← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaSAO/5/2014disposed of

Savitri Devi Etc. v. Krishan Kumar Etc.

2015-10-12Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal19 pages



     

 !""#$%$&'  ($!)$"($ &*!+")% ,,"-- &!% .% /)$%+ &/01 ) &*!+")%  "%,&*"&!% 



 ($!)$"($ &*!+")% ,,"-- &!% .% /)$%+ &/01 ) &*!+")%  "%,&*"&!% '

     

     

     



       ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* + # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

  /

 !" #  #

   $ % & '(

 % )&() '(  

 * 



+ +"



,

 "

""

'

$ % & '(

 "

!"

( '(





 , .

!

" 0  

 

  #

  

 % )&() '( 

!

 !"



) (& '(   * 1! 3.

 !"

 ''

( '(  /  1! 41 *  5 , 

 "0 + +"

 +"

  

"

   

%

 +"

4  ,

%



 * 



% '

)5

6#   !

'76- 8   

&& 8  4'

:

&&95 "  % ';

   % ';

  

% <'

!

/ % (7=   % -  ,

!

  

0

<<=6<7

&

>   

6#   !

-;;6;

8    --(( 8  "

 % ';(   % (7;  

% ;)7 !

/ % (7)

(7;

!

  

0

<<=6<7   % -  ,

;

 

%

6# :

?- 

 / % (7=

0

 # 

?-

% ;

<

  # 

?-  / % (7)

(7;

=



 " %

    ! . 

#   0   !

 !



"

 0   # %  !

0

,0 # !!



!

" %  "  8

$ 



 @!

   %

 

 !    

 0  

"

!

 2>

% = '' ( '(() !   )&' -'- -'& >/

  , !

!

 !

!

   %  0 

"0 " (& () <<7  ,# + +"

 +"

4  5 >   A % (7;

    +"

A % (7=   + +"

  

   +"

   : 0

: #  

  ,#

   

 ,

<

>   @ %

 "

  

# 

 % ;&76

-(

'(() " '7 ( '((7   0  (& () <<7

0 !

/ % (7=   + +"

# : 

# 

0 !

/ % (7;

    +"

"   #!

!

 

(

$ "  ! #!

 #  " /6    

                 



   

       



 !          



# 

 !         

$  %     

    

'

 .

  %

'

0

 !

 

  

0

    

 % -

# 

"

!"  ,  # 

!

 B"

0 " # 

 !"

 '( (< '(

 /  1! 41 *  5 ,

!



  !"

 

,  * 1! 3.

#



 , .

 " 0  

  #

  #

 !"

( '( #

  $ % & '( 

!

  !" 

  "   !

 

" 

 



- ( '( >   * 1! 3.



, ''

( '( 

 ''

( '(  

&

!

 0 !"

( '(



& ( '(  

< ( '(

 , ''

( '(

8 "

0 # " !



!

 !"

( '( ,  # " 8

 "  

" 0   ''

( '( 

#

!

0 0

   

!

 $

!

 !"

( '(   * 1! 3.

!

 " 0   /



, * 1! 3.





!

  



0 !

8

,8  !

;

!

 " 0  ''

( '( "

 !"



) (& '( ,0  !

!"

 ''

( '(  /  1! 41 *  5 , # 

 

 % )&() '( 



 * 



+ +"

  

< (7 '(

=

>    $ % & '( )   

,"    * 1! 3.

# !

,  , !

#   ",   " 0 

 # "

 

   " 0   /  !"

 



 , .

!

" 0  

  #

  #

@   ," !

" 0

 

 

 0 0   > "    0  " 0  A  ," 

"  $

 '- '-6

'& //

<

"

 $

 '- //   #

 # "

# 

  

" 0 

 

/  .     0 ?

"

# 

 #  6 "

 ! ",

 " ,  

'(

$

 '-6 //   #   # "

# 

  #

" 0 

 

   0 #

 $

 '- //

'

$

 '& //   #  #  " 

 "

# 

 "

  .

 

  ! # !  #

  "

,

''

@  /

 0 

  " "!      $

 '- // 

 '-6

'& // !

   !0  , 

"  %

 % (7)

(7&

: # % &

0

 !  "

0  /"" (& () <<7 4C: *

"  >  "" A % (7;

  +"

A % (7=  + +"

A

 ! +

+

  +"

" 4C: *   

'-

@    ," 

 % (7)

(7&

  %

! 0

"

+"

% &

$"

 .

% 7

: #  

  "

  !



   !

   0 %# 8    A % (7;

(7= ,#

!

   %

 +"

$

 ,!

 "

  

')

@# #!0  "" C: *

 # !

 

 @# # !

! 

% !" ,   % (7)

(7&



%    



+"

$"

 .

%

""   



%  

!

"" 0  

,    ,#

  %

  0 % (7;

(7=

 

 ! +

+

 C: *

0  A % (7;

  +"

 A % (7=  + +"

 

 ! +

+

  +"

$  % (7)

(7& # ,   "" 



  :

'&

@      " + +"

D6  #  6:

"  #!

6 &  

'()* '(*)*  

'()#+     

, 

   '(*+#-  *+$-  *+) 

     

, 

 '(*+#     .    

  - /  !   

