← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25263/2024dismissed

Union Of India Through Its Secretary To Government Of India And Others v. No 2977608x Ex Sep Ram Pal And Another

2024-12-12Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Ms. Justice Kirti Singh8 pages

  

           

 !"#$%$ &'((



  

    

  



 )'  *+)  ,,

, -

  *+), ,- ,  

 

!"#"$ " %& %$ ' (  ")

$)*" ' + ,,,, ,

, -

 .   +

-! !!

". $!

!

/ '"$"

'!

 "  " 01 +2 20+3 4 5 /+6$  "  "  

 %  #   *  - "% ** 4!

'!*"%% "!

- "%6$.!

!

*%"#' +'!

"'!

'!



!

"'

'' ''." "%%.

/ 0 #123 /&"

+7 # 08 +390"." *!"

:+ +0 +339 +9

"$9#!"21 "

' $'.!*!!

."  '%'

"' $ +." %%  *

&  20 +2 200+"."*!"

 !

'# .

:+ +2 20++'

 .!*!!

."" " " "!/*#/   "

!

# '*!"

'# $ +."%"*  %.  # *"%  *"

  .    "

 ;



 -  -<    &  1=  >-?  &  @

A ;



""

.""  B:0C '  %'

"   *"%  <"$ 

  !

 "#

*# *%" 

"

")"

'#%"

** $ ." "

B:0C'%'

.

0+ 0+ 20+2  ?.

$  !

 ."      !

    '  !

'!

!#!

& :

% "

 $ +'%  $

# * - $' "' '

"'!

'' ''

" $

"%%.

)  " 01 +2 20+3  ") "'!

"  !



  



        

 

         

   

       !"# $%!%

 & '

() *    $+%"$%!% ,     

        

              -.     

  

  ! !"#$%%&'"$  !%!$$%!" 

   /

   

       /       01%2    $%2  3

% "

 '#!

"' " ""   4"6$

# * - $!

 /'"!"'% !

"

"!

".

!& 32/4& % ! 50 3&"# /&%0! 3 56 $ $ &3 &"&!3&#% ! 5$% /3  = * %'!

 #!"!

  - "%  !"  '"%     !"#%      !

  )"    

%"$  "  !

 "#  "  %  "%*"

   *"%*%"  *" '  %.!" )"% "! .!" *!"

*#% ' #' "

# !

  "

%"#"" "

' !

" $" !"   ' "*!

!

"" "" *#% '  *) * * "  "!

)" 

%"" !

&%$ & 2/0

$ &%! 3347.(8(   (#'')'$! *) +,%$- ."#)"

.,#",  -")+  $!$!  !  $*)$!  $  $,  %$- %%#/+$%0 $##                

 

  

  /4

          

 

3

 

&%$ & 2/0

$ &%! 3347.9

1  %%  "#$.%  $!!  $2  "#  '')'

*) +,%$- $$,%$-%%+$%0 +D:

               '





 & '

5  /4

         

 

3   & %' !

   # !"!

- "%.!% "%%.  4"6!".   !

)4"6

"E

%"+D3'!



%" '!

# $+38+%" "

%"+D3 !

!67   8    

              

  1% 9

  

   :/     





  



     ;

  /              

   /  

  $%   /  

                 $%        

8   

 /       

    /     

     8  / 

  

  !

 "  

"$       )"         " ) *

- *"   :21'

20+8% " 4

%5/03$ :% &$ & !&"$  3%.

*    +0 20+9$ .!

 "  #%" F  ."   '!



- $!"3.#"#$"#-".#.% $-" $'+%""#"' #%$$'""#452% ""!""#!%/"+%"#45%$- %63 -! - "' * )"

%" ) !" #'

%"+D3'!



%"' # $  +38+$  

            

       !

$!

- "%"% ) !"  

   

          

        

       

-!

") *." *!"%%

'"

?;

 & "!

."!

%

 5&) *  *" % "  &$ & !&"$  3%:% 4 %5/03$ $ * 2D $202+$.!*!&)% "% 4" 

31D8'202+6

" )"""

"!$"** ") *" !

$<   1!1  

/    



4 / /    

!% $%$!  =  (#($/)#%-$$-"+-%"$)!"#$%% "# %  $,)"%  !  "#  )"'"  --)%2  "",  "# $%!"""#%$-'" "#!%/"+%!"# / " $)!,

2!%"%)

$ $'+$$$ + 

/  /      3

* %'!

'!

 #!" !

& $"### '+=

"." F "!

 " $.!

"$ +!" %

+0

""+2"

' .!!

&.!

"' $!

."

 *!"

'#!

& "**'!

 %"* %.

*"%*"



?.

$

!

" '!

"F"%'



 ' !

& .%/ %   $

*# ""

* '!

*# '"

 $!* ' ! ' & ".

%% "'!

"

 "

 !"$! !!

  '! !

&$!

 * 

" F"%'

 $!

$! !!

." F 

*#%  F '+=

"$"!

'!

*#

% '  ?.

$.!

 '! ) !

&$!

"*F ""

.!*!!"

"  " '# '#%" !

 " "

 "

")"

#%" $!

!

" "%# '"

$!  %%'!

   ) !

 &$.!

"' !



" 

*# " '!

5 !

& $"!

.!

!

."  F   

)"% *!"

'# $""%  !

"*"

'  $ *  "

)  # # $    .

%%    !

  $"!

 "!

F 'F"%'



$'!

!

*# % '!

"   *!$.!

!  !



5 .!

!

*#  *!"

      '  #  )   #/**

&"% $.!

# "**'"

4"6$"

"% !#$!"$ ) %  !" '!

#%"   $  !"  !

  *%     *#%  "

1 F"%'

 $"!

'!!

 " $' !     !

  & %"% $ !

"

' !

  *#% F"%'

 ' !

 &$!*""!

."

'!

*# .

!

' ' $!

* '!

 #'+0

""+2"

'

!

&$  " % # !

 # !"!

!"*#% !

" +=

"'F"%'

 !

 &

+0

$ #'!

5%"'%".4"6

?;

 5&*" % " 

 ! % '$7%#8)$.  +." % '

' &

'!

"

!

'$" "% 

- ++ !

$*  #'!

7 

 5&$*" % "3   !9%&'"$>/   5 12 .!

$" *%""#" !

5 $!"!

'' ''$"!

!"

*# .

!

** %"% "%!

 " "  !

 )      !

       '  !  

E  F"  !

"  ''

 #" !'") +2 )   !

.  *   *%""  '  %".  #"   *4"6#"E !

" *%""

" 5%"'%".

 #$!

$!

5%"'%". #$"#" ) * 4"6"%#"E !

 *'



')/"/)!

*    %  ** $  $  

$  "%  % ** $!"" #

E!

" .# "

  #"  $"!"$!

'%% *#% $" %  $

  *) "$'" $' %"

"%"*!

$& 0 3"3 ! 5$% /3  +:

"' #"!$!&'# !

. ".! )""

) $!

#

+1

#  $""

- "% ** $#"" ""''# +=

 '"% .!"%%  "%*"46$'"

    ;,

, -

<  ;- ,< ((

 "!#"

5 53%6 1$&2=3 % &"

%= 5 5336 3

>0 %=