( <;

5<<8)$( )+#,

1+ $20(## $%+20 +(%)+*% 0 B((#(+D2,8A=8D*+$%+2 $%#(,, + ( 1(>>1(+ ((,,>)+,2+($ 2( 5A

(2+B(2,+( % 1(()$* (0 (1+,+1( 0'(#,+ 2+%( $( ,$(#+029(#,2)$( 0' +

10 +('*(29(#,2) *+)*(+$++#- 3)+$(#%

1(($20(#$(+1)+$%$++

2+%( +

1++ $20 1( @<

+ ( ++ (1(# (%$ %+(#+0'200+,

%)+(#+1 (+(1(# (%$ %)+ 2 $2( *+( *)++#++0'(#, ,2(1 #%,* 2+%(<;

5<<8)

+#+ ,2(1(1(

1+$20(## $%+ 20 +(%

2(%)$2+$%+*$4 B (( , + *, (0-3 , + ( 1(#

(%$ %1+ ( (%)+$1(#+ 0%+1$B ( 2+ )$%+#+,,(2( 0%20 $(#0 1(>>1(+1(# (% $ %) + ( + 2+%( $( ( (' +

1$20(## $%+

1(#+(% @5

( %*++#+ (,+ ( $(#0 + ((>)+#++ 2+%( +#+

1+$20(## $%+

1(# +(%) + 0% 20 ( 0 + 1(#

(% $ %) *+ + ( 1 + (

%)+$%,(2( 4 (2,(2( (0$20 2 + 1(# (% $ % + 0 * +#+$92( (#($20(# (+% 5<<= @@

+,)+( $9%)$%+

2+% *+$% ( + ( () + 29(,2)+$%)+( 1 2+( ,+1(# (%$ %1+ )*+(2++ $420,+(

(2+#, (#,+ 2+%() <= <:

5<<=)*+$%)+(($202( )+

( % 1(( ( $20 #, ) +#+ 0 0$(#0 (+%)5<<@)(+D2,8A=8D(02+

) +$% + 0'(# , #(,-3 , + +0 ) , +

, + () ( ( 2( 2+($ (((,2++ 0%$

1 $%+ !10) + , + $,( , + (+$( , + 1(# 22 )+$20(# 1( (% @:

(%*++( ( <= <:

5<<=) ( 0'%2+(#)+,+( $(##(, +

((,,> 9)+$9(*+ +1 %$2'(#)+$%(+$ +( ,2(1 ,* ()*+(2+$%B ( +(#+)( (,+(1(# (%$ %1+ (

+,)+$9(+,2 %+* 22(,+ (

)0'0 % (42( + , >2+%B2#( ,21%2)1(>>1()+ ((,,> @=

1( 0(,*+( $20(# 5< 5<<8) 1(>>1( + ((,,>) +#+ 4( + (# 1 ,,(2( + + #( , 21%2( $,+(0)$+(#1 ,,(222 )*(++#( ,21%2$20(#

$,+(0)+0%+$(,#%,*

2+%() ) 9%#% ,2(1

1 +$20(## $%+20 +(%)+0 ,2(1 1( 0(5< 5<<8 2(%+ 1( (%2 $, $% $%+ (

+(0%)+ (2( , 0(%

! +$*' 1(>>1(+ ((,,>)+$%+ (

) $ * #% 0(($) $20 (# + ((,,> @;

+ , 0'(# + ( 22() ( $ 0$((C ,0+(,20+)+ 2+%( +

1+$+$200 (0,+1 % 1(()$( *++0,( 1(

1 (%2(2)+ ,+ , >!02+%) +B2+20 (%#($ ,21%2)1(> >1() + ((,,>) + ) +

( 2 , 0 %(42(* $1(>>1(+ ((,,> @A

(%)(* $$% )(+ 1( *' , + , + - 3) $+ + 2+% ( +

1+$(#$+,* E$+ ,(#( + 0(,+)+(1#1 ($(# % 1(()*+ (2 $0 , 2(2+($ 2+)+ 2,0 % (42((,* (9( $9+ ( 6<

0 %)0(#(,+20 (%#($ , 21%2 $20 B2 ( 0 , + ,2(1

2+%(- 3 (0,+ ,2(1

1 +$20(#0 $%+!10)%)$( 0(# ++0(2,(#(1(>>1(+ ( $20 $%+1,,(2)1(>>1(+ ((,,> *1) *++( +

1+$+,- 3) , # 29((%) +$% 1 + 20 (% #( ,21%2) (,( $20 B2 (, (

' 0(#%$20 $,+(#,,(222 ) $( % 0(# + 1 0( $20

+)+( 0( 0( + ,2(1 (- 3)$( ,2(1

1+$20(## +* $202 (C

++ (

$20 )(0,1 (20 $%+((">@<<<,5<<5 ( ,1 1A&8 >41 24B#&212 31@1 11

24, *+$%+( + +#(,0 (,1,+

((,,>) +) 1( + #(, 0 +#+ + $1 ,2(1 2+% ( + $1 ,2(1

1 +

*1) ( + (

+ 2+(#,(##(%+*( ,2(1 2+%#(, ( + ,2(1+

1)+ +$10 )()#%( 2 +( (,2$20 # ,0+#++((+#+ *+ *( ((- 3+1( (#+

( 2+%( %+( 1 (2( ) (2(0+% 1(() 2(%*++#, (#,+ 2+%( ,+

1+$20(## )++*$(# % 1((0(,(#(,(+D2,8A=8D)+, *0 *(#+ 2+%*0 *(#+

1(# +(% 2(1% +

( 2+%( E #

+,)%(2+1 (2- 3)*+$%)+ #(,$201( )( (2(0+1% 1((

" +(#(,(22*,$+( 1 (22 +1* + (

1( +(2( ,+ , >2+%#(,+ ( )+ ((,,> ) +#+ ,2(1 2+% () ) 9% ,2(1

1+$(#0 $%+

1(#+(%

+,)+ 2 +1 (2- 3)$%+ (

( ( 0 2 +

( %)+$2020 ( (+,20++ 1 (2- 3 *$%+(+* (2(09+ ($(#% 1((22 6:

%)+,)+*22(,%#((0 B 2($20(# * + ((,,>)+*% 22(,% 0(%

*'(##(+

#( +( #(# $ $1(% ,0 ,2(1 2+% ( ,0+ ,2(1+

1$20(## $% +

1(#+(% 6=

)*+B (2( 2(1(%((# + 0 00 2(:,+ 4$(#00

- #(3)%0 02)+#++%2

8@,5<<@)$% (#+$2(8)*+$%)

*0 0(($$20#(, ,+ , + () ( ( 2(2+($(((,2+ + 0%$

1 $%+!10$, +$,(,+(+$(,+1(#22 ,)+2 $% 2(11( (+ ,2(1 2+%( + ,2

1+# $%+

1(#+(% +$%)+*%22(,+ (

5 ? #) + 2 , 0 % (42( 1(>>1( +

((,,> 8 19 3248

#2 6.

,0+)$++

* +1 (2

$%+ (

(9+ (

+ 1 (2 $% + ( ? # ( 0(( ,,(0 6;

+$(9(,*22 (#%*

+ 2 2(0 ,( $% ,

8 G !0 2+%( 2 +,,2+ ((,,>( (2 (1+ (,+( % ,

8G!0 2+%$$42+ (2( (">=;=<>5<<.

2+$ *22 (#%

&. /

+ )& & *+ !%!!!"

'1(#+ "++ '(#E &

"++ $ &