  

,

 '(*+$   0   1,  

       

     

,  

   '(*+)       

 -2 

   1

    . 

  !  3   

, 

                   &         



   3 3       !

, !-     , 

       

,

 '(*+)4  /  ! /15    

3   *6$  0&      !    



,              15  3     15        ,               '(  *+) 

 15    &      

,  15 '(*+7   '() '8)  

'(9        

,

 '(*+7    !

,       

 !

 ,           

  :

     ,

  ,;<, "!

  

;

,   

 =/">   , ? =/"   ,  1

   2 

-     , 

       ,  &    

            =/"        

!

 ,   

        , !    2 

     

          :

             :

 1

    0  &

       =/">   '(*+)         1

   4 '8*+7        

!

 ,

  , ! 2 

  &  ,      $#9+                     =/">?153   

,      

 

 !

 &   , ,, &   

,  /    /4 '8*+7 & !        

15,  %

';

@    " 

!" 0!

" 

"  "   !

 ,#

"  6:

" + +"

D6

'=

! " C: *

 , % '

<

0 #

8 0  ,  % '

<

 !  % (7;

(7=

 

 ! +

+

 

  "

6:

" + +"

    

% '

<

" ""

0 # :   

#  % '

<

#!0 "  

 % (7)

(7&

#!0 

'7

  "" !     #0 8

" 

"  ! !

  







  %

'<

  !"   * 1! 3.

    >  !" "



" ,#   "

! !

   , 

     "



" 

  !





"   "

   , 

#

" ,  

8  

0 "

-(

* % '

< ,!

6   % (7;

(7=

 

 ! +

+



" 

#

" %6 !

% '

< "" #0 8

#

 

"   " ,

 " #!

@  

"0

!  #!

  

    8 >     

!     >       "

 

"   

 !

0 !

-'

   ,   !

    



        / ,  0"  :

" C: *& *7  ,

  "   C: *6< *6 (

  :   +"

%

   % (7;

  

! 

  C: *6

#

!

   %

  

--

"



  0   #  " *"  C: *

0 :,  0 ,!

,  0 8 !     #   :  

-)

@    ,"

!

0 

# !  %

'

#!



 0

 !

 !

  /  ""    $ 

 .  

 !!

  "

: ""

  "     / 

   

-&

%  ,!    ""  ,# : ""

"  % " ,!  #!

 # "" 0  !  <(

<

   

 "

 # " 0



 # "

   !

#   # $

 '- '-6

'& // %  

  "  .#

,

" 

" "

""   !

-;

$ 

 , ''

( '( -   

  !

0  ,!

   , 0

  2 "!

" 0  ''

( '(  #

  ,

!

 " 0  

  #

  # " 

0

 ,

" 0   #

-=

!

   " 0 

8  # 

0 >  # 0 #  

 0 "

 !"

 '( (< '(

  ,!

   0 "

  ,!   > "

 "" ''

( '(   

 ,

     " 0  !!



  , " ,

 , 0 8 ! 

-7

>   /

0

   ,#  ,  

 0  / 

 "    "!

" 0  # ! !

0 ?



 0 #

     " 0 

"   , !



  ,

 ! !"

 '( (< '(



  " ,  !    %

'

:

!  %

'



  # 0 

 ,  ,

, !

#  0  ",   " 0 

  # "

 8   > "    8"  #!

" 0   0 #  8"  #!

" 0  ,"  0

-<

@     ,"

 2 .

!3 

  "!

" 0 

  

#  

 0 ""

  

!

 $ ,"  2    ,"  "

: !



  ,#

%



" 

"" !    

    0

 0 !

    

 !"

 ''

( '(

 

 !"



) (& '(

 0 .

 

)(

>    $ % & '( )  "

 

() '(

 ! #   0   ,0  "!

" 0  ''

( '(     !  ! ,  @# "

0

) (& '(   !

   

() '(   

 % )&() '(  0    $ % & '( >

#  

"

 

 $   $ !

#

"

   ! , / ,# $  

) (& '(  

 !   ! 

() '(

    : 

   # . ! " " "0     '( (< '(

"    * 1! 3.

 " 0  ,  0

" 

  #  0 !   * 1! 3.

, , 

# $

 '- '-6

'& // 

!!

#    " 0 

 ,  # ! !

0

 0

! "



!

 

)'

>  "

 !  #!

" 0 

0   !

0

 0 !"   ! $ % & '( !  "      #  !"

  ''

( '(

!"

) (& '(

!

)-

.!

  

 

" 

!

  " 

 , !

 % )&() '(

#0 8 ! 0 $ % & '(   ! ! 

() '(

"

!

,

!

 !"



'

( '( 0 "

% ';

!

$ % & '(

))

>

#

     !

() '(    , ! /   " 

 

 % )&() '( "    # " ! !

0  , 0

!

!

"

 , "

)&

!0  #

 

 

( '(   * 1! 3.

 * 1! 3.





 ! !

 ,  ,   0

#  #  #!

" 0    ,? 0

     " 



,  * 1! 3.

'

' '( &

);

 

( '(   * 1! 3.



 

 % )&() '(   "

!

," 

)=

 * 1! 3.

# ,!



:0

,  ,0 #

 :

" "

 ,  $,

' '( &

  3